Preview

The Mcwane Incident

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
788 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
The Mcwane Incident
The McWane story was a very unfortunate series of events that were caused by company negligence. I believe the company decided to make a turn around only because they started to see the negative consequences that were going to happen to them if they did not do so. McWane industries seemed to care little about their employees and the environment in the past and only care now because of liability reasons. They should have made changes before the first incident even occurred. I do believe that they have changed their ways now. They now are more concerned with the consequences of their actions. Regardless of the reason, they are providing a safer environment now and therefore deserve to be operational. I was baffled how McWane found workers who …show more content…
They had been violating the clean air act and clean water act. Companies are required to ensure proper disposal of waste. McWane was illegally discharging pollution into Village Creek and the Delaware River. They were taking the easy way to get rid of waste because their holding tanks kept becoming too full for the amount they were producing. Instead of waiting for the cleaning process and stopping production they continued to pollute the environment. McWane industries violated the clean air act by releasing heavy levels of pollution into the air. They were aware of the illegal activities they were participating in but continued to do so. McWane only cared and decided to change once they got caught. It is outrageous to me that they got away with these violations for as long as they did. In my opinion their needs to be stricter enforcement against companies like McWane …show more content…
In congress enforcing programs is a less popular action. The public also is not pushing for stricter laws on the matter. The incidence that had occurred were declared accidents so harder state felony charges could not be filed. In believe this is an issue more people need to be made aware about. It seems the only people who care are the victims who are involved. I believe workers compensation laws also protected McWane industries. In the incidence that occurred with McWane there was contributory negligence, assumption of risk and the fellow servant rule involved. The employees were aware of the hazardous conditions they were working in but continued to do so. Also the injuries were partially their fault. I believe that is why McWane could not be charged

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Satisfactory Essays

    The legal case in subject is with Williams Construction, a company that was under investigation after a trench collapse, which resulted in the death of Jose Aguiniga, and serious injury to Adam Palomar, two employees with Williams Construction. At the conclusion of the investigation, under the guidelines of the Occupational Safety and Hazards Act, or OSHA, Williams Construction was charged with four violations that resulted in excessive fines. The investigation concluded that Williams Construction failed to instruct employees and managers on recognizing and avoiding dangerous work conditions, failed to ensure that employees did not have to travel more than 25 feet to a safe zone, failed to have an employee that was trained and experienced in trench safety, and failed to make sure that the walls of the air were either sloped or supported. The OSHA investigation concluded that if these regulations were followed, the tragic event could have been avoided. The legal issue is whether or not the courts and the construction company itself should up hold the violations of specific OSHA standards.…

    • 827 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    The fly fishing outfitter did not have any legal recourses that were discussed in lecture. The fertilizer plant did not violate the Clean Water Act section 402 because the plant obtained a permit prior to discharging the pollutant. Also, the EPA and the state approved all discharge action reported. Additionally, common law claims are inadequate because pollution caused by industrial activity is considered a negative externality. The producer and consumer of the product are not directly responsible by the impact. The cost of the externality does not take into the consideration of the cost of the goods. Likewise, it is difficult to quantify impact and distribute the responsibility equally. Legally, the polluter has no criminal liability due…

    • 146 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Clearly they were a well-respected, well-trusted company not too long before they were raided, and during a time that they were under investigation (not known to the public at the time) for fraudulent activity…

    • 1172 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Cineplex Odeon Case Study

    • 1173 Words
    • 5 Pages

    For them to operate there must be necessarily have these programs intact because these are the fundamentals and core for a management system to work. All three safety programs demonstrate an important trait in which a large company should provide to all employees. Especially working for SilverCity I experienced my own share of injuries and incidents, however there were solutions to everything. Records were taken down and yearly meetings were in place for employees to go over the new rules and safety procedures. These are things most companies should be able to do for their employees and Cineplex provides us with information that we need to know in order to keep working at this job safely. This is why the three priority safety programs that I named are to be the company’s main focuses and are programs that are already in place in the…

    • 1173 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Mgmt 520

    • 3747 Words
    • 11 Pages

    The proposed regulation would not fix the problem it is intended to remedy and that it would cost more. Also there would be a tax not a safety change, in which OSHA deals with health issues. Two arguments available would be arbitrary and capricious and/or abuse of discretion, ultra vires, substantial evidence test…

    • 3747 Words
    • 11 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Centralia No. 5

    • 499 Words
    • 2 Pages

    Driscoll Scanlan, who was a state mine inspector, notified public sector safety professionals from state and federal agencies of the hazards as a result of inspections. Scanlan addressed many issues concerning the safety of the employees and ways of which to resolve these issues. He could have addressed some other issues as well, in hopes that he would get someone to pay attention to what he was saying. Scanlan investigated the mine several times and he should have addressed the issue that too many workers were in the mine at a time. When the special commissions were doing their investigation, they found that there should be no “more than a hundred men working on a single split, or current, of air” (Stillman, 2010b, p.36). Another issue Scanlan could have addressed was the fact that when the special commission board was investigating the mine, no one was told of the date of the appointment. Every person has the right to be able to prove their issues and concerns, and by the Mining Board not informing the Union of when this was going to take place, was very unprofessional. The…

    • 499 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    It is the legal responsibility of a worker to maintain the health and safety practices in place and work in a way to ensure that they do not endanger theirs or other’s health, safety and welfare.…

    • 4017 Words
    • 17 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Because one of the owners wasn’t trusting that resulted in more deaths and believed. To be employed now I could not imagine even being in that situation, having to see lives lost and think about all the loved ones your losing. Women who you talk to everyday shoving and kicking you out of the way to survive. I am happy laws are made to prevent this from happening again. It an awful thing to witness someone who goes to work and doesn’t return home for dinner, that is an awful feeling. Loved ones were lost, daughter and mothers. Mothers that were working with their daughters either saw their family member die or escape. The fact that not everyone at my job takes the fire safety tips or any safety tips serious should really reconsider, I know I will. Safety should be the priority of all unions. This fire should not have happened with the proper guide in dangerous situations. In the video it says that there were a dozen pales of water in the corner, that was there precaution. That is ridiculous, it was already engulfed in flames how was anyone expected to grab them. Thank goodness today people notice the importance of workers safety, even though to notice costed many people’s…

    • 542 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    A surge in workers injuries led to young workers demanding improved health and safety conditions. Although employers initially denied the poor working conditions and rejected requests…

    • 1250 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    We live in a world of history, a history of past, history in the making, and a history not yet known. History has a way of affecting people’s lives though we often do not recognize it. Most of us do not come to the realization the daily lives we are living and the world surrounding us will one day be studied in history books. This is especially true for children. What youth often thinks, “One day, people will read about this in school”? For children who are born into a time of unease such as the Great Depression or World War II, this is extraordinarily true. Children born and growing up within difficult times simply assume the situation is a way of life; though they may hear elders speak of difficult times, they know no different life. I had the pleasure of interviewing a gentleman named Kenneth Dwayne McGaughey whose life’s story met this situation. Through stories of history, I will share some of this thoughts and memories with the connections to historical times and events.…

    • 1922 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Meat Packing

    • 327 Words
    • 2 Pages

    "OSHA's voluntary compliance policy did indeed reduce the number of recorded injuries in meatpacking plants. It did not however, reduce the number of peaple getting hurt" (663). The amount of employees in the slaughterhouses that are injuryed and sick from the jobs they do, is huge. It is hard to beleave that the goverment puts a price on how much your body parts are worth. $35,000 dollars is what you get when you lose an arm. That wouldn't be enough to help my family survive for a year. The goverment should relook at the price of how much money should be paid to injuryed workers.…

    • 327 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Buisness Ethics

    • 675 Words
    • 3 Pages

    McWane is a manufacturer of water and sewer pipes, by melting metal and casting pipes. Seems as if they were more like slave drivers interested in productivity and not employee safety. They had more safety violations than any of their six major competitors. Also, employees were injured or and even lost their lives while working at this company. Is was noted that approximately 5,000 employees were injured or lost their lives during the 1970’s There was also, a very high employee turnover rate of almost 100 percent at the Tyler Pipe Plant. McWane attempted to cope with the heavy employee’s turnover was by recruiting ex-convicts from local prison. OSHA had noted that many of the employees had major scars and disfigurations that could be noticed from far away. In 1995 the company had 400 more safety violations. McWane has a fortunate record of commercial success, but an undesirable reputation as one of the most dangerous workplaces in America. Reference Source: http://www.pbs.org/wgbh/pages/frontline/shows/workplace/mcwane/two.html…

    • 675 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Best Essays

    First, I will address the issue of labor. The maintenance teams are on site and do frequent run-downs to insure that equipment is functioning properly. There is detailed safety procedures regarding every machine and task, the machinery has automatic and manual shutoffs, they use proper safety gear, there is a variety of emergency stations, and the facility is well air-conditioned. Additionally, it has been years since there were any serious injuries; the main problems are back pain and of course … paper cuts. These policies relate to what William Clifford discusses about the Duty of Inquiry in The Ethics of Belief. Clifford uses a ship-owner that is unsure about the safety of the ship before a voyage as an example to illustrate that regardless of the outcome it is unethical not to achieve certainty in regards to the safety of others. As we can see, AG takes the proper steps to ensure that there is a safe work environment.…

    • 1062 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Best Essays
  • Good Essays

    Case Study: US V. US

    • 726 Words
    • 3 Pages

    In 1999 the supreme court ruled on a case in the same matter as Judge Stevens. There is sum responsibility the company has to protect the environment and those that rely on the resources from this environment. A company that produces an item should in good faith ensure that its customers understand the proper use and disposal of the product. If the company does not know that its customer is not properly using or disposing its product the producing company should not be held liable for the disregards of another company. If this other company that is not properly using or disposing of an item that leads to contamination and is part of the producing company then the producing company should be held liable for any cleanup…

    • 726 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Facts: Matt Theurer was an 18 year old adult that worked at McDonald’s part time. His friends and family worried about him because he had many extra-curricular activities, worked for the National Guard, and worked for McDonalds. McDonald’s informal policy did not allow high school students to work more than one midnight shift per week or split shifts. There was a special clean-up week McDonald’s held, Theurer worked five nights. One night he worked until midnight, another until 11:30pm, two nights until 9pm, and another until 11pm. On Monday, April 4th, 1988, Theurer worked from 3:30 until 7:30pm, followed by the clean up shift beginning at midnight until 5am on April 5th, and then he worked another shift from 5am until 8:21am. During that shift, Theurer told his manager he was tired and asked to leave from his next regular shift. The manager accepted his request, and Theurer began to drive home. He was driving 45 miles per hour on a two lane road when he either fell asleep or became drowsy. Theurer crossed the dividing lane into on-coming traffic, and crashed into Frederic Faverty’s minivan. Theurer was killed and Faverty was seriously injured. Faverty settled his claims with Theurer’s estate, and then he filed suit against McDonald’s.…

    • 1194 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays