People often say they don’t want to see druggies representing their country (wherever they are from) and so they should be banned for life, but can athletes that take performance enhancing drugs be labeled as druggies. Their physically fit in shape and generally healthy, everything a typical idea of a druggie isn’t.
Lifetime bans could produce fewer convictions, because harsher punishment means greater "burden of proof"
First, the reality is that a lifetime ban represents the harshest possible punishment for an athlete, for it takes away their livelihood, often without a fall-back plan (ask a 26-year-old cyclist what their second career option is, for example). It is, literally, a case of "off with their heads", because you may as well do this. Now, in order to do this fairly, you have to be absolutely, 100% certain that you are punishing a person who deserves it. And sadly, the science is, as of this moment, not able to provide those guarantees, and there is always some doubt if an athlete wants to contest the origin of a doping positive.
So ask the following: "If there is a 2% chance of a false positive test, then how comfortable are we issuing lifetime bans?" Then ask: "If there is a 10% chance of the positive dope test being the result of contamination of supplements, then are we comfortable with a lifetime ban?"
Now, imagine being the decision maker who has to evaluate a legal case where the athlete says: "I do not contest the positive dope test, but my defence is that it came from a supplement (or meat). I was therefore not cheating." Can you confidently judge and condemn this person as a cheat?
Given the science of anti-doping today, and the complexity of these cases, I'd argue that you simply cannot make this decision, and if your punishment option is to hand out a lifetime ban, I'd argue that you're far less likely to find dopers guilty when presented with this defence!
We do not want our young people looking up to people who use drugs, but we also do not want to give those who are in admired positions of proposed authority to be forgiven of their sins. However, we are more than willing to allow those who use illicit street drugs a second and third, sometimes even a fourth chance at resolving themselves from what, these days, is being regarded as a disease instead of what it started out as- a very poor personal choice on the person who is now using.
Steroids are not safe. We all know this. Use of these sorts of drugs, when not prescribed for an actual ailment, cause more damage than good. We do not like when our heroes are found out to simultaneously be human as well as talented. It is far easier to see this sort of behavior when it is displayed by a rock star or a spoiled rich kid, but when it is our heroes, we want to punish them severely, and more so than we would if the person in question were some street hooligan with no hope for a future. We will gladly help the hooligan, because that makes us a hero. We have helped a person lift themselves out of a personal and spiritual poverty and in the process have been given the chance to tell the world that because of something that we did, whether it is directly or indirectly, that person is now, in the eyes of better society, whole again, and it was all due to something we did for them.
We are more willing to uplift an entire population of people who cannot even remember their name rather than allow those who could be the example of having done the bad thing, and now, after a lot of work and LOTS of apologizing, be the example that they were cut out to be.
I say let them have a second and third chance at it all. And why not? We let crack heads, meth heads, alcoholics and wife beaters do it. Why not someone who has access to the media who can truly be the role model that they did not ask to be when they signed those multi-million dollar contracts?
You May Also Find These Documents Helpful
-
Global Electronics, Inc. (GEI), has its main office in Sarasota, Florida and the company employs about 2,300 people at its three U.S. fabrication facilities (located in Huntsville, Alabama; Evansville, Indiana; and Reading, Pennsylvania), and has 4,000 employees at its assembly and test facility in Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia. Discrete power semiconductors and analog, digital, mixed-signal, and radiation-hardened integrated circuits for signal processing and power-control applications are at the heart of what GEI designs, manufactures, and markets.…
- 2253 Words
- 10 Pages
Better Essays -
Jose Canseco (baseball player) argues in his book, “We (the players) didn’t see performance enhancing drugs as a big deal. We didn’t see using steroids as being in the same category as cocaine, marijuana, crack, or ecstasy” (213). However, using performance enhancing drugs and taking unfair advantages over others is cheating. At the professional and Olympic level, each athlete is responsible for the drugs they consume and knowing if any of these substances are on the World Anti-Doping Code Prohibited list. Using performance enhancing drugs in professional sports is…
- 90 Words
- 1 Page
Good Essays -
Drugs in the sports world as you can see tarnish gameplay and damages a lot of athletes careers just off of one bad decision that they decided to make. The athletes discussed didn’t even need to do none of the following drugs and they could of have a the same successful careers by just working harder and having more faith in their selves. Athletes should go the extra mile to promoting not to do drugs to influence the younger generations and to also go the distance to influencing their own teammates. Drugs causes the downfall of athletes that had so much potential in their careers. The side effects of all drugs are horrible and no athletes should not want to experience those side effects. It’s always better to actually train properly and develop your body naturally instead of putting drugs in you system because at the end of the day no sport last you a lifetime. Sports are made for people to learn valuable lessons in life and to have fun with it. Putting drugs in your systems to gain a competitive edge in sports is pointless because of how they can cause you to have lifetime problems just because you wanted a bigger edge. Life is bigger than sports and it’s important that the youth and athletes know that it shouldn’t be a time where you need drugs to be dominant in sports. There are plenty of athletes that are very talented and don’t need any drugs to maintain their great performances. Drugs will always remain a…
- 1072 Words
- 5 Pages
Good Essays -
Stripping Lance Armstrong of his seven Tour de France titles for doping was a harsh blow to athletics.Armstrong’s case was a milestone in the history of sports: it marked the time when society’s worst fears came true . For years, coaches and athletes alike have been finding ways to twist the latest scientific developments for their benefit. Performance-enhancing drugs, particularly those that can slip past drug detection tests, have become prevalent in the world of sports. While some argue that sports cannot move forward without performance-enhancing drugs, the majority views doping as unethical.…
- 913 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
In the past year, there have been many stories about professional athletes getting caught or coming clean with using performance enhancers. Lance Armstrong was stripped of all medals after beingaccused of PEDs. He later came clean to the public, apologizing. He obviously realized he was wrong. Another more recent story is Alex Rodriguez, top paid athlete, is a part of the 20 MLB players listed to receive at least 100 game suspension if proven guilty. In the article, “MLB seeks to Suspend A-Rod, Braun” by T.J. Quinn, Pedro Gomez, and Mike Fish, it explains how at least 20 MLB players are under investigation for using PEDs from Tony Busch (founder of Biogenesis of America). In hopes of making a deal with attorneys Bosch, “…pledged to provide anything in his possession that could help MLB build cases against the players.” (, T.J. Quinn, Pedro Gomez and Mike Fish. "MLB Seeks to Suspend A-Rod, Braun." ESPN. ESPN Internet Ventures, 05 June 2013. Web. 10 Sept. 2013.) The MLB suspended 13 players, including Alex Rodriguez for 211 games based off of Busch’s records. Fans everywhere can be arguing or agreeing on this issue. In the case of lance Armstrong, not only was he stripped of medals, his Livestrong foundation dropped him as a spokesman and founder title. Was he wrong for using PEDs? Did he deserve his punishment? These are common questions fans ask each other on this issue.…
- 446 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
The general consensus is that performance enhancing drugs should not be allowed in professional sports. Performance-enhancing drugs are against the spirit of sport, as it creates an unfair playing field. If professional athletes use drugs, it will encourage others to use performance-enhancing drugs and promotes unhealthy and dangerous behaviour. Many different performance-enhancing drugs pose severe health risks and can endanger an athlete’s life. Performance-enhancing drugs should not be allowed in professional sports.…
- 709 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
If the athlete is patient and works hard he or she can achieve the same strength that they would obtain using supplements. Athletes are trying to cheat using unnatural shortcuts to gain their muscle instead of spending the long hours in the weight room. As an athlete who has been training since the age of three I am at the brink of making the Canadian Olympic team and achieving gold but under one condition, I would need to take performance enhancing drugs to make the team due to the fact if I don’t I will be cut. So I have to make the decision and I have decided to go against taking the drugs due to the fact I would not want to put the substance in my body, I would want to achieve my goals with hard work and training, not to mention the negative effects it could have on my health and body, and I would not fully be satisfied or proud of my self knowing I cheated to achieve my goals as it is against the rules and morally wrong while also adding the fact that it will be degrading to the sport and if I were to get caught my reputation would be…
- 627 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
The use of performance-enhancing drugs in sport has become a huge issue in all modern codes of sport. In the recent 2012 Olympic games in London, it was suggested that as many as 60% of the athletes were taking illegal drugs. You only have to open the newspaper or turn on the television to discover a new batch of professional athletes that have been caught ‘doping’. Although athletes are regularly drug tested, there have been multiple cases where athletes have been able to cheat the system and return negative results. Australia has been a front-runner in the fight against sports doping, and has even established a…
- 1676 Words
- 7 Pages
Powerful Essays -
Many people do not see the severity of drug use in professional and High School athletics. Drug use in professional athletics is looked upon as somewhat of a serious problem, but also very discrete and low key. Every once in a while and individual might see a prominent figure in a certain sport being reprimanded for the use of an outlawed drug. However , that athlete may just be one of the many who happened to get caught. Athletes today seem to find no moral problem with using performance-enhancing drugs, or in other words, cheating. Athletes feel that because they are "stars" there should be no repercussions for their illegal activity. Today, drug use in sports has reached enormous proportions in society and destroying athletics from the ground up. The use of steroids and other performance enhancement drugs also effects athletes at the high school level. It does not matter how good the athlete is, a zero-tolerance policy should be in place at all levels of competition.…
- 857 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
Some people say that the only way that athletes will stop using the drugs is if they get a lifetime ban from the sport they love playing. The complicity of medical professionals and shadowy labs are often involved. Corruption in general has and also doping are ubiquitous in both amauter and professional sports. It has taken the character of a symmetric threat. A lot of athletes that are serious about the sport is that you will do anything to win and the competitive sport can be fierce.…
- 475 Words
- 2 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
When watching someone participate in any sport, the audience thinks about how much effort was put into practicing, and not what the player smoked to gain their superhuman stamina. In sports, the competitors need to practice to become better, not default to who has the money to buy the best drugs. Performance enhancing drugs may help during a couple of games, but it’s not worth putting so many lives at risk. Forest Tennant JR., who is an NFL drug adviser, has estimated that half of all professional athletes have been exposed to drugs in their careers.…
- 1171 Words
- 5 Pages
Good Essays -
It always raises an eye when an average athlete suddenly becomes the fastest or the strongest in their sport; in many cases they have stopped depending on talent and now rely on a performance- enhancing drug for success. Substance abuse in sports is shown to be common because of their benefits, various scandals in the media, and new polices companies have now had to implement. The act of "doping" or the use of an enhancing-drug has become a social norm though out all sports.…
- 550 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
Have you ever wondered how many professional athletes take performance drugs? Well about one athlete out of every ten athletes have taken performance enhancing drugs sometime in their career. Athletes take these drugs to increase their level of play on the field or on the court. These athletes gain an unfair advantage on their opponents. Steroids are ruining sports all around the world, as they continue to attract people to these substances, but we can reduce the steroid use in sports if more severe penalties to our rules are enforced.…
- 870 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
Should professional athletes be required to take a drug test? Drugs affect everybody in certain ways. They can really mess with you mind and body. Depending on the drug, some can have lifelong implications. They can especially have a lifelong implication if used by teens that are still growing.…
- 964 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
Common types of these drugs are steroids, stimulants, hormones, and supplements. Such drugs are used to increase an athlete’s strength, endurance, and ability. By increasing these factors, it allows athletes to recover quicker, train harder, and improve their stamina. The long term effects of some performance enhancing drugs is that they allow athletes to have a longer career because it is helping protect their bodies. For all of these reasons, performance enhancing drugs are illegal in the world of sports to keep the game fair. The first act against the use of drugs in sports was in 1976 when the International Olympic Committee banned the use of steroids (Cable News Network [CNN], 2016). Congress became involved in the issue by passing the Anti-Drug Abuse Act in 1988 which made “possession and distribution of nonprescription anabolic steroids for non-medical purposes a crime” (Cable News Network [CNN], 2016). In 1999, the World Anti-Doping Agency was established and a year later, in 2000, the U.S. Anti-Doping Agency was created (Cable News Network [CNN], 2016). Between the establishment of these two agencies and current day, the amount of athletes caught using performance enhancing drugs has increased…
- 1314 Words
- 6 Pages
Better Essays