Preview

Manet

Better Essays
Open Document
Open Document
1240 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Manet
Harold Shaw
Hum314
November 12th, 2012
A comparison on Venus or Urbino and Monet’s Olympia
As the upper class Renaissance movement took pace in Italy during the 14th century many different originally theories and beliefs became relevant in Greeks and Roman life. Mainly the importance of the individual was held higher then before. This lead the way for artist such as Giovanni Bellini to express their art, religious beliefs, and ideas through paintings of landscapes and portraits. They used bold colors and out linings to show emotion. Many artist seemed to reproduce the same images in serious, making some minor or major changes to the scenery, lighting, or personnel in the image. Artist such as Titian chose to paint pictures that depicted everyday life, and pictures that viewers could immediately recognize.
In a period for the 16th century through the 19th century there were two strikingly similar paintings constructed by two well known artist. Titian’s portrait Venus of Urbino and Monet’s Olympia possess so many similar characteristics that at a glance they can be hard to differentiate. The best way to show the differences and similarities in these paintings really is to compare and contrast a few key features. Monet’s painting was actually inspired by Titians creation. Both showed a nude woman lying uncovered in bed starring directly into the viewer’s eyes. During the 16th century through the 19th century it wasn’t uncommon for the subject to be a nude woman, such as Venus and Cupid in 1522 and Danae and the Shower of Gold of 1744. The women in these paintings usually we the wives or relatives of Royalty.
Titian whose real name is Tiziano Vecellio is considered to be by many the greatest Venetian artist of the 16th century. The birth date of Tiziano still remains a mystery because of a misprint that occurred as Girgio Vasari wrote his biography. Titian was born in Pieve de Cadore, in the Alps north of Venice he started his early career studying behind two

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    The harsh lighting expels midtowns and shallow depth which emphasizes her nudity. The painting is supposedly modeled after Titans, Venus of Urbino, however, I consider it to be a mockery of Titans work. Titan presents a goddess while Manet presents a prostitute. Unlike Titan’s Venus, whose left hand entices the viewer and politely covers her genitals, Olympia’s left hand obstructs as if she was forcibly doing so. This is an interpretation of how she is not reliant on men. Manet also replaces the dog with a black cat which is another symbolization of prostitution. On another note, the size of this work is quite large for this sort of painting. Paintings at this stature should be portraying historical events, not what I see before me. In conclusion, this work should not be displayed in a gallery such as the…

    • 308 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The Birth of Venus was the first big painting done on a canvas during the Renaissance in Florence. Botticelli made his own pigments which added a lot of brightness and to his paintings. This made his canvas painting have the freshness of frescoes. The proportions of the figures show exaggeration which makes the painting look mythical (“Birth of Venus”)…

    • 634 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Ap Euro Renaissance Terms

    • 361 Words
    • 2 Pages

    1. Botticelli: One of the leading painters of the Florentine renaissance, developed a highly personal style. The Birth of Venus…

    • 361 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Manet's of other work Olympia was an appropriation of Titians masterpiece Venus of Urbino. It wasn't the nudity or the presence of her fully-clothed maid that shocked the audiences, it was the intense stare in her her eyes, giving a hint the that she is the one with power. Olympia was know to be a prostitute, it was a known fact in society, but the controversy was the fact that Manet had captured her in his work with such power and determination, society did not like it at all. In studying both these works by Manet, it is evident that an artist will not always create their works with the audience in…

    • 1002 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    One area where Renaissance artists expressed their interest in human nature was in paintings. First compare the picture of the Madonna with the Renaissance painting of the Mona Lisa. Leonardo da Vinci showed a woman as she really looked. He used shading, natural folds in clothing and human expression to paint a person. This is very different from Buoninsegna’s painting. He painted a statue. The face has few features, and is 2 dimensional. The child looks like a little man, and he uses religious symbols to portray emotion. Leonardo da Vinci’s painting of the Mona Lisa demonstrates the new Renaissance idea of human nature because it illustrated a shift from the use of symbolic representation to convey and idea to the use of human emotions or recognizable scenes. It also shifted focus from religious figures to the individual in a natural setting with greater realistic detail.…

    • 535 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    During the thirteenth and fourteenth centuries, a transformation occurred in Italy with respect to society, economics, politics, and religion. One of the major factors that led to such a change was the shift from a farming culture to a culture of industry dominated by merchants. This led to an urban economy, the expansion of cities, and the alteration of government to accommodate the growing population. In addition, Christian sects such as the Franciscans and the Dominicans began to form, advocating new religious philosophies involving bringing faith to the masses. This combination of reform in the economy and in organized religion brought about an increase in the production of art. The creation of artworks became an esteemed industry, and artists gained more respect in the eyes of Italian citizens. Typically, most of the art that was produced was religious in nature, and was seen as a mechanism for visually representing faith in a more tangible manner. During this dynamic period, artistic styles began to change as well. A transition from medieval, Byzantine art to a more naturalistic, humanistic style occurred in Italy. This included an increase in drama and emotion in art and a revival of Classical forms and ideals, leading to the designation of the period as the "Renaissance," meaning rebirth.…

    • 2302 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    24) What Florentine painter led the way in the movement toward nature and people as the primary subject matter of Renaissance…

    • 534 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Neoclassical Art Analysis

    • 1010 Words
    • 5 Pages

    This masterpiece was created by Jean Auguste Dominique Ingres in 1814 and is perfect example of Neoclassicism which was the revolt of the Rococo style of art. The artwork is placed in the Louvre Museum in Paris. This painting captures the image of an odalisque, which we refer to as a concubine. The painting depicts beautiful hues of blue, and a dark background and shadows which creates a seductive scenery while enhancing the curves and shapes of the model. With the contrast of light and dark colors, Ingres was able to achieve the illusion of depth. Ingres favored long sinuous lines which is show through the way he painted her elongated back. The volumes of the nude, bathed in an even light, are toned down in a space without depth (Louvre). I also like the details of his work, from the detailed headpiece, jewelry, feather duster and even the designs strategically placed on the curtains. Ingres was highly criticized for his art work and his paintings were unpopular due to others not understanding his…

    • 1010 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Titian made his Venus of Urbino in Italy 1538 during the Venetian Renaissance. Titian has domesticated Venus by moving her to an indoor setting, engaging her with the viewer, and making her sensuality explicit. Titian’s composition is and use of color is a common indicator of his Venetian Renaissance style. The frankness of Venus's expression is often noted; she stares straight at the viewer, unconcerned with her nudity, making it clear she is ready to please. In her right hand she holds a posy of roses whilst her left covers her groin, provocatively placed in the center of the composition. In the near background is a dog, often a symbol of either fidelity or sexual profligacy; that the animal is asleep hints that the woman portrayed is unfaithful. Manet’s Olympia was done in France, 1863, during the Realism period. Olympia’s title alludes to a socially ambitious prostitute of the same name in a novel and play by Alexander Dumas the younger. At first Manet seems to pay homage to Titian’s subject matter and composition. However, Manet made his modern counterpart the antithesis of Titian’s. Titian’s female is curvaceous and softly rounded, Manet’s is angular and flattened; Titian’s Colors are warm and rich (Venetian Ren style), Manet’s are cold and harsh, like a photograph; Titian’s Venus looks coyly at the (male) spectator, Manet’s Olympia appears indifferent. The relationship with Olympia is underscored by the reaction of her cat, which—unlike the sleeping dog in Titian—arches its back at us. Finally, instead of looking up at the viewer, Olympia gazes down at us, indicating that she is in the position of power and we are subordinate, just as the black servant brings her bouquet. As the figure covers herself waiting for payment her posture gives a sense of Realism. In recreating Titian’s Venus, Manet overturns the entire tradition of the accommodating female…

    • 337 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Titian Research Essay

    • 636 Words
    • 3 Pages

    The Italian Renaissance artist, Titian, was arguably the best painter of the Venetian school. Titian was born in 1488 in Pieve de Cadore, Venice, Italy and died there on August 27, 1576. He mostly composed religious and mythological pictures, setting standards for physical beauty and lust (C.S. Forester, 695). For example, in Titian's work, "Venus and Adonis", he constructed an image of a nude woman viewed from the back reaching for a male in one of his mythological pieces (W.R. Rearick, 25). His reputation has never suffered a decline and was even declared by art theorist, Giovanni Lomazzo, "the sun amidst small stars not only among the Italians but all the painters of the world" (Marco Sampaolo, 696). Titian's two major cycles of paintings of mythological and religious subjects are considered as one of the most influential and crucial creations of the Italian Renaissance. Even today his paintings continue to cloud their image as portrayed by scholars (W.R. Rearick, 23).…

    • 636 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Both paintings were painted in the Renaissance, although the Birth of Venus was painted in the Early Renaissance and Venus of Urbino was created in the High Renaissance. Venus is said to be the goddess of love, sex, beauty and fertility. She was also the first non-Biblical female nude painted. One painting shows the story of how Venus was created and the other uses symbolism to create an allegory of marriage. Both paintings use chiaroscuro, which was used in oil painting during the High Renaissance, to contrast between light and dark to shape figures. In The Venus of Urbino, Venus is staring right at the viewer, while in The Birth of Venus, Venus is looking off to the side. The direct eye contact is used to symbolize confidence and sensuality while as in the other painting Venus is almost ashamed to be naked so she is trying to cover herself in modesty. In The Birth of Venus, there are bright and vivid colors, common in the High Renaissance. In The Venus of Urbino, dull tones are used to highlight the body of Venus. Both paintings utilize light and dark contrast as shown that Venus’ body is illuminated and very light due to her fair complexion and the surroundings are darker in color. In The Venus of Urbino, there is little movement because she is laying down, which is the complete opposite of The Birth of Venus where movement is very evident because she is standing on a seashell. The mood in the Birth of…

    • 1102 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    the reclining nude

    • 874 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Throughout history there have been many artists that have helped art take a new turn, as they express their attitudes, beliefs, influences and concerns through their work, this becomes evident through all the ways that the reclining nude is depicted. Titian was the first artist who established the reclining nude by painting his version of an idealized female form as we are able to see in “Venus of urbino” (1538). Edouard Manet was known for challenging his society through his version of the reclining nude recreating it in his work “Olympia” (1863) in order to show the culture of his time. Yasumasa Morimura also appropriated work, recreating manet’s in order to challenge cultures and gender roles in society through his work “futago” (1988). Jean Ingres challenged how the nude was portrayed and positioned, this is evident through his work “la grande odalisque” (1814). In turn the gurilla girls, a well known feminist organization who bring up contemporary issues through the appropriations of Ingre’s work created “what does a girl have to do to get hung” (1989).…

    • 874 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    The two paintings from the museum that will be of interest are just over one hundred years apart. Although they both show the similar mythological theme, they were painted by different artist at different times. Peter Paul Rubens’ piece, Venus and Adonis, was painted in the mid 1630’s. In this time, baroque style was becoming international. Peter Paul Rubens was a flemish painter, who had a role in making this style as renowned as it is today. The style of baroque was born in Rome, however Rubens spent eight years in Italy and he absorbed the style there. He studied the techniques and took in the language and culture, and he exhibited extraordinary learning and imagination. This is the reason behind why historians believe he competes with the best Italian artists. He’s realm is of his paintings specifically his portraits and altarpieces. However, when browsing in the Metropolitan Museum of Art, one comes across this breathtaking painting with much substance; Venus is accidently struck by the child, cupid, and falls in love with…

    • 456 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Italian Renaissance painter Tiziano Vecellio, also known as Titian, created one of his most well-known paintings in the year 1538. This work, Venus of Urbino (Figure 1), is an oil painting that depicts a nude young woman reclining on a couch or bed in the luxurious surroundings of a Renaissance palace. Created for the Duke of Urbino, Guidobaldo II Della Rovere, this work commemorated his wedding to Giuliana Varano that took place in 1534. Titian’s work, based on his master, Giorgione’s Sleeping Venus — completed in 1510 (Figure 2) — places Venus in an indoor setting, which engages her with the viewer, making her sensuality explicit. Titian’s Venus of Urbino is perhaps his most well-known painting because of its ambiguous meaning. Various interpretations…

    • 874 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Venus had two aspects: she was an earthly goddess whom produced and made humans aware or human physical love or she was the Heavenly goddess who inspired intellectual love in humans. It could be argued that when viewers looked at this artwork in the fifteenth century they would’ve looked at this painting in a way that their minds were lifted to the realm of divine love, spiritually and physically.…

    • 1550 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Better Essays