Preview

"The Reader" by Bernard Schlink about post WW2 Germany.

Powerful Essays
Open Document
Open Document
2167 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
"The Reader" by Bernard Schlink about post WW2 Germany.
More than just a book, The Reader reminds that the concepts of guilt and responsibility are not clear-cut ideas, and even more so during the Nuremberg Trials. Guilt is simply one of the many human emotions, but the feeling of guilt is unique to everyone and there is no one meaning for guilt. Though guilt is such a strong feeling, judgments must not be made simply on how "guilty" one feels for their actions. If that is so, then Hanna would never have gone to jail at all. Judgments should instead be made on the actions of a person and whether the person was right or wrong in what he/she did. This is the concept of responsibility. How responsible a person was for their actions should determine how "guilty" a person is for their crimes. But responsibility is such a difficult question to resolve and deal with because how can you judge how responsible a person is for their actions? In the case of Hanna's trial, how was responsible? The powers that be made the decisions, but people under them carried out these decisions. So who is responsible? The people who made the decisions, or the people who carried out the decisions? It seems that the person who holds the knife must be the one responsible. But fortunately and rightly so, justice is never so easy.

Guilt and responsibility, being human emotions can never be pinned down, because it is human nature to be fickle and therefore there will always be a gray area when it comes to determining the true meaning (if there is such a thing) of guilt and responsibility. The problem is that we have come to believe that guilt and responsibility is the same thing, but in reality they are poles apart. This misunderstanding comes around due to the fact that courts often give the verdict "guilty" or "not guilty." But just because a person have been proved without any doubt that they are responsible for the crime, it does NOT mean they feel any remorse or sadness for committing the crime. Two different eras, two different circumstances and

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Powerful Essays

    “I find you, Alice Dubson,Guilty of the murders of Sarah, Jonathan and Tyson Dubson” the judge's words reverberated through the courtroom causing searing tears to well within her now glassy eyes and her to shake her head while incoherently screaming “no” as if she was a broken record player. Her body was trembling as continued to scream at the judge who merely smirked at us while fondling a disgustingly thick roll of money under his podium. Her screams echoed through the halls as we were dragged away by four disgruntled officers. “Stop screaming you stupid little girl” I roar causing her to go silent in fear while tears continued to stream down her pathetic little face. As we passed the jury their disgusted glares…

    • 658 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    The narrator in this chapter tries to convey the theme of guilt, shame and fear. The theme…

    • 1545 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    On the Other Side: Letters to My Children from Germany 1940-46 was written by Mathilde Wolff-Monckeberg during the Hamburg air raids of WWII. Wolff-Monckeberg says in her first letter “This war would be conducted with the most horrible weapons and resources, its whole justification based on a daily incitement of lies, not an honest war, but an illegal and mean exploitation, as far as we were concerned.”1 The first letter boldly states that Wolff-Monckeberg views Germany’s participation in the war as a shameful endeavour driven by the “Fuhrer’s blind lust for conquest”2 Wolff-Monckeberg makes this ever apparent with letters about, Nazi invasions into other countries, the struggle that became surviving in war time Hamburg, and the shame brought on Germans by the atrocities committed by the Nazis.…

    • 994 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Hanna Schmitz’s illiteracy played a pivotal role throughout the novel. Moreover, this is most notable during Schmitz’s war trial. This became a very repetitious act for this character throughout the novel. The literature suggests that the biggest life decision the former Auschwitz guard made through illiteracy, was the decision of the prison sentence. Schmitz found that it was easier to settle for a life sentence, than to come clean about the issues regarding her illiteracy. "So you're saying that the arresting judge misinterpreted the fact that the defendant ignored all letters and summonses, and did not present herself either to the police, the prosecutor, or the judge?" (Schlink 98) The biggest struggle that Schmitz faced was keeping her…

    • 338 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The book “Imperial Germany 1871-1918” by Volker R. Berghahn has the under title Economy, Society, Culture and Politics and was first published in 1994 by Berghahn books. The used edition is the revised and expanded edition published in 2005 and summarizes the events in the ‘Kaiserreich’ (1871-1918). Furthermore, the book has 388 pages and is divided in five parts which are Economy, Society, Culture, the Realm of Politics, and World War I. Each part has numerous under parts giving the reader detailed information about each part. In addition, the author did tremendous research on the German Empire, founded by Otto von Bismarck in 1871 and lasting until the end of World War I, to clarify the broader outlines of the development between 1871 and 1918 and to explain why Germany went to war in 1914 and lost that conflict four years later.…

    • 1028 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    A stunning adventure involving Nazis, nukes, fighting, failure, and everyday heroes, from the author of the award-winning The Nazi Hunters. Neal Bascomb delivers another nail-biting work of nonfiction for young adults in this incredible true story of spies and survival. The invasion begins at night, with German cruisers slipping to harbor. Then planes roar over the mountains, and soon the Nazis occupy all of Norway. They station soldiers throughout the country. They institute martial rule. And at Vemork, an industrial fortress high above a dizzying gorge, they gain access to an essential ingredient for the weapon that could end the war: Hitler’s very own nuclear bomb.…

    • 196 Words
    • 1 Page
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    June Tangney’s short essay, “Condemn the Crime, Not the Person”, is about the difference between two emotions: shame and guilt. There is a problem in the court system when it comes to traditional sentences. There are people who even encourage America to look for shaming as a way to save money rather than taking care of an inmate in jail. However, Tangney states that recently, there is a realization that these cheaper ways are actually not effective. It makes the criminal’s situation worse, according to the author. The two feelings of shame and guilt are very different. I agree with Tangney’s argument because punishing a criminal should be in the fairest way with the…

    • 554 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Darrow reinforces his ethos as one of many participants in the war that causes Leopold and Loeb’s insanity, altering their madness from a one-off, unique case, to one caused by a nation-wide bandwagon calling for violence. Beginning by establishing his role in the Civil War, Darrow discusses how he serves as yet another “old man… [who] believed” in the war (Darrow). By establishing the “belief” that he too takes part in, Darrow begins this transfer of guilt from the murderers, to the whole of society, beginning with himself. Darrow’s reinforces his ethos by his acknowledgement that he too took part in the war, for if such a revered and renowned attorney took part in the bloodshed, then so too may the masses, opening the jury to be susceptible to his claim that the entire nation cries for blood. Following the establishment of a personal role in this war-mongering, Darrow begins repetition of the word, “we”, as he associates the entire jury with the blood-lust shared throughout the war (Darrow). Darrow associates the entire crowd with himself and the guilty as he prepares to lay further guilt on the defense - a guilt now shared by the jury. Discussing the young boys, Darrow looks to their upbringing as the entire community “trained…

    • 2234 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Andersonville Prison

    • 4639 Words
    • 19 Pages

    When one turns on the television today they are made witness to all the crimes that are present in society. It is impossible to sit through thirty-five minutes of news without anger and rage becoming aroused. This is because society is bothered by infinitesimal paraphernalia. Society also believes in human rights and punishment for those who violate such rights. Yet what constitutes humanity? Ever sit there and watch the news and wonder just how far humanity reaches? When is it time to say this is a human rights violation? Every wonder when someone 's morals and ethics begin to effect their ability to do their job? Ever wonder why in every news story the "bad guy" always become caught? Ever wonder how many people on death row might not be guilt? Some of them could have even been used as scapegoats. Yet how does one become a scapegoat? Could someone out there have that much hatred and anger to blame one person for the faults of many? Is the need for blame significant? Does desire lead to more hatred and evil? What does it feel like to be blamed for something that might not be wrong, and to be put on trial knowing that the jury wants to blame someone? In society and in the United States since its founding, there has been a need to place blame. Imagine how the person being blamed would feel. Henry Wirz did not have to image it; he lived through it and died for it. Someone is always to be blamed, even if they were just following orders. Orders which can only go so far until humanity takes effect. Henry Wirz was used as a scapegoat for war crimes committed during the Civil War at Andersonville Prison, however that does not justify his acts or make him an American hero.…

    • 4639 Words
    • 19 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Better Essays

    The slaughter is said to have expressed the will of a small circle of lunatic Nazi and not the will of the German people, who were antisemetic but not murderously so. It is said that the killing was conducted out of the sight of the nation and with industrial efficiency by a relatively small number of people insane with ideology. The effect of these premises is to make the Holocaust a political and not a social event, with the happy consequence that responsibility for it rests squarely on a small number of identifiable political and military operatives and not on the German nation as a…

    • 2492 Words
    • 10 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    The story positions the reader to question the society Leonard Mead (the protagonist) lives in as the scenario’s he faces are unusual and different and in a sense cause the responder to evaluate their own life and their position in it. There are particular scenes in this story of unfair behavior and discriminative acts that cause the reaser to become, involved making personal judgments as well as getting them to make relations to their own life. Normally, we view the shared values and behavior in a society as strength, creating belonging in the sense of a united society. However in this story the nature of the crime, and the severity of the punishment are so great that we are led to question and criticize the ideal.…

    • 558 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Adolf Hitler’s excerpt from “The Nuremberg Law” in our textbook underscores the captivity, humiliation and oppression of the Jewish People by Hitler during his rule in Germany. Adolf Hitler was a maniac, cruel murderer, and military dictator who had a racist ideology in which white, non Jewish Germans were superior over all other races and used his Nuremberg Laws to define, dehumanize, ostracize and expel the Jews from the German society. Hitler was focused on leaving his deep rooted hatred for the Jews as legacy to the German society that in his will, written few hours before his suicide, as he wrote…

    • 1472 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Better Essays

    Guilt Crime and Punishment

    • 1556 Words
    • 7 Pages

    A person obtains Guilt when they are accused of a crime they have committed, substantial, and minimal. Though there are exceptions sometimes when guilt begins to form and we have no power over it. On the contrary Guilt can also be when somebody who is blameless are said to have committed the crime. Guilt can come in many forms but one most common is a emotion. Though majority of all people that have a conscience feel bad for the wrongdoing that they commit. In the novels Crime and Punishment by Dostoyevsky and Metamorphosis by Kafka the authors incorporates guilt into the plot showing guilt and its motives take part in the transformation of Gregor and Raskolnikov.…

    • 1556 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    The first chapter of Stefan Zweig describes what he calls the “Golden Age of Security”. In this passage, he discusses his childhood during the First World War. He describes his experience as the “Golden Age of Security”. He describes his Austrian Monarchy and the lifestyles of the citizens. For example, every family had to calculate their budgets as stated by Stefan Zweig, “Every Family had its own budget and knew how much could be spent” (Zweig 23). The “Golden Age of Security” refers to the era where everything was normal and everyone had a balanced life and how life was good for everyone. As shown in the text, family owned houses that were passed g the generation, relatives deposited money for babies for their future. This is the ideal…

    • 318 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The Iron Rule

    • 745 Words
    • 3 Pages

    On its publication in English in 1997, The Reader was heaped with praise, but also severely criticised for its apparent prevarication about judgment. We are drawn into sympathy with Hanna as it gradually emerges that she was illiterate. Women in the camps were given a temporary reprieve from the gas chamber on condition that they read to her. Was her inability to read being offered as a partial excuse for her crimes? Was Schlink playing on the emotions of his readers in order to blur distinctions where, for the sake of history and justice, there should be none? (The reader of the title could be any one of her blighted reading companions, Hanna herself who finally learns to read in prison, or of course each of us.) In fact, the narrator dispenses judgment liberally throughout the novel. Hanna is guilty. When she insists in her final confrontation with him that only the dead can call her to account because only they understand her he finds it ‘shabby and too easy, the way she had…

    • 745 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays