Torture's Dirty Secret By Naomi Kich Analysis
Naomi Klein’s article, “Torture’s Dirty Secret: It Works” from the May 30, 2005 asserts that torture is a tool that has been used for a long time by investigative personnel to extract important information from detainees. Naomi Klein describes the effects of torture on its victims by including a victim’s ordeal in her article. One of the victims of torture that Naomi Klein includes in her argument is a Syrian-born Canadian known as Maher Arar. Maher Arar is the world’s most famous victim of rendition by US officials. He was detained by US investigators at an airport in New York and then rendered to Syria. Arar was held in a tiny cell in Syria for ten months. While in detention, he was periodically taken out for beatings. The evidence that was
…show more content…
Klein extends an emotional appeal to the audience by describing the extent of fear that torture has caused among members of the public. She gives an example of the Muslims who are resigning from positions of leadership in the Muslim Community Association of Ann Arbor in Michigan. Klein adds more emotional appeal by putting down the remarks made by the president of them Muslim organization that membership has declined leading to a reduction in donations. Klein expects the audience to understand the hidden effects that the fear of torture has had on Muslims and Muslim organizations. By terming the cells as mouse-infested, Naomi Klein is appealing to the emotional conscience of the reader in order to bring to their attention the real meaning of torture through the use of imagery. Klein also compares the size of the Syrian cells to a grave and thereby creating feelings of sympathy for the detainees. Klein tries to appeal to the reader’s emotions by adding that the only times when Maher Arar was taken out of the cell was when he was to be beaten. This strongly appeals to the emotions of the reader Naomi Klein also uses passages about sexual humiliation of prisoners written in a new book by a former military translator and approved by the Pentagon. In order to support her claim about the extent of the torture, Klein adds that even in this book written by the former military translator, the sections regarding the use of widespread torture have been removed to conceal some information from the
Klein extends an emotional appeal to the audience by describing the extent of fear that torture has caused among members of the public. She gives an example of the Muslims who are resigning from positions of leadership in the Muslim Community Association of Ann Arbor in Michigan. Klein adds more emotional appeal by putting down the remarks made by the president of them Muslim organization that membership has declined leading to a reduction in donations. Klein expects the audience to understand the hidden effects that the fear of torture has had on Muslims and Muslim organizations. By terming the cells as mouse-infested, Naomi Klein is appealing to the emotional conscience of the reader in order to bring to their attention the real meaning of torture through the use of imagery. Klein also compares the size of the Syrian cells to a grave and thereby creating feelings of sympathy for the detainees. Klein tries to appeal to the reader’s emotions by adding that the only times when Maher Arar was taken out of the cell was when he was to be beaten. This strongly appeals to the emotions of the reader Naomi Klein also uses passages about sexual humiliation of prisoners written in a new book by a former military translator and approved by the Pentagon. In order to support her claim about the extent of the torture, Klein adds that even in this book written by the former military translator, the sections regarding the use of widespread torture have been removed to conceal some information from the