Preview

Were the Colonists Justified in Declaring Their Independence?

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
796 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Were the Colonists Justified in Declaring Their Independence?
Colonists sought independence from British government for a multitude of reasons. Tension quickly rose between England and the thirteen colonies due to the unjust taxing without fair representation in Parliament, the colonist’s rights to assemble were taken away by the British, and there were many unreasonable Acts and laws put into place in attempt to have complete control over the colonists as well as intimidate them. For these reasons and the suffering that the colonists endured at the hands of the British government, I feel that the colonists had plenty just causes to separate themselves from England.

Of the many objections pitted against King George III, the one that most angered the colonist and is by far the strongest grievance written in the Declaration of Independence was taxation without representation. The people living in the thirteen colonies did not have direct representatives in the British parliament. Because of that, the colonists had no way to vote for how they would be taxed or who would represent them. Due to this lack of representation, the British government was free to tax the colonists in any way and for any amount that they wanted. With no way to fight taxation and no way to claim their rights, many colonists feared that their property could be taken away through unbearable tax wages. The Stamp Act and Townshend Act were put into place to regulate the trade of the colonists as well as collect taxes from them. Britain was abusing the colonist’s rights as Englishmen through doing this because laws in England stated that “somebody may not be taxed if he or she does not have a voice in government.” The anger and fear that came from the free reign that Britain had over the colonists smoldered until eventually war broke out.

The years leading up the Revolution saw the British government introduce a number of taxation laws. But there were many other events that led up to colonists’ declaration of independence from British control. The

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    The colonies declared independence from Great Britain due to an underlying tyrannical theme. The colonists were upset about many things, but taxation without representation was the biggest. King George III taking over also worried the colonists. Colonists had a proclamation line that stopped them from expanding west which was not a major reason for leaving Great Britain but still helped the cause of the colonists. The proclamation line was a reason for the colonists to declare independence by proving the tyranny narrative.…

    • 440 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The first of the main reasons that the colonists want to separate from the English rule would be the acts that Britain put on the colonists to pay off the war debt from the French and Indian War. The first one of those acts was the Sugar Act. This act was passed by the British Parliament to put restrictions on colonists’ trade. The act increased the duties on items such as sugar,…

    • 362 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    1. Looking back on the early history of the United States, one can easily identify the key concepts and reasons that the original colonies had declared independence, and ultimately devised a new form of government. To be able to examine the causes for separation from the nation’s European background, one must first look at to the beginning of the new word. Looking back at the first successful colonies founded in the new world, Jamestown in particular, one can see that most of the new colonists who inhabited Jamestown were extreme separatists.…

    • 1057 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Thomas Whately, advisor to George Grenville, the British chancellor of the Exchequer, was correct by saying in Document 1, "We are not yet recovered from a war solely fought for their protection." Whately was referring to the French and Indian War (1754-1763). This war indeed cost Britain much, and I do believe the colonists were greatful. However, Britain, after 1763, did not allow the colonists to move west. The colonies were increasing by becoming crowded. New taxes angered them as well. Not being represented in Parliament was tyranny. "Taxation without Representation" was the battle cry. The Stamp Act of 1765 started it all. Every paper, from playing cards to legal documents were taxed. Document 2 refers to this tax as well as the Townsend Act which required the colonists to pay a tax on all British goods. According to Document 2, this taxes purpose was for simply "Levying money upon us". Still, this tax like the Stamp Act, was levied without representation in Parliament. Colonists boycotted British goods in favor of their own manufactured goods. The 13 colonies were gradually becoming aware of self-government. Men like Patrick Henry and John Dickinson considered these taxes unconstitutional. They voiced their opinions openly.…

    • 707 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Many; colonies remain faithful to Britain but, I am against the Britain. Colonist' are faithful to Britain because they do not have enough weapons and don't have an army to go against Britain. Although some of the colonist didn't want to be in war because they would risk their lives and they have family members. Colonist didn't have money to buy supplies, food, clothes so far British were a strong army. Although they are under British rule they have the right to vote but if they are against them they will have to confront with them. It is possible for the colonist to remain faithful but, we must declare independence and fight because of the Quartering Acts, Boston Massacre and taxes.…

    • 683 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    British Independence Dbq

    • 1131 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Both the Stamp Act and the Tea Act were laws that the colonists highly detested. The Stamp Act required that all legal documents contained a stamp that could only be purchased from an official tax collector. This angered the colonists because Britain was using it as a direct way to make money for themselves and the colonists didn’t get to decide how the tax should have been executed. This one act was seen as something that could open the doors to many more just like it. The classically heard phrase, “No taxation without representation”, was the biggest issue here. Even though the British did believe the colonists were being represented because the members of Parliament did think about all of their subjects when making laws, they were not. Parliament could not have been thinking about what was best for the colonists as they did not know. The Tea Act required that all tea be bought from the British East India Company in order to stop the company from going bankrupt. This meant that the colonists had no say in what they were drinking because they were forced to only buy from one company. It gave the British East India Company a monopoly on tea sales in the colonies. Once more this angered the colonists as they again had no say in this decision. A tiny island all the way across the ocean should not have been able to regulate the prices in the colonies. All of these requirements placed on the colonists made it impossible for them to look anything but weak to the rest of the world. The British gave them no leverage with any other global powers. These people in the colonies had been living on their own, far away for Britain for years and they deserved to be able to shape their own country and their own identities in any way they wanted because they were different than the British people.…

    • 1131 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    The Americans were not justified in declaring independence from Britain. In the Declaration of Independence the Americans laid out their reasons for the break from Britain, most of which were complaints that seemed baseless or selfish. The Americans complained about taxes, about quartering soldiers, about having to obey the laws of a government across an ocean from them, etc. Any reasonable human being would see these things as perfectly acceptable considering the circumstances though.…

    • 319 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Better Essays

    On July 4, 1776, thirteen colonies in the north received her independence from the Great Britain. The American Revolution began as early as 1763 but the thought of being an independent nation began in 1767. Before 1763, the colonist in America praised the British government as John Adams stated, “the [British government was the] most perfect combination of human power in society for the preservation of liberty.” After the seven years war, however, the British were bankrupt and the parliament decided to make interest from the American colonies. This led to many up raises known as the American Revolution. Such up rises include the stamp act, quartering act, declarative act etc. The major impact that influenced the Americans to change their views about Britain to become an independent nation was the Townshend act also known as the revenue act.…

    • 926 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Yes, our founding fathers were justified in declaring from Great Britain. The colonist had to pay many taxes to Great Britain, the taxes were also very unreasonable. Also, soldiers would just come to your house and you would have to let them stay no matter what. So if you had family members in your house you would have to make room for the soldiers to stay at your house. You would have to feed the soldiers and provide warm water for them. The Proclamation line of 1763 would tell people where they had to live and the people did not like this. This is why I think that the fathers were justified for declaring independence from Great Britain.…

    • 118 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    The colonist had power but not much. However, with what little they had, they used against the king. The stamp act and sugar act were placed which made the colonist angry. This placed all tax on printed material. The king wanted money from everyone. They felt as if they had no power or a voice to speak up for themselves.…

    • 339 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Britain’s territory in North America grew immensely. Although King George held Christian beliefs, in theory he was more drawn to controlling the colonies and exploiting them for profit. His loyalty was to his faith, but more to being in power. With continued battles over land and expansion, the British Parliament enacted new tax laws designed to force the colonists contribute to the costs of war and ongoing protection. These new laws included the Stamp Act and the Tax on Tea. The very though of taxation threatened the roots of what our early Founding Fathers believed in. It was as if our early Founding Fathers were David, attempting to overcome Goliath. The laws were met by boycotts,…

    • 933 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The colonists felt unfairly taxed, watched over, and ignored in their attempts to address grievances. Religious issues rose, and economics were the essence of many issues. The colonist didn’t pay near as much taxed as the people that lived-in Britain, colonists had no representation in the British Parliament. To tax them without offering representation was to deny their traditional rights as English subjects.…

    • 371 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Although there were many reasons that American Colonies began to resent Britain, the new ideas presented by the Enlightenment and the Acts that the British government continued to implement played their own parts individually and combined. When British Philosopher, John Locke, stated that all men have the right to “life, liberty and property”, he proposed that there was such a thing as an illegitimate government. Because an illegitimate government claims entitlement to take, not provide protection for and violate the civil rights of its subjects without an impartial representative protecting the overall good of the general population, it is in direct conflict with his new philosophies of freedom. Free thinkers in the Colonies began to recognize that their rights were slowly being taken away and the biased nature of the Acts being enforced. Nonetheless, there were still many Colonists that sustained loyalty to England and were not influenced by the mere presentation of new libertarian views. However, when Acts began to not only impact the lives of the impoverished but began to spread to the loyalist elites, this seemed to achieve what free thinking could not. As each new Act was developed and implemented the spectrum of social classes affected began to change. For example; the Proclamation Act limited the distance of what land could be settled in relation to the location of the original Colonies which upset western farmers, whereas the Stamp Act requiring stamps to be bought and placed on most written materials from legal documents to playing cards directly affected all groups of people. With the Enlightenment having already provided the basic arguments on undermining british rule, the British government inadvertently supplied further justification with each Act showing a new kind of prejudice or evidence of Englands apparent greed that it inspired Colonists to not just ask for independence, but to demand it. According to Locke, if a government violated any of the…

    • 353 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Were the colonists morally justified in declaring independence? British government actions were unfair to the colonists, and the colonists had the right to rebel against British rule resulting in the American Revolution for the fight for independence. Reasons colonists justified for independence was taxation policies were unfair, no representation in the Parliament, and many passed acts and laws. The unfair policies, acts, and laws were immoral and corrupt to the colonist’s rights that lead to an unjust government. However, rebellions and many men who stood up, became leaders who are known as the founding fathers, they used the unfair treatment from Britain as a foundation for the Declaration of Independence that would protect the people and be governed properly.…

    • 541 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The colonists were frustrated by the the tyranny that surrounded them on a daily basis, for the king choose a monarchy in a democratic society. The ego and arrogance from the king was visible to the people which ultimately led to them to start an uprising. Because the king was so power and money hungry, he soon stripped away the rights of the people/colonists. The colonists were very upset with the king’s abuse of the Royal Crown for many of the regions were growing resentment towards the King and Parliament because there was the issue of “taxation without representation”. This means that the many taxes were being put in place without any proper representation from the states to voice their opinions on whether they agreed with it or not, and of course it was also the matter where they did not approve of the amount taxes anyway which increased the need for representation.…

    • 1692 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Good Essays