Preview

Two Advantages And Disadvantages And Different Forms Of Government

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
918 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Two Advantages And Disadvantages And Different Forms Of Government
Comparisons between different forms of government and their respective advantages and disadvantages have been made throughout history, and will continue to be relevant. Aristotle famously compared forms of government based on two main criteria: how many people hold power, and who’s interests are they serving (Wikipedia, 2018).
Monarchy in Ancient Greece was a form of government where the king, or monarch, held absolute power over his subjects. The monarch’s claim to power was based on inheritance, or belonging to the royal family. As a form of government it can be argued that it is the most successful, as it survived all over the world from ancient times to present day. Non-ruling individuals belonging to the royal family were part of the
…show more content…
Citizens voted for all legal and executive decisions. The best known and most radical democracy in antiquity was the Athenian democracy. In practice, due to the economic restrictions to political participation, ancient democracies resembled oligarchies in the sense that only the richest citizens, the aristocracy, were able to run for the highest political offices, and they were secretive and controlling of what they presented to be decided by vote in the general assembly. All modern democracies were based on the Athenian democracy, but they differ from it. Modern democracies are representative democracies in which the general public elects a number of political representatives to vote on most political issues, and the general public votes on a limited number of issues presented for vote by their elected representatives. The difference between this and oligarchy, and it is a significant difference, is that the political representatives cannot veto the direct vote of the general public. Otherwise, modern representative democracies can end-up resembling oligarchies very closely, and in some instances even aristocracies. Diverging from Aristotle’s views on the subject, many argue that democracy stands in direct opposition to tyranny, because democracy is the rule of the many by the many for the many, and tyranny is the rule of the many by one for the one.
These four main systems of government have existed since antiquity, and they continue to exist in varied forms even today. While some have tried to devise other forms of government, democracy seems to be the best system we have so far. However, it is an imperfect system of governance, and given the many changes technology is bringing to other areas in our lives, it is inevitable that technology will eventually impact our political structures as

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Satisfactory Essays

    Using ancient Sparta as a case study, I would say that the Greeks did not place a lot of emphasis on monarch. In fact their perception and relationship to monarchy was very subdued .The Spartans operated a bi-monarchial system of monarchy .In essence; they did not value monarchy, in the sense that monarchy can only be practiced absolutely for it to have a true meaning.…

    • 232 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Democracy has been around for hundreds of years and while the basic principles have stayed the same though each society governed in a slightly different way. The most influential democracies were Greece, as it was considered one of the first democracies, and the Roman Republic which lasted several hundred years. Because each sovereignty ruled differently, they had different advancements in the areas of democracy especially in the people's role in the government, the method of voting and fairness of law.…

    • 318 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    A monarchy is a governmental system in which the head of state is a single person. The first ruler of Rome and the founder of Rome is Romulus. During this time period Rome’s power was passed down by blood. This is one of the reasons why monarchies fell. Slaves, and other lower class citizens revolted at the fact that they couldn’t…

    • 849 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Greece’s early ideas of separation of powers within a democracy have been integrated into American governmental systems. In Athens, a democracy was established in 508 B.C. when Cleisthenes overthrew the aristocrats (Document 4). This government was a direct democracy, where members of the Assembly, which was made up of all free male citizens over the age of twenty one, voted on every issue (Document 3). The Assembly also elected the Council, Board of Generals, Board of Officials, and the Juries. The Council was made up of five hundred members who served for one year. This body suggested ideas for the assembly to vote for. In addition to the council, there was the Board of Generals, who led the army and the navy, as well as proposing ideas to the assembly on military affairs. Furthermore, there were also the Board of Officials and the Juries, who were involved with court cases. The Board of Officials directed the courts of justice while the juries combined were judges and jurors. Each trial, at least two hundred and one juries were chosen to participate. These branches of the Athenian democracy could be compared to the separation of powers currently utilized in the United States’ government. For example, ancient Greece’s Council is akin to the legislative branch in American government. Congress has the power to write bills that will be considered to be turned into laws, much like the Council had the power to propose ideas to be…

    • 1442 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Week 3 Democracy Paper

    • 695 Words
    • 2 Pages

    The first well-known democracy was in Athens. Though other Greek cities set up democracies none were as powerful, stable or as well documented as Athens. Athens democracy had some of the highest rate of participation known. There are few reasons why Ancient democracy differs from modern democracy. One being that the Athenian democracy was exclusive. Only certain people could participate. Another difference was the main bodies of governance; The Assembly, the Boule, and the Courts. Finally the legal system was less challenging in Ancient Athens.…

    • 695 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The kind of government that Ancient Greece had was democracy, wherein everyone is given a chance to be heard and “the administration is in the hands of the many and not the few” (Reilly 91). This gave its citizens to have a say on the events and decisions that occur in the city. It is also a form of government where “aristocrats [were] stripped of all their powers except for certain judicial functions” (Bowra 93). Anyone was capable of being part of the government regardless of their job or their state and each part of Ancient Greece had their representatives to ensure that each part able to contribute and lead. This had a significant part to its rise to power because this form of government was able to develop a trust among its people and it was used as a means of being able to communicate effectively among the people of Ancient Greece.…

    • 500 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    8th Grade Paper

    • 436 Words
    • 2 Pages

    Ancient Roman Republic and ancient Greek Democracy strongly influenced the government we have in the United States today. The United States mainly composed of these two types of systems. The U.S. also shares the history behind these systems of why they were created. They were created for getting rid of tyrants and kings, and allowing people to have a voice in the government. In my opinion the U.S. uses the Roman Republic system the most because we vote for representatives to make laws. But…

    • 436 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Athens and Rome with their similar styles of governing shaped the world, spreading culture and influence, however, there is contrast is in their systems of government. I hope you have a coffee to keep you up while reading this paper, now let me tell you the differences on this paper.…

    • 270 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    III. Is Representative Democracy Best?A. For a representative democracy government to work their must be:i. A opportunity for genuine leadership competition1. individuals and parties be able to run for office2. free communication 3. voters perceive that meaningful choices existii. Guidelines for fair leadership campaigns.B. Framers of the constitution -i. Thought that representative democracy was best because -1. less chances of it offices being manipulated2. help prevent political offices being used for private gain3. reduce the need for constant pollsii. Set up government to protect -1. Civil rights of all people2. Minorities 3. From concentration placement of power. IV. How is Power Distributed in a Democracy?A. Elitei. Persons who possess…

    • 461 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Better Essays

    The goal of the Athenian people was to establish a form of leadership that enabled them to have more input and control while reducing the tenure of its leaders. This began with the elimination of “hereditary” leadership and brought about the change of requiring kings to be elected every ten years (Mills 94). One of the last and most significant changes during the Monarchy government was the elimination of the office of king thereby eliminating the ruling of one person with significant power (Mills. 94). This benefitted the Athenian people as during this period each king had a group of nobles who served under him and there riches grew which culminated in a powerful body called the “Areopagus”. Areopagus was the name of the hill that the nobles met on and it was from this group that the oligarchy would develop (Ancient Athens 1). Oligarchy: a government where a small group of people exercise control for corrupt and selfish purposes (Merriam- Webster: online…

    • 2106 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Ancient Greece is normally associated with the origin of democracy. Basically, Greek government evolved from single rule to small group rule to rule by the people. Because each city-state in ancient Greece possessed its own government, some of these types existed other than democracy, namely monarchy, aristocracy, tyranny, oligarchy. This essay will compare and contrast the ancient governments, namely monarchy, aristocracy, tyranny, oligarchy and democracy in Ancient Greek city states.…

    • 516 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The Concept of the Polis

    • 751 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Sparta had a mixed government, with democratic features. There were two kings, each hereditary. This arrangement had the convenience of allowing one king to lead the army while the other stayed behind to mind things at home. This way they would always have back up. Five ephors, elected by the citizen assembly, were chosen to run the government. There was a Council of Elders made up of the two kings and 28 elders which made most decisions. At age 30, male Spartans were eligible to vote.…

    • 751 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    During the seventeenth and eighteenth centuries, there were various forms of government, including democracy and absolutism. Not only is this an important topic because it deals with the government, but it also deals with the citizens and their perception of the government. However, at this time democracy was a better form of government because the people share the power with the government, the person in power does not have absolute power, and it protects the rights of the people.…

    • 394 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    In ancient Rome they had a republic then switched to more of a monarchy and the Greeks had a democracy. Rome had the division of laws into Jus Gentium and Jus Civile. Jus Gentium (law of all nations) referred to the universal principles all people have, which are fundamental to all human beings. Jus Civile (civil law) would encompass all of the specific norms within a region. This is like our modern government in the sense that the laws apply to everyone and not just a specific group of people. Rome also had the corvee system which was popular within the empire. The system required subjects, usually peasants, to provide labor as a payment of tax. Rome’s form of government was a republic which influenced other form of government in our modern world. Rome’s republic allowed adult citizens to have control, primarily land-owning males. In Greece democracy was created and it was one of the most enduring contributions to the modern world. It gave power to the people and was comprised of three separate institution like today.…

    • 560 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    A Democracy in Ancient Greece. The cities of Ancient Greece were organized into city-states, or small independent nations. Athens was one such city-state. For many years, Athens was ruled by a small group of wealthy and powerful men known as the Great Council. Members of the Council passed laws that favored wealthy people like themselves. Between 750 B.C. and 550 B.C., however, this system of rule began to change.…

    • 565 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays