MacCaig uses word choice to describe the sparrow and other birds in relation to different types of classes within society. MacCaig begins by describing the sparrow by saying “He’s no artist”, “a proletarian bird.” meaning someone whose only contribution to the state is his offspring and calls the sparrow “dowdy” meaning dull clothes with no colour. MacCaig is saying that the sparrow is nothing special; the sparrow is dull, talentless, boring and colourless. MacCaig continues by saying that he lives in “a slum” and would “rather a punch up in a gutter.” to gliding over oceans. By this we can assume that the sparrow rough and violent. Whereas MacCaig describes the other birds as “ballet dancers, musicians, architects” therefore MacCaig is saying that the other birds are talented and educated which is a complete contrast to his description of the sparrow.
MacCaig continues to contrast the sparrow and other birds by stating in stanza three about the sparrow that “He carries what learning he has lightly ... on the usefulness whose result is survival.” MacCaig is saying here that the sparrow only keeps what information is useful to his survival. Whereas MacCaig then states that the other birds will “die in the snow” when winter begins and that the sparrow will survive. MacCaig is commenting that despite the other birds various talents it is the dowdy talentless bird that continues to live and that the educated talented birds will die because their talents and education is not what can get them through difficult times. Therefore the poem informs