Preview

Minority Report: Free Will Vs Determinism

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
2353 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Minority Report: Free Will Vs Determinism
Elbert Hubbard, an American writer, publisher, and philosopher, once said, "Life is a compromise between fate and free will." Not only in today's society, but all throughout time, there is the constant debate between free will and determinism. The debate has been presented in movies, plays, and other forms of literature. Most people either believe that they have the choice to make decisions (free will), or that life is already decided for them (determinism). I believe, however, that free will and determinism coexist, which is referred to as compatibilism.
The movie Minority Report is set in Washington D.C. during the year of 2054. The city is at the point of full automation: cars are self-driven, iris scanners are used as a way of identification,
…show more content…
When the PreCogs predicted the murder and revealed their vision to the PreCrime members, they were already determining the victim(s) and perpetrator(s) future. When the officers of PreCrime arrested the "criminal," they did not allow him to exercise free will because he was not able to completely live out the situation. In all of the murders that were stopped, some would have actually pulled the trigger, stabbed the victim, etc., but others (like John) would have realized that they have a choice; they do not have to choose the life of a murderer. The ones that followed the PreCogs vision followed the lines of determinism because it was predicted, but those, like John, who would have decided not to exercised free will. Like Thomas Hobbes said, "Freedom exists when physical restraints are not present;" PreCrime, placing a halo on the pre-determined murderers and placing them in containment, took away the ability to exercise freedom because of the physical …show more content…
The idea has been displayed throughout various forms of literature and also through academic textbooks backed by philosophers. The thirteenth edition of Philosophy: A text with Readings, used Walter Stace's, an American philosopher, idea of free acts and unfree acts as support for compatibilism. He said that a free act would be Gandhi fasting because he wanted to free India, but a man fasting in the desert because there is no food is unfree. Gandhi made the decision to fast in the desert, therefore exercised his power of free will. The man, on the other hand, was fasting due to a predetermined cause- being stranded. Both of these acts, or similar scenarios, have actually taken place which demonstrates that free will and determinism

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    It has been recommended by some that humans have the capability of demonstrating free will and mindful choice to be a part of or engage in criminal behaviour. Others have recommended that our behaviour is 'pre-established'. With reference to “AJCSD Criminal Behaviour – Free Will v. Determinism” the document critically analyses the above argument from a phycological perspective with regard to free will and determinism stating that freedom has never been absolute, free will and determinism has been a very important aspect in trying to explain and define causality of criminal behaviour it’s important to note that, free will and determinism polarises psychology and law.…

    • 429 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Compatibilism, in other words, soft determinism is the “belief that free will and determinism are compatible ideas and that it is possible to believe both theories without being logically inconsistent. Compatibilists believe freedom can be absent or present in situations.” Therefore as a compatibilist, I believe that despite determinism being true we still have the freedom to control our actions.…

    • 668 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    One of the main questions that we face is whether or not, we as humans have genuine freedom. Are we free to make our own choices? Do we decide what happens in our lives in the future? Or are our lives set pathways in which we have no say at all? Are all our choices already decided? In other words, do we have free will or are our actions pre-determined, or both? Hard determinists, libertarians and soft determinists all set out to provide answers to these questions, holding different views on whether or not free will and determinism are compatible. Both hard determinists and libertarians believe that free will and determinism are incompatible but hard determinists reject the idea of free will whereas libertarians support the idea of free will and reject determinism. On the other hand, soft determinists believe that free will and determinism are in fact compatible.…

    • 2062 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Afterwards, I will be defining what is free will in my personal opinion as well as whether or not free will is compatible with determinism. Baron d’Holbach was known for being “one of the leading philosophers of the French Enlightenment” (Pojman & Fieser, A Defense of Determinism, p. 396). He was also…

    • 597 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    There are three main positions in the free will debate; determinism, compatibilism, and libertarianism. In my opinion, the strongest argument of these is compatibilism due to it agreeing with my views and beliefs on the subject of free will.…

    • 200 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    The stereotypical definition of determinism, to the layman, goes something like this: "All events are predetermined so we have no free will." Actually, this is more or less the definition of hard determinism. Determinism, however, according to professor of philosophy Sandra LaFave, can co-exist with free will in the form of soft determinism, the philosophical theory that all events indeed have causes but that humans can still act voluntarily. Soft determinism provides a more widely-acceptable definition of determinism that agrees more with common usage of the words "free will" and "cause."…

    • 374 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Better Essays

    The debate between freewill and determinism stems from the apparent conflict between the universal rule of causality that is deeply rooted in nature, and between the apparent ability of human beings to choose between multiple courses of action in order to lead to the most desirable outcome. The universal rule of causality simply claims that inorganic matter such as tables, chairs and rocks are acted upon by whatever forces affect it, however, human beings seem to be an exception to this rule by their unique ability to ponder about how to go about making decisions in their life and which…

    • 1181 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Determinism is a controversial topic to free will with multiple theories proving and disproving it. As printed in The Collins Cobuild Learner's Dictionary, determinism is defined as “...the belief that all actions and events result from other actions, events, or situations, so people cannot in fact choose what to do.” Meaning, all life choices are predetermined from the minute we are born, to the minute we die. In contrast, “freewill is an individual taking control and responsibility for his/her actions according to his personal will” (Freewill Verses Determinism). People who believe in Free will, accept the idea that life is not predetermined, and they can independently act however they see fit. Free will and determinism can be further simplified and have multiple differences as well as similarities.…

    • 1475 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Gary Gutting, the author of the article, What Makes Free Will Free? deliberates that we do not have free choice as we assumed which a researcher confirmed. By free choice, this means the conviction that our conduct is dictated by our own unrestrained choice and that we have complete power over our activities. Also, Gary Gutting examined various thoughts on determinism as the researchers suggested. Determinism refers to the conviction that all human conduct or any other occurrences have a cause. This is opposed to a person's will to accomplish an action. Gary Gutting discussed what David Hume, a philosopher, believed and the belief of David Hume is that both determinism and free choice are possible, they are compatible with each…

    • 1857 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    I would lean more towards the compatibilist view stating, unless I am the cause of my actions I am not responsible for them. As compatibilist holds that free will and determinism are compatible, we can properly understand what it means for our actions to be free so we see that a free action is doing what one wants. Believing in compatibilism doesn't mean the determinist view is false, but if it is true, we can still have free will. I believe that we make decisions based on our own desires and beliefs. It is said that compatibilists attempt to revise and weaken the commonsense notion of free will. Thomas Hobbes was the first person to articulate a compatibilist position believing that although the person is free to act on their motive, the motive is determined. In other words, he says “Everything we choose to do is strictly determined by the need to relieve the physical pressures of our bodies. Humans…

    • 632 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Freewill Vs. Determinism

    • 792 Words
    • 4 Pages

    However, one possible outcome is you if believe you have one choice but, you only have outcome. So, when you think of freewill it is incompatible with determinism. Freewill tend to be illusion we think were free but were not. Determinism tend to be that everything we do is cause.…

    • 792 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Causal Determinist

    • 539 Words
    • 3 Pages

    According to Freedom, Determinism, and Causality, by Sober, it mentions three views of freedom: hard determinism, libertarian, and soft determinism. Being a hard determinist means you do not have free will, an incompatibilist, and causal determinist. Libertarians are free and incompatibilist; soft determinist are people that say that we do have free will and are causal determinism. An incompatibilist has many options and is free to pick any one of the choices. A causal determinist is when events turn out the same even if you go back in time. In this essay I am going to argue that we should be hard determinist because we do not have free will to choose our genes and environment.…

    • 539 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Various philosophers have explained iterations of free will in more depth, resulting in a greater number of issues connected to it. When arguing against free will, the concept of determinism is advanced as the main argument. Determinism is the philosophical idea that every event or state of affairs, including every human decision, and action, is predetermined. The main perceived threats to our freedom of will are various alleged determinisms. These can be physical, psychological, biological or theological in nature. For example, suppose you meet a person you are instantly attracted to. Practically every thought and emotion in your body commands you to approach the person but for various reasons you hold back; the moment doesn't feel right.…

    • 157 Words
    • 1 Page
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Arguments about free will are mostly semantic arguments about definitions. Most experts who deny free will are arguing against peculiar, unscientific versions of the idea, such as that free will means that causality is not involved. These arguments leave untouched the meaning of free will that most people understand which is consciously making choices about what to do in the absence of external coercion, and accepting responsibility for one’s actions. Hardly anyone denies that people engage in logical reasoning and self-control to make…

    • 890 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    When we take a look at the basic idea of the given movie, which describes a situation where crime can be predetermined, and therefore stopped, we can easily notice that it has some correlation with deterministic point of view. Determinism is the philosophical doctrine in which person perceive the life, and the world around him as predetermined. Everything what happens is already well planned, each move, every decision, every step, which would mean that we don't have our own free will. Even though we are making certain decisions throughout our lives, according to this theory, it has nothing to do with our own decisions in the end. One of the interesting scenes at the beginning of the movie was when the drug dealer inside the dark alley appears…

    • 270 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays