Top-Rated Free Essay
Preview

Northern Ireland vs. the Protestants

Better Essays
1234 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Northern Ireland vs. the Protestants
The true causes of unrest are sometimes difficult to determine. Frequently, there are a mixture of political alliances, economic differences, ethnic feuds, religious differences and others: This paper looks at the unrest between the Catholics and Protestants in Northern Ireland.
In Northern Ireland, "the troubles" are partly rooted in Catholic/Protestant differences, partly in political allegiances, and probably partly in hatreds that go back so far that the exact reason is lost in the mists of time.
Let 's take a minute to look at the history of Ireland. Saint Patrick (c.389-461), the patron of Ireland, came from England to Ireland to convert the inhabitants to Christianity. At the time, the only Christian religion was Catholicism. He came to educate the people and succeeded beyond any rational expectation, as Ireland eventually became almost exclusively Christian, as well as a center of scholarship and culture. Even when the Protestant Reformation swept through Europe and England in the 16th Century, Ireland remained staunchly Catholic, thereby triggering the Catholic versus Protestant conflict that plagues Northern Ireland today.
The five monarchs of the 118 year Tudor Dynasty in England (1486-1603) particularly Henry VIII (r.1509-47) and his daughter Elizabeth I (r.1558-1603) -- had an enormous impact on Ireland and its people. In addition to imposing Poynings Law on Ireland, they ousted the Catholic Church and replaced it with a Protestant Church, thereby sowing the seeds for centuries of religious conflict in Ireland. They extinguished the "Kildare Supremacy" and established the principle that the King of England automatically became King of Ireland. They partially destroyed Irish culture through an "anglicization" program that imposed England 's language, laws, culture and religion on Ireland; and they "re-conquered" Ireland by defeating the Gaelic lords at Kinsale, thereby extinguishing the old Gaelic order and paving the way for plantations and eventually for "union" with England.
The Battle of Kinsale, along with the "Flight of the Earls", marked the end of the old Gaelic order, and established England as conqueror of Ireland. What followed next -- the 17th Century "Plantations" -- were perhaps the most important development in Irish history since arrival of the Celts. They divided Ireland apartheid-like into two hostile camps.
Under these Plantations, the Ulster Plantation (1609), the Cromwellian Plantation (1652) and the Williamite Plantation (1693), 81% of the productive land in Ireland was confiscated from the native Irish (Gaelic-Irish and Norman-Irish alike, but invariably Catholic), and transferred to new immigrants (invariably Protestant) from Scotland and England. The Plantations impacted Ireland in two major ways. First, they introduced into Ireland a new community, eventually 25% of the populace, which differed radically from the natives not only in religion, but also in culture, ethnicity, and national identity. Second, in Ireland 's overwhelmingly agrarian economy where land equaled wealth and power (and vice versa) the Plantations caused a massive transfer of wealth and power to non-native landlords, whose backbreaking rents then thrust 85% of the natives into crushing poverty and degradation. The Plantations are the root cause of the class warfare (rich landlord versus poor tenant) and religious/cultural clashes that have plagued Ireland since 1610.
Plantations were the medieval equivalent of "ethnic cleansing" in that -- in theory at least -- all occupants of confiscated land were to be evicted and resettled in Connacht where they would be less of a military threat. Anti-Catholic animus played a role in the Plantations, but other motivations were more important. For the new immigrants, the principal motivation was fertile land at bargain rents. For the Crown, Plantations would deprive dissident Irish lords of the land that was their only real source of power; and further, there would be established within Ireland a loyal non-Irish minority which would served as an unpaid police force to keep dissident Irish in check. Halfhearted attempts at plantation had been made under Mary in the 1550s, and under Elizabeth in the 1580s, but neither had instilled the pro-English mind set sought by the Crown. But after the "flight of the earls", the time seemed right for a serious plantation program.
Although nominally directed at the aristocracy, the Plantations also devastated peasants, who suffered the loss of their property rights under the ancient Gaelic law of gravelkind, which previously had virtually guaranteed them a decent, living from the soil. It turned out that peasants were needed for hard labor, so many of them, despite the original "resettlement in Connacht" plan, were allowed to remain as farm laborers or tenant-farmers, but at low wages or backbreaking rents that thrust them into abject poverty. Predictably, both in resentful peasants and in their Gaelic lords, there developed a 285 year obsession, sometimes violent, sometimes political -- to overturn or modify the confiscations via "land reform", a term which (depending on time and place) might mean anything from a complete reversal of the confiscations to a modest improvement in tenants ' rights.
"Catholic versus Protestant" has been the convenient shorthand to describe divisions within Ireland, but this is overly simplistic. The important dividing line was between a conquering people (who happened to be British, English speaking and Protestant) and a vanquished people (who happened to be Irish, Gaelic speaking and Catholic). The conquerors then confiscated the land and wealth of Ireland, thus creating the class warfare, which has long plagued Ireland: rich landlord versus poverty stricken tenant. No one would deny that religion, ethnicity, language and culture were and still are important components in the mutual antagonism, particularly in segregating an individual into one of the two camps, but the sheer longevity of these hostilities is attributable to enduring disparities in power and wealth.
As indicate in the first paragraph and through this paper, I believe that perceptions and culture played a role in the ongoing unrest in Northern Ireland. Our perceptions of the universe represent our individual subjective reality.and culture strongly influence our subjective reality. Also, our behaviors are based on our perceptions. So how we react to our perceptions is a result of our learning and cultural conditioning. Another part of this is the beliefs, attitudes and values of a culture.
After reading the information, I believe the unrest in Northern Ireland has a long history and came to be due to the beliefs, attitudes and values of the cultures. I believe politics and the invasion played significantly into the culture and the attitudes of the people. I believe that ethnocentricity, the fact that the different cultures put their own culture and society as the top priority and having the most worth contributed as well.
If we look at Religion itself, the fact that a cultures beliefs about religion have caused conflicts throughout the ages and still does today that it is not hard to understand why the conflicts still exist in Northern Ireland today.
Is there a chance that this can be resolved? I don 't believe so until the Catholics and Protestants learn to communicate with each other and accept that they are not like each other.

References
1. Communication Between Cultures, Authors Larry A. Samovar and Richard . Porter, 1991
2. "Humans and (in)Humanity" see: http://members.xoom.com/searcheagle/human/human.htm
3. "Religious Tolerance.org" see:http://www.religioustolerance.org/curr_war.htm
4. "Desmond 's Concise History of Ireland" see. http://members.tripod.com/-JerryDesmond/index-2.html
5. "Ireland in Brief" see: http://www.irelandemb.org/infor.html

References: 1. Communication Between Cultures, Authors Larry A. Samovar and Richard . Porter, 1991 2. "Humans and (in)Humanity" see: http://members.xoom.com/searcheagle/human/human.htm 3. "Religious Tolerance.org" see:http://www.religioustolerance.org/curr_war.htm 4. "Desmond 's Concise History of Ireland" see. http://members.tripod.com/-JerryDesmond/index-2.html 5. "Ireland in Brief" see: http://www.irelandemb.org/infor.html

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Better Essays

    Aa big part of this was because of the potato famine they experienced that put a heavy toll on Ireland financially. Considering a good portion of Ireland was Roman Catholic, politically stuck together as one big voting body. They were very dominate in their ways and very tough. They disliked the British and the blacks and feelings were mutual. However, many Americans disliked the Irish because they increased competition for jobs for natives.…

    • 1579 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    England was experiencing a rising conflict in its country in large part from religious conflict between different types of Protestants and factors including financial problems Charles I experienced as King. England was a Protestant country and when Charles I started implementing changes to the church, many got upset and fears he was turning the nation to Catholicism. Charles I also didn't spend his money wisely, just like his father, and found himself in the need to find more money in different ways. With Charles finding new ways to get money, he upset many people. England’s civil war in 1642 arose in large part due to differences in religious attitudes, the authority of the King and the lack of money he had in England.…

    • 1645 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Between 1547 and 1559 England was faced with numerous rebellions in response to the changes in regimes. During Somersets protection of Edward VI there was a major rebellion due to Somerset introducing the Act of Uniformity 1549 which lead to the creation of the new Book Of Common Prayer. This is known as the Western Rebellion, this caused major problems for Somerset as it showed that the majority of the people were against his regimes and wanted the country to remain Catholic, therefore this shows that England was torn apart by religious revolutions because if Somerset would have not tried to reverse the laws of Catholism the rebellion would have never happened. Another rebellion that was caused by religion was Wyatts rebellion, even though the main motive for this rebellion was due to her marriage to Phillip II of Spain many of the Wyatts urban supporters came from Maidstone which was a Protestant stronghold. Also the rising only occurred in the South which is evidence that it could have been religiously motivated as the majority of the South were Protestants and the Northerners where Catholics. Consequently this proves that England was torn apart by religious…

    • 710 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    For well over a century, there has been political turmoil throughout the Irish isle stemming from the British occupation of Northern Ireland. With this occupation goes a tradition of armed resistance to the British military and other political installations. This tradition generally only found effective expression when large sections of the Irish people, faced with the British government's denial of the legitimate demand for Irish independence, exercised the right to use armed struggle (Coogan 10). The Irish Republican Army (IRA) was formed after the Easter Rising of 1916, which was the first major uprising in Irish history. Their goal was to remove the British from the Irish isle and unite Ireland once and for all under home rule. Although many may consider the IRA to be nothing more than a terrorist faction that has had no political strength and puts its own best interests first, it is clear that their actions have influenced Irish and British politics and that, even through violence, they keep the best interests of their people at heart. To this day, however, the British maintain that their influence is needed in the north and have yet to show any signs of…

    • 2516 Words
    • 11 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In fact there’s no doubt that Irish helped stirred America history, bringing fresh ideas on the economy, politics and fighters to achieve America freedom. For instance, The Jackson Family or the Kennedys are true families that show that Irish immigrants brought new ideas and shaped America. Andrew Jackson was a soldier, who fought in New Orleans to defeat the British colonies and obtain freedom to America for it, then he became president who helped Irish immigrants and to get them new opportunities, and he achieved the western expansion. There’s no doubt that Irish help built America by fighting as soldiers among other to achieve freedom, Irish became true patriots for this land because they were so grateful to have the opportunity that back in Ireland was taken away from them,…

    • 486 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    As far back as the 1600s there has been trouble between the people of Ireland. The people were divided into two groups, the Catholics and the Protestants. Both groups believed that they were superior over the other. Protestants believe Catholics were not entitled to equal rights. The Catholics fought back causing a divide in the country.…

    • 154 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Saint Patrick was a very influential person who converted the pagan Irish to Christianity. And not just is he an inspiring role model and saint to Christians, but he is also an iconic symbol of Ireland and its history…

    • 650 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The formation of the United Irishmen association portrays the disunity in Ireland over British politics. The United Irishmen called on French help in their 1798 rebellion. This raised the fear of French invasion strengthening the failure of the rebellion. Nonetheless, the existence of the rebellions within Britain in the eighteenth century confirms that not everyone wanted a united kingdom, and they were prepared to fight against it. The final evidence of disunity in the British Isles was the support from the established churches to the government and the national war effort.…

    • 1349 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Best Essays

    The English Civil Wars of 1642 to 1651 had religious connections indefinitely, yet to say that they were wars of religion is slightly blindsided. Economics, national and foreign policy and the rule of King Charles I all played pivotal roles in the wars, in particular, the role of the King and his failings to rule. Such failings lost support for the King on a large scale and led to the argument that this was the beginnings of democracy where the people wanted to look elsewhere from the monarchy for a better governed country. The wars were not fought intently for religion but instead against the monarchy and the dreadful rule of King Charles I for a better led democracy. Such democracy was largely connected and associated with the Parliamentarians who offered opposition to the failing Royalists and hope for change. With the Royalists and the Parliamentarians fighting for power and for leadership of their country, two parties with no major religious qualms were set to go to war. For the Roundheads, the ultimate desire was not religious but was to “safeguard parliaments place in the constitution from the creeping threat of royal absolutism’ that had seemed to be prevalent since at the least 1626.” The parliamentarians offering opposition to the Royalists were in a political sense, seen as the answer in the search of democracy through which they gained mass support. However in answering the question, religious connections must be analysed with a mind on the importance to the civil wars.…

    • 2119 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Best Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Irish Imperialism

    • 1269 Words
    • 6 Pages

    England learned a lot about its colonization of Ireland. David B. Quinn, also known as D.B.Q., has explored the connections between Ireland and the new world in two of his books; Raleigh and the British Empire and The Elizabethans and the Irish. In his books D.B.Q. discussed how the English conceived negative connotations towards the Irish population and how they dealt with it. At some points the English sought to convey their better ways, and to convert the Irishman into Englishman. At other times the English just wanted to be dominant over the Irish. England learned from their many mistakes in its Irish Colonies. In Quinn’s The Elizabethans and the Irish he frequently discussed two particular principles that characterized Tudor policies…

    • 1269 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    The modern political history of Ireland can be separated into two time periods. The first period is it's time spent under British rule as only one territory of the United Kingdom. The second period, which represents the beginning of the modern Irish state, took place during the early twentieth century. The road to national sovereignty was neither easy nor short as Britain was far from eager to let its dependent state go. The first organized movement towards independence occurred in 1916 when revolutionaries declared Ireland to be free from British rule on Easter of that year. Despite the ultimate failure of this initial push towards freedom Britain eventually granted the southern 26, of 38, counties dominion status in 1921. Further steps were taken in 1937 when Ireland drafted its constitution and was granted full sovereignty. The final phase in southern Ireland's independence came in 1949 when its status as a British commonwealth ended and the nation was declared a republic. However, even after disassociating itself from the United Kingdom the southern counties of Ireland wouldn't be completely satisfied as long as the remaining 6 counties that comprised Northern Ireland were still a part of Britain's empire. The predominantly protestant northern counties of Ireland have been a barrier to peace in the region from the first days of the Republic up to today. These counties are considered as a separate state but can also be considered as the same nation. This topic will be explored in more depth after the explanations of both the current Irish state as well as what can be considered the Irish nation.…

    • 1583 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    A civil war between Ireland and Britain seemed inevitable by the 27th of July 1914. Problems had been brewing in Ireland between Protestants and Catholics since the time of Oliver Cromwell. However, it was not until the introduction of the third home rule bill which made it seem likely that Ireland would finally be independent, that the problems between the Catholic nationalists and Protestant unionist caused major concern for Britain and the likely outbreak of a civil war.…

    • 2994 Words
    • 12 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Over the centuries the Irish people suffered from war, hunger, abuse, occupation, and religious persecution but through it all remained the people they knew who they truly were. The Irish people are arguably the most persecuted society in the western world but through all the suffering the Irish people held true to their culture and fought for what was theirs. The British Empire may have released their control over many countries with a struggle but none like the battle for the Emerald Isle. The Irish fought tooth and nail and emerge as an independent nation. There are 10 events that I believe contributed to the creation of the Eire over the centuries.…

    • 687 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Eventually, the Irish were able to become really important in their communities, and Catholicism became one of the biggest Christian groups in…

    • 441 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Analyse the role and the influence of the Catholic Church in the Irish education system to date.…

    • 2230 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Powerful Essays