In an news story published in Time South Pacific titled "There 's No Sure Hit Here," California Assemblywoman Sally Lieber is offering a bill that would ban the spanking of children less than 4 years old, and make spanking a misdemeanor punishable by a $1,000 file and up to one year in jail. (Sayre, 2007). Are we going crazy? Should the government be allowed to step in and tell you the proper way to raise your children? I believe that Germany tried that in the 1930s and look what happened there.
The question is how can we stop this slow decline into anarchy? The first way is for children to learn that their misbehavior or actions have consequences. I read a response to an article called "Other techniques are better than spanking." describing when the author was in seventh grade he was caught bouncing a basketball in the hall and was spanked along with three other boys. As a result of the spanking he said that "One thing 's for sure: I never bounced another basketball in that hallway." (USA Today, 2002) Do I think that this was a bit extreme for the offense, yes I do. In this case it worked; his behavior was changed by punishment. If a child is shown that by acting up, they will get their way, how do you think they are going to act? What do you think will happen as they grow and are allowed to do anything they want in school because the teachers have no control due to corporal punishment being outlawed? Will they learn anything; well it doesn 't matter because teachers are not allowed to hold children back anymore. Then they drop out of school, get arrested for stealing because they wanted something but didn 't want to pay for it. This destructive behavior needs to stop. Spanking can help.
The second thing that we need to do is give teachers back their authority in the classrooms. Two years ago my wife and I went to a parent-teacher conference and during the discussion we learned that teachers are being taught in workshop not to give their students "the look" as this might cause emotional harm. He also told us how disciplining a student requires tedious amounts of paperwork and many parents refuse to let the teachers or school discipline their child. We were both flabbergasted when he told us that they are not even allowed to hold a child back for poor grades. They can only recommend to the parents that the child be held back.
According to an article called "Corporal punishment is legal in 22 states. Would you support its use in your school? YES", Defiance, chaos, threats, cursing, assault. All these behaviors have risen from rare to frequent in many schools since the elimination of corporal punishment. He goes on to say, "The occasional spanking of a boy or girl for bad behavior provides an immediate, painful consequence that con convince them and their friends to pay attention" (Mason, 2005). I know that when I was in school, the thought of getting spanked at school was horrible, but what was even worse was the knowledge of what would happen when I got home.
Education is also needed for our parents and children. There is a big difference between correction and abuse and they need to be made aware of it. I do not condone the use of excessive force when spanking a child. Nor do I think that kicking or punching them is acceptable. A few firm swats on the bottom is all that is needed. There needs to be legislation passed that allows parents to spank their children as a disciplinary measure, and the parents and children need to know about it. Many parents falsely believe that they are not allowed to spank their children, and they fear being reported if they do. I have heard too many times children telling their parents that they will call child protection services if they spank them. This is not acceptable.
Parents need to take back control of their children. Are children born knowing what is best for them? What is dangerous or safe? What is right or wrong? No they are not, it is the parents responsibility to teach their children these things and to help them to become contributing members of society. Look what is happening to this country when parents fail in this responsibility. If spanking your child now can mean potentially keeping them out of trouble in the future, would you do it? I am sure that most people have heard the saying "Spare the Rod, Spoil the Child". I really believe that they knew what they were talking about when they wrote that.
References
Mason, D. (2005). Corporal punishment is legal in 22 states. Would you support its use in your school? YES. NEA Today, 24(1), 38-38. Retrieved Friday, March 09, 2007 from the MasterFILE Premier database, www.ivytech.edu
N.A., N. (n.d.). Spanking can produce positive outcomes. USA Today, Retrieved Friday, March 09, 2007 from the MasterFILE Premier database. www.ivytech.edu
Sayre, C. (2007). THERE 'S NO SURE HIT HERE. Time South Pacific (Australia/New Zealand edition), Retrieved Friday, March 09, 2007 from the MasterFILE Premier database. www.ivytech.edu
References: Mason, D. (2005). Corporal punishment is legal in 22 states. Would you support its use in your school? YES. NEA Today, 24(1), 38-38. Retrieved Friday, March 09, 2007 from the MasterFILE Premier database, www.ivytech.edu N.A., N. (n.d.). Spanking can produce positive outcomes. USA Today, Retrieved Friday, March 09, 2007 from the MasterFILE Premier database. www.ivytech.edu Sayre, C. (2007). THERE 'S NO SURE HIT HERE. Time South Pacific (Australia/New Zealand edition), Retrieved Friday, March 09, 2007 from the MasterFILE Premier database. www.ivytech.edu
You May Also Find These Documents Helpful
-
Picture this scenario, you and your three year old daughter are walking through Wal-Mart. She spots a toy that she really wants. Your daughter asks if you’ll buy if for her. Now, you’re on a budget. You have only enough money to purchase the items you absolutely need. You tell her no. This is when all hell breaks loose. She starts kicking and screaming. Your daughter rolls on the floor crying and shouting that she wants it. What do you do? In today’s society the only socially acceptable response you may have, especially in public, is to pull her aside, and give her a stern talk. Discuss with her why she can’t have the toy. Explain in terms she can understand, why it is wrong to throw a temper tantrum. Now, when I was little, if I threw a tantrum in the store my mother would pull me aside, and whoop me. She would tell me that she said no, and that’s final. How has our society evolved to the point where properly disciplining your child is wrong?…
- 1710 Words
- 7 Pages
Good Essays -
Slap, bang, crack! There goes another spanking. Maybe you think that spanking helps prevent bad and misbehavior from children, but did you think about how it doesn’t help them? Spanking should be illegal in the united states. There are people/guardians that abuse the children everyday because they take it too far. Spanking should not be provided in the united states because of the incidences that are provided here.…
- 475 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
Some parents that are against spanking have good reasons as to why they choose not to spank their children. For instance, according to studies that were done at the University of Manitoba, Canada, two to seven percent of patients seen for mental disorders were linked to physical punishment as a child. “Individuals who are physical punished have an increased likelihood of having mental health disorders” (Afifi, 2012). According to a study by Tracie Afifi, an author of Today’s Pediatrics, found that 1300 people out of 35,000 responded to which,…
- 1301 Words
- 6 Pages
Good Essays -
Parents have always struggled with ways to appropriately discipline their children, especially in modern culture. Several years ago there would have been no question about acceptable forms of punishment. Today people can not parent their children the way they want to. There are radical groups out there that are dictating the way we care for them, and this is not right. When did society become so manipulative over our parental duties? Even in today’s society, a good old-fashioned spanking is still a beneficial form of punishment.…
- 1370 Words
- 6 Pages
Powerful Essays -
Is spanking an effective means of discipline for kids, or does it merely teach them to be violent? Fewer topics have generated so much emotion as whether to spank or not. First, what does the law say? Is it illegal to spank your kids? The answer is no-but parents who spank must be very careful to avoid running afoul of the law. California law defines child abuse to include any case in which a child exhibits evidence of skin bruising, bleeding, failure to thrive, burns, fractures, etc. and the condition is not justifiably explained or the circumstances indicate that the condition was not accidental. For purposes of the child abuse law, parental discipline through spanking may not be justifiable if the child is bruised or otherwise injured. Thus, spanking is not illegal, but injuring a child is.…
- 1121 Words
- 5 Pages
Good Essays -
The topic of spanking children as punishment has caused serious controversy dating back to as late as the early 1960s. This topic not only brings out the statistical points but the ethical and moral points as well. Spanking kids as physical punishment is wrong for all ages because it can not only have psychological damage but intellectual damage as well.…
- 503 Words
- 3 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
Is corporal punishment an effective way of disciplining children? Corporal punishment is a violation inflicted on children, teachers, and others in names of “discipline” which is experienced by a large majority of children in many states worldwide. In the United States, there are laws protecting children from physical abuse, including at school and home; nevertheless, most American parents think spanking is an appropriate method of discipline for children. There are some countries that have passed anti-spanking laws such as Germany, Sweden, and others, but other countries do not have any support against spanking. Spanking children can leave physical scars, affect mental problems, and be ineffective in that children do not understand which is…
- 2666 Words
- 11 Pages
Good Essays -
“According to a Harris poll conducted in 2013, four in five Americans believe that it is sometimes appropriate for parents to spank their kids.” There is a difference between spanking to teach a lesson, and spanking just because. In a study examining 20,000 kindergartners and their parents, researchers found that 80 percent of Hispanic parents admitted to spanking their children. Parents should only spank their children to discipline them, to teach them what is wrong. There should be limitations of course. One of the limitations should be with younger children one should only use one's hand, and the spanking should never leave any marks beyond redness of the skin. Another limitation would be the age you spank your child; it should not be when…
- 786 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
"The fundamental need of American education is to find ways of engaging today's children in the thrill of learning. Fear of pain has no place in that process." - The Christian Science Monitor. Because Ms. Peña and I are in compliance with this statement, we have decided to bring to the attention of the community, the corporal punishment of Sinton High School. There are many effective ways of properly punishing a disobedient student, but there are also limits to certain disciplinary measures. Grant it that a student from Sinton High School may now choose their own punishment, with consent from the parents, it is up to the administrator to keep in compliance, and with in the limits. Bruises, cuts, and/or broken skin should not occur in the process of administering corporal punishment. The eight constitutional amendment clearly states that "no cruel or unusual punishment should be inflicted." If markings are found on a student, the boundaries and law have been broken. Rupturing these boundaries surfaces the question, "Just exactly WHY are we administering the corporal punishment to students, to hurt them?" "...the use of corporal punishment in schools is intrinsically related to child maltreatment. It contributes to a climate of violence, it implies that society approves of the physical violation of children, it establishes an unhealthy norm...Its outright abolition throughout the nation must occur immediately." - U.S. Advisory Board on Child Abuse and Neglect.…
- 835 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
On one side of the debate, there are parents who believe it is okay to spank their children. On the other hand, there are those parents who think their kids should never be spanked. Part of the problem with spanking is that everybody sees it different. Spanking is seen as a form of abuse, while others think it is a form of discipline. Spanking can be a good way to discipline your kid (s), but it can also be a bad thing. I believe that spanking your kid to help getting their attention to stop doing bad things is not considered “abuse.” You should not spank your kid out of anger or frustration, but love to help straighten them out and get them back on the right…
- 1330 Words
- 6 Pages
Better Essays -
There is a big difference between spanking a child and beating a child. I believe that spanking should consist of tapping on the hand, spanking the buttocks, pinching, and small punishments of that nature. I am against parents using other objects to beat that child or physically punching or beating that child. When it comes to beating a child, that would be considered child abuse and parents can go to jail. Also abusing a child can cause them to be aggressive when they get older and abuse their spouse or children in the…
- 913 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
Your 8-year-old refuses to put away her toys. Your 11-year-old isn 't turning in his homework on time. Your 16-year-old has come home late for the third time in a row. One of the biggest challenges in raising children is providing proper discipline. Punishment sometimes comes in the form of name calling, isolating a child, or using physical force, may or may not give you immediate results. There has been increasing debate about how we can effectively discipline children - and the rights and wrongs of corporal punishment. This paper will look at (1) the change in societal views of corporal punishment of children (2) the effects of corporal punishment on children, and (3) alternatives to the use of corporal punishment on…
- 2682 Words
- 11 Pages
Powerful Essays -
Spanking has become a debatable topic for decades. Some people are in support of it, while others are against it. According to the Farlex dictionary “spanking is defined as a number of slaps on the buttocks delivered in a rapid succession as for punishment.” In reality Spanking should not be considered as a child abuse. It should only be considered an abuse based on how it is issued. Parents are not supposed to beat their child on the head or in the face. If that happens, it will cause injury to the child, which will be termed as an abuse. First of all, it is not any parent will to develop hatred towards his or her own child, but it is the behavior of the kids that will lure their parents to beating them. There are certain kids who are so difficult in a way that, no amount of words or other punishment can stop them whenever they are doing something bad. Their parents…
- 969 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
On the other hand, spanking should be considered punishable by the law because a child should never be hit for doing something wrong. As stated in a law for the State of Arizona, “ A parent or guardian or other person entrusted with the care and supervision of a minor or incompetent person may use reasonable and appropriate physical force upon the minor or incompetent person when and to the extent reasonably necessary and appropriate to maintain discipline (Spanking Laws).” Several parents of today would disagree with this reason to not spank their kid. Never is not the word that should be used in the statement towards spanking. Talking to a kid about what they did wrong sometimes isn’t enough. Taking action of something that was not okay or something they have done several times is not a bad thing. According to a study done by Parenting.com, “ 74% of mothers believe spanking is acceptable for kids ages 1 to 3.”(O’Callaghan) Studies not only help a parent realize what’s actually right, they state the facts as well. In all honesty, the law should never punish a parent for how they believe to discipline their…
- 862 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
Spankings, name-calling, and yelling mothers and fathers have corrected their children this way for years. For centuries, children were considered the property of the parents. Parents were able to discipline their children in any way they saw fit. As time has progressed, the courts have taken an interest in how children are disciplined. The courts think and people who spank their children are abusing them, children should be in the care of their biological parents, and the punishment for child abuse is adequate. Society has not done enough to protect vulnerable children.…
- 1263 Words
- 6 Pages
Good Essays