Preview

Nanook of the North vs Exile

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
621 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Nanook of the North vs Exile
Anna Harris
February 14, 2013
Rights to Representation
First Essay Assignment
(insert title here)
Before taking this class, I didn’t realize there existed a full-length documentary about the Inuit, let alone two. After all, having grown up in the States, the only native group I’ve ever known about has been the Native American Indians. Of course, I’d heard of the eskimo before, but I knew nothing about them besides the fact that they hunted seal and lived in igloos. So, after watching Nanook of the North and Exiled, I know a lot more about the inuit than I originally did. Both films were very informative, but very different.
Nanook of the North is the more comical of the two is has a very cheery vibe to it. Of course, Robert Flaherty thought that the inuit were a happy-go-lucky group of people, so it makes sense that the film he made based on them would be so bright. The film is a basic description of everyday life for the Inuit. Flaherty shows the way they travel and hunt, and manages to keep the film bright even when the family is starving.
The one problem the film has is the fact that it isn’t real. Nanook and his family are all actors, the most Eskimo-like people Flaherty could find. Knowing that everything was staged took away from the authenticity of the film for me. Certain scenes, like the scene with the phonograph, just seemed silly and fake to me. I can’t blame Robert for any of this. After all, he did manage to make an informative film that at least looks authentic, despite the fact that the traditions in the film were no longer being practiced. On top of that, he captured the stunning landscapes of that corner of the world that many people in the 1920s had never seen before.
I also enjoyed the soundtrack quite a bit. In my opinion, one of the most important features in silent movies is the background music because people nowadays are so accustomed to films with sound. I think the music was lovely, and appropriate in each scene.
The second film,

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Powerful Essays

    Krech, Shepard. 1981. Indians, Animals, and the Fur trade. Athens: The University of Georgia Press. .…

    • 1782 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    However, White Lies about the Inuit is no dry textbook or dictionary. Even its title is playful and provocative, because it incorporates two important…

    • 588 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Igloos Research Paper

    • 398 Words
    • 2 Pages

    Not many people know how igloos have changed, but they have changed in many ways. For example, the word ‘igloo’ originates from the Inuit word ‘iglu’. Also, the large knifes the Eskimos use were originally made from bone, but as traders came in they got iron ones. Igloos were once used all the time by the Inuit as temporary homes to follow herds of animals, and they still are! But now, the women and children don’t have to live in igloos while the men are out hunting. Instead, they live in villages.…

    • 398 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The sound design is most evident in the beginning when Casey is opening the box. You can hear the iconic sounds of legos smashing together, as well as the very satisfying sounds of a metal key hitting the wood box. The rustling of paper as he is looking through all of the memories was also nice and clear. The sound of the typewriter writing was also very well done throughout the entire piece. Lastly, the score really complements the action on screen. It has an inspiring, curious, and sad mood all at the same time. Even more so, the score gets out of the way of the dialogue when it needs to, so that you can focus on the story.…

    • 1066 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    “The family is more interesting than the one named first, in so far as culture has not smudged too much of their naturalness.” Tigganick’s family is said represent the natural survival instinct that guides the Eskimos’ lives, they only seek to hunt, have food to fill their stomachs and to fill their lamps with fish oil. They know no other purpose than to survive in their rough conditions. “The survival instinct controls their whole life, they do not know any other task than to supply their stomach with fat and their lamp with fish oil, as task which under the prevailing circumstances, certainly seems big enough to fill a whole human…

    • 1192 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    The Inuits are also different because they live in the cold and this means that Inuits leave in coldest environment and they don't live in the same environment that the other tribes do.The units do travel with some of the same gear, but the Inuit use dogs unlike other tribes.Which means that the Inuits travel somewhat differently.…

    • 510 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    When the early settlers of the Americas arrived on the East coast of what is now Canada, they discovered a people that was remarkably different from their own. First impressions would deem these people as “uncivilized” (source) “savages” (source) who lived “miserable lives” (source). However, as time went on the settlers began to realize just how deeply rooted this Aboriginal culture really was. The Mi’kmaq lived a simple nomadic hunter-gatherer lifestyle, able to recognize the stars and changing of the seasons leading them to a variety of different sources of food dependant on the season. Culturally they were a spiritual group, one that believed to live with the earth, not…

    • 981 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    The Northwest tribes (specifically the Haida tribe) and the Arctic tribes (specifically the Inuit tribe) are very different from each other. To start of thy live in very different climate zones and weather. In the northwest it is usually warm and humid. In the arctic it is usually cold and freezing.In the arctic they have to be very quick and swift to catch whales, seals, and walruses. In the northwest they also have to be very quick and swift to catch prey. They both have it hard but they manage still to this day to be alive. They manage to stay alive because they work hard all day every day. In both tribes the women make and cook things like clothing, bags, sacks, and other interesting things.The men make tools and work all day. They gather…

    • 400 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    While watching the video, “Reel Injun” it made me realize how much the First Nations people as a culture were impacted and wrongfully stereotyped. The video was very informative on how they were viewed and how the Western Europeans portrayed them in the Western Films.…

    • 448 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Shaun Of The Dead Satire

    • 707 Words
    • 3 Pages

    The soundtrack was impressive and gave suspense and drama as where needed. The special FX was up to date and gave a realistic feel to the movie. The cinematography is what brought this film's ratings up in my opinion. I really like the irony in the lightning, Especially Pegg's use of zoom-ins and quick cuts… hilarious. Also, the camera angles of when Ed drives himself and Shaun to his parent's house dodging zombies left and right was also very entertaining. I believe I almost jumped out of my seat in fright when Ed hit the lurking zombie speeding down the…

    • 707 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    JOHN L. TOBIAS Canada's Subjugation of thePlains Cree,ß879- 885 ONE THEMOST OF PERSISTENT MYTHS Canadian that historians perpetuate is that of the honourableand just policyCanadafollowedin dealing with the PlainsIndians. Firstenunciated the Canadianexpansionist in literature of the 187os as a means to emphasizethe distinctive Canadian approach and the uniquecharacter theCanadian to of west, 1 it hasbeengivencredence G.F.G. Stanleyin hisclassic Birthof by The Western Canada, and by all those who use Stanley's • work as the standard interpretation Canada's of relationship the Plains with Indians in the period 187o-85. Thus students taughtthat the Canadian are government paternalistic far-sighted offeringthe Indiansa was and in meansto becomecivilizedand assimilated into white society the by reservesystem,and honest and fair-minded in honouring legal commitments made in the treaties. The PlainsIndians, and particu• larlythe Plains Cree,are saidto be a primitivepeople adhering an to inflexible system traditionandcustom, of seeking protect to themselves against advance civilization, takingup armsin rejection the of and of the reservesystem and an agricultural way of life.4…

    • 11622 Words
    • 47 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    E The traditional lifestyle of the Inuit is adapted to extreme climatic conditions; their essential skills for survival are hunting and trapping. Agriculture Was never possible in the millions of square kilometres of tundra and icy coasts from Siberia to Northern America and Greenland. Therefore, hunting became the core of the culture and cultural history of the Inuit. Thus, the everyday life in modern Inuit settlements, established only some decades ago, still reflects the 5,000-year-long history of a typical hunting culture which allowed the Inuit peoples and their ancestors to achieve one of the most remarkable human accomplishments, the population of the Arctic.…

    • 1629 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Essay Paper

    • 1079 Words
    • 5 Pages

    In this essay, the articles ‘Listen to the north’ by John Ralston Saul and ‘Which ‘Native’ History? By Whom? For Whom?’ by J.R. Miller will be analyzed, specifically looking at each authors argument and his appeal to ethos, logos and pathos. In the first article, ‘Listen to the North’, author John Ralston Saul argues that current Canadian policy when it comes to our north, and the people that reside there, is out of date and based on southern ideals that hold little bearing on the realities that face northern populations. He suggests instead that the policies and regulations should be shaped by people who know the territory and it’s needs, namely people who live there. In the second article, ‘Which ‘Native’ History? By Whom? For Whom?, Author Jim Miller discuses conventions in recording native history, focusing on an area he refers to as native-newcomer history. He discusses topics such as who should be recording said history, and for whom it should be intended, as evidence in the title. Both of these articles provide arguments that appeal to ethos, logos and pathos, but it is my opinion that John Ralston Saul makes a more convincing argument to his audience in ‘Listen to the north’ than Jim Miller makes in ‘Which ‘Native’ History? By Whom? For Whom?’.…

    • 1079 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Inuit Haie Tribe

    • 594 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Before other people came to Canada their interesting tribes.The tribes that live in Canada like the Inuit, Haida, and the Sioux all have unique stories.The Inuit, Haida, and the Sioux have their differences and they have things in common, I will tell all of those right now.…

    • 594 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Inuit Youth Suicide

    • 1824 Words
    • 8 Pages

    He conducts his research through ethnographic fieldwork from 2004-2005, which includes 27 interviews with Inuit between the ages of 17 and 61. Overall he states that the rapid culture change in Inuit society has left the colony destabilized within their kinship social organization which leads to high suicides rates in male youth. The Inuit people had to assimilate to a totally different social structure when the government began to control their region in the 1950’s. The forced colonialism inevitably ruined the kinship and social structure of the community. This newly unstable society has greatly affected the modern day Inuit…

    • 1824 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Powerful Essays