Preview

Things They Carried Essay: The Power Of The Truth

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
856 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Things They Carried Essay: The Power Of The Truth
The Power of the Truth
Novelist Tim O’Brian once said “A lie, sometimes, can be truer than the truth, which is why fiction gets written.” In his novel The Things They Carried, O’Brian argues that “story-truth is sometimes truer than happening-truth” (171). O’Brian opposes the idea of absolute truth, and believes that all truths are subject to change. He believes that a fictional story can be more true than an actual event. However, a story, no matter what story, cannot be more true than an actual event; a “story version” of an event is merely a shadow of that event—a make-up-caked, dramatized, Hollywood shadow. It is impossible for “story-truth” to be truer than “happening-truth.” In The Things They Carried O’Brian creates a daughter,
…show more content…
He created a grand staircase on the ship while in reality this staircase was so small passengers had to go up and down single file. A Pablo Picasso painting is featured in the film, although Picasso was not popular during the time of the Titanic, and his work was not widely distributed. The diamond necklace in the film, titled “The Heart of the Ocean,” never existed, much like the love story between invented passengers Rose Bukater and James Dawson. These creations served Cameron’s purpose to paint a theatrical telling of the event, but the movie was just …show more content…
The most powerful aspect of the film The Titanic is not the love story. It is not the grand staircase, or the luxurious dining room. It is not the interaction between characters, or the extravagant “Heart of the Ocean.” The most powerful aspect of The Titanic is that it actually happened. At the end of the film, there were 1,502 dead bodies sinking and in the freezing salt water of the Atlantic. No “story-truth,” no matter how elaborate, could create a greater tragedy than a “happening-truth.” Why not? Since “story-truths” are not as true as “happening-truths.”
Therefore, the notion that a story could ring truer than an actual event is in the wrong. A lie cannot reveal a deeper truth; only truth can uncover truth. Stories provide an escape for the imagination. They allow the reader to imagine a different reality and to glimpse into an alternate world. However, stories are only stories. They are not real. The only way the reader can understand a true reality is to read a true account of that reality. Although this account may be less dramatic than the “story version” of the reality, it is in fact the reality. It is the truest truth; the

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    For instance as a reader you feel emotionally connected with all of the characters. The reason the reader feels this way is because of the excellent writing style of Tim O’Brien and the way he appeals to the reader's emotions. With “Story Truth” you can be drawn into the story and become more interested in what's going on. Often exaggeration adds more interesting points to the plot of a story O’Brien takes advantage of that thus this quote “You can tell a true war story by the way it never seems to end.” Following the passage in the novel a person may realize that this sentence represents the theme of the entire book a never ending story. All in all “Story Truth” keeps readers emotionally connected while reading.…

    • 128 Words
    • 1 Page
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    In Lying: A Metaphorical Memoir, Lauren Slater attempts to create a new kind of truth called metaphorical truth: emotional truth explained using metaphors instead of facts. She confuses fact and fiction even though it is a memoir and thus creates a convoluted tale of herself where she may or may not be epileptic. Initially, the readers believe that she uses metaphorical truth to make them understand the essence of her life. By the end of the book, they begin to also believe that she wants to ask them, as a last resort, to help her in her healing process by the following: giving her much need attention and through that, letting her clear her conscience of guilt over the wrong acts that she had committed. They feel that she is successful in this aim because of the use of metaphorical truth. Firstly, this metaphorical truth gives rise to two different emotions within groups of readers that motivate the same overall action of them helping her. Secondly, it acts as a leverage to ensure that they cannot critically judge her.…

    • 1671 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Truth and non-truth are several aspects emphasized in Tim O’Brien’s novel The Things They Carried. Throughout the novel, O’Brien “[blurs] the lines between fiction and nonfiction” (Smith), and explores how using fiction to convey the war affects the readers more as they learn about the soldiers. By using juxtaposition and by incorporating fictional parts in the novel, O’Brien shows how truth is less important in war stories than non-truth since non-truth makes the reader look at war stories at a more emotional level than truth.…

    • 1319 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Do you think that all the soldiers just carried physical objects? Most people just think that all they carried are guns and such. But they carried must more than physical objects. They carried intangible items. There were many tangible and intangible items they carry. But the most important items are the intangible ones. There are many intangible items they carry. But some of the most important are love, memories, and fear.…

    • 683 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Tim O’Brien brings the characters and stories to life in The Things They Carried. He uses a writing style that brings stories to life by posing questions between the relationship of reality and fiction (Calloway 249). This is called metafiction and it exposes the truth through the literary experience. Tim O’Brien uses metafiction to make the characters and stories in The Things They Carried realistically evocative of the Vietnam War.…

    • 782 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Alan Moore, the creator of the comic V for Vendetta, once stated, “Artists use lies to tell the truth. Yes, I created a lie. But because you believed it, you found something true about yourself.” In the quote moore describes the power that storytelling has on people. He explains to us that just because there is lies in the story, that doesn't mean that we cannot take something away from it. Similarly in the novel, The Things They Carried, the author, Tim O’Brien, uses stories to tell us about his time serving in the war in Vietnam. And even though most of these stories are not entirely true, that does not mean we cannot learn from them. Storytelling is a tool that allows soldiers and people, to escape the brutal hardships they face in everyday life, and create their own world and stories of “the truth,” and in the end it’s these stories that allow us to be happy and deal with that real life struggle.…

    • 865 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Wood says, stories, more often than not, are associated with written literary works such as novels and fairytales, visual entertainment like movies and other forms like songs. Fisher claims that these aren’t the only sources to find stories (200). From typical conversations with friends, to a student’s presentation, a teacher’s lecture, a church sermon and a convicts plead, the use of narrative and stories is found.…

    • 2165 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Better Essays

    But of course, like all other cinematic adaptations, the true story of the Titanic was altered and visually enhanced to make the film more appealing to a…

    • 1435 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Movie Review of Titanic

    • 1096 Words
    • 5 Pages

    The movie, Titanic, opens with treasure hunter Brock Lovett, who is searching the Titanic wreck for a necklace named the Heart of the Ocean. Lovett hopes to find the Heart of the Ocean contained within a safe he uncovered from passenger Caledon ‘Cal’ Hockley’s safe. He instead finds a sketch of a naked woman wearing the desired necklace. A woman of 101 years, named Rose Calvert, sees this photo shown on the news and contacts Lovett. He is uninterested at first in what she has to say, but becomes intrigued when she tells him that she is the woman in the drawing. Rose is then flown onto their search boat to tell her story about Titanic. We learn that Rose Calvert used to be Rose DeWitt Bukater and was a first class passenger on the Titanic. She spoke of a drifter, Jack Dawson, who won third class tickets for the Titanic in a poker game. Him and his friend Fabrizio caught the ship just as it is leaving. Rose, her mother Ruth, and fiance Cal, all were first class passengers on the Titanic. Unhappy with how she believed her life would be in the future, Rose runs to the end of the ship and plans to jump. Jack saves her by not only talking her off the deep end, but also pulling her to safety when she slips. As the movie continues, Rose and Jack get closer. The movie is a deep description of their love affair. I really enjoyed this movie. The plot line was so involved with the actual events that happened on that day 100 years ago. I’m also a sucker for a good chick flick that can make me cry so I loved that! The writers got did a great job of appealing to a younger audience. The movie, overall, is very entertaining. You know you’re watching a good movie when you don’t even notice that you have been sitting in a theater for 3 whole hours watching a movie. It really captured the audience. The plot line was also very clear. There really was no discrepancy between what was going on. The audience was definitely told exactly what the characters were feeling and why they were…

    • 1096 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The concept of telling the truth is a complex idea. The truth can vary based on an individual’s perspective and may be distorted by experience and misunderstanding. It is a creeping assumption of the modern world that there are things more important that the truth. The truth may also be covered up because it is difficult for people to cope with. These ideas are explored in Joe Wright’s film Atonement and the Poems ‘Homecoming’ by Bruce Dawe and ‘Mirror’ by Sylvia Plath. All texts are post modernism texts.…

    • 1476 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    The Titanic - Irony

    • 346 Words
    • 2 Pages

    “The Titanic was unsinkable…” was a thought that ran through many people’s heads as they heard the news that it had been struck with an iceberg. They believed it couldn’t sink because the Titanic was so big and strong that nothing in the world could take it down. Whenever people today think of the Titanic, we think of how it sank and how many people lost their lives, which is an example of dramatic irony in itself. We know the devastating end of the Titanic, yet most of the people in this story did not.…

    • 346 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Essay About Monster Story

    • 801 Words
    • 4 Pages

    For what makes a good or even excellent story? A shred of truth can go a long ways. In fact with every film today there is some shred of truth that they originated from. Take Schindler’s List a true story of Oskar Schindler during World War II – a man who saw the Jewish Holocaust in Holland and changed from corrupt businessman to a concerned…

    • 801 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Sometimes a lie is better than the truth. Now I’m not saying that you should lie to your parents about the dent on their car or lie to your friends about getting lucky with that girl last weekend, but every so often a situation comes along in which a small fabrication will better warrant the situation. In the novel Life of Pi, the author Yann Martel tells a fantastic story about a young boy at sea, trapped on a lifeboat with a 450lb Bengal tiger. During their journey, the unlikely castaways face an epic adventure of survival; crossing paths with such characters as a homicidal hyena, a motherly orangutan, a dead on arrival zebra, and a French blind cannibal. In the end the two find sanctuary after 227 days upon their arrival to the coast of Mexico. Now I know what you’re thinking. “This sounds pretty unbelievable”. Well you’re right to think so, but the truth in this case, is something you’re better off not knowing. The end of the novel brings about the knowledge that the animals in the story were in fact people and their grim deaths, including that of his mother, Pi had witnessed. Given the setting, this shouldn’t be seen as a lie, but rather as story telling. The act of story telling is a great thing. It can drum up adventure in the heart of the audience, make you feel a great deal of emotion for someone you’ve never met or isn’t even real, but to some it is a way to cope with an occurrence in which the truth is too terrible to deal with. We’ve always been taught never to lie and therefore it is an act that is seen as wrong be any means, however, given the right circumstances telling a lie, whether it be to yourself or to others, is the best possible way to avoid a traumatic experience of the past. Throughout the story Pi tells the more enjoyable version of his story, though the realization of this does not occur to the reader until the end of the novel. Through retrospection it is easy to see the fiction and the significance it holds.…

    • 1033 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    The Unsinkable Ship

    • 1392 Words
    • 6 Pages

    “84 years after the sinking of the RMS Titanic, a 100-year-old woman named Rose DeWitt Bukater tells the story to her granddaughter Lizzy Calvert, Brock Lovett, Lewis Bodine, Bobby Buell and Anatoly Mikailavich on the Keldysh about her life set in April 10th 1912, on a ship called Titanic when young Rose boards the departing ship with the upper-class passengers and her mother, Ruth DeWitt Bukater, and her fiancé, Caledon Hockley. Meanwhile, a drifter and artist named Jack Dawson and his best friend Fabrizio De Rossi win third-class tickets to the ship in a game. And she explains the whole story from departure until the death of Titanic on its first and last voyage April 15th, 1912 at 2:20 in the morning.” (Anthony Pereyra, date N/A)…

    • 1392 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    The movie “Titanic” takes place in 1912 and is based on the wreckage of the ship, and a love story. Rose is the main character of the movie; Rose is the fiancé of Cal, Cal’s father owns a big business in Pittsburgh. Rose’s mother wants her to marry Cal for his money. Rose didn’t want to marry Cal, so in the beginning she is about to commit suicide when she meets Jack. Cal then shows up and questions both of them and Rose makes up a story, she says she wanted to see the view and almost fell off when Jack saved her. Cal buys it, and Rose and Jack become good friends. She asks Jack to take a portrait of her wearing nothing but the necklace, (the necklace is a present from Cal ironically) he agrees and draws her, and then they go into a car in the middle of the ship and make love afterwards. Then they go up just in time to see the ship hit the iceberg. Cal sees the portrait and necklace stored in the safe, and Cal frames Jack for stealing the necklace to have him arrested by slipping it into Jack’s pocket. Jack is arrested and handcuffed to a pole. Rose gets an axe and cuts him free after she runs away from Cal, Cal tricks Rose and says if she gets on the lifeboat he will make arrangements to get Jack and him on another lifeboat, but she finds out he’s lying. Rose wouldn’t leave Jack and she jumps back onto the ship with him, the ship then breaks in half and sinks completely. Cal gets away on another boat by pretending he’s taking care of a child. After the ship sinks they swim to some wreckage and Rose gets onto a table that doesn’t have room for Jack. They talk for a while until Jack finally releases his grip on the table and drifts to the bottom of the ocean; Rose is later saved by a rescue lifeboat.…

    • 668 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays