Top-Rated Free Essay
Preview

Specialization vs. Generalization in Education

Powerful Essays
1267 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Specialization vs. Generalization in Education
Specialization vs. Generalization in Education

Everywhere we turn today we see specialization. The most respected and well paid doctors and dentists are often those who perform just a few procedures. Many attorneys cover just one area of law. Even kids are specializing in how they play! With the spread of “travel teams” whose seasons are often more than six months per year, young athletes, starting at the age of 8 or so, are now forced to choose one or two sports at the expense of all others.
Specialization produces excellence—but only within a narrow range of endeavor. We have become a society where even the narrowest of activities is treated as a sport with its own heroes. Repetition and mastery of a very specific activity is now the model of stardom. But even Adam Smith, the famous economist who advocated the division of labor in society, admitted that the system had a major drawback:
The man whose whole life is spent in performing a few simple operations has no occasion to exert his understanding, or to exercise his invention in finding out expedients for removing difficulties which never occur. He naturally loses, therefore, the habit of such exertion, and generally becomes as stupid and ignorant as it is possible for a human creature to become. (Adam Smith, The Wealth of Nations, 1776, Book 5, Part III, Chapter II)
Smith never solved this riddle: How to get all the material advantages of specialization while avoiding its intellectual pitfalls? But it’s clear that he saw educational reform as the best option—his critique of the division of labor is located in a discussion of educational reform.
Today even college education, which used to aim to produce versatile professionals, is specialized. This has been the case for a long time; it has been a major social trend since the end of World War II. The expansion of the American university system, and more precisely, the growth of graduate certification, is a major factor here.
Consider a B.A. student who shows promise in historical studies. The student can choose not to specialize at the B.A. level but will probably opt to write a B.A. thesis on a pretty focused subject, simply because a thesis is expected of those who apply to graduate school.
When the student moves on to the M.A. level, the student will now be required to declare a specialty, such as modern Britain. Finally, for the Ph.D. the student must produce a very long dissertation on a specific topic within the specialty: charity groups in early Victorian England. At this stage, generalizing and synthesizing count for little. Showing complete mastery of the particular topic is everything.
Ironically, as the student advances through the degree system, he or she learns more and more about less and less.
The same is often true in the technical fields. Many students now specialize in computer science and acquire no basic knowledge of engineering or other fields. That might be okay if the field of computer science did not in turn break down into specialties, such as cyber security, information retrieval, and so forth.
What are the costs of this specialization? One cost is that the areas of learning that we call “disciplines” are now exciting only to those inside of them; often, they even fail to inspire insiders for their whole career. The massive expansion of universities in recent decades has made it possible to produce hundreds of experts on Victorian England. They can now hold their own conferences and sustain their own journals. But who benefits and who cares? Even the specialists are suffering from doubts about who their audience is and what their role in society as a whole is. A tone of self-abnegation and cynicism is palpable among many academics today.
Another cost is that students rarely encounter university teachers who think across disciplines or pose vital problems that cut through multiple fields. As a result, the students are often bored and stifled. They feel they are being tested on their disciplinary knowledge and not on their capacity to assemble the building blocks of knowledge in a creative way.
The biggest cost is the risk that we will not have individuals capable of rising to the pressing needs of our time. In “Interdisciplinary Problem-Based Learning: An Alternative to Traditional Majors and Minors,” Robert J. Sternberg of Tufts University identifies four such needs:
(1) finding a way to manage—or ideally eradicate— epidemics (e.g., AIDS, SARS, perhaps avian flu); (2) achieving ways to manage or eliminate terrorism and terrorist attacks; (3) finding ways to combat global warming and related changes in the atmosphere before it is too late to keep the earth habitable to humans; and (4) developing positive, effective, ethical leaders who have at heart the best interests of all their stakeholders, rather than primarily their own interests or those of groups to which they feel they owe allegiance as a result of family, tribal, political party, economic, or religious ties.
Sternberg adds: “These four major problems, in common with virtually all problems facing the world, can be solved only through multidisciplinary thinking. They very well could form the bases for problem-based majors and minors in university settings.” (Published inLiberal Education, Winter, 2008, vol. 94, no. 1)
Sternberg describes a new initiative at Tufts to encourage students to combine diverse disciplines into specially crafted majors. However, right here at UMass Amherst, we have had the kind of program he describes since the 1970s. The Bachelor’s Degree With An Individual Concentration (BDIC) is a program in which students invent their own cross-interdisciplinary majors.
The student must draw on at least three disciplines and must envision ways of applying the special major in his or her future career. Examples of such majors are: “Economics and Legal Studies,” “Marketing, Communication, and Graphic Design,” “Organizational Development,” “International Peace Studies,” “Computer Applications in Finance and Economics,” “Film and Women’s Studies,” “Community Health Education,” and “Arts Administration.”
The students are energized by the fact that they construct a unique and interdisciplinary curriculum. One student wrote in her senior summary: “I can say that I truly enjoyed what I studied in college. After all, I’m the one who created it.” Instead of being tested on their mastery of a pre-existing discipline, the students get credit for being inventive. Many BDIC alumni have gone on to become versatile and thoughtful leaders in fields related to their specially designed majors.
Fortunately, there is a growing trend among colleges and universities to offer programs like BDIC. The University of Connecticut was one of the first to follow the lead of UMass by establishing an Individualized Major Program in 1974. More such programs have been founded in recent years in response to the widespread disenchantment with conventional academic structures.
These programs are not perfect. But they provide a partial alternative to the problem of specialization in modern society. Today everyone has a responsibility to ask themselves whether they are reaching as high and wide as they could in their education and careers. Educators in particular need to challenge themselves. We need more academic degrees that produce a versatile problem-solving competence, and fewer degrees that merely attest to specialized expertise.
Or maybe we need fewer academic degrees, period. A greater willingness among university administrators to hire persons who have been successful in real life activities, whether or not they have doctoral degrees would certainly invigorate the academy. Our future may well depend on having more people who are less educated involved in the instruction of our youth.

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    Benefit Of Sports Essay

    • 951 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Athletics is ingrained in the human experience and is an integral part of American culture. Because of that, many of my weekends and after school hours have been dedicated to either watching a game or starting one with the kids in the neighborhood. Athletics runs deep in my family. My great uncle was a professional baseball player and my family, including my father, three brothers and a sister, are all very involved with the various team sports. It’s this immersion into various sporting activities that has led me to the understanding that engaging in athletics has a very positive impact in our lives. Additionally, sports are extremely important in building one’s character through hard work, learning to work with others on a team and by learning how to cope with the joy of winning and the inevitability of losing.…

    • 951 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Fewer kids play amid pressure.” by Machael Rosenwald, the author addresses an issue widely faced by many children. Quitting sports because of the pressure their parents put on to them to keep playing to hopefully become a professional “elite athlete”. A survey was taken to see what the top factors contributing to kids happiness was. The results helped to prove the fact that children aren’t in games for winning or being the best. This is proven when the article reads, “...low on the list: playing in tournaments, cool uniforms and expensive equipment. High on the list: positive team dynamics, trying hard, positive coaching and learning”(Rosenwald 3). As this shows, children enjoy not being pushed to constantly be the best. Instead, they prefer being encouraged and not being forced into…

    • 478 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Before 10,000 BCE the primary source of drink was water. When beer was discovered in Mesopotamia it was considered a step up from water. Water was…

    • 451 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Professional athletes are celebrities in today’s world. The superstars of their sport get paid millions of dollars every year. They are also role models for many young people that wish to play the same sport. But it wasn’t always that way; however, sports have always been affected by the culture of that time. In the 1960’s sports have been affected by war, racism, and politics.…

    • 1175 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Submitted by: Stephanie Sturgill, Candidate for B.A. in Physical Education, Morehead State University, Dr. Steve Chen, Assistant Professor of Sport Management, Morehead State University…

    • 2489 Words
    • 10 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Dark Ages Ahead Analysis

    • 773 Words
    • 4 Pages

    In “Credentialing Versus Educating”, the third chapter of Dark Ages Ahead, Jane Jacobs discusses a change in the intent and practice of higher education at universities and colleges. “Credentialing, not educating, has become the primary business of North American universities” (Jacobs 44). The institution of education has shifted its focus from passing on knowledge and teaching students to have critical faculties for the stability and growth of society, to simply certifying individuals in order to be considered for a job. Educating involves the learning of new concepts and gaining proper knowledge while credentialing is focused on obtaining a degree through four years of higher education. Jacobs makes the distinction by outlining that an education and a degree are not the same thing. According to Jacobs, there is an emphasis on selecting job applicants who have desirable qualities such as persistence, ambition, and the ability to cooperate and conform.…

    • 773 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Are College Athletes Paid

    • 2258 Words
    • 10 Pages

    The term, “student athlete” is a polarizing one. In today’s America, college sports -- particularly football and basketball, are as much a part of the sports enthusiast’s landscape as is any professional sport. In any case, with enthusiasm comes money. In this case, billions of dollars are generated by television viewership, merchandise sales and university boosters. College athletes are the driving force behind an industry where television executives, university presidents, athletic directors and coaches are compensated in a manner which makes them among the most wealthy people in the world. The athletes receive in return an education from a well respected university, along with name and sometimes facial recognition in their fields of interest. However,…

    • 2258 Words
    • 10 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Student athletes work hard to be extremely successful. In addition to school, recruitable athletes devote over twenty hours a week to their sport. Athletes devote time and money to become successful, additionally, athletes raise hundreds of thousands of dollars for the schools that they play for just by getting people to come to their games alone. Athletes receive scholarships to play for schools, but these…

    • 895 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    One of Americans’ favorite pastime activities has been watching or participating in college athletics. College athletics have always been something more pure and interesting than professional athletics because it isn’t about the money. However, over the years, college athletics have changed for the worse, as players have been drifting further away, core reason being lack of funds for the players (Eric, p. 250). This has led to the call for reforms in the National Collegiate Athletic Association (NCAA) decision against payments for student-athletes.…

    • 745 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    As early as the third grade, I remember being involved in sports. Whether it was volleyball, basketball, or dance I have been given the privilege to play on many teams. The life of a young athlete is great, however, it can become very stressful. At all ages an athlete is forced to cope with school, sports, and a social life. Along with all of that, athletes are expected to deal with extra stress and even stricter rules. Over the years I have realized all student-athletes are treated differently and are held to a higher standard. (1)…

    • 499 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    I, Pencil

    • 303 Words
    • 2 Pages

    Adam Smith’s “invisible hand” is illustrated in the story by having each person working for themselves to make a profit thus creating something society wants, pencils. The government may have a problem in producing a pencil because choosing the people who would be the most efficient in each job is extremely complicated, if not impossible.…

    • 303 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Sports are traced back to 760 B.C. and are still a big part of society’s entertainment today. In today’s world, everyone wants to be the best at sports and will do anything to accomplish that, which is exactly what athletic programs all around the world are doing. High school athletic programs are now an all year type of thing, a famous quote said i“there is no off-season”. Athletes are being pushed to be in one sport all year long, instead of multiple sports per year. Pushing one sport is taking place so skills can be practiced continuously.…

    • 872 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Nearly 65% of children say they participate in sports to be with their friends (Statistic Brain). Sports were established so that the individual could not only exercise, but also to compete against a rival. Just as there are individual sports, there are team sports in high school. The idea of a team sport is that every single person on the field or court must work in unison to have the greatest opportunity to win. In addition to the increasing popularity of sports, the average child’s age when they join a team is decreasing. For example, the age that a child joins a basketball team has shifted from fourth grade to first grade or even kindergarten in the past decade. School is the primary factor when you review the participation in athletics,…

    • 980 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Smith attended the University of Glasgow when he was only 14 years old, which I consider impressive and hard to believe. The Wealth of Nations is a documented industrial development in Europe. Adam Smith was the first person to get all of the ideas on The Wealth of Nations together and explain it to the average reader. He is the person responsible for popularizing many methods taught at school such as “classical economics”.…

    • 1452 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    College Tuition

    • 1071 Words
    • 3 Pages

    In today's society, the idea of a college education has become less of an option and more of a necessary requirement and is commonly considered the only way to acquire a successful career and life. There are many careers, in which a college education is not technically necessary, that can often be just as or even more successful. With the cost of college tuition increasing with every passing year, the controversy of whether college is really worth the cost and burden is growing too. If our society wants to continue displaying a college education as somewhat of a necessity for success, I believe the cost of it should shift to being a more realistic price, suitable for the majority of students striving to go to college.…

    • 1071 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Better Essays