Preview

Significance Of Phoebe In A Thousand Splendid Suns

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
541 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Significance Of Phoebe In A Thousand Splendid Suns
Another significant subplot that Phoebe faces that is similar to what Sal faces is they were both convinced their mothers would come back and wouldn’t just leave them. When Phoebe and Sal’s mother were here, they knew that their mothers loved them a lot. When their mothers left, both characters were absolutely positive that their mothers would return to them because their mothers love them so much. Since they thought their mothers love Sal and Phoebe so much, both characters thought their mothers wouldn’t leave them. Sal says, “I would not leave the place to which, I was convinced, my mother might return,” (page 104). Phoebe says, “ ‘She might not come back, Phoebe-’ ‘Shut up, Sal.’ ‘She might not. I just think you should be prepared-’ ‘She …show more content…
You’re being too horrid,’ ” (page 182). Sal refused to leave Bybanks because she was so sure her mother would come back. Even if she did know it in her head that the chances of her mother returning are very slim, she refused to accept it. Phoebe thinks Sal doesn’t know what she is talking about when Sal says Phoebe’s mother might not come back. She argues with Sal and is being stubborn and doesn’t want to listen to Sal because she knows her mother is going to come back. Both girls felt like their mothers wouldn’t just leave them. Sal says, “And just like Phoebe, who had waved her mother’s sweater in front of her father, I had brought a chicken in from the coop: ‘Would Mom leave her favorite chicken?’ I demanded. ‘She loves this chicken.’ What I really meant was, ‘How can she not come back to me? She loves me,’ ” (page 125). These girls thought that their mothers’ wouldn’t leave them behind. When their mothers did leave, Phoebe and Sal thought they wouldn’t leave their favorite items behind. But what they really meant was, how could their mothers just leave them like that without any explanation. They thought their mothers were definitely going to come back to them since they love them so

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    In addition, Gram and Gramps also helped Sal accept her mother’s death. Within the book, on page 143 Gram says to Sal, “Sometimes you know in your heart you love someone, but you have to go away before your head can figure it out” (Creech 143). I can infer, that Gram was trying to explain to Sal that her mother didn’t leave because of her, but to clear her mind. Gram saying this to Sal was important for Sal’s knowing that her mother didn’t leave because of the baby that died before birth. Along with Gram saying that to Sal, she one day realized, “that our whole trip to Lewiston had been a gift from Gram and Gramps to me. They were giving me a chance to walking my mother’s moccasins - to see what she had seen, and feel what she might have felt on her last trip” (Creech 262). Although Sal didn’t realize it during the trip, looking back, she figures out that Gram and Gramps were leading her through the stages of grief and allowing her to cope with the loss of her mother. Surely, Gram and Gramps had an impact on Sal accepting her mother’s death in numerous ways.…

    • 275 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    hope" in life and she was the only thing that brought them true joy. Phoebe was…

    • 510 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    CD: Holden talks about how Phoebe would always see the same things that he has seen in the museum. These things will always be the same but every time she would see them she would be…

    • 926 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    they just wanted to put this part of their life to rest and start new.…

    • 1316 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Right next to the carousel is a golden ring that all the children try to grab as they go around and around. Phoebe is no exception to this and prompts Holden in to thinking: “I was sort of afraid she’d fall off the goddam horse, but I didn’t say anything or do anything. The thing with kids is, if they want to grab the gold ring, you have to let them do it, and not say anything. If they fall off, they fall off, but it’s bad if you say anything to them.”(232) This could be seen as a way for Holden to realize that there is no real need for a catcher in the rye, if they run off the plain of childhood and off the cliff into adult hood this doesn’t mean they are lost forever. Instead it is just something they have to do, it would be bad to say anything to them. Holden sees this moment as a way to coup with the inedibility of growing up. Then after the ride finishes it starts to rain and Phoebe, being the awesome sister she is places Holden’s red hunting cap on his…

    • 1734 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Better Essays

    His initial reaction is much different, upon hearing that the police have recovered Susie’s hat and that the amount of blood they found indicates that she is likely dead, he immediately retreats away. “He was too devastated to reach out to [Abigail] sitting on the carpet…he could not let [her] see him” (Sebold 32). Jack does not know what to do or say to console his family and feels like it is his responsibility to stay strong for their sake. After the initial shock, Jack decides to devote his time to finding Susie’s killer, hoping that he will Susie as well. His efforts are focused on keeping busy so that he may not be reminded that Susie is gone. His constant guilt for not being able to help Susie when she needed it most withdraws him from his own family. Jack is still overcome with grief at times, leading him to break the bottled ships that he and Susie had worked on. He tries to make up for his emptiness by developing a relationship with Lindsey, to replace Susie. His grief also prevents him from developing a strong relationship with his son, Buckley, who constantly feels overshadowed by his older sister’s death. Jacks severe reactions greatly affect the relationships he still has; driving his wife away and forcing Lindsey to grow up prematurely. “[Jack] could see glimmers, like the colored flecks inside my mother’s eyes – things to hold on to” (Sebold 306). Eventually Jack can see that…

    • 1141 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    In doing so, she reflects on her role in their relationship, expressing, “I didn’t know to keep up his strength I had to give up little pieces of mine. I did. I took on his life as mine and mixed up the pieces so that you couldn’t hardly tell which was which anymore.”…

    • 1095 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Holden Caulfield Symbolism

    • 1743 Words
    • 7 Pages

    Phoebe is the youngest figure in his life and is at the age where she is between a child and adolescent. When Holden feels Phoebe’s innocence is threatened, he gets defensive and angry. As he walked the halls of Phoebe’s school he comes across profanity written on the wall and automatically thinks “how Phoebe and all the other little kids who would see it, and how they’d wonder what it meant, and finally some dirty kid would tell them and maybe even worry about it” (201). This upsets him because profanity is a gateway to loosing innocence completely. Phoebe created the whole gist of becoming a hero figure of The Catcher in the Rye. He kept “picturing all these little kids playing some game in this big field of rye and all. Thousands of little kids, and nobody’s around- nobody big, I mean- except me. What I’d have to do, I have to catch everybody if they start to go over the cliff” (173). Holden’s altruistic ideal is now proposed in words that he wants to keep children from falling off the edge, and becoming a grownup which to him is the same as death. Holden than gives Phoebe his red hunting hat as a way to never truly lose her innocence. Only to be disappointed to see her “take off my red hunting hat-the one I gave her- and practically chucked it right in my face” (207). Salinger delibritly put this in the book to show that everyone must lose their innocence at one time or another and cannot be avoided but only postponed. “The thing with kids is, if they want to grab for the gold ring, you have to let them do it, and not say anything. If they fall off, they fall off, but it’s bad if you say anything to them” (211). This challenged the thoughts of Holden’s ideal of being The Catcher in the Rye. Throughout the book he constantly believes he can save others, and watching Phoebe reach for something that she might fall off of scared him, but not enough for him to go save her. He found…

    • 1743 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    One external force that causes Phoebe to change is when her mother left because Phoebe loved her mother. For example, in Walk Two Moons, it states, ‘‘‘It is not. My mom loves me and she would not leave without an explanation.’’’ This quote is from the part when (after Phoebe’s mother left) Phoebe was talking with her father about her mother. It proves that Phoebe loved her mother because she was sure that her mother loves her and wouldn’t leave without telling her. Phoebe is showing that she is worried about her mother and it shows that Phoebe cares about her.…

    • 223 Words
    • 1 Page
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Impact On Sal

    • 422 Words
    • 2 Pages

    The author points out on (page 276) It says one day I realized that our whole trip to Lewiston had been a gift from Gram and Gramps to me.They were giving me a chance to walk in my mother's moccasins.From this I knew that Gram and Gramps were helping Sal to accept her mother's death because Gram and Gramps took there time so Sal can walk in her moccisins.In (Creech 153)”Sometimes you know in your heart you can love someone but you have to go away before your head can figure it out.”The author reveals that when Sal’s mom died it was hard to believe she died,But at the end she accepts her mother's death.So Gram and Gramps made an impact on Sal and helped her to accept her mother’s death. In conclusion ,Walk Two Moons, Sal is impacted by Phoebe's mother.Sharon Creech’s motive for including the theme” relationships impact and change people” was to compare to Phoebe's story.This…

    • 422 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    When Holden comes home at night to see Phoebe, he mentions that regardless of what a kid is doing “they still look all right” (Salinger 207). Holden is watching Phoebe sleep in D.B.’s room right before he wakes her up. He mentions adults look funny when they sleep with their mouths open but kids always look fine. Multiple times throughout the novel, Holden mentions that when kids are young such as in elementary school, they are perfect and innocent. The kids are pure and Holden wants to keep all kids this way by stopping them from growing up. Holden feels that it is his duty to protect younger children by shielding them from the real world and ensuring they are safe. Another instance where Holden shows how Phoebe determines his societal views is when he ponders what would happen to Phoebe if he contracted pneumonia and died. Holden explains Phoebe is “quite fond” (Salinger 202) of him. When pondering this thought, Holden realizes how much he loves Phoebe and what she would go through if he died. Holden decides to sneak home to see Phoebe. Holden gets home and waits for Phoebe to wake up, and then begins to talk to her. Holden talks to Phoebe about D.B. in Hollywood and eventually Phoebe finds out he got kicked out of school. For a while, Phoebe and Holden fight about being kicked out of school but eventually Holden and Phoebe carry on their conversation. At this point in the novel, Holden realizes how special Phoebe is to him and why he is constantly thinking of her. Holden always recalls great memories of Phoebe and he always raves about how pretty and smart she is. Holden loves to strike up conversation with her and always thinks of her when making decisions. Holden realizes Phoebe is a guiding star in his…

    • 656 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    However, he eventually realizes that her loss of innocence will happen regardless of how strongly he tries to stop it. Holden wants to protect Phoebe and the other children at her elementary school from reading vulgar language on the wall. He aims to prevent Phoebe from losing her naivety and innocence by learning what the curse means. It concerns him to simply think about the possibility of this happening. Later on, Holden has a sudden realization. Holden finally comes to accept that children need to grow up and make their own mistakes and learn from them independently. He is willing to let Phoebe grow and realizes that he cannot prevent her from losing her innocence nor can he prevent Jane from doing the same. Even Holden will lose his innocence at some point and there is nothing he can do to stop this. He realizes that the three of them must grow up unlike Allie…

    • 570 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    During the beginning of the book, Sal refused to empathize with others because she thought she had a bigger problem at hand, her mother. In this quote, Sal refuses to empathize with her father and how he Mrs.Cadaver, and her relevance to their family. “Who cares? I thought. Who cares how he met Mrs.Cadaver?” Sal isn’t looking at her father’s perspective and is lacking empathy to her father. She is also disrespecting her father which affects the way she is viewed. In the middle of the novel, Sal is beginning to empathize with Phoebe, when her mother leaves instead of being stubborn and ignoring. “I felt bad for Phoebe. I knew I should get up and try to be nice, but I remembered when I had felt like that, and I knew that sometimes you just wanted to be alone with the birds of sadness.” Sal is starting to empathize with others because instead of forcing a situation with Phoebe she remembers how she felt when her mother left and decided to give Phoebe space and time. At the end of the novel Sal is empathizing with people in all sorts of situations. In this quote, Sal is starting to learn more about herself than at the beginning. “It seems to me that we can’t explain all the truly awful things in the world like war and murder and brain tumors and we can’t fix these things, so we look at the frightening things that are closer to us and we magnify them…

    • 1324 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    This sense of detachment is shown metaphorically in the next line when she states that “[her] daughters and sons have put [her] away with marbles and dolls” (2). This is further shown in a hyperbole to describe her children “putting her away”, when they only drifted apart from her. While her children are putting her away, “her…

    • 187 Words
    • 1 Page
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    • They feel powerless and helpless because they can't get their parents back together. They can't speed up or slow down the process.…

    • 530 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays

Related Topics