Preview

The Role Of Thanksgiving In Larry Watson's 'Montana 1948'

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
802 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
The Role Of Thanksgiving In Larry Watson's 'Montana 1948'
“You see I know that Uncle frank’s suicide solved all our problems” To what extent is David making a realistic judgment with this statement ? When young David, witnesses his licentious uncle commit suicide, he unrealistically decides that his death was the answer to all of the hardships faced by the family. ‘Montana 1948’ by Larry Watson, depicts the tale, of deterioration and destruction of one family through heinous crimes committed by certain characters in the novel. The offences carried out by Frank, destroys David family forever. When the emotional twelve year old watches Frank, die, he wants to reverse the adverse effects of his uncle’s crime and death seems like the answer to like the answer to their problems. However David does not realize is that Frank’s death did not solve their problems but merely changed them. …show more content…
However, within a space of one afternoon, the family is plagued by fear .suspicion, grief lies and betrayal. When David discovers of the sexual abuse and mistreatment carried out by his well – loved uncle his innocent world turns upside down. , David loses his role model “the charming, affable uncle frank was gone for good “and his perspective of his heroic uncle. Through the offences carried out frank, David’s outlook about his family changes forever. Had, frank not commit the crimes, David might not have lost his role model. Due to the wrongdoings of frank, the young protagonist watches his father, facing moral conflicts that destroy him emotionally. David realizes that his uncle’s crimes had affected his father adversely “I knew for the first time how this experience with his brother had ruined him physically “. Through frank’s crimes, David watches the deterioration of his family and his innocence, within the space on one afternoon. It is when David, comes across these hardships that he wishes to reverse the effects of his uncles

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    The story follows the Hayden family and their struggle with loyalty and justice. Family members include: the narrator - 12 year old David, his father and town sheriff Wes, David's mother Gail, his uncle Frank, grandfather and predecessor as sheriff Julian and the housekeeper Marie Little Soldier. When David's family's Native American housekeeper Marie falls ill, Frank Hayden, the local doctor is called. When Marie refuses medical treatment, David's parents, Gail and Wes, discover that Frank has been preying on the local native American women, raping and molesting them. Wes confronts Frank at a dinner at their father's house. Wes and Gail reach a compromise. When Marie is found dead, Frank convinces the family it is a result of the illness, however David proves (with many reservations) that Frank had murdered her, in order to silence her. The family faces much turmoil as Wes attempts to remain loyal to justice and family, but his inability to make a choice leaves him to imprison his brother in the basement. At this stage, Julian intervenes, showing his clear favour for Frank over Wes. He sends men to break Frank out of his jail, however Gail fights to stop them, leaving her deeply traumatized by the experience. That night, the family hear the sound breaking glass in the basement, but pass it off as caused by the anger of Frank. Next morning, Wes finds Frank dead in the basement, having committed suicide. The family choose to cover up the suicide, in an attempt to save Frank's…

    • 374 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    David is a good person unlike his father. He supports the truth and doesn’t support the stuff said by the church. He feels that everyone should be treated equally though he himself is scared of the fringes and the mutants. The only one who stops him from doing so is his father and he teaches all the other members of the family to also be like him.…

    • 904 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Montana 1948 is a very good example of what it was like to be part of the fringe of society. The author does an extraordinary job at depicting certain struggles of power between the characters in the book. The reason these struggles are so easy to pick up on is because the narrator describes the characters to full detail. This allows for a further enhancement of the book to which you can become more acquainted with the characters. There for you can predict the struggles between characters. One of the main struggles in this story is between the Fringes of society and those who have power. By power I mean those who are able to speak for themselves and defend themselves. Good examples of power, in the society of Montana 1948, are the white men. Those who would be considered a fringe would be the Native Americans, women, and children.…

    • 775 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    “Imagination, of course, can open any door- turn the key and let terror walk right in.” As we envision what is to happen to our lives, we frequently get ourselves stuck on the troublesome decision of two restricted ways. The way of good; making a legitimate living, and celebrating in the organization of family. Now and again makes you live in all out obliviousness to whatever is left of the world, putting blinders on the honest. At that point obviously the way of malevolent, dim and fear; to which prompts negative outcomes and unforgiving discipline. Truman Capote utilizes these two life decisions to tell the grisly murder of the Clutter family, in his piece In Cold Blood. A noteworthy part of his work is the loss of honesty. The plain Kansas…

    • 137 Words
    • 1 Page
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In this Novel the growth of David from a small boy to a courageous man is focused. David is a seventeen year old boy from Scotland with the nickname of “Davie.” David is a young boy who tragically lost his father and mother and who is now left alone with no parents. After being left alone, David becomes an orphan. David is then led into a house where his father lived in his childhood. David there meets his uncle Ebenezer ,“Is your father dead?” “I was so much surprised at this, that I could find no voice to answer, but stood staring” (Stevenson 23). Ebenezer first attempts to kill David and then kidnaps him. Uncle Ebenezer was cruel to David and treated him very harshly, David’s uncle strongly disliked David for coming into his life and interrupting him. Ebenezer is a very selfish uncle and envies David for being young and everything he does. In Kidnapped David for the first is exploring the world. Balfour is inexperienced and is frightened about never going out to the “real world.” David’s goal is running away from the torture of his uncle and not having experience of going out to the real world. David is blamed for a murder he did not commit, and his attempt is to escape from all his enemies, since he has become a victim of Captain of Hoseason and his Uncle Ebenezer. As David escapes he meets the other main character Alan Breck Stewart. They both come to meet each…

    • 1380 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Just like in the book Montana 1948, I would like to write to you about how human nature is explained through loyalty and justice. As we have gone to school together for seven years, I would like to show you how the faults of our human nature can be explained through what has happened in Montana 1948. Throughout the book, the faults of human nature are seen as loyalty outweighs justice which as seen through Frank molesting Native American girls. Wes’s loyalty to his brother, Frank, and his prejudice towards Native Americans questions the belief of justice. Wes has received all his power from his parents, so it is nearly impossible for him to go against his family. However, Wes is stuck between his father, a powerful, intimidating man and his…

    • 1544 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    The poem “David”, written by Earle Birney is a very emotional and allure piece. The major theme that pursues throughout the whole poem is maturity. Which includes the beginning of such, and all the obstacles that must be overcome. The tone is a very cynical one, especially when David asks Bob to push him off the cliff. Birney also uses figurative language and poetic devices to create an element of tension, complexity and emotion.…

    • 375 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    David’s uncle, Frank, the doctor is described as “He had been a star athlete in high school and college, and he was a genuine war hero, complete with decorations and commendations.”(p. 37) So when Marie, David’s nanny, fell ill, Frank was the obvious choice to treat her. At this point he was just the Uncle, who happened to be a doctor. But when Marie’s allegations of rape came to…

    • 893 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    This Boy's Life, set in America in the 1950’s, is a compelling memoir by Tobias Wolff, whom recreates the frustrations and cruelties faced throughout his adolescence, as he fights for identity and self-respect. During this period of time, America underwent major changes in the political and economic spheres, which in turn were responsible for its social makeover. Society in this time was geared toward family; marriage and children being part of the national agenda. The 1950’s was also an age of male dominance, where even if women worked, their assumed proper place was at home. Throughout the memoir, the protagonist, young Jack Wolff, makes it difficult for the reader to feel much affection towards him, as his actions prove to be troublesome and unruly. However, as the memoir progresses, Jacks struggle reveal the reasons for his actions which sequentially shape his character, providing the readers with understanding and sympathy towards his inexorable situation. The fraudulent lies and deceitful ways of Jack can be frustrating upon the reader; though we come to realise that he does this in order to be accepted by the people around him. Jack also engages in fights and unfaithfully betrays his best friend Arthur, although it becomes evident that he only does this in order to gain Dwight’s approval of him. The lack of a real father figure in Jack’s life has a profound impact on him and his desperate attempt to develop his identity, which further supports the readers’ emotions of sympathy towards him.…

    • 1592 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    A Child Called “It” by David Pelzer is his own autobiography of his life as a child being abused by his alcoholic mother, Catherine Roerva Pelzer, who isolates him from the family, then abuses him, and nearly killed him through starvation, poisoning, and once stabbing him. Since Mother starved him for days, he began to steal food in order to survive, and when she finds out he has stolen food, she abuses him with her own “games”. Dave reflects on the “good times” in his childhood, because Mother was once a wonderful, loving mom, but the drinking habit, illness, and Father being gone took over her life, leaving both emotional and physical scars on her child which will haunt him for life. His father, Stephen Joseph Pelzer, a fireman in San Francisco, is a frightened man who as watches Dave is beaten, starved, and humiliated. Mother has stopped calling him by name; instead she would refer him as “the boy” to “it”. He was starved for 10 consecutive days, stabbed, forced to eat his brother’s diaper and a spoonful of ammonia, burned over a gas stove, stayed in the bathroom with ammonia resulting in a near fatal outcome, smashed his face into the mirror while screaming "I'm a bad boy", lying in the bathtub naked with freezing water for hours.…

    • 427 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Unfortunately, Marie dead after a few days Frank went to the house. Frank claimed her dead because of pneumonia. Basically, she was sick, but David knew better, he went to deputy sheriff Len McAuley’s house. Len was drunk and reveals the fact that he also saw Frank walking into house before Marie was found dead. David chose to tell his parents what he knew, or at least part he knew about Frank. This shows that he was developing in the area of honesty. Before, David would kept all this to himself, rather than face his parents with knowledge he knows will displease…

    • 751 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Character in Montana 1948

    • 614 Words
    • 3 Pages

    An important character in Montana 1948 is Wesley Hayden. He is introduced as a weak and oblivious character, who lives under the shadow of his brother Frank. Throughout the story, it is shown that Wesley is a lawyer who was coerced into being a sheriff due to the pressure put on him by his overpowering father. In this essay I will explore why Wesley Hayden is an important character in the novel Montana 1948 by Larry Watson. He is used to illustrate the theme of loyalty vs. justice, he grows the most as a person in the novel and he has to cope with making difficult decisions so the reader will empathise with him.…

    • 614 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    We learn of this problem when Montag is speaking with the rescuers after his own wife attempts suicide. The medics inform us that they attend to 9 or 10 suicide calls every night. The high occurrence of suicides had led to the invention of special machines to save suicide “victims.” Suicides are often committed out of despair, and often some type of mental disorder is present in the person who commits suicide. Suicide has become a serious issue in the world, more so in the developed nations. Suicide rates are highest in the Baltic states, such as Lithuania, Belarus, and Russia. The suicide rate in the US is half that in Russia (30,000 compared to 60,000). Since the time Bradbury wrote Fahrenheit 451, the suicide rate in the US has nearly tripled. Almost 11,600 people took their own lives in 1950 (Suicide Rates by 100,000). Suicide rates parallel with levels of unhappiness in these countries. The Happy Planet Index, which rates countries based on several factors, rated Russia, the Baltic states, the US, along with many countries in sub-Saharan Africa, the lowest in “happiness” in the world. Interestingly, these countries also have the highest rates of suicide. Bradbury uses the suicide to dramatically illustrate just how unhappy the modern citizens are. The attempted suicide of Mildred could be considered a contributing event into Montag’s journey towards finding his own…

    • 1523 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Thanksgiving is considered by many as being the worse meal of the year. Why? Because of the extreme overload of high-starch carbs that trigger blood sugar spikes for so many people. Just think of it. Pumpkin pie with a scoop or two of ice cream, corn bread stuffing, mashed potatoes, sugar-laden cranberry sauce and green bean casserole, that's why.…

    • 541 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Essay On Thanksgiving

    • 445 Words
    • 2 Pages

    Should Christmas decorations be on display prior to thanksgiving? Well, no because I think that it breaks tradition or people spend more money than they usually have. On the other hand some readers might disagree because some want Christmas to last more longer so they can enjoy it. Don’t go away more details are coming your way!…

    • 445 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays

Related Topics