The old Horatio Alger stories capture the American dream pretty well. Those who work hard, apply themselves and play fair, they tell us, will be amply rewarded. Those who avoid responsibility, exploit others and cheat will get their comeuppance. This notion is at the heart of American entrepreneurialism and professionalism, and of American artistic and sports endeavor as well.
So why do people like Jeffrey Skilling and Bernard Madoff get away with so much for so long? There is no simple answer, but those two were both in it for the money, it appears, and there is ample evidence to suggest that money may not be the best way to motivate desirable behavior. In fact, it may be one of the worst ways.
Most successful entrepreneurs say that their primary motivation has been to build something lasting, not to make a lot of money. Certainly great professional leaders like Marvin Bower, who built McKinsey & Co., John Whitehead, the former Goldman Sachs senior partner, and Supreme Court Justice John Paul Stevens would tell us that their motivation came from the work itself, and that the lasting respect of others was far greater than money as a measure of accomplishment. And very few great artists are in it for the money. Money is a byproduct, and usually a secondary one at that, for such achievers.
Emotional sources of motivation are more powerful, and they are best conveyed informally in an organization through the respect of peers, the admiration of subordinates, the approval of one’s personal network and community and the like. Money becomes the default motivator because it is measurable, tangible and fungible — and trouble strikes when the prospect of a lot of money becomes the primary goal. That usually feeds a very self-serving emotion, greed.
What works better than money?
It depends on what kind of motivation you’re after. Money is better at attracting and retaining people than at influencing their behavior. Those of us who subscribe to the writings of the authority on motivation Frederick Herzberg, who died in 2000, believe that the most effective way to motivate work behavior is by focusing on how people feel about their work itself.
Recent studies by David Rock, an executive coach, and Jeffry Schwartz, a neuroscientist, have identified several motivators that influence behavior more effectively than money. For one, people want to elevate their status. Organizations often assume that the only way to raise an employee’s status is by a promotion, but status can be enhanced in many less costly ways. The perception of status increases significantly whenever people are given credible informal praise for daily tasks rather than waiting for annual results.
People are also motivated by having autonomy, but more money doesn’t often equal greater perceived autonomy. In fact, you usually have to give up autonomy to rise up the compensation ladder. The real heart of autonomy as a motivator, however, rests with the perception that you are executing your own decisions without a lot of oversight or rules, which is hardly common in the corporate world today.
Similarly, feelings of relatedness and fairness are motivators. They are determined more by informal interactions, social networks and daily perceptions than by money or formal promotions.
This is not to suggest that money doesn’t motivate. Certainly it encourages self-serving materialism. But those who rely on money as their sole or primary motivator are on perilous terrain, particularly if they ignore other more powerful and emotional sources of human motivation.
A few years ago we did research with elite military units that included the Navy Seals, the Green Berets and the Marines. Not surprisingly, we found that money is not what motivates an emotional commitment to such groups. We also learned that pride in daily training exercises was almost as important a motivational force as pride in the unit. And the Marines spend 75% of their military life in training exercises.
The Marines’ boot camp takes 12 weeks while other services take 8. Those 12 weeks are devoted to exercises designed to inculcate the Corps’ emotional values of honor, courage and commitment. During that arduous period, recruits are required to do all kinds of anxiety-producing things like leap off high towers, swim in deep water with full backpack burdens and run miles up and down hills.
Their drill instructors are master motivators whom they initially hate and fear. Before long those instructors become aspirational role models who breed respect, courage and commitment. A drill instructor is up at the crack of dawn before his recruits, works into the night preparing for the next day and changes his uniform several times a day. (He always looks the part of a Marine leader.)
To understand the emotional commitment that drill instructors engender, we conducted a focus group discussion with some eight recruits 10 weeks into their program. One of them was a young woman about 5 feet tall who weighed less than 100 pounds. She looked a bit out of place to us, so at one point we asked her what had attracted her to the Corps. Her impassioned reply remains a permanent fixture in our memory: “Gentlemen, the Marines make me shine — every single day!” That is pride in one’s work at its best, with money irrelevant.
Over the past five years we have studied many master motivators like that woman’s drill instructor. We have conducted hundreds of case studies across dozens of companies. And the results are always the same. Money just doesn’t matter much. Some use it, most don’t. For those who do, it is but one small element in a motivational arsenal. Their primary focus is on finding emotional connections, sources of pride, that they can use to make each and every person they affect feel good about their daily tasks. And they succeed no matter how boring, difficult or unpleasant the job may be.
Thus, they instill the kind of emotional commitment that is never self-serving, never short term and always energizing. Their secret is that they use informal elements of their organizations — personal networks, relationships, feelings, values — to counterbalance the formal. The more you rely on money as your weapon of choice, the more likely you are to encourage self-serving behavior.
To avoid the money booby-trap remember:
–Emotional commitment dwarfs purely rational compliance every time.
–Money encourages self-serving short-term behaviors better than it motivates lasting institutional achievement.
–An overreliance on monetary rewards invariably erodes emotional commitment.
–Pride in one’s work itself is what brings on lasting improvement in behavior.
–The informal elements of motivation are at least as important as the formal ones.
Jon R. Katzenbach is a senior partner in the New York office of Booz & Company. Zia Khan is vice president for strategy and evaluation at the Rockefeller Foundation. They are the authors of Leading Outside the Lines: How to Mobilize the Informal Organization, Energize Your Team, and Get Better Results, published in April 2010 by Jossey-Bass.
Comments are turned off for this post. 199
28
5
27
14
Report Corrections
Reprints & Permissions
You May Also Find These Documents Helpful
-
Money is the motivating factor for most people nowadays and people will do almost anything to get it. Increasing your wealth has become a necessity in today’s materialistic society and continues to spread. People…
- 323 Words
- 2 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
As we have seen in class, sometimes the companies need to motivate their employees in order to achieve the goals that interest the company. As we know one of the best motivators (to achieve good things or correct bad things) is the money.…
- 2533 Words
- 11 Pages
Powerful Essays -
The traditional form of the American Dream is portrayed through hard work, the ability to better yourself, and financial success. Throughout the course of time, not only do customs change, but the ideals of the American Dream are modified as well. In most cases the basic characteristics of the traditional American Dream is translated through the actions of a successful society. Although this philosophy does not imply to the modern beliefs of the American Dream, many individualists began speculating that there are two options to the ideal American Dream, whether it’d be success or failure itself.…
- 647 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
There are many ways of going about and achieving The American Dream, Some may exploit the talents of others, inherit money, or work hard to the position or job they want to have. In the current state of the economy, some do not have time to pursue the ambitions of man. As we advance the time to teach the generation on how to progress becomes longer,…
- 904 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
Money is a major motivator for employees, but it’s not the only motivator. Employee motivation can be as individual as the people who work for you. “But you can boil down employee motivation to one basic ideal: finding out what your employees want and finding a way to give it to them or to…
- 790 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
Many have, are, and will continue to work hard for many different and varying versions of The American Dream, such as Nikola Tesla, astronomers searching for extraterrestrial life, or Lennie and George in Steinbeck’s novel Of Mice and Men. Some may be lucky enough to obtain The Dream but for many more, all that will be found is hard work but no…
- 478 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
Money is the priority. However, all the money in the world can’t make you prosper, but it’s the experience you’ve been through that makes you prosperous.…
- 791 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
Money allows people to specialize in what they do best, thereby raising everyone’s standard of living.…
- 26621 Words
- 107 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
Our ancestors have made these opportunities available to all through the creation of values. These values included, work-ethic, faith, and equality. When I hear the term “American Dream”, I think about the duty of maintaining the ethics of my ancestors, who have cleared some of the pebbles, sticks and sunken holes on various pathways. The American Dream means to follow the footsteps of one’s decedents, but branch off of the path, and go further. Adding to the amount of trail covered, then makes it easier for someone else to reach their destination.…
- 750 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
When looking at the American society and its culture, one could safely say that through hard work individuals are able to succeed in the country. The “American dream”, in a sense can be accomplished by any individual that puts determination and initiative to their dreams. The division of a society based on economic status can create restrictions that can make some individuals work harder than others, nevertheless, any person can be successful no matter what race, gender, or age one is.…
- 339 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
Many people grow with the mentality that making the most money possible is the wisest decision to make. However, is it always about the fortune? Or do dreams matter more? In “Bricklayer’s Boy,” money seems to be the motivational factor towards happiness and success. But, there comes a point where passion conquers wealth even in a competitive society as today’s.…
- 903 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
We have always heard that people learn in different manners, so naturally different people are motivated in different ways. Most have assumed that motivation comes from an outside source; however individuals also have their own motivating forces. As a manager, it is important to realize this, recognize those forces and make the appropriate changes for each person. With many different theories as to what the best method is for motivation, it is best to completely understand all of the methods to know which option is best for your employees. A common mistake managers make is to assume that money is the…
- 1161 Words
- 5 Pages
Good Essays -
America has been held up as the golden standard of living to many regions of the world to the point where a symbolic phrase has been created to describe the idea. The phrase “American dream” first appeared in literature in 1931 in a book written by James Truslow Adams titled The Epic of America. In the book, Adams wrote described what he interpreted as the principal purpose of the life of an American; he wrote of a land where happiness was not based off of material objects like cars or high salaries, but rather where opportunity was given based off of skill and achievement. In addition, Adams illustrates that the American dream means being “recognized by others for what they are, regardless of the fortuitous circumstances of birth or position.”…
- 381 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
Money is one thing that serves as a unit of success because most often than not you have to be in a good profession to earn a massive amount of money. People respect people who have huge amounts of money because…
- 819 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
Bill Gates, Warren Buffet, Larry Ellison and Amancio Ortega are all in a list of the world billionaires. What does these guy do? They are known as an entrepreneurs. Each of them have their own childhood memories. Some of them did not finish their school nor becoming best student among their friends. As I observe, the down fall of someone did not measured base on their performance back then. The measurement are as in this reality. The achievement had shown how well they did manage to become a successful person. Not only for their own benefit, but also for public or user base on their ideals. Their contribution give good impact not only to the nation but also for the world. As the world become a better place to live. The question is what motivates them to become someone in the industry? The entrepreneur possesses a level of commitment and a vision that are easily observed. They are inventive, aggressive, confident, tireless, competitive, and possess an intense level of focus. Best word to describe them are they are genuinely believe in what they are doing and thereby inspire others toward the same goal. Base on the article I do agree with the key factor that motivate the entrepreneurs. The key factors are wealth, intrinsic motivation, and social responsibility. Wealth, in my opinion is something that most of us dream off. Wealth give a great satisfaction after a great hard work. With wealth, it somehow give someone a power to control something they want. But the most important thing is how well do they spent the wealth. Some say that money can buy happiness but when there is no love how do they live in a peace. In other world, the used of the wealth itself can also benefit others. For example, a portion of money can be donate to the welfare. Furthermore, for the entrepreneurs, some portion of the wealth is to be kept for the sake of their generation. Living in this urban lifestyle can sometimes be very hard to control. This is because…
- 853 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays