Gonzalo’s mothers wipes dirt from him, proving that even though they can provide very little for their children they have not lost their dignity or pride.
After seeing the life that Gonzalo is accustomed to this scene is a stark contrast. Because of these unsettling images, there is some relation to the ideas of Cinema Novo. The goal of Cinema Novo is to reveal the truth, rather than to show only the dominate culture like traditional cinema. To accomplish this affect, film makers use unsettling images, and sounds to cause the viewer discomfort. I believe that the gross injustice seen in this film accomplishes this goal. The second scene which captures Chile’s political environment during the 1970’s is the debate in the chapel.
This meeting brought together parents from the upper-class families and the parents of the newly admitted poor children. It is evident from the very beginning that the schools new socialist policy was controversial. The poor children are bullied and told that they do not deserve to be there. The program that allowed these children to be admitted is one of many examples of the leftist changes instituted by Salvador Allende before he was ousted. During the discussion we hear opinions from both sides of the isle. The upper class parents suggest that the children just cannot mix and that their children should never have been exposed to liberal ideas, or the poverty in their country. When one woman from the slums speaks, she tells a tragic story about why she moved to that town in the first place. She says that her husband struggled to find a job and when he did find a job caring for animals on a farm he was treated unfairly. If the animals became ill, he would not be
payed. In both of these scenes we see the struggle of the lower-class for survival. They work themselves to the bone in order to provide the necessities. The film contrasts this with Gonzalo’s life or excess. His family has more than enough because the upper-class lives on the back of the lower-class. They hold all of the wealth, therefore they hold all the power. When a popularly elected leader opposes this system, he is removed.