Preview

Social Security Privatization

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
527 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Social Security Privatization
Social Security should not be moved into private accounts because that system will not work and instead will dismantle the program. If Social Security were to be privatized, it would be very expensive. By contrast, leaving the government with managing the task of Social Security would be cheaper and allow the government to earn more in returns due to the pay-as-you-go system of the program. That money would then be used in other ways by the government, helping clear the national debt. Even if Social Security is destined to reach insolvency, privatization would not be able to save it. If anything, it would actually make the problem worse, because it would take many workers’ taxes from Social Security and place them into private accounts controlled …show more content…
This cannot happen, for it is immoral, and because it would damage the economy significantly. Another challenge brought upon by this, is that many workers would also be reluctant to pay for retirees’ benefits, while also having to pay taxes for their private accounts (Bosworth and Burtless). Former president, George W. Bush was for privatization and had tried to get it through Congress, during his term, but the attempt was unsuccessful. In his State of the Union address, he stated "We should trust Americans by giving them the option of investing part of their Social Security contributions in private accounts”. This statement does not hide the fact that many Americans have the intelligence when it comes to managing finances. Following his address, where he advocated for privatization, Bush’s public dissatisfaction rose significantly because of the way he handled Social Security. Legislators knew that privatization would not be a good idea, and did not allow the Bush administration’s Social Security to be passed, because his plan would dismantle the program not rebuild it (Galston). However, the fact that private accounts allow for family members to leave their benefits behind for their successors, should be recognized and implemented by the government. Although, overall Social Security is best …show more content…
However, people who support Social Security staying in the hands of the government argue that it is cheaper, it would be difficult to move funds to private accounts, it would build upon the US high national debt, and many Americans don’t have the financial knowledge to make wise investment decisions. Privatization should not occur because it is a risky system that jeopardizes our economy and ultimately will destroy the Social Security program. Even though there are many different viewpoints on this topic, both side of the argument can agree that the problem with Social Security is something that needs to be

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Powerful Essays

    In Saskatchewan, people's attitude towards privatization varies. Today, a growing number of people believe that SaskTel as a Crown corporation should be privatize. There are many critics of SaskTel who call for the privatization of it, if not all Crown corporations. Many argue that SaskTel could operate more efficiently as a private company than as a Crown corporation. Such critics argue that free market is a more efficient mechanism for the allocation of goods and services and that privatization will give the public greater choice at a competitive price. They argue that Crown corporations dominate the Canadian economy and are inefficient, prone to political interference, and distort market forces. They believe that Saskatchewan people deserve to choose which company they would like to do business with and at what price. The public also wants to see the benefits of competition. Most of them think that the government is more worried about protecting one of its cash cows than anything. Supporters of privatization say that it leads to reduced government debt, increased efficiency, and stimulates an entrepreneurial culture. In addition to critics of crown corporations, there are other arguments for the privatization of SaskTel such as the following: First, it is often argued that governments have few incentives to ensure the enterprises they own like SaskTel are well run. Whereas private owners will lose money if their businesses are run poorly, thus public money can sustain even the most inefficient enterprise. Moreover, because federal government owns Crown corporations, public officials may only be interested in improving a Crown corporation when its performance becomes politically sensitive. The government may put off making any improvements to a given corporation due to political sensitivities. Second, corporate executives and personnel may be selected for…

    • 2081 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    In terms of advantages, privatisation of services such as jails and public schools will help to reduce the economic burden on the government. This allows the government to have more funds to devote to other goals such as to lower inequality or providing access to education. Furthermore, the government of United States have always been known for its budget deficit. As such, privatisation can help to reduce this budget deficit and also prevent overcrowding effect from occurring when government borrows funds to sustain what was seen as traditional work such as maintaining prisons and employment agencies. Next, another advantage of privatization will be the improvement in quality of service due to increase in competition. Privatisation will increase number of firms in the industry. As a result, competition will force these firms to increase efficiency and quality of work and this can benefit the public who are able to enjoy services of better quality at lower prices.…

    • 467 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The meaning of Privatization has been widely debated as the years progressed, however one idea scholastics and experts appear to concede to is; privatization is a relationship between a private- sector organization and an administration office with the end goal of finishing a venture that will benefit the pubic. Privatization relationships are the upfront of ideological, political and economic debates, they continue to be used as political tools to solve problems associated with increased demand for public services growing concerns with the size of government, and decreased opportunities for additional resources (MaNamara, Morris 2008). No one public private partnership is the same, each utilizing different arrangements and public management…

    • 211 Words
    • 1 Page
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Thus health insurance in America should be Single Payer for every one deserves to be happy and healthy. Every single person in the United States of America is Human and therefore should be treated as such: they should be treated with respect and kindness and understanding. Every single person deserves to live a life of prosperity and contentment and I believe that Single Payer will bring all Americans one step closer to a life of bliss and peace of mind. Single Payer could save many American lives from the grief and tediousness of everyday…

    • 1842 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Padm 500

    • 330 Words
    • 2 Pages

    The Social Security Administration is sometimes predisposition depending on the prevailing circumstances. Specifically, policy changes are not taken into consideration by the Social Security Administration. At the Social Security Administration, policy are given priority rather than the concerned and welfare of the citizenry. System theory may be used by the Social Security Administration in term of inclination to experiment with new comportments and to adopt those mechanism that seem to be more effective and pragmatic. The SSA obviously exercise no lenience, it focuses more on policy than the welfare and sentiments of the citizenry.…

    • 330 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    The Social Security has managed to maintain a surplus since 1983 and will continue to do so until about 2037, if action isn’t taken to raise taxes or increase the contributions. President Barack Obama has a unique idea of imposing higher payroll taxes on wealthier individuals. Individuals may be under the impression that the Social Security may be broken because the amount of benefits they receive is minimal and expect those benefits to be their sole income. Individuals must come to the realization that Social Security is only there to supplement their income and not be their only means of an…

    • 1690 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Roosevelt is a salient president in this country’s history for multiple reasons, including being the only president to serve more than two terms. One of these key reasons is the Social Security Act. When he began the proposal process to the legislative branch, he actually never used the terms ‘social security’. This is quite significant and sometimes overlooked when defining a problem and framing an issue. FDR would often refer to the plan as economic security to be favorable from both the democrats and the republicans. Another emphasizing term used to frame social security was it’s focus on “Elderly assistance” and that the law is a child of the Great Depression, thus making social security seem innocent and innovative. Altymer states paraphrases President Roosevelt ‘s description as “Furthering the security of the citizen and his family through…

    • 1240 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Trump and any future president must make it an economic prerogative. In the 1930s, Franklin Delano Roosevelt enacted two federal governmental programs to traverse the economic downturn the United States faced. Every American citizen when they reach their sixties are entitled to the programs Social Security and Medicaid. In the 1930s, an American, on average, lived to their early 60s and some did not receive the programs. However, nowadays, the life expectancy for an American is their late 70s and most procure the benefits. The “Baby Boomers”, a generation of rapid growth in the 1950s, are now retiring in masses and accepting Social Security and Medicare. There are not enough working citizens to withstand the aging population and support the entitlement programs. Over two-thirds of the federal budget is tied to entitlement programs and is on path to increase until it consumes the whole budget. Healthcare is the paramount roadblock to the budget crisis with an increase from 5% in 2010 to 20% of the economy in 2050. Obama spent $634 billion to reform the healthcare system and passed the Affordable Care Act, but is seeing the ACA disentangle with the current administration. Clearly, the two parties recognize healthcare as an issue, but are in opposition on how to fix it. The bipartisan issue is facing partisan turmoil and the debt, now exceeding the GDP, will not be conquered until the federal government works…

    • 893 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Privatization In Canada

    • 369 Words
    • 2 Pages

    In other words, when private sectors cannot keep up with demand, or are not able to make deliveries of goods and services, this is when the government will step in to assistance and provide aid. On the contrary, the government will only provide services as long as it benefits citizens. This means that services will only be provided by the government when these services are in of revaluation, high in demand or government assistance is needed, there for services sometimes alter between statuses. Throughout this essay the terms public service and private service sectors will be examined, clearly defined and discussed. Privatization in Canada will also be inspected, and the question of when it is appropriate to privatize public services will be answered with support. The type of services which citizens should have access to will also be clarified and public interest will also be explored. Therefore, this essay will argue that Canadian businesses and corporations should be public sector services when the main function of the businesses are to serve citizens with essential services and goods, whereas self-sufficient businesses and corporations which have mainly profit in mind should be privatized for the good of Canadian…

    • 369 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Our debt is going to consume the nation in the future and welfare is just one of the…

    • 643 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    I have found that there is one major drawback to social insurance, the growth in our population. With an increase in population and a decrease in the job market, it is harder for people to go back to work when they have been laid off. Our economy at this point is still unstable. With more and more workers joining the workforce each day and our jobs being sent overseas it is easy to see the drawback to social insurance programs. The one drawback for Social Security according to Chambers & Wedel (2005) is that if we are to make it to the projected year of 2040, those who are in workforce will be forced to provide a higher amount of money out of their checks. I feel that any drawback related to social insurance funding is based upon the growth in population and the decrease in our…

    • 302 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    The privatization of Social Security basically means that each account would be individually owned and operated (Anders and Hulse). Presently, the funds received from each individual’s payroll tax are invested in the Social Security trust fund, which is controlled by the government (Koleva). As said by writer Yoana Koleva, “these accounts actually do not belong to the employees and are more of a tracking mechanism that provides information to determine the benefit amount received once the employee reaches normal retirement age” (Koleva). Therefore, privatization proposes that the accounts are privately owned and controlled, as opposed to the current system in which each individual’s Social Security account is controlled by the…

    • 2274 Words
    • 10 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Health Care Reform

    • 864 Words
    • 4 Pages

    From FDR's New Deal to Lyndon Johnson's Great Society, the United States government has attempted to centralize extensive social policies. In the early eighties, when recession and inflation were at a high, Ronald Reagan took office and pronounced that the federal government needed to take a lesser role in the lives of the American people. As Theda Skocpol comments in her book Boomerang: Clinton's Health Security Effort and the Turn Against Government in U.S. Politics, the Reagan administration instilled a dislike of centralized government in the American people. This was a major reason, according to Skocpol, why the Clinton Administration failed to nationalize "Health Security". It was this fear of centralized government and Clinton's failure to reform Health Care that makes a more centralized social policy unlikely in the near future.…

    • 864 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Viewpoints On Welfare

    • 1406 Words
    • 6 Pages

    Welfare should not be government funded because people must work for what they want and not rely on government…

    • 1406 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Since Franklin D Roosevelt created the Social Security act in 1935 after the great depression many Americans have depended on it as their only source of income after they retire. People were not overwhelmed with worry about saving for retirement because the act had been considered a great success for many years. A survey of 1,200 people done through AARP “confirms that Social Security is at the very core of most Americans’ retirement” (Pianin, 2015). However in recent years worry about retirement and social security has been on the rise for many aging Americans. According to a Gallup Survey recently published “66 percent of Americans believe Social Security is in a “state of crisis,” while slightly more than half of those still working doubt they will ever receive Social Security benefits” (Pianin, 2015).…

    • 1598 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Good Essays