Preview

Preliminary Legal Studies - Same Sex Marriage

Powerful Essays
Open Document
Open Document
2013 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Preliminary Legal Studies - Same Sex Marriage
Assess-2 /Legal Studies. Hayley Galvin
Preliminary Law in Practice: Investigating a Contemporary Issue

Contemporary issue: Same Sex Marriage
Marriage is both universal and central. All across our country, in every town and city, every social class, every race and ethnicity, every religion or non-religion, people get married. To be told “You cannot get married” is thus to be excluded from one of the defining rituals of civilised Australian society. Homosexuality and the laws regarding same-sex marriage are issues that previous generations have refused to acknowledge in regards to religious contentions of the church to prevent such laws. Although there have been many efforts at the international level to protect the rights of homosexuals, individual countries have often been slow to introduce domestic legislation that reflects international agreements. In Australia, same-sex marriage is not yet legal. For law to be considered effective, it must be universal, which means it changes constantly and consistently. Justice is achieved through equality, access and fairness. Not allowing same-sex marriage sparks debate within society, particularly as it challenges the law in its attempt to achieve justice. Effectiveness of the law and achieving justice can be sufficiently evaluated and achieved through; the laws enforceability and responsiveness, the protection of the individual rights, meeting of society's needs, the application of the rule of law, resource efficiency, accessibility, and ensuring the law is universal.

In order for the law to be truly effective, it must be both universal and just. Though in regards to same-sex marriage, this is not the case, as it doesn't apply equally to homosexual couples due to past legal responses to this issue. In current, Australian society, we derive our definition of marriage from the 'Hyde v. Hyde and Woodmansee (1866) Wilde JO (later Lord Panzance)'. Mr Hyde was accused of polygamy as he married two different

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Powerful Essays

    In contemporary Australia there exists a wide variety of family structures. Traditionally however, the law has mainly recognised the nuclear family and has been slow to recognise other family arrangements, particularly same-sex couples. As a consequence, not all families receive equal recognition under the law. To improve justice for all people, there has been a gradual movement towards equality for all family units, regardless of their composition.…

    • 1579 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Better Essays

    Due to the long-awaited family law reforms signifying the recognition of same sex relationships, one may say, “society moves ahead and the law limps behind.” It was in the 1969 that the ACT Homosexual Law Reform Society was formed, indicating society’s demand for equality. Such demands were first recognised by the Property (Relationships) Legislation Amendment Act 1999 (NSW), which enabled access to the District Court for property divisions and financial maintenance orders, and granted inheritance rights to same-sex de-factos. Finally, after 2 decades of Gay and Lesbian Mardi Gras marches, The Commonwealth government passed the Family Law Amendment (De Facto Financial Matters and Other Measures) Act 2008. The legislation expanded the definition of de-facto relationships to include, “2 persons of the same sex.” This, amongst other amendments, ensured that same-sex couples are afforded the same rights and obligations as heterosexual couples, under around 50 Commonwealth statutes.…

    • 1100 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    The issue of whether or not gay marriage should be accepted in Australia has been largely debated in politics and among the general public for a while now, and it seems as though it will remain a continuous issue for some time to come. The majority of Australians are currently split over whether the traditional view of marriage being solely between a man and a woman should be preserved, or whether this view of marriage is out-dated and should be redefined in order to allow gays the right to marry. The Australian Labor Party was also divided on this issue at a recently held federal conference. In the opinion piece “Welcome, gays, to… what?” (published in the Herald Sun in December 2011), Wendy Tuohy contends in a supportive tone, that gay marriage should be allowed in Australia, and in a more inquisitive and somewhat deflated tone goes on to question the meaning and necessity of marriage in today’s world. Similarly, Michael Newton believes that our laws should reflect on the new sets of values which are present in the modern world. In his letter to the editor titled “It is nonsense to cling to the past” (published in The Age on the 16th of November 2011), he presents a reasoned point of view, that although marriage has had a certain meaning in the past, to assume that it should stay that way would be completely irrational. A contrasting viewpoint is presented in the opinion piece “Tsunami-sized backlash on same-sex marriage looms” (published in The Australian on the 12th of December 2011), in which Barry Cohen attacks “the pro-gay marriage brigade”, expressing his traditionalist views and stark rejection of same-sex marriage in a very deprecating and slightly satirical tone. A cartoonist named Spooner drew a cartoon (published in The Age on the 22nd of November 2011) which presents two clashing views of the issue. A non-Christian audience would derive a message in support of giving gays the right to marry, whilst a religious audience may see the opposite.…

    • 1904 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    As society evolves it grows in diversity and acceptance to which regard the legal system must change to better serve societies needs and values. With reference to this the legal system’s approaches to protect and recognise the rights of same sex couples in relation to same-sex marriage has proven to be ineffective. Whilst there has been reform through the Corbett v Corbett 1970 (One of the couple had undergone a sex change operation so the courts reformed the sex requirement from birth certificate to the…

    • 689 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Could you imagine if you had met the ideal person you wished to share your entire life with but the law would not allow you to? That is the position that many homosexual Australians have been in since the settlement of this country. Same sex marriage is currently not allowed in Australia but I and a proven 60% of other Australians strongly believe it should be. Gay people pay taxes, serve in the military, participate in the workforce, are our neighbors, friends and family. Logic and decency would suggest that they should have the right to marry, just as any heterosexual couple can. However, there are people who disagree with this belief, take for example the government, namely Australia’s prime minister, Julia Gillard, several religious groups who believe marriage should be kept between a man and a woman and those who simply wish to deny the happiness of two people in love because of their anatomy.…

    • 1290 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Legal Studies Family Essay

    • 1498 Words
    • 6 Pages

    Family law is the most complex aspect of the Australian legal system as it is constantly under review and reform pursuing to adopt society’s continual change in values and principles. The changing of laws in an attempt to be parallel with society is a strenuous process. Nevertheless, legislations are reflective of contemporary society’s values and ethics. Numerous legal issues arise in regards to family including, same sex relationships, domestic violence and divorce ideally on the best interest of the child, where family laws have been imposed to protect individuals and aim to achieve justice.…

    • 1498 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In the past, people wouldn’t even consider the possibility of same-sex marriage or cohabitating, death penalty or prison life is the only choice for those people who break the rules. As attitudes changed and better-established social policies, the stigma of homosexuality has reduced, it is now more socially accepted, Netherlands was the first country to permit same-sex marriage in 2001, and then there are more and more countries starting to legalize same-sex marriage. However, Kath Weston (1992) point out that many gay couples are now deciding to cohabit as stable partners, they would reject monogamy and family life and in favor of causal relationships. Allan and Crow argue that, because of the legal framework which recently came up, same-sex partners have had to negotiate their commitment and responsibilities more than married couples, this may have made same-sex relationships both more flexible and less stable than heterosexual relationships. Also, supported by David Cheal (2002), while many gays and lesbians welcome the opportunity to have their partnerships legally recognized, but some fear that it may limit the flexibility and negotiability of relationships, therefore, rather than adopt what they see as heterosexual relationship norms, they wish to retain a status of ‘difference’. Nevertheless, Social policy is now beginning to treat all…

    • 918 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Family LAw

    • 2126 Words
    • 6 Pages

    The legal recognition of same-sex relationships in Australia has evolved dramatically since the 1980s to a point where most jurisdictions provide same-sex couples with the same rights and obligations as heterosexual de-facto couples. The recognition of homosexual peoples was first reflected in 1982 through the insertion of Part 4C into the Anti-Discrimination Act (NSW). At the federal level, the 1984 Federal Sex-Discrimination Act (Cth) was enacted. Demographically, Australia is continuously developing into a more secular society, resulting in the waning influence of the Christian Church on the political front. Nevertheless, the 2004 Amendment to the 1961 Federal Marriage Act, which defined marriage as the legal union between a man and a woman”, was described by many as “enshrining the institution of marriage”, and is only reflective of the views held by the more conservative and religious members of society. To this day, the legal definition of marriage remains unreflective of society’s progressive views, resulting in the law languishing behind.…

    • 2126 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Informal Logic

    • 2064 Words
    • 9 Pages

    In the United States marriage laws are not supposed to discriminate, yet many people believe that marriages are clear religious and official vows, between a man and woman, which include the ultimate expression of love. The traditional belief does not claim a specific sexual orientation for homosexuals in this country who are Americans, and have the right to marry. This essay identifies specifically to the question; “Should homosexuals be able to marry.” Some people say “yes” and some say “no. Therefore, an evaluation of the marriage laws for the United State that allows homosexuals marriages, and the fact that the Universal Declaration of Human Rights and Constitution claim that homosexuals are equal, and have the same rights and limits as heterosexuals.…

    • 2064 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Family Law Reform

    • 1358 Words
    • 6 Pages

    As society has shifted its beliefs and attitudes towards same-sex couples, with increased acceptance, the law must be adaptive and responsive to provide same-sex couples with increased rights and legal recognition under Australian law. The recognition of same-sex relationships in Australia has increased dramatically where gradually, more jurisdictions provide couples with same rights and obligations as heterosexual couples, highlighting the efficiency of the legal system. Hope and Brown v NIB (1995) initiated law reform momentum, in which the couple successfully argued that the NIB health fund discriminated against them by refusing to grant them a ‘family’ status policy due to their family arrangement and sexual orientation. The Equal Opportunity Tribunal found this to be discriminatory and hence, the Property (Relationships) Legislation Amendment Act 1999 legally recognised same-sex couples as de facto unions under federal law, entitling them to receive benefits previously not accessible. This significant legislative change gave same-sex couples access to the District Court to divide property, claim financial maintenance and inheritance rights, previous rights which were denied. This legislative breakthrough created precedent for same sex couples to be recognised as a family and is…

    • 1358 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Law Reform- My Report

    • 568 Words
    • 3 Pages

    * the case-waiting for the big day-in six years, Michele and Lisa Saffery held onto their dream that one day they could legally marry in Australia. The women from Wagga Wagga and their two children, Gemme 6 and Jordae 5 carried a huge rainbow flag during 8000-strong gay marriage rights march the Labor party National conference in Sydney. Along with many others, the couple decided to have the same surname despite not being married, were disappointed with the conscience vote approved at the conference. ''I have to say to Julia Gillard, 'Damn you!''' Michele said. ''All Labor MPs should be voting 'yes' on this issue. The conscience vote is just a cop-out for Julia.'' An observant Jew, mr.whitmont-stein dismissed arguments that allowing same sex marriage was an attack on religion. “the whole point of marriage is equality, it’s not about religious institutions”, he said. Lisa Saffert and Michele are Australian but also hold British passports but they insist on marrying in Australia…

    • 568 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Marriage Act 1961

    • 992 Words
    • 4 Pages

    According to the Marriage Act 1961, marriage in Australia is defined as, “the union of a man and a woman to the exclusion of all others, voluntarily entered into for life.” It is said that a “good law” is that which consists of five key features; one being that the law reflects the changing values of society (Sykes, 2002). The aspect of marriage being allowed only between a man and a woman has been widely contested among people as society has evolved and this provokes debate.…

    • 992 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Lets Talk About Dying

    • 393 Words
    • 2 Pages

    In Peter Saul’s (2011) “Let’s Talking about Dying” talk, he opened up with a very poignant statement that when 2000 brain cells die daily he argues that our dying process really truly has started. As a physician, he reports that he has seen many changes in the last thirty years.…

    • 393 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Australian Family Law

    • 646 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Family law is an aspect of law that deals with issues such as divorce, child custody, adoption, marriage, financial affairs and more. The current definition of marriage is ‘The union of a man and a woman to the exclusion of all others and is voluntarily entered into for life.’ This definition was established by the monumental case Hyde v Hyde on 20th March 1866. The definition of marriage has been questioned over a number of years but do society and their beliefs correspond with legislation that has been passed. As of 2015, 16 attempts have been made to amend the Marriage Act to legalise same-sex marriage in Australia, all of which have been unsuccessful. As it stands Australia are not looking to modify the current legislation, but over time Australia could potentially change their Marriage Act.…

    • 646 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The forms of marriage vary and always have varied historically and culturally. And now we are at the moment where we see other big change coming. Same sex marriage is that change that has already started happening in our society. There are a lot of perspectives on this issue and gay marriage is among one of the most controversial topics that the United States talks about.…

    • 962 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays

Related Topics