According to Sontag the desire for beauty is not wrong but the obligation is. Women like being flattered by the opposite sex thus making women feel inferior. The ideal form of beauty that is set by American society makes women scrutinize every part of their bodies, which creates this self-oppression. Women want to achieve that perfection that men want from women in order to be considered beautiful. I agree with Sontag 's claim, because women are judged thoroughly by how they look and what they must wear in order to achieve beauty. This forces women to analyze each part of their body, such as how Sontag explains, "Breasts, feet, hip each in turn is submitted to an anxious, fretful often despairing scrutiny" (par. 6). This gives them this obligation to BE beautiful and make changes. Men, however, are less compelled to be beautiful and don 't feel the need to make changes. As a young adult - woman, most of the time I feel required to "dress-up" when I walk out of my dorm room. However, there are times that I look at myself and think why should I "dress-up?" However, I still do, just because I feel that obligation. The American media now a day plays a big role in stereotyping women and how they should appear. More and more, we see the American Media placing those anorexic looking women on the cover of magazines. In addition, we 've seen a number of new technologies, mainly for women in our time, to improve their bodies. During the publication of Sontag 's article, there wasn 't as much pressure or technology for women to achieve the ideal beauty that the American society portrays. Women, in this day and age, undergo plastic surgery, botox, and enhancements to be just like those women on the cover of Vogue or other influential magazines. Unlike women, men aren 't dissected into different parts to improve their image, although there are ways to help improve men 's appearances as well. Not only does the American Media portray those extremely thin, flawless skinned "beautiful" models on the cover, causing women to want that image, those models also portrays health issues that concern women, such as bulimia and anorexia. However, it is less common to see these sorts of health issues for men. Another article supporting Sontag 's view, as well as my view, is by Tara Eastland. She explains the theories of sexuality, sexism, and cultural ideals. This article, "Eating Disorders: A Feminist Issue," explains how these theories lead women into developing eating disorders. In the beginning of this article, Eastland makes an argument by saying that fat is a symbol of women 's sexuality and her power. She then supports her argument through Naomi Wolf, explaining that eating disorders are a way for women to defy the society of men and denying their own sexuality. Eastland then goes on stating that sexism is another reason for these eating disorders. Women have to keep up with the "ideal" feminine appearances and actions. Not only does sexuality and sexism develop these disorders, so does our cultural ideal of beauty. Eastland continues saying that women see eating disorder as some sort of an achievement. Thus, they feel as if they have gained that ideal beauty that our cultural ideal portrays. Eastland believes that our media, such as the fashion industry, exploit women 's beauty. Men lead these industries and are the ones who promote this sort of beauty through placing skinny looking girls on magazines and televisions. She then goes on stating that in order to solve this issue; the media/society should embrace all sorts of women 's body types. In her article, Eastland summarizes that our society "instructs" women to fulfill certain behaviors and appearances; thus causing women to distort their body through eating disorders. Tara Eastland supports Sontag 's and my view of how society depicts the beauty of a woman and how they should achieve that ideal perfection of beauty. Showing how sexist our society is such as how Eastland states " female thinness is not an obsession about female beauty but an obsession about female obedience If women cannot eat the same food as men, we cannot experience equal status in the community" (qtd. in Eastland par 2). This quote proves that if women aren 't "obedient" they are considered unattractive. This causes women to feel bad about their looks because of how the patriarchal society depicts women. If women don 't conform to the ideal standard of beauty they can 't be considered beautiful. As clearly shown in Eastland 's Eating Disorders: a Feminist Issue, there is an unfair standard of beauty between men and women. The sexism depicted within the article also plays a role in how society influences women. Eastland states that, "The anorexic may begin her journey defiant, but from the point of view of a male dominated society, she ends up as the perfect woman. She is weak, sexless, and voiceless, and can only with difficulty focus on world beyond her plate" (par. 5). This illustrates that when a woman transitions from this full figured woman to a thin stick, she is considered beautiful to a man; however, she then becomes weak inferior, without real power, because she conforms to this sort of action. As a young college student, I was under the influence that being skinny would/will make me beautiful. It is observed that amongst college women, there are disturbed eating habits (Eastland, par 11). During my first year, I had decided to become a vegetarian because I didn 't want to gain the freshmen fifteen. Not only did I become a vegetarian, I would also skip meals, and go to the gym every day for two three hours. I had felt that need to conform to American society 's ideal standard of beauty. This incident reminded me of Eastland 's argument which stated, that women who have eating disorders might challenge their pursuit for thinness aggressively, but in the end she will end up looking and feeling like the perfect woman because she finally attains society 's ideal beauty (par 5). After I had returned home for the summer, I weighed myself and discovered I was 98 pounds, which was not normal for my height. My mother, family, friends, and even high school - teachers were saying that I looked thin. I was pleased by the comments, but then was also question if I was anorexic or bulimic. Of course the answer was no, but I still knew it was a form of an eating disorder as well as psychological mind games. Once I had attained that "look," I was pleased by it. However, I had realized that having this sort of diet was killing me inside. I was truly not happy, my energy was drained, and I lacked that vibe I once had. I slowly and continue to struggle with returning to "normal" diet: by eating regularly, exercising but not to an extreme, and decided to not be a vegetarian. Becoming "normal" again is a hard task because I still have to overcome the influence of the media. In Eastland 's article states that sexist roles in society cause women to have a lower self esteem and a loss of control resulting in eating disorders (par. 11). As a young adult, I look around and I feel as if I am judged because I am not going with the ideal standards of beauty. The fact that I feel as if I am being judged does lower my self esteem and brings me down emotionally. The damages of American society and media are not only seen through physically, but also mentally. Eastland states within her article: "The ideology of semistarvation undoes feminism; what happens to women 's bodies happens to our minds. If women 's bodies are and have always been wrong whereas men 's are right Where feminism taught woman to put higher value on ourselves, hunger teaches us how to erode our self esteem " (par. 17)
The notion of women being categorized as only something good to look at forces women to self - oppress. However, there needs to be a radical change that should occur. Such a change could happen through altering the perception and accepting all types of women 's beauty, by broadcasting it through our media through television, magazines, even the fashion industry (par 17). Becoming influenced by male dominated society 's standards of beauty, women become weak, sexless, and voiceless (par. 5). The fact that women compare themselves to these thin anorexic models is not mentally and physically healthy; women should embrace their body types and what they were given. After my realization of not being happy inside, my mind is affected because it appears as if I am being judged because I am not trying to achieve the ideal look. However, reading a statement in Eastland article, "Fat is sexual in women to ask women to become unnaturally thin is to ask them to relinquish their sexuality. Women who develop eating disorders, especially anorexia, are denying their sexuality and natural female body" stated in Eastland 's article (par. 3). I realized that this is who I am. Women shouldn 't look at their "flaws" as unattractive, but as something that makes them unique from other women. The American media places an "unequal burden on women" to preserve that ideal feminine appearance, it is also stated that men profit from the thin ideal (par 7). Why not use this same method in promoting beauty of every woman? Beauty does not only come from the physical appearance but also from within. To be truly happy as a woman, one should appreciate what they have instead of being satisfied with superficial enhancements to attain American society 's standard of beauty. Men and the American society should look at women wholly, as a person, not through individual parts - physically. Women have beauty that appears outward and inward, which shows through their personality, nurturance - kindness, and intelligence; similar to how the Greeks had looked at beauty outward and inward. Magazines and televisions should bring out these women 's inner attributes because that is something that shows who they really are, not just by the ideal standards of American society. Many leading women in our generation project this sort of beauty of being successful as well as showing their physical attributes; look at Hillary Rodham Clinton, Tyra Banks, Oprah, and many more. These women have come a long way of becoming beautiful successful women that they are today. The beauty that personifies from these beautiful and successful women comes from their individual attributes as a whole. We as women should learn to believe in our own beauty inside and out.
Works Cited
Busceni, Santi and Smith, Charlotte. "75 readings: An Anthology Women 's Beauty: Put Down or Power Source?"
Eastland, Tara. "Eating Disorders: A Feminist Issue" Vanderbilt 14 Oct. 2006
Cited: Busceni, Santi and Smith, Charlotte. "75 readings: An Anthology – Women 's Beauty: Put Down or Power Source?" Eastland, Tara. "Eating Disorders: A Feminist Issue" Vanderbilt 14 Oct. 2006
You May Also Find These Documents Helpful
-
We as Americans reminisce on history to see and understand the advancements we have accomplished and the same can be said of not only the advancement of women but also the image of how women are portrayed. Although in today’s day and age, their figures and beauty are scrutinized but also exploited. For instance in both Tennessee Williams motion picture, “A Street Car Named Desire” and Lorraine Hansberry A Raisin in the Sun you are able to see the evolution of the not only the portal of women but also the advancements they accomplish.…
- 508 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
As the text states, “All memories of the time when women were considered beautiful have been expunged, because the power beauty gave them over men was considered an insult to manhood” (Burdekin 412). The men in the text understood that in order to maintain order and dominance, beautiful women cannot exist. This behavior is similar to the modern cultural practices of Middle Eastern countries, where females are restricted to clothing that obscures their beauty, whereas, women in the United States promote equality and freedom in dress, thus representing women’s fear of losing their identity and the ability to express their…
- 1842 Words
- 8 Pages
Better Essays -
Interwoven through the Encyclopedia’s entries, one can trace the way the Enlightenment thinkers constructed the ideal characteristics of a “natural” woman. The…
- 1458 Words
- 6 Pages
Better Essays -
* No it is not neutral or stable. Health is measured on certain medical statistics, but the type of questions asked or the type of people analyzed vary based on sex, . Health standards vary according to climate, age, height, class, diet, gender, race, and bodily configurations. All of these influence health as a concept. The body is never in a state of perfect optimum health. Have a cold? Not enough sleep? Tripped on the way to class and have a bruise? The body is always in an ever-fluctuating state. Health also depends on what people feel about themselves. “What’s important is that I feel healthy.”…
- 2374 Words
- 10 Pages
Good Essays -
Cited: Barry, Dave. "The Ugly Truth About Beauty." The Longman Reader. 7th ed. Ed. Judith Nadell, John Langan, and Eliza A. Comodromos. New York. Pearson, 2005. 368-70…
- 859 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
Both “The Birthmark” by Nathaniel Hawthorne and “Eye of the Beholder” by Rod Serling are both short stories that introduce two young, beautiful women who, despite their beauty, are castigated by positions of power for their uniqueness. While Hawthorne uses symbolism and third person omniscient storytelling to create an allegory in which perfection among the common is what’s desired by its characters, Serling tells of a world in which the thing that’s unacceptable by society’s standards is non uniformity. However, each author suggests that society’s obsession with supremacy and unattainable standards of beauty results only in the conflict and segregation of peoples.…
- 470 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
Beauty in all of its intricate aspects, can be misinterpreted, judged, and crushed to its very core for the same reasons it was once praised. Society diminishes the prominence of beauty, while simultaneously inflicting pressure on the eradication of its imperfections. Women, nowadays, rely on more than just water, soap, and self-confidence to fabricate the mask society deems as pragmatic, and truly necessary. Although the misconception of the physical qualities possessing the upper level in the hierarchical scale of beauty has blindsided millions, there is time remaining to instill the concepts of authentic beauty, according to the article by Nicole James. Knowledge does not necessarily amplify wisdom, and therefore despite the exponentially…
- 434 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
Communication is very important between people of different ages and abilities. It enables people build relationships with others at their own level of communication, it is important to be able to communicate at different levels and different methods of communication to enable the child, young person and adult to develop good communication skills and be able to hold conversations with others. Communication helps everybody to develop confidence and self esteem and to help the person forget they have a communication difficulty as every one will be able to communicate at appropriate levels.…
- 1038 Words
- 5 Pages
Good Essays -
Answer the following questions in 50 to 150 words each. Provide citations for all the sources you use.…
- 430 Words
- 2 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
· For the Greeks, beauty was a virtue: A kind of excellence. Persons then were assumed to be what we now have to call—lamely, enviously—whole persons. If it did occur to the Greeks to distinguish between a person’s “inside” and “outside,” they still expected that inner beauty would be matched by beauty of the other kind. The well-born young Athenians who gathered around Socrates found it quite paradoxical that their hero was so intelligent, so brave, so honorable, so seductive—and so ugly. One of Socrates’ main pedagogical acts was to be ugly—and teach those innocent, no doubt splendid-looking disciples of his how full of paradoxes life really was.…
- 1030 Words
- 5 Pages
Good Essays -
Is there true beauty or is it all just a cultural construct? “The Birthmark” and “The Eye of the Beholder” both provide treatments of beauty and perfection by showcasing a woman’s struggles to reach societies standards. Although the core meaning of the texts are in relation, the writers of each text use different literary devices to shape the way that the message and the perception of idealized beauty is portrayed to the audience. Author Nathaniel Hawthorne uses symbolism, imagery, and allusions while writer…
- 560 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
To begin his argument, he states that the concept of beauty confuses him, especially the idea of a beauty standard. Socrates proceeds to say that beauty does not have a standard, rather everything contains beauty in its own form. If one was to ask Socrates the question of what is considered beautiful, Socrates would answer that everything can contain beauty, but one must recognize the beauty in something for it to be labeled as beautiful. This answer is the safest one he can provide, for he feels that this principle will never be overthrown. Socrates’s believes that “by beauty beautiful thing become…
- 1151 Words
- 5 Pages
Better Essays -
In A Woman’s Beauty: Put Down or Power Source?, Susan Sontag elaborates on the internal hardships women face due to societal gender roles that have existed for millenniums. She poses a series of historical and modern day contradictions to highlight the absurdities of these rigid gender roles and the way we think about the role of women. While her message is meant to appeal to all women, she risks alienating many who may feel as if beauty is something they truly don’t want to give up.…
- 1599 Words
- 7 Pages
Better Essays -
Beauty has been something to talk about up into ancient times. Women that are seen in portraits and old photographs are symbols of what…
- 1366 Words
- 6 Pages
Good Essays -
In ancient India, the women enjoyed equal status with men in all fields of life. Works by ancient Indian grammarians such as Patanjali and Katyayana suggest that women were educated in the early Vedic period. Rigvedic verses suggest that the women married at a mature age and were probably free to select their husband. Scriptures such as Rig Veda and Upanishads mention several women sages and seers, notably Gargi and Maitreyi.…
- 1240 Words
- 5 Pages
Better Essays