Preview

Violent Media Is Good For Kids Analysis

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
2033 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Violent Media Is Good For Kids Analysis
An article called “Violent Media is Good for Kids,” that was written by Gerard Jones, a renowned comic- book author, is arguing that violent media can be helpful for children, rather than be harmful. He talks about how parents don’t take the time to look at how helpful violent media can be for their child. Violence can encourage children to learn how to reach for their own inner power that they may have never been able to find before. Children as they grow up can learn the positives and negatives of violence, which can help them later on in their future choices. As for with “creative violence-head bonking cartoons, bloody videogames, playground karate, ty guns- give children a tool to master their rage”, this term is correlated to the idea …show more content…
He starts off the article by stating “my parents, not trusting the violent world of the late 1960s, built a wall between me and the crudest elements of American pop culture”. He then explains that once he was allowed to view such content such as comic books he “suddenly had a fantasy self to carry my stifled rage and burned desire for power.” In the later future he gets inspired by the power the Hulk possessed and then gained confidence within himself to then become a writer. Readers are most likely to believe his claims that violent media can help kids, due to his experiences of using violent media to improve himself as a child and when he grew up. Another appeal he uses to show he is knowledgeable about the subject is by explaining how he is a parent as well and is seeing how exposure to violent media is affecting his son. He goes further into detail about how he exposed his son to violent media to overcome some fears he had. He states “I took my cue from his fantasies and read him old Tarzan comics, rich in combat and bright with flashing knives. For two weeks he lived in them. Then he put them aside. And he climbed the tress.” This helps his claim by providing readers both his and his son’s experiences of how they both showed good outcomes of being exposed to such media with gaining confidence rather than gaining negative violent behavior. Yet, he also demonstrates an awareness of his audience’s assumptions of how violent media could promote violent tendencies or acts to be acceptable to children. He states “I’m not going to argue that violent entertainment is harmless. He then is explaining how he isn’t going to say that exposure to violent media is fully nontoxic to a person’s mind even a child’s. This overall helps to strengthens his

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    In “Violent Media Is Good For Kids,” Gerard Jones takes his position on how the comic books violence has led him to further develop as a person and inspire his career as a writer. In fact, he talked about how the Hulk led him out of passivity and loneliness as a young kid. But this is only about one person and not everybody else. Nobody is the same in this world.…

    • 585 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In reading “Violent Media is Good for Kids”; by Gerard Jones, he doesn’t argue against the fact that some harm has come from violence in the media. However the author does convey the fact that he has first handedly seen the positive effects of well managed use of violence in different mediums. Mr. Jones has reinforced my view and opinion on violence in the media by informing me to the efforts of him and his colleague to help children use their natural feelings in a positive manner and find an enlightening outlet.…

    • 414 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    In Gerard Jones’ “Violent Media Is Good for Kids” found in our text, Practical Argument, Jones argues that children should not be sheltered from violence. Gerard Jones discusses his own experiences growing up in a home that banned any violent media. He was a scared, introverted child in desperate need of help understanding the feelings he was taught to bottle up. When a few Incredible Hulk comics somehow made it past his parents and right into his eager hands he was a child reformed. The stories of the violent brute known as The Hulk gave Jones an outlet for his internal rage. Consequently, he became braver and happier with his new so called “fantasy self”.…

    • 307 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Vivian Sobchack Analysis

    • 334 Words
    • 2 Pages

    Sociologists and cultural critics still argue about the effects of media violence. I don’t think anybody really knows the answer so why even bring it up in the first place? So kids, why even stock the flames? Still, violence and sensational gore is part and parcel of the beloved action-adventure film, science fiction, and suspense thrillers. It is an important component in the craft of screen writing. In this age of computer animation and special effects, it has become as mundane as ‘coffee and donuts’. Believe me, if they ever pull it all out, you’ll sit up on your sofa one day after your favorite show, or leave the movies after the world was saved and wonder what you…

    • 334 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    In Gerald Jones’ article “Violent Media is Good for Kids” contained in the book Practical Argument he uses logos to present his argument that the censorship on the emotions of children. The censorship of children from their own emotional tendencies is preventing them from exploring and understating themselves. Jones provides example of this by describing a little girl that had been acting out her anger in her writings and drawings. Adults that interacted in her life attempted to control the violent acts that she wrote about causing her to act out more. With the help of the little girls’ she was encouraged to express herself in her writings. This led to the girl to become more self-confident about herself and to channel her anger better.…

    • 226 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Gerard Jones, in “Violent Media is Good for Kids,” expresses personal experiences about how violent comic books can often help children break through their shells of self-isolation. Because Jones largely discusses his own opinions, I feel the essay should provide more statistical evidence to support his thoughts. Although I agree with his point that children do need to have an outlet to express their underlying rage, I think a boundary of how extreme we can allow children to stretch this idea needs to be set.…

    • 934 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    In “Violent Media is Good for Kids,” the author Gerard Jones claims that violent media is good for children because it prepares them for violence in reality and teaches them how to control with rage. He argues against people’s view of violent media being negative influence on children. This view suggests that it is important to keep children away from violent media because it promotes imaginary gun battles, killing, blood, and violent fighting. In response, the author argues that such violence in media can give children a tool to master their rage.…

    • 259 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Jones uses his life as an example in proving that violent media is good for kids. He explains how his parents tried to shield him from violent media but "the Incredible Hulk smashed through it." The Hulk taught him to be a more self-empowered person. He tried this violent…

    • 582 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    A story written in by Gerard Jones called Violent Media is Good for Kids that appeared in Mother Jones under the political section, written 28 June 2000. He is an author of several works to include fictional and non-fictional works. His written for Marvel Comics and other companies. The essay talks about his life, how he was sheltered from violence or what his family felt wasn’t appropriate because of his parents. However, it was his mom that got him hooked on comic books, she thought it would teach him about the bigger picture, he liked the violence. The comic books helped him evolve as a human. And as he evolved, so did his needs for greater substance or more complicated story lines. He argues that comics are healthy and that is teaches important lessons about life, emotions, and the interactions of life.…

    • 543 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    2. In what ways do the authors contend that media violence can harm even young children?…

    • 3176 Words
    • 13 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Violent crimes and aggression can be motivated by violent video games. Columbine school shooters(Eric Harris and Dylan Klebold) and theater shooter(James Holmes) all played these games. They would play these games for long hours daily. Studies show violence is motivated by the games that kids are playing. They act out these violent and illegal actions on their games and then do them in real life. Most of the teens in todays generation can honestly say they have played a violent video game at least one time in their lives. Therefore, they have had to act out a violent action. There are many ways this can affect a child's behavior in a negative way.…

    • 888 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In my opinion media shouldn't be held responsible for corrupting the society because there are many other factors which contribute to the corruption of younger kids in a society. Television, Music and video games are held responsible all the time when something goes wrong in a society regarding the kids. Factors like personal issues and lack of understanding and also the miscommunications between kids and the adults are other reasons which add up to the reasons for the "desensitization" of younger audiences. Regardless, media does have a negative impact on the society, especially the children`s, due to the popularity of media that is presented and promoted in our everyday life's. It allows younger viewers to believe that the media is more genuine than actual reality, therefore creating aggressiveness and attitude changes in youngsters, creating major impacts on the future of the society.…

    • 973 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Jones uses his personal experiences and researches to support his thesis that violent media is not entirely bad for the children. Jones was a lonely boy and his parents did not let him connect with the violent media. He lived like a nice boy until that day when “Incredible Hulk smashed through it” (para. 2). He got a chance to play with violent video games because his mother’s students convinced her to violent media has a positive side too. That one change helped him to be “unafraid of his desires and the world’s disapproval.” Now he can handle any difficult situation, and now he would be able to fight against the modern society. Another example that Jones gives to prove his point is his son experience. Jones mentions, “In the first grade, his friends started climbing a tree at school. But he was afraid: of falling, of the centipedes crawling on the trunk, of sharp branches, of his friend’s derision” (para. 6). Jones gives his…

    • 618 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Violent Media

    • 801 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Jones begins by describing his own childhood and the loneliness felt by being consumed with internal fears of adolescent boyhood and acceptance. His parents who didn’t trust the violent world separated him from “the crudest elements of American pop culture” until the Hulk arose through Marvel Comics (195). To his world, the Hulk represented everything he was feeling. The Hulk’s rage carried Jones into this fantasy world where he was unafraid of “the world’s disapproval,” and became “unhesitating and effective in action” (195). This enhanced creativity ultimately resulted in his ideas transferring into paper and as an adult saw his own creations turned into games and cartoons. Jones promotes this upon his own son who he sees shying away from perceived stereotypes and enhances his own creativity to surpass the most basic fears such as tree climbing. The problem with his initiating argument is that Jones is comparing violent media to an angered superhero. The Hulk and all other Marvel Comic books do display forms of violence; however, they also function as moral lessons for…

    • 801 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Confliction

    • 572 Words
    • 3 Pages

    In “Violent Media is Good for Kids,” Gerard Jones states and tries to prove that violent media is indeed good for children. He attempts this by saying that he believes, he grew up too passive because he was sheltered from the media. Hearing that the media has "lofty messages of pacifism and tolerance,” his mother borrowed some comics for him to read so he could learn about independence. After reading the comics he said that he followed Hulk for a while then switched to "more sophisticated heroes, “and "finally found my own lead along a twisting path to a career and an identity." Later on, his son was afraid to climb a tree, so Jones read the stories of Tarzan to his son. About a week or two later, his son was climbing trees. He also gives other examples of children who used violent media to overcome their stressful and hurtful lives. "When we try to protect our children from their own feelings and fantasies, we shelter them not against violence but against power and selfhood." Jones is right to say this; violent media can help kids if it is used in the right way rather than being abused. In recent years there's been dispute about whether or not children should view, or listen to violent media. In "Violent Media is Good for Kids" Gerard Jones says that we should. "When we try to protect our children from their own feelings and fantasies, we shelter them not against violence but against power and selfhood." Jones is right to say this; violent media can help kids if it is used in the right way rather than being abused. He doesn't include statistics to back-up his arguments and that is a downfall of Jones's essay. He does however include examples as to why he believes that violent media is good for children. His examples my not be credible, but when you think about it he has a good point: violent media is good for kids if used the right way. So instead of trying to keep the kids away from the media we should…

    • 572 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays

Related Topics