Preview

The Captive Differences: Rowlandson Vs. Smith

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
855 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
The Captive Differences: Rowlandson Vs. Smith
The Captive Differences between Rowlandson and Smith
There was a time where Native Americans ruled the plains with an iron fist, a time where their authority was unmatched by civilized law and when puritans and early settlers alike shook with fear and respect for their Barbaric Neighbors. Why did the Natives show such ferocity? Perhaps the early settlers, not only forced their beliefs, but forced the natives out of their land as well. Anger, anarchy, and revelry spread like a plague and in the midst of its ravaging invasion, stories of those who were caught in its path and those who survived shared their stories. Individuals such as John Smith and Mary Rowlandson were some of the few who lived through the atrocities and managed to log them. The differences and the similarities of their captures are up
…show more content…
Both endured a form of slavery and imprisonment and both were forced to reckon with nature and alien like cultures and customs. Both were held on a pedestal made of their own potential to survive. They each furthered their skill and grit in order to take on the elements. However, of the two, John Smith has a reinforced foundation as a narrator due to what little he had to lose other than his life and rather than being tortured he established a trade agreement and was later assimilated into the tribe nearly becoming one of them . Mary Rowlandson, however had a substantial amount to lose such as the respect of her fellow settlers, regression, and wellbeing. The events that took place within her capture differentiate from those of john Smith. Mary Rowlandson was never fully assimilated and formed no such bond with her captors. Though, both have their differences, both narratives are nothing short of remarkable. Tales of survival and assimilation are by far the most enduring. Though both narrators have their differences, their reliability and their stories are nothing more than captivating and

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Satisfactory Essays

    During the year 1763, the town of Paxton, in eastern Pennsylvania, had become a hotspot of political and racial unrest. Inhabitants of this town, including many Scots-Irish immigrants, had grown tired of their government’s lack of interest in their vulnerability from outside attacks and inadequate supplement of means for defending themselves. So in December, after a day of heavy drinking, the Paxton Boys decided to take it upon themselves to defend their own. The boys raided a small village of friendly, peaceful Conestoga Indians, killing 6 and taking 14 captive. This led to warrants being sent out for their arrest, but because of fellow frontiersmen who felt the same as they did, there were…

    • 379 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    In the beginning of Mary Rowlandson’s narrative the Natives aren't so nice. The Natives had rebelled against the English Settlers, killing their men and capturing the women and children. Mary Rowlandson and her children are captured. Mary talks about how she is starved, and threatened to be punished if she doesn't do what she is asked, but the hardships that Mary endured were nothing compared to what the Native Americans endured during their enslavement by the English…

    • 962 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Analyzing the statements of Mary Rowlandson, the document gives an insight to the troubling relationship between the Native Americans and the Colonists which have broken out into battle. This depiction fails to explain what other significant events have led up to this attack, and instead paints the Natives as savages who have attacked for no reason, which led to the captivity of Rowlandson. After her captivity, the document focuses on issues such as how religion becomes her motivation to expect to survive, and attempts to view the series of events which unfold under the order of the Natives. These issues beg the question of previous interactions between the Colonists and Natives, which introduces the bias of the writer, shows the religious ties to her captivity she believes oversee the situation, and…

    • 851 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Mary Rowlandson, a Puritan woman with a strong religious ethic was captured by the Indians or as she describes them “savages” during the King Phillips war. Mary was faced with severe amount of pain and suffering and was held hostage and stripped away from her basic necessities. Her children were also captured and separated from her, sold or bought by other Indians. Throughout her narrative “The Sovereignty and goodness of God” Mary dealt with unremarkable sufferings however, she remained sanguine about the difficulties she encountered, portraying her hardship and misfortunes as a test from God. After Mary survives the terrible conditions she feels blessed and very thankful that she has finally escaped those treacherous Indians and has returned…

    • 1028 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Mrs. Mary Rowlandson in the excerpt, The Sovereignty and Goodness of God, asserts that Native Americans are barbarous savages; only the grace of God guided the author to survival. Rowlandson supports her claim by illustrating the bloody attacks the Natives led against the colonists and the deaths of her closest family members and friends. The author’s purpose is to expose the cruelties of the Native Americans in order to persuade all educated colonists that Native Americans are cruel, not friendly, and cannot be cooperated with. Therefore, the author writes in a grieving and anguished tone for all educated white colonists with mixed knowledge and perspectives on the trustworthiness of Native Americans.…

    • 111 Words
    • 1 Page
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    To back this theory up in Ronald Takaki’s book From a Different Mirror For Young People he says on page 33 paragraph three “William Tucker went to a Powhatan village to make a peace treaty. After they had signed the treaty, he persuaded the Indians to drink a toast- then served them poisoned wine, killing an estimated two hundred” this just proves our point showing how low the colonists stopped to get rid of the native Americans. But the real question is who really is the savage, well the definition of a savage is fierce and violent. It might just be our opinion but we think that colonists, in general, showed more violence toward the native Americans than they showed to the colonists. This period in American history is a truly interesting and complex time filled with many tragic moments but with an equal amount of heroic but over all the bad trumps the good and leaves us with a good story and opportunities to see from a different perspective. But more important it leads to a new way of thinking and the beginning of a truly amazing…

    • 1721 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Mary Rowlandson Analysis

    • 497 Words
    • 2 Pages

    Mary Rowlandson was an English woman born in 1636. Her parents were John and Joan White. They had moved to Massachusetts in the year of 1639. They were a Puritan family and strongly devoted to their religion. Mary Rowlandson was especially devoted. She went through what is called King Philip’s War. The Indians following Metacomet raided the homes of Plymouth. During this war about 5,000 Indians were killed and about 2,500 colonists were killed. Mary was moved and sold, along with many others including her children, by the Indians(213). The Indians beat, starved, tortured, dehydrated, and killed the colonists that they took. Some of the Indians were not abusive towards their “property” or slaves. Some were gentle and helped the colonists in their time of need.…

    • 497 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    At first sight, these two works have little things in common. The settings are very different one from another and the narratives depicted different times and also different historical contexts. Mary Rowlandson was a Puritan woman, wife and daughter of Puritans’ reverends, established in Lancaster, Massachusetts, in the colony called New England. The book entitled A Narrative of the Captivity and Restoration of Mrs. Mary Rowlandson (1682) reports her captivity – with her children – by Indians during King Philip’s War in 1676. She was captive eleven weeks that ended with her release after undergo extreme conditions in wilderness, even the death of her youngest child in Mary’s arms the first week of the captivity, and only with the companion of a bible.…

    • 554 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Tim O’Brien’s novel In the Lake of the Woods perpetually references the preceding atrocities that blemish American history. Within the chapters titled ‘Evidence’, scattered amongst the evidence accumulated for the fictional investigation into Kathy Wade’s disappearance, quotations from characters both authentic and fake exhibit the catalogue of concealed violence embedded in American history. Quotations reference the brutality in the battles of Lexington and Concord where the colonists were “as deplorable as the Indians for scalping and cutting the dead men’s auditory perceivers and nasal perceivers off” (262). Further references contained in the Evidence chapters regarding the Native Americans reiterate the words “exterminate” (260) and verbalize…

    • 243 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Better Essays

    She was a house wife, brave, religious, and married to an important man that eventually helped her and her child be free from the native americans. When Rowlandson was captured she was basically taken on a journey going through different places until the indians had taken her to King Phillip (tribe leader). King Phillip was then going to decide what he was going to do with her and the other people that were captured by the indians. Basically all the indians wanted was to exchange Rowlandson for some goods that will benefit the Native Americans. Of course this is not right to be exchanging a person for thing. it is similar to selling a human. Like when the white settlers would sell african americans for hard labor. However, we could say its fair that the Native Americans captured people to get what they wanted. First of all the Natives were also abused and treated poorly. Second the white settlers took over a lot of the Native Americans land for Agriculture, and they also hunted most of the game that the Native Americans hunted to eat everyday. We can understand why they revolted because they obviously didn't want their land taken away. Native american families barely eating and a lot of them starving. Obviously everyone would be unhappy if some aliens come and took over the land and left the natives in a bad…

    • 1328 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    At the Exposition, Native Americans served a dual purpose, albeit a contradicting one. While they were showcased as objects of civility and Christianity, Native Americans were also portrayed in the exact opposite manner of civility and Christianity: barbarity and savagery. Rydell’s argument, while effective, loses some of the nuance of the reactions by government agents regarding the deliberate contradiction of the Native American presence at the Exposition. Some government agents, particularly those connected to military affairs, appear to have reacted indifferently towards the apparent contradiction and in fact seemed more concerned with menial issues than the stalling of Native American “progression.” Yet, other government agents, particularly those more invested in the advancement and assimilation of Native Americans, expressed similar concerns to those suggested by…

    • 418 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    In 1675, the Algonquian Indians rose up in fury against the Puritan Colonists, sparking a violent conflict that engulfed all of Southern New England. From this conflict ensued the most merciless and blood stricken war in American history, tearing flesh from the Puritan doctrine, revealing deep down the bright and incisive fact that anger and violence brings man to a Godless level when faced with the threat of pain and total destruction. In the summer of 1676, as the violence dispersed and a clearing between the hatred and torment was visible, thousands were dead.(Lepore xxi) Indian and English men, women, and children, along with many of the young villages of New England were no more; casualties of a conflict that was both devastating to the lives and the landscape of New England, as well as the ideologies of both the Indians and the English Puritans that inhabited this land.(Lepore 18)…

    • 2158 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    In the winter of 1838, one hundred thousand Native-Americans in the Georgia region traipsed the 2,000 mile journey that is detaily described by the Library of Congress, “During the fall and winter of 1838 in 1839, Native-Americans were forcibly moved west by the United States government. Approximately 4000 Cherokees died on this forced march, which became known as The trail of tears”(“Indian Removal Act”). This instance indicates just how much the United States government tyrannized Native Americans. Native-Americans knew that their homeland will forever be lost even though they settled in the area thousands of years before any caucasian.…

    • 777 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    “A Narrative of the Captivity and Restoration of Mrs. Mary Rowlandson” is a personal account, written by Mary Rowlandson herself about her eleven-week captivity by the Indians, which not only gives the readers a first person perspective of life in captivity, but also an insight to Rowlandson’s views of the Indians. When first reading this narrative, one would think that the main purpose is to simply tell how horrible her experience in captivity was, and how it had changed her. However, that is not the main purpose of her narrative. In fact, her captivity changes neither her Puritan value nor her view towards Indians. Throughout the narrative, she unapologetically, and continuously compares them to animals—and even Satan—for not being Puritans.…

    • 1132 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In the General History of Virginia, using biased language, John Smith portrays the natives as uncivilized, but his portrayal goes deeper than using the word savage. (despite the fact that this is nothing more than a clash of cultures….) Smith refers to the natives as “savages”, barbarians, and “more devil than a man,” and mocks their dress and behavior.…

    • 570 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays