“Organs for Sale” is an argument written in response to the on-going ethical debate of a market-based incentive program to meet the rising demands of organ transplants. With many on the waiting list for new organs and few organs being offered, the author, Sally Satel, urges for legalization of payment to organ donors. Once in need of a new kidney herself, Sally writes of the anguish she encountered while facing three days a week on dialysis and the long wait on the UNOS list with no prospective willing donors in sight. She goes on to list several saddening researched facts on dialysis patients survival rates, length of time on the UNOS wait list, and registered as well as deceased donor numbers. While Sally is…
Another concern about selling organs is that the poor will not be able to buy organs, its going to become like e bay market where people bid and the poor will not have a chance and therefor die.…
Compensating donors for organ donations is one of the most controversial debates we have today. The shortage of organ donations in America is the one of the main reason there is a sudden drive to supplement the possible sources of organs. It first began with the move from donations of organs from cadaver to donations from living donors, and no the debate is rerisen, to the possibility of building a market for organ donations with a financial incentive.…
There has always been a debate between creating a legal market for organs rather than accepting the fact that the black market will always exist. If there had to be a decision made regarding the legalization of organ purchases, my answer would be a definite no. Many people can argue and come up with plenty of reasons as to why it should or should not be legalized but in the end the meaning of an “Organ Donor” would be taken away.…
There are donors selling their organ(s) to gain profits. Basically, it is the poor who could use the money and thus, selling the organ(s) to the rich. The wealthier buyers would have the upper hand and can easily secure themselves an organ. Indeed it could help save the lives of the rich but how about the poor? Not only do the lives of the rich matter, but generally the lives of all patients who are suffering do too. Priority should be given based on the severity condition of the patient on the wait list, paying attention to the suitability of the organ from the donor to the patient (eg. Blood type). Possibly, the patient’s immune system should match with the donor in order to receive the organ, else it could go wrong (KidneyLink, 2014). If the above system fails, patients might start looking for alternatives to retrieve an organ and in this case, by the back-door option. Some donors believe that they can survive with just one kidney and do not mind selling away one of theirs to either gain money or to save a life (Castillo, 2013). The black market sales of organs has gone as far as social media where some are seen looking to buy organs to help a family member or some to sell their organ(s) to live a better life. Besides this, black market sales is the faster option as compared to being on the waiting list in…
In the essay “Organ Sales Will Save Lives” by Joana Mackay, kidney failure is the main topic in this essay. Honestly, I did not really have an opinion on organ sales. It just knew a bit about it. However, after I read this essay, I felt like I completely agreed with her argument. She argues that the sale of human organs should be legal. As we learned, some key features in an argument include a clear and arguable position, necessary background information, and convincing evidence. In Mackay’s essay, at the very beginning of the essay, she clearly states her position, which is “Governments should not ban the sales of human organs; they should regulate it.” Throughout the entire essay she gives a lot of reasons about why she believe that the sale of human organs should be legal. Also, she pointed out that there is a black market where people can purchase and sell kidney by a very good deal. Meanwhile “there are over 60,000 people on the waiting list for kidneys, and it takes an average of 10 years for your waiting to end”, in black market, they don’t have to wait a line for ten years. This is very surprising. This evidence stood out the most for me because I did not know that people have to wait for 10 year to get a kidney. Furthermore, in the third world countries, they are willing to sell their kidney, which cost about $1000. Sadly, because they need money to by food and clothing for their family, so they are willing to do anything to get money even sale their kidney. It is so sad to know about…
As everyone knows, there are millions of people waiting desperately for an organ to save their life's. Now a days there are countries like Singapore that allows the commercialization of organs for a really high amount. Even though; United States prohibited the option to sell organs for money, I believe that having the option to save other people by selling an organ is a very smart idea. In "Yes, let's Pay for Organs" by Charles Krauthammer; a political columnist, writes an essay to demonstrate that maybe selling organs for a low price would and may help to our society in general.…
Some people strongly believe it is morally wrong to sell human organs. As with any moral issue, we can argue our differences for a lifetime. However, would we continue to challenge each other if we, or someone we love, was facing death and the only hope for a cure was through organ transplant surgery? Would we continue to waste valuable time debating while they suffer with the side effects of a temporary treatment? I believe it is time we set aside our personal viewpoints and focus on a permanent solution to this ever-growing…
During my research I’ve found many pros and cons concerning the commercialization of Organ Transplants. One of the pros would be that it shortens the waiting time for those in need of transplants. For example, if you have been on a waiting list to receive a kidney and there are more donated organs you will receive one quicker to save your life. Another pro for commercializing organ transplants are an individual’s rights to have the freedom to do what they wish with their body organs. Some people might equate this example to abortion stating that the government shouldn’t be able to tell you what to do with your body. During NOTA (National Organ Transplant) act of 1984 “one commentator has argued that the "very existence of a law forbidding alienation of organs paradoxically portrays the human body as 'an article of commerce ' that lies within the purview of Congressional power and would otherwise be subject to sale on the market."(Gwen, Mayes) There are some more pros to these organ transplants such as money incentives for those in financial strain, and tax benefits for the government. Anything that can be sold on the black market, would be more beneficial…
When it comes to being immoral, opponents also tend to include that it is against their religion. This is a matter of state and religious views that are separate, making this argument is void. With it being immoral, that is hard to understand because currently it is legal to sell ones sperm, blood plasma, and other body parts/functions. It is also legal to use a surrogate mother. If someone wants to sell their own organs, then they should be able to sell their own organs to save a life. Opponents think that there will be businesses that will pursue organs for donation. It will then escalate so bad that people will turn to violence to get organs from people so they can sell them. These opponents think that the government will allow a market without regulations. Of course the government will regulate this. They will have set prices, restrictions which will probably include that the organ seller must also be the organ donor so stealing someone else’s organ would be completely pointless. Another argument made against the market is the fact that the procedure is dangerous. When a donor is making the decision, they’re usually made aware of the dangers and have to sign a waiver. Same will go for those who sell. Opponents also tend to argue that transplants don’t extend a person’s life for that much longer. According to government statistics, the majority of people are still living five years after the operation. Specifically these statistics include 69.3% of kidney operations, 74.9% of the heart, 73.8% of the liver, and 54.4% of the lung. From this, one can conclude that these transplants do help significantly in prolonging one’s life. (Analyses* what does this mean?) This argument the opposition makes can be easily dismissed. (Why can these be…
What is the incentive for people to donate? Many believe that if the buying and selling of organs becomes legal, that this would be a unique way of not only saving thousands of lives every year, but also allowing many people to be pulled out of poverty and live a life where one’s family is provided for (Shafer and Cunningham, 2011).…
If altruism were sufficiently powerful, the supply of organs would be large enough to satisfy the demand, and there would be no need to change the present system. But this is not the case in any country that does a significant number of transplants. While the per capita number of organs donated has grown over time, demand has grown even faster. As a result, the length of the queue for organ transplants has grown significantly over time in most countries, despite exhortations and other attempts to encourage greater giving of organs.…
I agree with your reply pertaining to an organ being priceless. However, I have a respected perspective for those who are for or against, some may even agree to disagree about organ sales. This problem exist today since this is just a controversial topic. For most this is a discussed topic for those who have experienced this tragedy as reality. What about those parents with children who work and their children walking to and from school, or playing outside and an unfortunate act for organ sales relocate nearby? The uninvited or unknown possibilities can hit close to one’s home. Individuals have the right to sign, seal and deliver their own body parts rather it is right or wrong but committing an unlawful act and to harm to others for pocket…
Hence, there is a need to do more research on whether does organ sales has a positive or negative impact towards the society which includes both developed and developing…
Imagine you are in the hospital and that you have been placed on life support because you are in need of a new kidney, heart, or liver. Would you be put on the national transplant list, hoping to get the life sustaining organ you need, or would you go look for someone willing the sell the organ you are in need of? People donate their bodies to science every day so that students can dissect them and hopefully learn something. There is also approximately 18 people who die every single day while waiting for an organ transplant (www.inpublicsafety.com, 2014). In 2014 there were over 100,000 names on the national transplant list. Each month another 2,000 names are added to this list (www.inpublicsafety.com, 2014). It would be very difficult to watch someone you love die because a match for organ donation could not be found. It would be even harder to watch that same loved one die because they purchased an organ off the black-market. Organ sales are dangerous and unethical due to the selling of diseased organs, high cost of the organ, and unsanitary conditions.…