Preview

National Parks: a Double Edged Sword?

Powerful Essays
Open Document
Open Document
1765 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
National Parks: a Double Edged Sword?
National Parks: A Double Edged Sword?

Justin Pearly

Environmental History
Prof. Mark Bishop Newell
Tuesday July 21, 2009

Pearly 1 Few places can match the sheer diversity of wildlife and culture that exists in the country’s national park system. Humans, with the future in mind, have “set aside” these beautiful sites of wonder and awe. But at what cost? Do national parks end up being good and bad at the same time? Our national parks are a supposed to be a natural treasure. Here the unspoiled grandeur and beauty of nature can be appreciated in its most pristine form. However, the amount of people that are visiting these parks has risen to levels that threaten the very beauty and well-being of these paradises. Its now seems apparent that there is a price to pay for allowing humans into an area that did not have many humans before. To understand the present state of the nation’s parks, and ultimately their entire future, it is crucial to first look back at the past. The first national park was Yellowstone National Park. This sprawling park contains such amazing geological and biological sites that it had been considered a national park long before it was ever officially named one. Its combination of diverse wildlife, and geologic features such as, waterfalls, canyons, geysers, and hot springs made it obvious to any who had experienced it, that this was a place that should be preserved just the way it was. That was why in 1872, President Ulysses S. Grant made it officially the world’s first national park. The only problem being, it was a completely unique creation, the first of its kind. This means that all ground that they covered would be new. Due to inconsistencies with the way national parks were being governed, and the fact that there were was no central governing body for national parks Congress created a
Pearly 2
National Park Service that would operate within jurisdiction of the Secretary of the interior. Signed by President



Bibliography: De Voto, Bernard. “Shall we let them ruin our national parks?” Saturday Evening Post, July 22, 1950. Chittenden, Hiram Martin. The Yellowstone National Park Beckman, Wendy Hart. National Parks in Crisis: Debating the Issues (Berkley Heights: Enslow, 2004) Wendy Hart Beckman, National Parks in Crisis: Debating the Issues (Berkley Heights: Enslow, 2004) Beckman 18, 19 Beckman 65-68 Beckman 19, 20 Beckman 14, 15, 53

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Satisfactory Essays

    Long Term: The Antiquities Act of 1906 signed by Theodore Roosevelt is the original authority for nearly a quarter of the 413 sites that make up the national park system. The Antiquities Act lead to more than 100 million acres of national forests. Now there are national wildlife refuges in every state. Theodore create wildlife revitalization and…

    • 138 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    According to the Preface (xvii) of Crimes Against Nature, Jacoby explains his belief of American history as he states “American history is a history that regards humans and nature not as two distinct entities but as interlocking parts of a single, dynamic whole”. Though his ideas have a broad selection, Jacoby constructs his argument on three case studies he has previously done: the creation and administration of Adirondack Park by the State of New York in the late nineteenth century; the federal government efforts to manage Yellowstone National Park through civilian life and military activities between the 1870s and 1910s; and the different protection ideas and efforts at the grand canyon by different public land agencies from the 1890s and 1930s. In each one of these cases, selecting certain boundaries and rules for these areas had consequences for the residents who lived in that area. In Adirondack Park in New York, the mountains surrounded some of the little towns and abutted others meaning a serious concern of limited use of the forest for natural…

    • 1739 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    My first concern is the amount of money being spent for development compared to how much is being used for sustaining the environment. National parks provide an extremely unique learning experience for millions of visitors every year, but in order to maintain it, we need to have more spent on conserving the ecosystem. In 2012 Parks Canada slashed the budget of conservation and science while doubling the budget for tourism and development in national parks. Furthermore, in 2015-2016 only 13% of Parks Canada’s spending was dedicated to nature conservation.…

    • 547 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Olmsted was best known for the creation of the New York City Central Park. He was a strong proponent of conserving the Yosemite scenery and predicted that Yosemite will attract millions of people; “far noblest park or pleasuring ground in the world.” Interestingly enough, at the start, Olmsted did not like Yosemite’s landscape. Slowly he fell under its spell. His first action was to hire geologists with the single goal of drawing a survey of Yosemite. He was motivated to attract millions of people, he once said, “An injury to the scenery so slight that it may be unheeded by any visitor now, will be one of deplorable magnitude when its effect upon each visitor’s enjoyment in multiplied by these millions.” Olmsted, among many others in the beginning of the park's history, was a strong advocate of teaching and encouraging the eager people to love the beauty of the place without exploring it for personal…

    • 1202 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Isle Royale National Park

    • 1934 Words
    • 8 Pages

    Scott, Doug. The Enduring Wilderness: Protecting Our Natural Heritage Through the Wilderness Act. (Golden: Fulcrum Publishing,…

    • 1934 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    They insist on visiting a national park because it is a place where nothing is man-made and everything seems more refreshing. By visiting a national park, people are hoping to have a mind clearing experience and a change of heart to someday appreciate the importance of our natural resources. Visitors may consider nature as the world of living things and the beauty of outdoors in its rarest form. Visitors receive the opportunity to learn more about nature’s history, different animals, landmarks, and the fundamentals of nature that they wouldn’t see outside of a national…

    • 606 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    This was to gain support in creating a national park in the state of Hawaii. January 20, 1916 was the date of the fourth and final draft of the Hawaii National Park bill; this was introduced by Jonah Kuhio. The committees met and on April 17 the House approved the bill. Then the Senate followed and on August 1, 1916; our president at the time President Wilson signed the bill into law and created the twelfth National Park. It wasn't until five years later that a group of people got together at the crater for the dedication of the Hawaii National Park. In the early years of this park the five year period was due to a restriction in one of the clauses which required that the park be "reasonably accessible in all of its parts" before the public funds could be used to maintain and develop areas of the park. The first superintendent of the Hawaii National Park came into office in April of 1922. His name was Thomas R. Boles; he was also an engineer by training. He had the first park headquarters built in 1923 by the parks staff and…

    • 739 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Olympic National Park is known for its summits, forests, peaks, and many hiking trails for people that love the park. While the park is beautiful there are species in the park that can eventually take over the park. Species like english ivy, Japanese knotweed, scots broom, english holly, herb robert, Canada Thistle, and the Himalayan blackberry are just the worst kind of invasive species. The invasive species will take over the park when not controlled. Seeds and plant parts carried by the visitors of the park help spread new and already known species into the park. Because of visitors bringing in invasive species, there should be a “cleanse” where the visitors are brushed down for seeds before entering the park and furthering the invasion…

    • 130 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    I will focus on research conducted about current barriers to recreation since historical information was discussed previously. Erickson, Johnson, and Kivel (2009) found that economic factors that were the result of workplace discrimination, had an effect on the access the African-American population has to national parks. Additionally, they discussed how fear from historical as well as current racism was identified as a barrier to park use (Erickson, Johnson, & Kivel, 2009). Mason and Koehli discuss the socioeconomic barriers faced by much of the First Nations population which impedes ability to access recreation facilities and opportunities (2012). They also discuss the lack of suitable facilities and programs provided on reserves, this is disproportionate to the amount of programs that can be found in other areas of Canada (Mason & Koehli,…

    • 648 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    The history of National Park system presented in the video tells us the story of people from different backgrounds who devoted their lives to build the national parks. The national park idea is aimed to preserve and protect the natural resources for everyone and for all the time. Through the history of National Park that captured in the video, it showed that everyone is included, given the equal opportunity to be part of the national park, regardless of race, ethnic, gender, religion, and age. National parks are preserved for all the generations to witness the American history; they all have a chance to see these precious places, species, and plants that exist in our country and to enjoy the nature. Parks belong to everyone and all of us, it’s…

    • 362 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    National parks definitely have a big significance in American history that is not even a question. What is questioned is just how important national parks are. People like Wallace Stegner, or Ken Burns believe that national parks are America’s best idea; however, people like Clay Jenkinson, director of The Dakota Institute, or Alan Spears, of High County News, would agree that National parks are indeed not the greatest idea of America. Clay Jenkinson directly said, “National parks are not America’s best idea” (The National Parks; America’s Best Idea). Obviously it is a split issue on just how important the National Parks really are but clearly National Parks is not America’s greatest ide.…

    • 676 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    However, there is one challenge in the event of reassigning animals from zoos to national parks, human safety. While there are not many animal attacks that occur in national parks, people tend to remember the ones that do happen because they are few and therefore surprising. What most people fail to realize, though, is that animals rarely attack and hardly ever kill. Those that do attack are most commonly grizzly bears and even then it was estimated that for every thirty million visitors there might be one death and for every two million visitors there was an estimated one injury (Herrero 1148). The chances of dying by animal attack in national park are small enough that people should not worry about it. In fact, there is a higher chance of…

    • 311 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Tourism is a large and fast-growing part of any economy. However, the number of tourists is rapidly increasing so it can destroy and cause serious damage to the naturally beautiful places where they visit. Therefore, there are many opinions suggesting the governments should set rules about restricting areas toward tourists. This essay will focus on two important reasons why tourists should be restricted from areas of natural beauty.…

    • 446 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    National Parks

    • 274 Words
    • 2 Pages

    If we didn't have national parks, people would be allowed to build over ALL of the land. If people built buildings all over the land, there would be no more room for nature. No room for trees, no room for animals, just a bunch of buildings all over the place. With no trees... and no animals… we'd all die. We need national parks for survival, nature is an integral part of our lives, and we need to preserve as much of it as possible in order to keep the cycle of life flowing. Aside from its beautiful sight, national parks are protected places where endangered and other animals are allowed to live.…

    • 274 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Depending on the area and terrain National Parks provide ample opportunities to the visitors to have a close encounters with the wilds. But what is so exquisite about the Indian National Parks is the variance that they are equipped with. Whether it comes to the flora, avifauna, and aquafauna, or witnessing various wild forms in their natural surroundings on an elephant or inside a jeep, wild ventures in are simply amazing!…

    • 6379 Words
    • 21 Pages
    Powerful Essays