Preview

National Memory Book Review

Powerful Essays
Open Document
Open Document
1398 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
National Memory Book Review
National Memory is a broad term that has previously been discussed by multiple scholars (Andrews, Park, Sturken). There has not yet been a consensus on the definition of national memory by scholars, however I define national memory as a dynamic form of collective remembering defined by shared historical experiences and cultural artefacts. National memory, to me, contributes to national identity and helps establish the legitimacy of the dominant narrative. It is a form of memory that is mutual to members of a nation, but fails to voice the experience of the individual. National memory has been extensively researched by many scholars. There have been multiple relevant studies done on how national memory can be skewed over time through the works …show more content…
Told from his perspective, Joe discusses his experience and his life in Gorazde, a U.N. designated Safe Area in Bosnia. This graphic narrative also features personal anecdotes of many Bosnians themselves as they talk about their role in the war or how the war affected them. I will use this book to argue that National Memory can be used to compare how the memory of a nation differs from individual memories of survivors. Safe Area Gorazde demonstrates how the Bosnian War differs from others recollection of it. First, I will begin by discussing the importance of landscape in Safe Area Gorazde and how it can be used by some locals as a replacement to cultural artefacts of national memory. Second I will discuss the overlap between individual’s remembering of the Bosnian War with a focus on the distinctiveness between their …show more content…
The Blue Road in the story is representative of freedom, as it was the road used by Americans to get from Gorazde to Sarajevo. This, like the Drina River is full of symbolism for the Bosnian locals. While the Drina represented war, death and bodies, the Blue Road symbolized freedom. At the end of the novels, when the locals from Gorazde were able to use the Blue Road safely, it dignified a positive change for the citizens of Bosnia. The Blue Road can be seen as a cultural artefact because it too serves as a physical reminder of past conflict, however instead of instilling fear like the Drina River, it embodies a positive resolution. While some countries may dedicate monuments to fallen soldiers celebrating their war victories, the Bosnian locals can utilize the Blue Road to showcase their war

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    In his “Safe Area Gorazde” Joe Sacco describes his experience visiting a Muslim enclave during the Bosnian War of 1991-1995. Tragically, this work is based on testimonies of residents of Gorazde, allegedly a UN-protected area where Bosnian Muslims are able to take refuge to avoid the ethnic cleansing perpetrated by the Serbian army. Gorazde is anything but protected which Sacco demonstrates throughout the book by ridiculing the UN and the US who are able to and responsible for protecting the residents of such enclaves, but instead turn a blind eye to what was going on. “…the U.N. extended safe area status to other Bosnian enclaves, including Gorazde. But the U.N. had yet to work out what the concept meant”, Sacco says (Sacco, 148). These designated “safe” areas are completely abandoned by the authorities who promise to watch over them, despite being some of the most dangerous places on Earth. The entire world seems to ignore the brutalities going on there – the destruction of towns, massacre of men, raping of women, and the murder and neglect of children. The residents have nowhere to go, have no hope, and little or no access to basic necessities. These conditions and the abandonment which leads to them is the central theme of this work. Sacco wants us to feel this situation and he succeeds. By the end of “Safe Area Gorazde” one is left seething. “Safe area”, as Sacco’s title suggests, was a new entry in the Orwellian lexicon during the Bosnian conflict. As Hitchens states in the introduction to the book, “the contempt is reserved for the temporizing, buck passing, butt covering “peacekeepers” who strove to find that swamp of low and “middle” ground into which the innocent are being shoveled by the aggressive” (Hitchens, Introduction). This is a great, if brief, explanation of the evolution of the word “safe”.…

    • 978 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    The Bosnians, Croats, and the Serbs eventually come to an agreement after acknowledging the disastrous effects of engaging in war (Sacco 212). Both sides demobilize the troops, and Gorazde rejoice. The Bosnians evicted from their homes return to their homes. The peacemaking makes residents realize the time wasted in battlefields and get used to the new situations as they resume their normal activities. Sometimes, wars bring peace, but they do so if one group decides to give up or both sides reach a compromise where they decide to start a peacemaking settlement. However, the peacemaking settlement must include some form of forgiveness and considers the causes of the war, which then help people to start a new life, as well as, live peacefully with one…

    • 2117 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Better Essays

    Bosnian Genocide

    • 1041 Words
    • 3 Pages

    The Bosnian Genocide is one of the most horrific events of our modern history. Under the former Yugoslavia, different ethnicities were all compressed under the regime of Josip Broz “Tito”, who managed to keep them united for 35 years, however after the death of Tito, violence escalated. Under General Ratko Mladić’s leadership, neighbors started killing neighbors, and changed the way Serbs, Bosnians and Croats treat each other up until now. Forgiveness for the killings is still hard to find, though more people are beginning to see the benefit in forgiving, and slowly the ethnic groups affected by the Bosnian Genocide are started to move toward each other.…

    • 1041 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    I would like to introduce to you today the concept of history and memory, and how these ideas can change from either individual to individual, or have a changing presence throughout time. History and memory are independent concepts, but largely rely on each other to interpret the full meaning behind a certain event. History can be anything that has helped shaped the world we live in today, and is generally based upon factual evidence and recordings. However, memories are the opinions created by each person and are normally subject to our own personal bias .…

    • 1329 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Witness Holocaust

    • 725 Words
    • 3 Pages

    The power of trauma can destroy testimonies and thus it is crucial for the post- Holocaust generations to preserve the memories of the Holocaust. In this paper, I have argued that the importance of proxy witnesses reinforces the living connection between the past and the present through the help of first-hand witness testimonies. Especially in the case of the Holocaust being “an event without a witness”, the living memories in this current time is the last effort for anyone to study the knowledge directly. Soon after, the Holocaust will be taught and learned all from proxy witnesses. As the time progress, the only matter that does not change is the history. Let us hope all the survivors of the Holocaust can make their individual stories to serve as a treasure to the history and not the epigraph only on their…

    • 725 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    “History repeats itself” is a phrase commonly heard and used by many people. After World War I, The League of Nations was formed as an international organization to preserve world peace. However, after World War II it became evident that the League was ineffective in its prevention, so it was replaced by The United Nations in 1945. The purpose was to become a collective international organization of countries to prevent events such as war and genocide from occurring, after witnessing the horrific atrocities of WWII. However, even after the formation of the UN, several other wars and genocides had occurred between 1945 to today, and in particular there was a brutal genocide in Bosnia. Bosnia lies next to the Adriatic Sea, paralleling the “boot” of Italy. Bosnia was part of the Austro-Hungarian Empire from 1878 to World War One. After the War, the geographical area became Yugoslavia. By 1980 the population of Bosnia consisted of 2 million Bosnian Serbs and Croats (Catholic Christians) and over 1m Bosnians (Sunni Muslim), all claiming Bosnia as their homeland.1 After the breakup of Yugoslavia in the early 1990s, tensions were rising in Bosnia and Herzegovina; between two ethnic groups, the Bosnians (Muslims) and the Serbs. It was clear a war was on the rise, but the UN’s repeated failure on multiple issues allowed what could have been a preventable war and genocide to happen. Firstly, the UN tried to limit their involvement in the war by sending only a limited number of troops for humanitarian purposes. Furthermore, they attempted to set up safe zones, which failed miserably because their forces were too widespread and the areas were open and exposed, easily allowing them to be taken over. Additionally, the Dutch soldiers that were guarding the safe areas were ill equipped and exhausted due to lack…

    • 2354 Words
    • 10 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Better Essays

    Memories make up the past and what individuals have experienced in life over time. Memories do not allow for us to forget what has happened, this is why preserving memory is so important. If something is forgotten, it is as if it never happened, which is tragic since that history was not kept alive. This section of movies focused on how filmmaking preserves historical memories. I have come to the conclusion that films preserve historical memory by making the background the memory they want you to remember. We see this in all three films that war is the canvas of the film and is preserved through the details of the individual's own recollections of the events. In this paper I will focusing on Peter Davis’s documentary Hearts and Minds; John…

    • 1381 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    1. The area has for centuries been comprised of long-suppressed religious and ethnic differences. Yugoslavia had always been made up of rival ethnic and cultural groups. Historically made up of Catholic Croats, Orthodox Serbs, and Muslim Bosniaks. In addition to cultural and religious differences, the area is strategic in accessing the Mediterranean, and has always been a flashpoint between the Ottoman Empire and the Hapsburg Empire.…

    • 703 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    By October 1998, the dictator of Serbia – Slobodan Milosevic – took Kosovo into a war. The presidential period of Milosevic was the bloodiest tyranny of Europe. Serbians were marching and protesting day by day, however, the protest was not enough. The Serbian’s world was filled of concentration camps, poverty, corruption, political instability, police brutality, and economic and social disintegration. The governmental institutions were “manipulated by the ruling regime and where neither human rights nor the rule of law existed” (Tongeren et al., 2005, p. 545). Citizens of Serbia started to feel hopeless showing their lack of interest for their own life, feeling apathetic and desperate. Millions of refugees and massive bombing camps during…

    • 154 Words
    • 1 Page
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    To struggle and even to die in order to avenge Kosovo became the common goal of generations. The roots of this fierce are found in Serbian literature written not long after the battle itself” (Emmert, 62). Here, we understand the strong collective memory associated with the loss of Kosovo and the desire of redemption by reclaiming the territory. Individuals involved in the battle who perished were described as martyrs through the eulogies and sermons written by religious figures portraying Lazar as “God’s favored servant” (Emmert, 62).…

    • 940 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    "Collective memory" is a term used to describe a pool of shared or recollected information held by a group, as a community or culture, and passed from one generation to the next.…

    • 685 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Cultural Memory: Quickly glancing at “memory” it seems to be something passive, something that is stuck in the past and will not physically reappear. It is something that has happened and is stuck in time, along with people, places, smells and etc. If you take a closer look at “memory though, it reveals that it is dynamic and connects all intellectual and emotional dimensions together. Cultural memory is symbolic.…

    • 2181 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    For as long as times could be remember people with differential ethic background, cultural, and religion; many of those are confronted by means of hatred. Disregarded from beginning to end, absolute dictatorship commonly look right through them freely. They hid their existence for a long times; unexpectedly they begin to rise onto the to surface seeking for “identity and self-concept”, with many effort this came to be the beginning called social memory the author’s indicate “the very first reason for memory staying in the agenda for a long time is tragic and dramatic stories while the second reason is to replace remembering with…

    • 104 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Bosnian War Essay

    • 555 Words
    • 3 Pages

    The Bosnian War, was one of horrific had broad impacts locally and universally. From setbacks to the universal reaction, a portion of the impacts changed the lives of Bosnians until the end of time. In this exposition, we talk about a portion of the impacts of the war, that left many thousand dead, scores of others and injured and social structures harmed.…

    • 555 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    It was the period of World War 2, from 1941 to 1945; Nazi Germany, together with Croatian Ustaša, fighting against the multi – ethnic Yugoslav partisan on the Balkans. It was the Partisans against everybody, facing opposition from all sides and ultimately, through courage and Tito’s military genius, the ones who prevailed in the end. The sacrifice was immense. More than one million died fighting the Nazis, with many more wounded or missing.…

    • 1525 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Better Essays