Preview

To What Extent Did the Liberal Social Reforms Mark a Significant Break with 19th Century Attitudes to Poverty?

Powerful Essays
Open Document
Open Document
2127 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
To What Extent Did the Liberal Social Reforms Mark a Significant Break with 19th Century Attitudes to Poverty?
To what extent did the Liberal social reforms mark a significant break with 19th century attitudes to poverty?

In 19th century Britain, the upper class and even the Government held a unanimous view of the poor. Their view was that poverty was the result of moral failings and that these people were responsible for their own social circumstance. The social elite stereotyped the poor as drunken and lazy, and therefore undeserving of help or attention. This was reflected in the ‘laissez faire’ approach taken by the Government where they believed that poverty and hardship were not things that they had a responsibility to deal with. However, in the late 19th century and the early 20th century these attitudes began to change to a more accepting and sympathetic view to poverty. This was largely due to the writers Mayhew and Dickens, and the poverty reports made by Booth and Rowntree. The former both brought the issue of poverty to the forefront for the public; Mayhew through the ‘Morning Chronicle’ and ‘London Labour and the London Poor’; Dickens through his novels. Charles Dickens was seen as a voice to represent the poor and in novels such as ‘Our Mutual Friend’ he showed their despair, writing of the poor house: “Kill me sooner than take me there. Throw this child under the cart horses feet and a loaded wagon, sooner than take him there.” This convinced the public of the plight of the poor while the hard facts and figures presented by Booth and Rowntree convinced the Government. So, due to the writings of Mayhew and Dickens, the reports of Booth and Rowntree, worries for national efficiency, the creation of the Labour Party and the work of certain individuals such as Churchill and Lloyd George, the Liberal Government introduced a series of social reforms between 1906 and 1914 which reflected the changing views of the public and those in power. The new reforms dealt with poverty in child hood and old age, and poverty due to illness and low wages.

In 1906 free

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    There was a growing awareness of poverty in Britain, especially in London in early 1900s. According to the research of Charles Booth in London, there were 25% of people that were living under abject poverty and over 35% of people were living under the poverty line of 0.90-1.05 pounds per week for a family with 3 children. The situation was severe and that was not only happening in London, but other cities as well. According to Seebhom Rowntree’s studies, there were 28% of people that lives in York could not afford to buy clothing and food. Social reform was definitely needed. At that time, some other new liberalism were arising, they aimed to give out minimum living standard for needy families. In contrast, the conservative was not doing anything good and the Education Act that did not please the society. As a result, a party that was providing more benefit to citizens and poverty became more successful and gained more voter’s…

    • 1006 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The Liberals made many social reforms which were not necessarily directly helpful to the individual issues at hand but they did create grounds for the welfare estate to be built upon and highlighted the areas which needed attention for a better minimum quality of life. Areas focused on were free meals and health checks at schools, pensions and insurances. For example, the 1906 School Meals Act allowed children to have a free daily meal. This was effective in 1914 as by then, 14 million were receiving the free meals which duly led to a better economy however the negatives outweighed the positives as the issue with having the act voluntary until 1912 meant that over half of the authorities didn’t provide meals. Furthermore, proving eligibility was very difficult so there were many errors which occurred with the system. Rather similarly, Old Aged Pensioners couldn’t receive their money due to identity proofing issues. Household issues were ignored which was one of the Liberal’s negatives however, this is without taking into account that only so many areas could have been focused on. Although the Liberals never catered for the needs of all people, their reforms managed to always bring some improvement into areas of health, education and the future of citizens, no matter how poor in places they were. The Liberal Social Reforms did improve the lives of the British citizens to some extent, the main achievement being that the existence of the reforms themselves allowed to building of the welfare estate which is a factor that makes Britain as strong as it is today.…

    • 932 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Some historians believed the government only took little action against poverty as socials commentators Booth and Rowntree showed it wasn’t the individuals fault. Winston Churchill summed up the aim of the liberals as he said This means that the liberal government provided very little help to the lower class so that they could help themselves escape poverty. Historians alleged that it could be estimated that as much as one third of the population would have been below the poverty line before the reforms and people feel no other government could have handled the issue of poverty any better at that time which shows the liberals were as successful as they could be towards the five social groups. However The Liberal Government largely focused on specific difficulties in society but failed to introduce solutions to deal with issues such as housing or National Health Service that affects everyone. This shows that the Liberal reforms 1906-1914 were only successful on a small scale as it was unable to improve the poverty levels of the whole…

    • 1589 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Better Essays

    In the 19th century, the poor people faced a very atrocious and frightful life in London. They starved if they had no jobs and had nowhere to live except for streets which were filthy and filled with crime. There was a poor law, as there weren’t even state benefits and if someone couldn’t pay the rent for the room they were given to stay in they were moved to union workhouses or prisons, which they unfortunately died in. Dickens uses these them of poor and rich in his novel through the character of scrooge to show people are just for the greed of money and how they can change, which puts quite a truthful moral to this…

    • 1791 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Liberalism or the New Morality movement of the 1920s was based on the concept that all humans are deservant of independence and fairness, and affected a major part of the American society with gender, caste/creed and sexual orientation aspects. Changes in the spheres of fashion, personal preferences and lifestyle changes, education and professional aspirations became apparent, thus leading to the end of simplicity, giving way to…

    • 67 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Elizabethan Poor Laws

    • 663 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Life for the poor in Elizabethan England was very harsh. Unemployment and rapid price inflation increased causing many villagers to leave their homes and come to the towns to look for work. However, they often could not find employment and ended up begging in the streets. Elizabethan Poor Laws, enacted in 1601, were incredibly beneficial in uniting the community to provide care and nurture for the qualifying less fortunate. These laws set a critical foundation for Britain’s welfare system and established guidelines for the “deserving” and “undeserving” poor. I chose this topic because it vastly influenced our world today, not only physically, but morally.…

    • 663 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    19th Century Liberalism

    • 378 Words
    • 2 Pages

    Nationalism as a radical idea of the early 19th century was destined to have an enormous influence in the modern world. In this ideology we find some points standing out, firstly nationalism has normally evolved from a real or imagined cultural unity supporting itself especially in a common language, history, and territory. Nationalists also have usually sought to turn this cultural unity into political reality and modern nationalism had its immediate impact in the French Revolution and the Napoleonic wars. This kind of movement emerged in the early nineteenth century. Though the restored order of Metternich which from 1815-1848 did suppress the revolutionary challenge, it nevertheless had to reconcile itself to some of the demands that had been made earlier and moderate constitutions were granted by most states. Post-revolutionary nationalism was the greatest threat to Metternich's restored order. The idea of national self-determination was repellent to Metternich. It not only threatened the existence of the aristocracy but also threatened to destroy the Austrian Empire and revolutionize central Europe.…

    • 378 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    They had few options for living, debtors prison or work in a workhouse. Many people would not help them and they were forced to go to these facilities: “I help to support the establishments I have mentioned---they cost enough; and those who are badly off must go there” (Dickens 4). Scrooge refuses to donate to charity, even though he is quite wealthy. Wealthy people, with money to share, continue only keep themselves in mind. The poor do not have much place in society or in the wealthy’s mind: “‘If they would rather die,’ said Scrooge, ‘they had better do it, and decrease the surplus population’” (Dickens 5). Scrooge does not care about the lives of the poor, and believes they should work. Drawing attention to the treatment of the poor inspired many to begin acting upon…

    • 603 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Oliver Twist

    • 884 Words
    • 4 Pages

    The setting of Saffron Hill, London shows the reader the horrid living conditions in London that the poor had to live in during the 19th centaury. The living conditions for the poor living in urban London were horrible and often dirty polluted and crowded ‘Most wrenched place he’d ever seen’. They were also diseased as there was poor sanitation and low standard of construction, the housing was cramped and so close to one another ‘as he follows dodger through the ‘very narrow and muddy’ streets’. There were people living on the streets and others crammed into housing and apartments with many other…

    • 884 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    This book also shows how poor Victorians suffer and the treatment they used to get. The poor were sent to workhouses and scrooge was happy about this. Not because workhouses were helping the poor it was more of a punishment. Scrooge was ignorant in the fact that he believed the conditions the poor lived in were self-inflicted, ‘I can’t afford to make idle people merry. I help to support the establishments I have mentioned- they cost enough; and those who are badly off must go there’ he believes they are uneducated and lazy so they deserve it. However in reality most people if given the opportunity and education would try to alleviate the quality of their lives.…

    • 844 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Great Expectations

    • 1103 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Education was an important cultural aspect of the Victorian era. Education allowed wider access to employment, and respect; for one could not become a gentleman and part of the upper-class without an education. Yet access to education was greatly determined to one’s position in society. Those in the upper class were given a higher priority to receive education than those in the lower class. Therefore it was very difficult for one to advance within society. This provides Dickens with the opportunity to gently satirize the class system of this era and to provide a Marxist view on the inequality of wealth and power.…

    • 1103 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Crossman, V, 2006, Politics, pauperism and power in the late 19th century, Manchester University Press, Manchester.…

    • 1447 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Dickens wrote in the 19th century England that was characterized by oppressed poor masses with few rights. The society at this time had an oppressive bureaucracy whose machinations made the life for the poor almost unbearably, and Dickens provided information reflecting injustices of the system and the resulting exploitation of the poor. Through Dickens’ series of stories like Sketches of Boz and Pickwick Papers published on the Morning of Chronicles he made known the suffering of the poor using a quick wit and significant intuitiveness about their lives (Smiley 4). Dickens wrote fourteen novels in three years with eight of them having 875…

    • 1546 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    The report compiled by the 1832 commission of enquiry displays its strong belief that the able bodied poor were and had to be put in their 'proper position' as the reform of the poor law was based on the commission’s findings this could suggest that they agree with the interpretation that main aim of the poor law administration after 1834 was to deter the able-bodied from seeking poor relief. However D. Englander, author of 'Poverty and Poor Law Reform in 19th Century Britain' acknowledges some accuracy within the interpretation of the question. However he dismisses the idea that the main aim of poor law administration after 1834 was to deter able-bodied poor from seeking poor relief by stating "the workhouse was always something more than a test of destitution for the able-bodied". Englander acknowledges the role of the workhouse and how they were implemented in an attempt to help the deserving poor. However Peter Murray author of 'Poverty and Welfare' supports the interpretation from the report written by the commission and consequently agrees with the interpretation in question. Murray labels the workhouses as "institutionalised cruelty", presenting a definite belief that the main aim of poor law administration after 1834 was to deter able-bodied poor from seeking poor relief. Overall, when considering the national aim of poor law administration after 1834 it was administered in order to deter able-bodied poor from seeking poor relief. However at a local level this was completely different, in order to cut costs the main aim of local poor law administration was to costs after 1834. Concerning the treatment of the deserving poor the administration after 1834 aimed to sympathise with the deserving poor however it was difficult to implement at a local level.…

    • 2439 Words
    • 10 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Industralization

    • 731 Words
    • 3 Pages

    It is known that workers in factories during the late 19th and early 20th centuries were severely mistreated; they were not granted the pay they should have received. It has been said that the society built places around factories for housing due to the many workers that worked in the factories. Edwin Chadwick broached this topic in his work Inquiry into the Sanitary Conditions of the Poor. He made it clear that people in the community had no fresh water. It was quite easy for deadly diseases to spread due to the congested living conditions factory workers were forced to accept. Diseases, not so surprisingly, increased the mortality rate in these urban areas. Chadwick emphasized that people living in these slums were subject to apathy from their governments. He suggested that precautions should be taken in order to assure that these people were given a real chance to survive. (Caldwell, 404-407). The poor were completely overlooked in urbanized societies. It seemed as if the gap between the rich and poor was growing drastically. There was no apparent middle class. The rich factory owners could pay their workers whatever they wanted. There would be no one to stand up for them. If the workers decided to ask for a pay raise, the owners could simply fire them. There was a plethora of people to fill in the empty spot. In Jack London’s essay The People of the Abyss, he touches on the subject of poverty as well. He emphasizes the term “ghetto” when speaking of the tenements workers and their families resided in. He stated that the ghetto is where the rich and powerful do not exist. The ghetto…

    • 731 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays