Preview

Rhetorical Analysis of “About Men”

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
317 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Rhetorical Analysis of “About Men”
Rhetorical Analysis of “About Men” In her essay, “About Men” (1984), Gretel Ehrlich claims that men are not as tough as they seem. Ehrlich creates the framework of her essay through casual analysis, imagery, and tone. Through the use of personal experiences and first person perspective, she shows casual analysis. Through her word choice and specific details, imagery is shown. And through the use of specific details, tone is revealed. Ehrlich’s essay is written in a casual analysis of how cowboys are perceived. Through her use of first person, Ehrlich creates a one-on-one experience with the reader. Ehrlich also uses her own personal experience as if telling a story to the reader. Through sharing her experiences, Ehrlich is able to create a bond between herself and the reader. Through the use of specific words, such as “pilgrimage” (360) and “conquest” (367), imagery is created. Both words are filled with meaning; “pilgrimage” gives the image of a great trek and “conquest” produces the thought of victory and power. Ehrlich creates visual scenes by using specific details, akin to how she describes how toughness is interpreted as “weathered skin, calloused hands, a squint in the eye, and a growl in the voice” (368). Ehrlich writes in a relatively denotative formal style. Her intellectual vocabulary contributes to a dignity of tone, while some of her words romanticize her cowboy friends, describing “that one caress of the face or one ‘I love you’ will peal for a long while” (369). The formal diction that Ehrlich uses reveals her attitude toward the subject. Ehrlich thinks highly of her cowboy friends and it shows in her elevated word choice, as in “androgynous” (368), “stoicism” (368), and “laconic” (368). In “About Men” Ehrlich potently uses imagery and diction to convince her readers that cowboys are not the tough, gruff men on the inside as they seem to be on the

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Satisfactory Essays

    This non-profit organization uses both rhetorical and symbolic means of galvanizing its membership. Rhetorically, the Boys and Girls Club has celebrated its volunteers and members alike. In the artifacts shown, the Club has verbally and publicly celebrated the people that make the organization great. They have vocalized how thankful they are for their volunteers in the APD and “Volunteer Spotlight” posts. The club has also showcased the members of the club by celebrating the kids championship status and a teenage Club member’s performance. The Club does not only galvanize its membership only rhetorically, but symbolically as well. In 1949 the Boys and Girls Club established a program to recognize the outstanding achievements of Club Teens.…

    • 163 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    2. The author changes the point of view to P.S's father on page 119. "Why isn't he crying, he wondered, and then he told himself that he wouldn't have cried either; that the boy had had plenty of time to cry; that he would never cry in front of his father again." This sentence is when the author changes the point of view from P.S to Stewart Wilkinson (aka. P.S's dad or sir).…

    • 647 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Dave Barry’s Guys vs. Men is a humorous essay that describes the major characteristics of “guyhood” even though he admits he can’t define exactly what it means to be a ‘guy’. In the essay, Barry uses plenty of gender stereotypes of men, guys, and women. His take on the existence of gender is comical. For instance, he says that “If God did not want us to make gender-based generalizations, She would not have given us genders”.…

    • 617 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Throughout these three articles or description of communities, the one that was very hard to understand would be "About Men" by Gretel Ehrlich. The main reasons why this article's community was very hard to understand would be because on how cowboys that were being described that was in the article was describing different people in different places so there really wasn't like a specific community to be described in this article. Also another reason would be on how different cowboys felt in specific places that Ehrlich been describing. For example, Ehrlich describes how Southerners moved to the West looking for work after the Civil War ended. He goes more in depth on how different cowboys treated women by tipping their hats and saying, "Howdy, ma'am", but still gave them the respect they needed. Ehrlich shows here how much of a difference time and war made men change the way they treated women. Also, he goes into a depth on how young cowboys weren't able to "express the complexity of what they feel" towards women. They still had "explosive emotions" and weren't able to tone it down.…

    • 596 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Lawson’s “Ballad of the Drover” and Wright’s “South Of My Days” are both narrative poems that tell contrasting stories of outback workers working differently on the land. Lawson employs the 3rd person and utilizes formal language by using powerful adjectives and imagery to represent the solitary personality of the drover. The drover has time to contemplate and take in the beauty of the landscape as he “hums a song of someone”. Personification of the land “thirsty pastures” illustrates the Drover’s intimacy with the land. Wright also utilizes the 3rd person but she uses colloquial language to engage intimately with her audience. Wright talks of multiple workers “Dan”, “Fred” and the “troopers. “Dan” is an older man with “seventy years of stories” and his “seventy years” are further enforced through the use of simile “seventy years are hived in him like old honey.” Wright further discusses the work; “Charleville to the Hunter” and “sixty head left at McIntyre” examine the work of moving cattle. “Fred” is “driving for Cobb’s” and simile “He went like a luny …… on his big black horse” because the “troopers are just behind” highlight the importance of work. Through their respective use of figurative language and their choice in language Lawson and Wright both convey stories of outback workers.…

    • 704 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    ‘Men are the savage and brutal forces of society’. Compare and contrast how masculinity is explored in two texts you have studied in light of this comment.…

    • 2014 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    In Jane Austen’s Pride and Prejudice, women in the Regency period had no right to pursue a career, to suffrage, to have political thoughts. Women with high level of education was deemed unnecessary as the parents believed marriage was the success of a wealthy and comfortable future. This is demonstrated in the quote “No governess! How was that possible? Five daughters brought up at home without of governess! I never heard of such a thing. Your mother must have been a quite a salve to your education”, as Lady Catherine was in shock and disbelief that Mr. and Mrs. Bennet did not employ a governess for the family. Austen uses exclamation and rhetorical question to portray that the family unit is primarily responsible for one’s intellectual and…

    • 291 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    All of us have different conflicts in life that we need to defeat, whether it is man vs. man, man vs. society, man vs. self or man vs. nature. We cannot control the outcome of man vs. nature, it presents challenges we are always looking for. If you can beat nature than you are a real survivor and can defeat anything in your path. For this paper, I am going to focus on two films that face the conflict of man vs. nature head on, Sean Penn’s Into the Wild (2007), and Jean-Marc Vallee’s Wild (2014). Jean-Marc Vallee’s female character in Wild detaches the typical stereotype shown in Sean Penn’s Into the Wild that wild stories belong to men and navigates and roots women into the American tradition of man vs. wild stories, leading us to question if people will ever say wild stories belong to men again. Although, similar McCandless and Strayed’s journey’s differ due to their gender, solely because in American culture we have seen men vs. nature, not women. First, I’ll show how McCandless is able to own the adventure film by having the benefit of flowing the path of many men that explored before him; then, I’ll investigative…

    • 487 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Better Essays

    The concept of being a man, and the idea of manliness, has been debatable in recent decades due to acts of feminism. Paul Theroux wrote Being a Man and was very opinionated as he said the idea of manliness was wrong and oppressive. Harvey Mansfield wrote The Partial Eclipse of Manliness, and stated that the concept of being manly has diminished and been overpowered by feminism. Both of these readings have provided valid and doubtful points in the discussion of what constitutes being manly, as well as how North American culture views the stereotypical man. Both authors are very opinionated and biased in their readings as they do not have any outside sources supporting their beliefs, but they do make effective arguments which further their attitude and outlook on manliness.…

    • 938 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    In "The Ugly Truth About Beauty,  Dave Barry suggests that men and women view themselves differently. People have known for many years that men and women have their differences. These differences often mean that there may be confusion between the sexes. In Dave Barry's essay, he uses three literary devices to determine how males and females feel about themselves. Dave Barry's essay not only suggests how men and women feel about themselves, but also how men feel about women. On this occasion, Dave Barry’s purpose is to enlighten men and women to show them what beauty means to each gender using allusions,hyperboles and ethos.…

    • 737 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Ernest Hemingway’s writing choices are famously in favor of clear and concise language, sharply contrasting those of William Faulkner, an author who is known to use many fluid descriptions, metaphors, and similes in order to emphasize certain ideas. Although both Faulkner and Hemingway choose to describe more than just what is plainly written, they differ immensely in presentation. Faulkner adheres strictly to his own tradition of using powerful language to give his stories a strong tone, as if spoken by a descriptive storyteller. Hemingway on the other hand describes his stories impartially, avoiding bias towards one character or another, and instead telling things the way they are (or rather, the way he creates them to be). Hemingway’s tone, style, and diction in “A Clean, Well-Lighted Place” is presented in a plain and unbiased fashion that allows its reader to capture exactly what Hemingway intends to say.…

    • 500 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    As a child, Alison, compared the way she saw men portray themselves and compared their characteristics to her father’s. “…And who answered not to the laws of society, but to those of his own craft,” (Bechdel 2006:7). She could see her father lacked the ideal masculinity that we as a society think of how men are typically considered. “I measured my father against the grimy deer hunters…

    • 197 Words
    • 1 Page
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    In “About Men”, by Gretel Ehrlich, the author describes cowboys like men who seem to have trouble communicating with and relating to women, yet cling to an "adolescent dependency" on women to take care of them. This trouble of communication with women can be perceived by others as a sign of weakness even a lack of virility. However, according to Ehrlich it may be because of historical and geographical factors. Cowboys who are mostly from the South kept that "chivalrousness and strict codes of honor" when the came to the Wyoming. This is why men would show a stand-offish and respectful attitude vis-à-vis the women. Also, due to the geographical vastness of the North, cowboys often work where there is no human beings or women. He is physically and socially isolated which "make emotional evolution seem impossible". Therefore, if it happened that he feels something for a woman, he would have trouble communicating because he is not use to the code of seduction that…

    • 505 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    How Men Become Men

    • 654 Words
    • 3 Pages

    How men become men? How men are men by being aggressive? Michael Kimmel in “Welcome to Guyland”& “Bros before Hos: the Guy Code” explains to us how men go through a social process by which men become “men”. Kimmel exposes some of the male myths in which society tries to establish ‘how a man has to be’. Kimmel makes a list of ten norms that the society or other men think that a man has to follow to become a real man, these norms are called “Guy Code”. Those norms defined as machismo are connected to Franco La Cecla’s “Rough Manners: How Men are Made.” Both Kimmel and La Cecla have the same perspective of what society thinks a man should be. I reject the “Guy Code” because being a man does not necessarily means to be aggressive or not being able to express your feelings because you look weak; on the contrary expressing your feelings and being yourself takes a lot of courage.…

    • 654 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Throughout this paper, I will try to prove this idea from the literature, the media and many other sources. I will try to highlight "the conventional or formulaic conceptions / images" of men and women in the minds of people. However, I am…

    • 1766 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays