Preview

Three Day Road Analysis

Better Essays
Open Document
Open Document
1316 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Three Day Road Analysis
French artist Paul Cezanne once said, “If isolation tempers the strong, it is the stumbling-block of the uncertain” (BrainyQuote). The topic of “the other” recurs so often in Three Day Road by Joseph Boyden, that it can be considered a motif. “The other” is a being who is isolated, separated, or segregated from their surroundings. It can be from their family, friends, co workers, anywhere someone can push them out of a circle. An other is usually considered to be a weak individual, one who doesn’t know what to do with themselves, someone who is lost. But what happens if a stronger, more focused protagonist becomes the other? Boyden decided to create his book around the idea of strong others, and didn’t write about weak or secondary characters. …show more content…
What happens if an other is surrounded by comrades or companions, but still feels like they are an outsider? This is what occurred during Xavier's time in the army. Despite being possibly the greatest shot in all of the allied forces, a simple downfall of not being able to speak English and having darker skin really held Xavier back and hurt him during his deployment. He observes his fellow soldiers exchange jokes and laughs while he struggles to understand what’s going on. “I am forced by my poor english to sit back and watch it all happen...while I become more invisible. A brown ghost” (Boyden 65). Back then, a life of an Indian was a hard one, especially being in the army. Surrounded by all white males who aren’t used to seeing or talking to an Aboriginal, adding even more pressure to perform well on top of just being in the army. He’s always on the outside of the circle, which a lot of people have experienced in their life, trying to listen to conversations, but constantly being blocked out and not being able to hear anyone talking. “Elijah begins to speak softly, so that the others around him must lean toward him (leaving X out)” (Boyden 242). To put it bluntly, it sucks to be excluded by people you work with, go to school with, or hang out with. Not a single person likes to be left out (except Niska) because it’s damaging to someone’s confidence and feelings. In the …show more content…
His reputation in the army grew exponentially since he was recruited, and was regarded as a skillful predator in the field, like he was at the top of the food chain. As he became more known, his comrades began to admire and revere him, always giving him praise. Kind of like an other, but one that you look up to or strive to be like, not someone going through a depressing time on the outside of a friend group. But the stress of being a role model and a leader got to him. He slowly started losing himself; using morphine, disobeying orders, solo missions, more ruthless killing techniques, all for the purpose maintaining his position. He even resorted to cannibalism, when asked “Is it horse?” he responded with “No, it is human, German to be exact” (Boyden 310). As one can imagine when someone starts to eat flesh, his comrades start to fear him. They become angry and confused, much like Xavier did, which can lead them to turning on the other. Every terrible thing that Elijah did led Xavier to kill him, which proves that this unorthodox other is the most dangerous to type of all, because it can lead to a subjects destruction. Elijah can also be called a ‘dynamic other’ due to the fact that he didn’t stay the same and seemed to transcend into something else, something that Xavier did not like at all.

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    The Story of Tom Brennan

    • 748 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Individuals' beliefs and attitudes are the product of the world they live in, and consequently these beliefs and attitudes are challenged when one moves into a new or different world. Both The Story Of Tom Brennan (2005) by J.C. Burke and The Door (When) by Miroslav Holub explore this notion of change through the experiences encountered when moving into different worlds. The Story Of Tom Brennan explores the journey, growth and self discovery of the protagonist, Tom, following his brother's drunken car crash. Similarly, The Door demonstrates the benefits associated with exploring new worlds, and the growth that occurs as a result of that exploration. Nevertheless, despite their difference in medium and time of production, both texts demonstrate a change in an individuals beliefs and attitudes is product on moving into new and different worlds.…

    • 748 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    On October 3 2016, author Joseph Boyden was at Mount Allison as part of the President’s Speaker Series. The event took place in 3 acts, using each act as an opportunity to share a secret from his life and beginning each with a special musical interlude during which Boyden played on the jawharp and harmonica respectively. In act one, he shared that the act of creating and sitting down and writing scares him. In act two, he confessed to believing that hardly anyone would read his first novel, Three Day Road, and that in the process of creating he gave up many times. In the third and final act, he confessed to being a young rebel who always sets out to challenge other people’s expectations. Following his lecture, he held a question period during which many audience members asked for writing advice and probed further on some of the earlier themes. As emphasized throughout the lecture {insert word here}, or everybody counts and idea tied not only to our school, but also as a step towards reconciliation with First Nations peoples.…

    • 515 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Both Monkey Beach and Three Day Road are Native American literature. Each author has his own unique way of inserting a presence of a mythical spirit or being into their stories to give the reader a feel for the supernatural. In doing so, the authors are successful at intensifying the experience for the reader. These supernatural characters play a significant role in the plot, and interactions between characters and their communities. This essay will describe, depict, and define these mythical creatures themselves as well as discuss the function they have in the two novels.…

    • 960 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Often times, we endure problems within ourselves that can either be solved or left alone to embrace. Whether it is mental or physical, many of us find it natural to undergo inner-conflict. In the two passages, “The Autobiography of an Ex-Colored Man” and “Quicksand,” the authors provide the audience with a theme that connects them both. After uncovering their internal conflict, they eventually decided to unknowingly distract themselves from the issue. This includes the way the authors utilized the setting and characters to convey their theme. When dealing with inner-conflict, the theme is developed by expressing personal past issues, discovering new people, and ultimately uncovering a sudden romance.…

    • 827 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Three Day Road

    • 373 Words
    • 2 Pages

    Set in 1919, following the end of World War I, the novel takes place in the wilderness of Northern Ontario and on the battlefields of France and Belgium. Niska, an Oji-Cree medicine woman, is the remnant of her native relatives who refused to assimilate in the 19th century. She rejected European beliefs and culture and continues to thrive in the bush in a manner befitting her and her traditions. Niska’s voice is one of two narratives that complete the novel. After getting word that her closest thing to living family, Elijah, is coming back from the war she paddles the three-day journey to meet him in town. She finds, however, that it is not Elijah but her nephew Xavier who has returned from battle. In an attempt to heal her only relative, who has clearly been sucked dry of his soul and has hardened with slaughter and turned hollow from morphine, she begins to recount the stories of her past. She believes that perhaps this will revive Xavier and the Three Day Road will not be one to his demise. Similarly, Xavier attempts to stumble over his story for his aunt and unearths ghosts of his bullet-riddled past.…

    • 373 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Three Day Road Themes

    • 1093 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Elijah has a goal to be a better sniper than Peggy and to prove to everyone else that he is by keeping track and advertising the number of kills he has. Xavier is also trying to compete with Elijah because Xavier knows that he is the better sniper. Xavier becomes increasingly frustrated because other soldiers continue to praise Elijah, to the point where he even gets a medal for his efforts during a battle, but everyone seems to be ignoring Xavier’s success.…

    • 1093 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In the novel, “Three Day Road”, by Joseph Boyden, the loss and regaining of identity is manifested in Xavier. Throughout the novel, as Xavier goes through the war, he feels as if he is losing his own identity as an aboriginal but begins to gain it back while with Niska. Within the beginning of the novel, Xavier starts off staying true to his aboriginal background, has a strong sense of morality, and understands his own identity. Xavier is a man who respects life, but as he goes through the war he loses that part of his identity a little. An example of when Xavier respects life is when he snares a marten. In the prologue of the novel, Xavier and Elijah are walking through a forest to see what they have snared, but when they find that the marten…

    • 862 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    What’s worse though, is how Xavier cannot properly communicate what he wants to with the soldiers. Elijah glorifies himself in his stories, while leaving Xavier out, and giving him no credit, even though the two work together as a team. Elijahs early upbringing in the residential schools gave him advantages over Xavier in gaining favor with the other soldiers. The difference between Elijah and Xavier’s personalities is night and day. Elijah is a reckless extrovert, while Xavier is a careful introvert. Elijah often puts himself and others in danger, unnecessarily, to feed his need for action and excitement. It is usually Xavier who ends up the victim of Elijah’s…

    • 1671 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    ThreeDayTrip

    • 447 Words
    • 2 Pages

    Moira’s bad attitude causes Barry to doubt his parenting skills and devours his confidence. Firstly, Barry‘s confusion in raising Moira alone, leads him to seek advice from others. W.D. Valgardson illustrates, “he sought the advice of women at work who had teenage daughters.” (Valgardson 2). The result of Barry’s confusion causes him to seek the advice of his fellow female mother workers. Secondly, when Barry seeks advice from his students, one of which helps. The student speaks, “The caged bird proves nothing but the power of the captor,” (2). The quote used by the girl, represents Barry the bird and Moira the captor and that Moira has more power which is causing Barry to be powerless. Furthermore, Barry’s anxiety makes him believe that Moira will confront him angrily. Moira says, “I’m smoking dope, six joints a day, and sniffing coke and participating in orgies,” (2). Barry causes himself to believe that if confronted Moira will say his worst nightmares, that she is doing drugs. In conclusion, Barry’s anxiety and confusion raising Moira causes him to have false beliefs and seek others advice.…

    • 447 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Three Day Road Analysis

    • 1390 Words
    • 6 Pages

    While Niska tells Xavier her stories throughout Three Day Road, it helps the two quickly change as characters right before our eyes. While she tells these stories to an unconscious, traumatized Xavier, she grows, and becomes more comfortable with him, and more comfortable sharing the stories. They also they seep into Xavier’s subconscious while he is drifting and help guide him through the hardships he has faced and the ones he is about to go through. When Niska tells Xavier the tails of her life, and Xavier’s upbringing, it brings back old memories of when he and Elijah were young. These memories help pull Xavier through his injury, addiction, and memories he just cannot forget. Niska ultimately gains confidence in telling her nephew these…

    • 1390 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    The meaning of “the other” is the quality or condition of being considered an outsider or different. With my chosen text, I believe “the other” is identified through society and status, as society believes these couples are opposites, where as…

    • 830 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Three Day Road Quotes

    • 558 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Throughout the book there are several variations of characters witnessing their acquaintances going through trauma & selfhood or in fact being the one under going these traits. For instance Xavier was the lead narrator for the story, he was also a cree soldier who fought for Canada during world war 1. Just like most soldiers after war, they need something to help them cope after witnessing all the gruesome experiences of war. Xavier used morphine to help him manage with killing elijah and life after war. The narration from the point of view from Xavier influences the themes of trauma and selfhood because we are able to view him from 2 perspectives, one being mental and one being physical. We see…

    • 558 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Two Sides

    • 788 Words
    • 4 Pages

    If someone wants to get a point across to a wide audience they must appeal to people’s emotions, logic, or show them that they are credible. In the book The Other Wes Moore the author tries to show his readers that any decision made could change a life in a positive or negative way. Throughout his book, Wes Moore compares the lives of two boys with the same name, growing up at the same time, both in bad neighborhoods. He examines these young men and tries to show when and why their lives changed for better and worse. People cannot choose their living conditions or who their parents are, but Wes Moore shows how the decisions made today can change a person’s future for better or worse. For his audience, use of pathos is the best way for the author Wes Moore to inspire his readers to listen to his purpose of this story and make a change in their lives. To further support his book the author appeals to the audience’s ethos and logos but they are minor in comparison to his appeal to pathos.…

    • 788 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Human nature is consistently displayed through the eyes of authors in literature. Whether it be the desperation of children whose lives are at the mercy of a beast of an island, or the perseverance of a young boy, crippled and disheartened; literature often conveys the determination, inner conflict and perseverance that makes us who were are as a race.…

    • 339 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Along the way Everyman tries to convince other characters to accompany him. The other characters are also allegorical, each character personifies an abstract idea like Fellowship, Kindred and Cousin, Goods, Good Deeds, Knowledge, Beauty, Strength, Five Wits. In his time of need he is deserted by his companions and wealth. He loses his Fellowship, Kindred, Cousin, and Goods. He also loses Beauty, Strength, Discretion and…

    • 640 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays