Preview

'The Importance Of Robby In Our Time'

Better Essays
Open Document
Open Document
2183 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
'The Importance Of Robby In Our Time'
Everyone has their struggles in life and Wideman’s main character in “Our Time”, Robby is no different. It all starts with the death of his street brother Garth, at first the reader doesn’t understand why this was the turning point in Robby’s life. However, we soon see how much Garth meant to Robby. Yet, while Robby plays a prominent role in this story he is not the main focus throughout the story. Also, Robby as a narrator is not the only one speaking. Wideman was brilliant to do this because you see Robby’s story through the point of view of others people. Overall, I really related to this piece. It may be because Robby and his story inspires me. However, it may also be because as I read on I continue to relate to Weidman more and more. When …show more content…
He describes the hospital as, “Hospital smell and quiet, the bare halls and bare floors, the echoes, something about all that he can’t name. wouldn’t try to name, rises in him and chills him” (423). I am happy they are around because they do save a lot of people’s lives, but it has such an eerie feeling to it when someone you love isn’t going to be one of the one’s saved. Robby states that by the time Garth got to the hospital there was “Nothing let of Garth to treat. They hid his messy death under white sheets, perfumed it disinfectant, pumped him full of drugs so he wouldn’t disturb his neighbors” (424). When I read this sentence, this entire piece actually for the first time I felt like Wideman was just reading my mind because a very similar situation happened to my aunt. Now I am not saying that the systems during Garth’s time and the current time are both corrupt, but I think depending on where you go, there may still be racism, which is what I believe Wideman was trying to point out by including this. My aunt switched hospitals because the new hospital was supposed to have better treating for her condition, but the doctors took too long to fully diagnose and give her treatment even though the other hospital told them she had stage four cancer. They gave up trying to help her and like Garth ended trying to cover up the messy situation. Why should the race of a person matter? Doctors are meant to help people, so you …show more content…
Robby’s stories were crucial for John because even though John and Robby were at the same places and did things together, there are a lot of differences in their memories. “My memories needed his. Maybe the fact that we recall different things is crucial. Maybe they are foreground and background, propping what he’s saved and it’s not mine, not what I saw or heard or felt” (453). When John says this it seems as if his mind was really repressing a lot of the memories he had and Robby talking about the events were the push he really needed to let his thoughts flow free. He states, “His story freeing me, because it forces me to tell my own” (453). It is not always to admit to yourself that you have a past full of memories-some which you may not be proud about, which could be why John repressed his. However, now that he hears Robby’s recollection of the events he can no longer hold back. It is amazing that they are linked and have that much of a bond. Simple words can bring about years of

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Satisfactory Essays

    This is a close analysis essay of a random 9 page selection from Spring 2014 Narrative, focusing on an interesting, but flawed sliver of life of a man named Wayne. I shall point out the good and bad points, and argue them, concluding with a final observation to ponder.…

    • 659 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Although the doctors did act ethnically on some action they did, overall, they did not act ethnically. A few things they had done right was when they had considered choosing the test subject was they had considered if the test subject was unwilling to perform the surgery. Charlie was all over the surgery. Another thing they had done right was they had considered how Charlie's life could be improved. Both Dr.s both knew how much it would improve Charlie's life if they had done the surgery on him.…

    • 407 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays
    • 490 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Next, memory is a pivotal element to a reliable narrator. Holden Caulfield lacks the ability to recollect certain memories, portraying him as an unreliable narrator. While disclosing…

    • 577 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Arriving to an appointment with her new therapist,the narrator waits at the front door patiently. The greeting the narrator receives is, “Get away from my house! What are you doing in my yard?” (Page 18), presumably because she is Black. The underlying racism in the mind of a White person can be shocking and scary to look at when on paper as it is throughout Citizen. Although the reader can assume that the therapist knew she had a patient visiting, she lost all control and screamed at her patient just because of the color of her skin upset her. In fact, the patient rang the bell of the therapist’s house, which should be assuring that the patient was not looking to do anything wrong, yet still, the therapist yells like, “a wounded Doberman pinscher or a German shepherd has gained the power of speech” (Page 18). The reader can also assume that the narrator would not be treated this way if the color of her skin was different. This is particularly disturbing because of it being the therapist’s first instinct to think the patient is doing something wrong and does not belong where she is standing. This proves the idea of white Americans becoming complacent and being blind to the issues that don't impact them…

    • 999 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Doctor- the doctor is a person who you see when you are unwell; they are responsible for telling you what is wrong or what your problem may be. He/she is also responsible for choosing the right medication for you and giving you your prescription.…

    • 1502 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    The Weird Ways of Wideman

    • 1693 Words
    • 7 Pages

    There are many difficulties that Wideman comes across as he struggles to explain Robby’s story to the reader. One of the main problems that he encounters is staying on topic. Wideman finds it difficult to tell Robby’s story without attaching his own flavor to it. Wideman is traditionally a fiction writer, so it appears challenging for him to not add his own parts into Robby’s story. This is observed when Wideman himself writes, “Do I write to escape, to make a fiction of my life? If I can’t be trusted with the story of my own life, how could I ask my brother to trust me with his?” (Wideman 672). All through the story Wideman takes time, such as this, to stop himself in the middle of writing to discuss an issue he is having with it. This is a style of writing that most readers have never seen before. Another problem that Wideman comes across is his ability to listen to Robby. His whole life he had been rejecting a fair amount of the things that came out of Robby’s mouth, and for the first time he had to actually listen to, and record what was being said. While visiting Robby, John explains how he listened to his brother in the…

    • 1693 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    John Edgar Wideman's biography about his brother Robby Our Time can also be seen as a story about accepting responsibility. There were many things throughout the story that could have been blamed for Robby's robbery and murder conviction. One excuse could have been that Robby seemed to be born under a black cloud. He was born on December 29 which seemed a foreshadowing of his whole life for two reasons. First, his birthday, the most important day for a young boy, was associated with tragedy, because both of his grandfathers died on December 28, his grandmother on December 29, and his sister lost a baby early one January. The close of the year, which contained his birthday, was often a time of mourning, instead of his rightful time of joy and attention. His birthday celebration was also upstaged by Christmas. " (Wideman 679).…

    • 996 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Above, O'Brien expresses to the reader that he wants you to feel what he felt. He wants others to understand what happened to him. The author writes for the reader. He also expresses above that story-truth is truer that happening-truth. Story-truth “makes things present”. In the authors words, it allows him to look at things he never looked at. He can attach faces to grief, love, pity and God. He can be brave and he can make himself feel again. In, the end, it allows the author to go back and experience things in a different way that he might not have necessarily wanted to experience again.…

    • 700 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays
    • 1109 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    John visited Robby for the maximum time he could which was three hours. It wasn’t easy to get the conversation going. John says “we were ready to talk. It was easy to begin. Impossible. We were neophytes, rookies (Wideman 674). Wideman had kids that Robby had never seen before thus giving them something to start their conversation. Even though the amount of time they got to spend talking was very limited John…

    • 1628 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The Nhs

    • 516 Words
    • 3 Pages

    * When you seek help because you feel unwell, the medical practitioner you visit will be able to inform you of the care options available to you.…

    • 516 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Unit 8 Child Care Level 3

    • 2669 Words
    • 11 Pages

    “Doctors make people healthier. When people get sick, doctors figure out why. They examine people, listen to them describe their health problems, and do tests to see what is wrong. They give people medicine and other kinds of treatment. They also give advice about diet, exercise, and sleep” http://www.bls.gov/k12/help06.htm see appendix 1 accessed on 09/05/2013…

    • 2669 Words
    • 11 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Calman lectured us ‘medicine’s assault on people of color’, and more vaguely, the present racial and ethnic disparities that exist in health care in the Bronx, and presumably across the globe. In more detail, he discussed disparities that his specific patients faced, including assumptions (due to implicit biases) that he made through his time being a doctor, assumptions based off of fears, implicit biases, and racial prejudices. “I cannot provide Mr. North with all that…institutions have to offer. He knows that. He has often tried to teach me that, and just as often is amazed that I am unable to accept it…The same considerations my family or I would receive are rarely given to him…There is absolutely no doubt that Mr. North is treated differently than my white, middle-class patients are treated.” (Out of the Shadows, Dr. Neil Calman) This passage from Dr. Calman’s article ‘Out of the Shadows’ is a perfect example of just some of the discrimination that is apparent in the healthcare field for those such as men of color, created not by accident, but by design throughout the healthcare…

    • 1751 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Better Essays

Related Topics