Socrates’ metaphor, “filling of a vessel,” relates to our type of educational system and administration. It is often that teachers do not want students to ask questions they cannot answer; they do not want them to question why everything is the way they it is, yet they force students to memorize it and know it for evaluations. This method of teaching does not give students anything valuable since they are not learning, they are memorizing. Memorizing a text is not the same as understanding the text presented and fully comprehending the information given.
Therefore, the “filling of a vessel” is not defined as education. To be able to understand the information presented defines education and its purpose.
The “kindling of a flame” is referring to thought and curiosity leading to asking questions in order to fully understand what we are learning. It is to teach information and have them understand what they are learning. Our education in school should be about grasping information and what it’s about instead of having to memorize something without knowing what we are memorizing.
The education we have in school is not as valuable in a mental nature in comparison to the education system we have now. This is because our whole lives our job is to memorize and regurgitate what we have been instructed to do resulting in a system that is not real education. The real education is the kind that where one is to ask questions in order to understand. It is the kind we unfortunately do not use in our education system. It is the kind we learn on our own from other sources.
You May Also Find These Documents Helpful
-
Freeing from the psychological prison we create by continuously depending on what we see and understand to be true realities can be achieved in learning and logical reasoning. “Will he not fancy that the shadows which he formerly saw are truer than the objects which are now shown to him?” (Socrates 19). Demonstrated in this quote, is the beginning stage of acceptance and awareness; hesitation. This growing open-minded approach to unfamiliar situations is required in order to leave behind our old and ignorant ways. Socrates suggests to the reader that preparation for the real world and a need to pursue truths through the use of education will serve as guidance down more desirable life paths. He also introduces the idea of the immense responsibility those who have been fortunate enough to access higher education have to provide leadership and improvement in society. But, with the power of wisdom, comes ridicule and seclusion due to the ignorance prevalent in a population that prefers to live with their minds trapped inside the cave.…
- 402 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
Education allows people to learn more about themselves, and therefore, learn more about each other. Really, the only thing that makes sense in life is to strive for greater collective enlightenment. Plato shows how people become content with life’s delusions when they are not constantly seeking the truth and how experiencing new things will expand their mind to new thoughts and ideas that they were previously blind to. Frederick Douglass shows how humans can use the lack of education to keep others in the dark and only through education can those people break free. Thomas Newman presents the idea that once you are educated, you shouldn’t be satisfied and you should continue to seek out new forms of knowledge. These three author’s ideas collectively…
- 163 Words
- 1 Page
Good Essays -
To learn, it takes from the individual ardor, desire, and passion/interest. He goes into detail of how reading helps us to accomplish this task, and how a lot of what we read helps dictate who we become in the end. He concludes with the opportunities that arise from one following…
- 164 Words
- 1 Page
Good Essays -
Education is not given the credence it deserves . we are a nation that has become accustomed to instant gratification. The very things that will create long term excellence and security for our country is being ignored in favor of the pursuit of frivolous materialism and…
- 795 Words
- 4 Pages
Better Essays -
What do students obtain through education? Freire in his essay ‘The Banking Concept of Education’ argues that students gain useless and meaningless knowledge through education, and I agree with Freire because education has become an act of depositing meaningless information into students. Freire believes the current educational system is flawed due to the “Banking Concept”, which Freire describes as, “an act of depositing, in which the students are the depositories and the teacher is the depositor”(Freire 72). Freire implies that teachers are only telling students what to know rather than conversting with them, which explains why Freire insists that “education is suffering from narration sickness”(Freire 71). This means that he believes that educators only fill student’s minds with information, that the teacher feels is important, without providing the students the meaning and personal relevance that information has. By using this method, the student is oppressed by the teacher and unable to fulfill a complete state of consciousness. I can remember several times in my educational experiences where I have been the “depository” in Freire’s Banking Concept of Education, but no experience is more relative than my Organic Chemistry class three years ago where I learned that problem-solving education is vastly superior to banking-education because it allows students to acquire true understanding of their world and the ability to reach consciousness.…
- 2451 Words
- 10 Pages
Powerful Essays -
In “The allegory of the Cave” Plato argues that education is not a matter of making the blind to see but of turning the learner “in the right direction.” What he means by this is that education is not about feeding someone information and expecting them to take it as the truth. It is about encouraging them to seek out the truths in the world around them, and helping them acquire the tools to do so. This point is extremely relevant to education today, which is mostly about test scores, and textbooks when it should be about helping students think creatively and encouraging them search for the truths in their lives.…
- 504 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
This method of “filling” students with information is “static” according to Freire and the significance of what is being educated is drained from the words. Instead of gaining the significance to what is being taught the “words are emptied from their concreteness and become hollow” (318). This is one of the reasoning’s behind why Freire believes the banking concept of education is a poor method of teaching.…
- 643 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
“This function of opening and feeding the human mind is not to be fulfilled by any mechanical or military method...in education our common sense fails us, and we are continually trying costly machinery against nature” (Emerson).…
- 942 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
Socrates was searching for the meaning of things; he wanted proof of what was defined which would give logical reason for itself. The fact that really hurt Athenians was the attack of the most fundamental principles of Athenian life. Socrates did not recruit people to follow him; rather he went out and asked them their views. His lectures were not characterized by forcing his ideas onto other people. The individuals brought their point of views on particular subject in dialogues set up by Socrates. Socrates’ way of testing or challenging a belief is by seeing what believer is committed to. A man, who makes a statement, especially in debate with Socrates, must…
- 2204 Words
- 9 Pages
Better Essays -
Still, there are many people who are in opposition to Socrates’ decision of remaining in prison and firmly waiting for his execution. Some critics would claim that Socrates is causing harm by accepting his execution and bringing an end to his life as a teacher. Yet, this claim is refuted because whether Socrates was executed, or he chose to escape and fled into exile, he would not have been able to teach the Athenian people either well. Also, he is not harming others through his death because of the incapability of doing good deeds by living. This means that Socrates would not be doing the right deed by not facing his death penalty because in order for him to continue to make the correct decision, Socrates has to both not escape prison and follow…
- 546 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
Education is about learning past events; about knowing historical figures; about learning important facts and information about the country you live in. Education is about learning of the world around us… Or so one would like to think. Education in America today has become a conglomerate of corporate distortion.…
- 301 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
Humanity’s most basic problem according to Socrates is ignorance. People have the tendency to think way too highly of themselves. They even become ignorant of their own ignorance. [The Apology 24b-26e]…
- 1851 Words
- 8 Pages
Good Essays -
The roots of education are bitter, but the fruit is sweet – Aristotle. Education is the wise, hopeful and respectful development of learning undertaken in the belief that everyone should have the chance to share in life. When you think of education, you think of places like schools or colleges that teach and tutor students in order to prepare them for the future. We notice that education is a concept almost everyone would agree is a universal good, also one that is plagued by seemingly endless controversy because education is said to be a powerful opportunity that you can either build from, or destroy all at once, it’s your choice. Education is built upon years of hard work, surpassing the all difficulties along the way. When in doubt you…
- 1435 Words
- 6 Pages
Powerful Essays -
The profound philosopher and scientist Aristotle know for his contributions to society and the study of humans proclaims “The roots of education are bitter, but the fruit is sweet”. (Aristotle). Through Aristotle, one can understand that education is vital to the success of humans and education is an arduous task, that often enough discourages many people, but reaches an equilibrium point of benefit’s. The quest of education, is a journey that leads to the demise of many, as society advances the quest only than becomes more prominent in the survival of the human’s success in our world.…
- 953 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
Learning is a natural ability that is wired into many animals DNA; the way that humans should learn has been debated by the various educators because of the endless ways to teach. Teachers and parents take this matter seriously like Ralph Waldo Emerson in “From Education” and Todd Gitlin in “The Liberal Arts in an Age of Info-Glut” who created essays on education; and Billy Collins in “The History Teacher” entail for then and who wrote a poem concerned with the status of education. These people show what the importance of education is entailing what learning should and should not involve; a teacher should respect and have patience for children; a teacher should also let a child have creativity and lessons of the past.…
- 851 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays