Preview

Should UK Constitution Be Adopted To A Written Constitution?

Better Essays
Open Document
Open Document
1555 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Should UK Constitution Be Adopted To A Written Constitution?
The UK constitution ‘should not be tampered with as it has served Britain well for centuries.’ This quote is from a news article made by the BBC in 2011 about whether the UK should adopted to a written constitution. However, the UK being unwritten encourages the evolution of its constitution.
In the statement Lord Steyn makes in the question, he is stating that the UK constitution is controlled, however the Attorney General thinks it is to be implausible, therefore meaning it is not believable and in fact the UK constitution is uncontrolled; these two opinions contradict one another.
A constitution simply means a system of rules, which sets out how power is held by the parliament and how the power relates to the people living in the UK. Along
…show more content…
Placed a statutory obligation on the state to act in accordance with the Convention rights.
Another one is the Parliament Act 1949 is an extension of the 1911 Act ; further limiting the power of the Lords. Baroness Hale stated in the R (Jackson) v Attorney General cases that ‘If Parliament can do anything, there is no reason why Parliament should not decide to redesign itself…’. , further developing Parliamentary supremacy within constitutional boundaries. The prevalent change to the constitution in recent years is the
Lastly, the Constitutional Reform Act 2005 , this is where the role of the Lord Chancellor was modified and the Supreme Court was established. This particular act displays the stability and consistency of separation of powers in the UK constitution and supports Lord Steyn’s statement. Without these separation of powers the UK would not be easily managed or controlled, however with these in place the UK constitution is well
…show more content…
It has evolved and changed with certain matters, for example the devolution in both Scotland and Wales. Although the weakness of this is that as the UK constitution is not entrench and can be changed so easily, leaves it vulnerable to abuse. Realistically a government wouldn’t make rational constitutional changes without having support from the political nation, knowing that they will have to face a re-election within 5 years.
The rule of law is one of the fundamental principles of UK's unwritten constitution. It is the principle that the law of the land applies equally to all. A.V. Dicey ensures a ‘government of law' and not a ‘government of men’. From this it can be understood that the government is law, without the government making law there would be no law.
A key case illustrating the rule of law is Entick v Carrington (1765). In this case the defendants claimed under a warrant from the Secretary of State; broke into the plaintiff’s house and took some papers. Plaintiff sued in trespass. The rule of law was upheld in the sense that the Court held that The Crown did not have the power to just decide to take an action for which there was not lawful proposition. This shows the limit of power the state has and how the Crown overcome the power of this

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Satisfactory Essays

    One strength that is highlighted in the source which is a strength of the UK constitution is that it is flexible. This is a strength as it therefore means the government and people can actually make things happen without having to stick to one kind of rule and one way of doing things. An example of the flexibility of the UK’s constitution is the recent implementation of the Same Sex Marriages Act (2013). However, the flexibility that is expressed by the fact that it is unwritten may in fact be manipulated if the ability to change the constitution were to “fall into the wrong hands”. For example, if somebody completely left wing or completely right were to come into power, they could effectively manipulate the system and change the constitution to suit them and their supporters.…

    • 407 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    The Great Awakening was an effective restoring that cleared the American Colonies, especially New England, amidst the essential part of the Eighteenth Century. Certain Christians started to disassociate themselves with the setup way to deal with oversee love at the time, which had affected a general slant nonattendance of stress among devotees, and rather, they got a handle on an approach which was portrayed by uncommon power and feeling in supplication. This new critical reclamation started with understood individuals like Johnathan Edwards and George Whitefield in England and explored to the American Colonies amidst the key part of the Eighteenth Century. Jonathan Edwards was a wonderful academician and religious pragmatist of the Great…

    • 643 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    United Kingdom changing radically with Labour’s landslide victory , the greatest since 1945. Led by Tony Blair, the party promised an ambitious programme of constitutional reforms which they themselves claimed would lead to “the most ambitious and far reaching changes to the constitution undertaken by any government in this century” (Hazell, Sinclair, 1999, p42)These reforms were also pioneered by Gordon Brown when he became Blair’s successor in 2007. While some of these amendments were successfully implemented others were abandoned or were watered down greatly. Also, the planned reversal of many of these reforms and other amendments made by the recent coalition Government must also be deliberated , however, as the coalition Government has only been in in power two years it is harder to see if they have had any real effect yet . Therefore this essay will focus on the constitutional reforms made by New Labour and will discuss that while they have made a difference, the impact has been limited and far less radical than they first proposed.…

    • 1694 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    One strength of the UK constitution is the flexibility that it has, for the reason that the constitution is uncodified or unwritten and is therefore not entrenched in law. Due to the fact that the UK’s constitution is uncodified or unwritten, it has an opportunity to modernise itself to the ever changing society or any other new circumstances that may arise. An example of the flexibility of the UK’s constitution is the recent implementation of the Same Sex Marriages Act (2013). This was brought in due to the number of LGBT people that wanted to get married, but, because of the current laws that were in place, could not. This shows one of the ways in which the constitution does modernise itself in terms of society. However, the flexibility that is expressed by the fact that it is unwritten may in fact be manipulated if the ability to change the constitution were to “fall into the wrong hands”. For example, if somebody completely left wing or completely right were to come into power, they could effectively manipulate the system and change the constitution to suit them and their supporters. While this argument is an effective argument, it is doubtful that the government of today will allow a person, hypothetically with close-minded views such as these, to be put in any place of power. Overall, today’s government, in terms of flexibility does not stand a high risk of being manipulated, as there are appropriate measures in place to stop this from happening.…

    • 963 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The flexibility of the British constitution is also shown through the constitutional reforms developed by Labour, which not only modernised by also is argued to have strengthened the British constitution. Due to this ability of being flexible and being able to change and adapt, the case for Britain retaining its constitution is in fact ‘extremely strong’.…

    • 861 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Secondly, some of the UK’s citizen thought that their current system is outdated, confusing and undemocratic. It must have a change, from uncodified constitution to codified constitution, and it is the logical conclusion of recent constitution reforms.…

    • 888 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Whether there is a constitution in the United Kingdom has been a controversial topic. The term ‘constitution’ itself is open to different interpretations. Some prescriptive authors argue that a constitution must satisfy a set of specific characteristics – for instance that it must be entrenched and superior to other laws, which is attributed to the people. Others consider that constitutions are codes of norms which aspire to regulate the allocation of powers, functions, and duties among the various agencies and officers of government, and to define the relationship between these and the public. While some believed that a constitution is as simple as ‘no more and no less than what happens. Everything that happens is constitutional. And if nothing happened that would be constitutional also.’…

    • 1266 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    What is the constitution? “the system of fundamental principles according to which a nation, state, corporation, or the like, is governed” ( ). Unlike most countries, England does not have a single codified constitution, rather it operates with the acts of Parliament or law reports of the court. Historically, the United Kingdom had the Magna Carta in 1215 that established the principles and guidelines of the rulers at the time and laid the foundation for constitutional government. Eventually the Bill of Rights would emerge in 1628 using the Magna Carta as a platform to establish basic human rights laws, built primacy over the monarchy and allow the house of commons to have free elections, etc.…

    • 159 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    There have been many reforms to the British Constitution since 1997, including changes to the House of Lords and Commons, the Human Rights Act, Fixed-term Parliaments and Devolution. However, the effectiveness of these reforms is arguable. Some of these reforms have not been fully made, or have not achieved intended results.…

    • 842 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    One way in which the UK constitution is no longer fit for purpose is that it lacks restraint…

    • 964 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    There is an argument that the UK constitution is indeed not fit for purpose. The UK constitution by…

    • 1184 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    A constitution is a set of rules that seeks to establish the duties, powers and functions of the various institutions of government. The constitution creates limited government so the government is checked and restrained therefore providing protection for the individual and their rights. the UK constitution is uncodified, which means that it is not all written down in one document therefore entrenched creating a higher law like that of America; it is split into several different locations, statute law, common law, conventions, works of constitutional authority and EU law and treaties. This means that the UK constitution is not entrenched or codified and sources such as common law and convention are not written down but are traditions and customs, the way government has always done things. The constitution is fit for purpose as it worked during the 2010 election when the outcome saw no overall winner and a coalition was created, it allowed for this to be done in just 5 days where as a codified constitution would have been much more ridged and have taken longer to work around or amend.…

    • 850 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In Zeffirelli’s and luhrmann’s individual movies on the Shakespearean play of Romeo and Juliet, they show a great deal of focus on the theme of conflict, which had occurred mainly between the two rivals of the play, the Montagues and the Capulets. Although the movies are based on the same play, they differ quite a lot. Zeffirelli’s version of Romeo and Juliet was set in the 1600s, which was accurate for the play. For luhrmann’s version, he set the movie in the modern era which inevitably causes a drastic difference between the two movies but they both focused their themes of conflict on the help of sound effects, costumes, and visual movements.…

    • 690 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    During Summer 2015, I was in the calm waters of Lake Michigan, preparing to try wake-boarding for my first time. My Dad had me hooked up to our rose-red WaveRunner and he asked me if I was ready. My life jacket was pulling on my throat a little bit so I pulled it back down, and said “Yes, let's go!” He took off and I was yanked out of the water! Somehow I managed to stay standing, and we kept going. My wake board was drifting a little too far left so I pushed my left foot forward, thus learning how to align with the center of our wake. Unfortunately, about five seconds later, a wave collided with our wake, forming displacement in the water, and I fell back down. Luckily I was not hurt and I would go on to keep trying for the rest of…

    • 149 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays