Although the theory has gone in and out of political (and sociological) fashion over the past 50 or so years, most of the research in this area does suggest that there is some form of relationship between material deprivation (and it's mirror concept, material affluence) and educational success or failure.
For example, with the development of School League Tables in Britain in the 1990's, two very important points flow from their publication:
Firstly, the high proportion of students from affluent home and private school backgrounds who achieve high levels of success at GCSE and A-level.
Secondly, the fact that the students who, overall, achieve the least in our education system are over-represented in poor inner city and rural areas.
Thus, the above would suggest a strong correlation (at least) between material deprivation / affluence and educational achievement, with students from materially-advantaged backgrounds achieving high rates of success and students from highly-deprived regional and family backgrounds achieving the least.
We can, for example, see this idea in action when we think about pre-World War 2 Britain. In this society, with it's wide disparities of wealth and income, poverty and deprivation were obvious explanations for educational differences in achievement between upper / middle class children and their working class peers.
However, in the years following the 2nd World War 2, material conditions generally improved for the working classes (with the introduction of the Welfare State, National Health Service and 1944 Education Act that provided free, compulsory, schooling), their relative level of achievement (compared, that is, with other social classes) did not improve significantly. This "educational discrepancy" was not only clear in the 1950's, but was also manifest in the more generally-affluent 1960's.
This, in part, led the Plowden Report ("Children and Their Primary Schools", 1967) to conclude that only in extreme cases did poverty play a significant part in explaining differential educational achievement.
You May Also Find These Documents Helpful
-
Material deprivation covers a wide range of issues, usually to do with lack of money in the family. Middle class families can afford to move into the catchment areas of high achieving schools which working class families can’t. This then leaves…
- 741 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
The idea that working-class children will most likely under-achieve due to a lack of culture, also known as cultural deprivation, refers to children lacking the norms, values, beliefs, skills and knowledge that a society would regard as important and necessary. The attributes that these children should know and learn are, in most cases, taught by their parents and are passed to the next generation through socialisation. All children are socialised differently, and the social class of the parent has a huge impact on the child and may affect their achievement in education. According to the cultural deprivation theory, some working-class parents fail to communicate and instil the appropriate norms, values, beliefs, skills and knowledge needed for educational success. However, there are other factors that can determine how well a child does within education. For example, material deprivation, cultural capital and economic capital can also have an impact on how well some children will attain, therefore cultural deprivation is not the only factor and may not be the most important reason to why working-class children under-achieve.…
- 1829 Words
- 8 Pages
Good Essays -
A social class background has a very powerful influence on a child’s chances of success in the education system. The children that are from a middle class background will normally perform better than the working class.…
- 1006 Words
- 5 Pages
Good Essays -
Some sociologists suggest that external factors have a hug effects, such as from cultural deprivation with the socialisation experience of children, values, expectations and norms transmitted at home. Driver and Ballard 1979 argued that high achievement in some Asian groups might be linked to the presence of close knit extended families. However with some ethnic groups many tend to have low income, which may explain why black pupils tend to underachieve as many children from low income black families lack intellectual stimulation and enriching experiences. Family structure and parental support can also have an affect, with failure to socialise children adequately is the result of dysfunctional family structures as many black families are headed by lone mothers and have poor care due to lack of money. This is a vicious cycle as someone who failed at school will affect their child’s educational achievement as the child may not get the extra help on work like other pupils may get, which can lead to their own failure causing a vicious cycle.…
- 532 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
It is well known and well assumed that working class pupils underachieve in school. Some sociologists would argue that the reason for this is related to home circumstances. They saw that working class pupils were somewhat deprived. This deprivation was material, meaning there was a lack of money and things that money could buy in working class homes. Also these homes were missing something cultural, an absence of attitudes and skills needed to be successful in school and their education. Working class children and children in poverty often live in cramped, cold, unhygienic surroundings. Shortage of money would mean that they would have to make money on their own without financial support from their parents. They would get a part time job to aid this problem at weekends and the evenings, leaving less time for school and leaving at the minimum age. Also working class parents may not be able to supply healthy foods and the home conditions can lead to ill health. This results in absence from school, tiredness and irritability.…
- 1202 Words
- 5 Pages
Good Essays -
| This theory suggests that working parents fail to transmit the appropriate norms, values, and attitudes that are the ‘Correct’ culture – needed for educational success.…
- 2833 Words
- 12 Pages
Powerful Essays -
These are very likely to have a large affect on the child’s development. Children that are from a deprived background and come to school are less likely to achieve as well as a child that is not from a deprived background (this is shown by statistics) as parents from a deprived background tend to find it more difficult to manage their specific needs which in turn will affect areas of development this in turn…
- 685 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
One way in which material deprivation may lead to underachievement for working class is because of poor quality housing. This is because they are unable to afford good quality housing due to their little income, normally from manual jobs. Poor housing could mean a small and cramped house. This could be because they are unable to afford a bigger house or are living in a council house; which is very small. If the pupil is living in a small house with a lot of people, they may have nowhere to do their homework or revise. This could therefore lead to them being constantly behind on the work and then underachieving. Poor housing can also affect the achievement of working class pupils, if they live in a catchment area with schools that are not highly ranked on the OFSTED league tables. As the working class have little money and therefore suffer from material deprivation, they may be unable to afford a house in the catchment area of a good school (one ranked highly in the league tables). Therefore, they are forced to go to a school that will not help them into reaching their full potential and therefore underachieve.…
- 758 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
Outline some of the ways in which material deprivation may affect educational achievement. (12 marks)…
- 524 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
Cultural deprivation theory states that those who are at the bottom of the class system are being deprived of some values, attitudes and special skills that are essential for educational success. This theory puts the blame for educational failure on children and their families, their neighbourhood and the subculture of their social group. The child who has been culturally deprived is lacking in skills, attitudes and important values that are essential to high educational success. Their environment could be said to be culturally as well as economically poor.…
- 669 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
. families with higher incomes tend to be those in which the parent(s) are highly educated. This has long been true, though the link between parental educational attainment and family income has grown stronger in recent decades, as the wage returns to educational attainment have increased since 1979. Because highly educated parents are more able and more likely than less educated parents to provide resources and opportunities for their children to develop cognitive and academic skills in both the preschool years and the school-age years, children of parents with college degrees may have higher academic achievement . .…
- 1002 Words
- 5 Pages
Good Essays -
The first factor that influences human development is a person’s socioeconomic status. This indicates a person’s position in society as determined by income, wealth, occupation, education, and place of residence. As a child, socioeconomic status has a big effect on the way a child is raised and the opportunities available to him/her. Children that come from high socioeconomic status families typically are more successful because they have more resources readily available to their children. They are able to afford high-quality childcare, education, and healthcare. Their children are also typically more involved in recreational sports and extra-curricular activities broadening their children’s horizons and talents. Children that are raised in low socioeconomic families lack the financial, educational, and social support that would make them feel equal to children from higher social standing families. These feelings of unease and not fitting in can lead to low confidence and low motivation. Children have to live with these feelings and the circumstances they were born into until they become adults and can make their own livings. Anyone is capable of overcoming his or her circumstances! When children grow up, they get to decide how far they want to take their education and what type of career field they want to go into as…
- 1662 Words
- 7 Pages
Good Essays -
• Poverty and deprivation. Hopefully not one of our own major influences, whereas in other, not so well off countries, this is a major fact as these children cannot have any education as there is not any available.…
- 417 Words
- 2 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
Affordability - There is a big disparity in educational achievements across social groups. Students from wealthy families have excellent educational background gained from exclusive private schools at the start of their education until they finish college. Unlike the students from the less fortunate families, wherein most of them could not even finish elementary nor secondary level because of poverty. They could barely afford to buy school shoes and pencils, not even the tiny amount of tuition fees from the public schools.…
- 427 Words
- 2 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
Students of low income families are five times more likely to drop out of high school than students from high income families. Poverty triples the chance of a student of leaving school early. Another link between family income and high school graduation is that children who live in poverty and read below grade level by third grade are three times as likely not to graduate from high school as students who were born in families with income above poverty level.…
- 442 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays