Reality for a group or individual is not built up of truths; rather it is built up of what is believed to be true or factual. The citizens of Oceania lacked basic human rights. They worked long hours, no sense of privacy, and clearly deprived of any happiness. It would be logical to assume that this form of government is cruel and rebellion would spread like wild fire, but the citizens of Oceania firmly believe that Big Brother is taking care of them. The reason they believe this is because they have no way to access any other source of information so they are left to accept what is told by the party. This one hundred percent belief that they are being taken care of clearly defines the reality of the citizens of Oceania, but has no validity to it. Winston starts realizing this when he reads a children’s book and says “In the end the Party would announce that two and two made five and you would have to believe it. It was inevitable that they should make the claim sooner or later: the logic of their position demanded it. Not merely the validity of the experience, but the very existence of external reality was tacitly denied by their philosophy.” This is the point where he starts realizing that the reality in which the party instills in the citizens of Oceania clearly is not based on logic (2+2=5) but is still enthusiastically accepted by the people.
Humans are social creatures, we learn socially and through second hand knowledge passed down from society. So it makes sense to believe that the building blocks of reality, the beliefs and values which make it whole, are hugely influenced by the beliefs and values that society allows to be instilled. The Nazi rule of Germany during WWII will always be remembered as one of the darkest periods in human history. Many of the values that Hitler instilled and forced upon the citizens of Germany share the same concept in which Big Brother spread their values of hate and control, making them perfect examples of each other. For both Nazi Germany and Oceania its citizens accepted the reality which practiced hate and scapegoat toward the enemy, ideas that would seem crazy in modern society and which would never be tolerated. So in Nazi Germany, why were these ideas so widely accepted? The citizens of Germany were surrounded by propaganda, the society in which they lived made it acceptable to act like that and enforced it, making the people believe that it’s the right way to think and believe, thus creating their reality. This is exactly the same way in which the party gained such control over the human mind, surrounding the people with propaganda hate, and nothing else, brainwashing the people to believe that it is the values reflected by the party is the most acceptable, and only way to act.
When it comes down to it, the true boundaries of reality are defined by what is comprehensible by the human mind, also known as the imagination. The extent of the imagination stretches out as far as what has been seen or felt. It is impossible to know exactly what it would feel like to be on Pluto. Why? This is because nobody has ever had the experience of living on Pluto. The citizens of Oceania are completely oblivious of the outside world. The only knowledge they have is that which the party as allowed them to know. This is why in the middle of hate week, when Oceania switches allies the people blamed Emmanuel Goldstein for all of the negative propaganda about Eurasia. This is clearly another lie which the party fabricates to suck the citizens of Oceania into the negativity of their reality. This is not questioned though because the only experience the people have in terms of what they have seen or felt has been controlled by the party, so whatever the beliefs values or decisions the party reflects, no matter how ridiculous, will be enthusiastically accepted by the people. When Winston goes on about his love affair with Julia, he makes love to her and his mind opens up to the true pleasures of life. The party publicizes the idea that sex is a completely pleasure less act and should only occur with intent for reproduction. When Winston makes love to her it opens his mind up to what is possible beyond what the party is telling them. So why did this happen? Winston went through an experience which was out of the ordinary, which opened up his imagination and logically magnified his rebellion against the party because he came to the realization that there is more to life than what the party is allowing them to know. These limits of reality are defined by how far the imagination can really stretch.
George Orwell does a fantastic job exemplifying the true meaning of reality. The idea that reality is merely an outcome of experience and knowledge and nothing else is exaggerated by the totalitarian rule of Big Brother and the complete control of Oceania citizens. The belief that present reality is completely valid does make it reality, even if it is not completely factual. This was shown by the residents of Oceania as it was obvious they were being fed lies but accepted with no question. Everything that is inside your reality has been influenced by society, whether it is known or not, it is impossible to control, but what really restricts reality is imagination. If the citizens of Oceania were exposed to anything other than the beliefs and values of the party, there is no way that they would act and respond to it the same way as their reality would open up to new possibilities. Considering all of this, there is no way to know what is really true and whether what we believe and value is right or wrong. We may be living in a reality in which many possibilities of life are hidden, just in the way that freedom was hidden from Oceania.
You May Also Find These Documents Helpful
-
Much of the more savage side of the Oceanian government is conveyed in the conversations that take place between Winston and O’Brien. O’Brien bluntly explains to Winston during a conversation meant to intimidate Winston to silence his growing questions about the purpose of Big Brother, “...always there will be the intoxication of power, constantly increasing and constantly growing subtler. Always, at every moment, there will be the thrill of victory, the sensation of trampling on an enemy who is helpless. If you want a picture of the future, imagine a boot stamping on a human face – forever" (34). Unlike the previous quotes from Foucault and Freud which present the triumph of the group over the individual, O’Brien allows for a glimpse into the mindset of those in power. Overarchingly, it demonstrates how individuals in positions of power view such power, and provides understanding as to why those individuals desperately try to keep power and the knowledge of how to wield such power away from those they…
- 460 Words
- 2 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
Motif- again pointing back to the theme of psychological freedom At the end, Winston writes in the dust the 2 +2= 5. It seems that he believes this which means that the citizens of Oceania are all under the mind control of the Party.…
- 3051 Words
- 13 Pages
Better Essays -
Characterized by great democratic advancement, the society has taken cautions into account. The novel has been able to carefully narrate and expose the realities of cold wars in our community. The book can demonstrate a genuine meaning of suppression as being the negation of the people, and a sign of respect to the state, the party, and the leaders. Despite the milestone made in freedom of speech and equality, the society is aware that regulations, laws, and order are a cautionary measure for a peaceful coexistence. In the novel 1984, the governing party puts in place measures of ensuring that each member of the Oceania is monitored and privately watched so that the party’s agenda is not compromised. The ruling party is aware that Winston works for the Ministry of Truth and it is not ready to have its reputation shattered by anyone.…
- 1349 Words
- 6 Pages
Better Essays -
In Oceania when you step out of line, you will be punished accordingly. That is the message George Orwell tries to get across to his reader in 1984. Since that is the notion he is trying to get his reader to understand as the author in this book, he obeys that rule as well. Orwell uses many literary devices and techniques such as symbolism, metaphors, tone, allusions, and many more… to make the reader understand what kind of society Winston is living in.…
- 907 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
Without expressing his needs and desires Winston would lose his mind and become vulnerable to the Party. Thus enabling the Party to control Winston entirely. His mother's reaction shows his relationship of love with the past and his longing for past times and attitudes. Winston's memory of the times right before he lost his mother illustrate the historical turbulence leading up to this point. This shows a clearer picture of the economic situation emerging. Winston went through the struggle of starvation and losing his family. This is makes him realize that the proles are in some ways superior to himself and other Party members, because they have maintained their humanity and their dignity. The idea of the proles persevering despite, the trying times, allows him to retain control of his mind but more importantly it gives him faith. "If there was hope, it must lie in the proles, because only there, in those swarming disregarded masses, 85 per cent of the populatio of Oceania, could the force to destory the Party ever be generated." (72) Winston does not merely dream of his family and past events. He fantasizes about "the Golden Country". The "Golden Country" is a place with pastures, trees swaying in the wind and a clear sparkling stream. This place represents Winston's ideal, where he can be at peace and not constantly dodging the Party and its tactics. The fact that Winston thinks about this in his subconscious mind is significant because he believes (as stated in Chapter Two) that the only thing you own is your brain and your thoughts. So his dreams allow him freedom from the totalitarian world in which he lives. They represent history, and the independence associated with history. The existence of the Thought Police is testament to the Party's determination to control people's thoughts as well. The Thought Police can see everything. They are capable of finding his thoughts through his diary,…
- 1002 Words
- 5 Pages
Good Essays -
Throughout the novel, Winston follows the Party’s strict rules and presents the idea of life without freedom by…
- 385 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
With brutal fighting, the dread of dying, the horrific killing. Who would want to live in a world like this? This is the state of Winston’s world with no way of changing it, this is the only way of living that the population has ever known. No one will ever know why or how the world used to be, who’s to blame? Ingsoc. Inside the party, there are four different ministries; the ministry of peace, plenty, love and truth, this gives the party the ability to control nearly every aspect of its nation. They are also able to control the past, through the ministry of truth, by ways of forgery, propaganda and lying. This runs very true to one of the party’s slogans “who controls the past, controls the future, who controls the present controls the past”. Anything the party detested from or did not approve of has the power and ability to erase and obliterate anything from history, thus meaning it had never existed. “The past was brought up to date. In this way every prediction made by the Party could not be…
- 792 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
Most people in Oceania don't know of anything that is happening around them. They seem to be going on with their lives as if nothing has changed. Winston is aware of what is going on around him, everything the government is doing. Winston is baffled that people are okay with everything. His conclusion is that maybe they have not been alive long enough…
- 994 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
As the main narration is based upon Winston’s thoughts of his surroundings, it is inevitable readers to disregard all the bleak concepts in his life. The opening chapter, Orwell’s immediately launches into descriptions of gloom, giving the readers the understanding of how horrible it is living under these revolutionists. Winston’s residential building, ‘Victory Mansions’, is shabby and decayed with “…electric currents…cut during the daylight hours…”; if these conditions are considered as ‘victorious’, there cannot be another more perfect reflection of bleakness than the life in Oceania . The deprivation of privacy described in ‘1984’ is also a significant factor. The peoples’ lives revolve literally around interrogating telescreens and posters of the “face…with a heavy black moustache and ruggedly handsome feature”. With all these Party concepts dominating people’s lives, there is absolutely no chance to escape from the harsh bleakness.…
- 972 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
In the novel, 1984, the protagonist, Winston Smith, live in a world full of thought policies, telescreens and proletarian. In Oceania, proletarian are under watch within 24 hours a day, 365 days a year, which mean they are being watched without any privacy. Also, they are not allowed to have any other thought other than what the party told them to have. For the people who do have the thought will being vaporized; never exist in the world, nobody will remember who they are anymore. The party slogan is "War is peace, Freedom is slavery, Ignorance is strength." It's apparently the opposite of reality, and it showed Oceania have a psychological control over their people. Every proletarian is required to be as orthodoxy as they can, but Winston still attempted to "stay human" by having thought on "Down With Big Brother."…
- 729 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
The Party which is the chief government rule of Oceania has strict rules limiting the person to think the way the Party thinks. The Ministry of Truth where Winston is employed does the job of destroying anything from the past that contradicts any rule of the Party or of anything Big Brother says. “Who controls the past,” ran the Party slogan, “controls the future: who controls the present controls the past,” (34). They create their own past to set up the future, if something changes now that was previously recorded, it was changed as to not harm the integrity of the Party. The ethical implications of the society are to control people and to do everything in their power to maintain sovereignty. It is the will of the Party to put fear into the minds of every citizen and alter their own free will to make them love Big…
- 884 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
In Oceania people aren’t allowed free will, they are all controlled by the party, brainwashed, and stripped of their humanity. There are no heroes allowed in this dictatorship of a country. “War is peace, freedom is slavery, ignorance is strength” (Orwell p.16) this theme continues throughout the book as the party controls every aspect of life. The country of Oceania is in an unending war with what Winston believes is Eurasia, as he looks back he is unsure how long it has been going on. Of course the party won’t let out exact details because ignorance is strength, and they wouldn’t want the people knowing that much. Even a lie can become the truth…
- 913 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
His original and personal beliefs are diminished and replaced with those of incorrect and unintelligent minds. In one instance, Winston is made to believe that 2+2= 5, when truly he knows the equation ends with a 4 really exposing the Party’s use of “alternative facts.” They pressure others to doubt what they have learned and fully commit to any information the Party provides them with. Currently, although no one is forced to believe everything that is seen and heard, the recent increase of unreliable facts, could one day lead to that of the reality in…
- 1013 Words
- 5 Pages
Good Essays -
Anyone who has ever read "An Occurrence at Owl Creek Bridge" will not soon forget. The storyline creates fantasy with verbal irony, dramatic irony, and irony of situation. The story is brilliantly written and full of suspense; with the superior use of character and the technique in the narrative flows together to produce irony with the intention to provoke surprise. This story is told with emotional realism, but irony in situation ending secures it vividly into the reader's mind.…
- 659 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
Perception and reality are two completely different ideas, they are accepted as they are understood and acted upon what is seen. Perception is how a person can see something whereas reality is how things actually are. For example, if you are driving and see the car in from of you, your perception would be that they are drunk driving but when they get pulled over by the police down the road, reality would say that the person was having a diabetic seizure. Most people have different perception but we all have the same reality. One person would think that someone is drunk driving while the other thinks that the driver is just messing around with his kids. In the cartoon, there is a man stranded on an island and a man in a boat approaching the island. They both shout out “I’m saved!” but in fact the man on the island is tired of being there and the man on the boat is tired of being at sea. They both have the idea that if they switch places they will be in a better position but will soon turn out to be in the same position as the other person. As I stated earlier, people have a different perception on certain things but the reality will always be the same. The meaning of this picture, in my opinion, is that people can see things from their point of view and act upon it differently than another person in the same position. They can have different thoughts, ideas, even actions but in the end they will end up doing almost the same thing. The man on the island is excited to go on the boat to try and get home but after being on that boat for a while he will realize that he would much rather on the island. The man on the boat approaching the island is excited to get off the boat but will soon realize he would rather be with the other person so he is not alone. The difference is what is real versus what is seen.…
- 363 Words
- 2 Pages
Satisfactory Essays