Preview

What Is The Difference Between The Book Thief And The Help

Satisfactory Essays
Open Document
Open Document
691 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
What Is The Difference Between The Book Thief And The Help
Stories give us in the modern day a glance of how things were in a time long ago. They tell of good and bad, have no filter, and are the closest we'll get to time travel. In days when everything is in constant change, it’s nice to have something that will stay the same. We get a glimpse into the past from the stories The Book Thief and The Help. Though they are different stories, they all teach us about the life and struggles of someone from their respective times. When we take the time to look at specific characters, we see some similarities and differences. Some of these are subtle and some are very broad. For example we see Liesel, a young girl living in Nazi Germany, hiding the secret of the Jew in the basement along with other things like her real mother's identity. This can be compared to Miss …show more content…
If we look at The Help, we see an intolerant, racist town. Through all the struggle of the help, they begin to turn the town around. We learn that it’s better just to treat people equally because we wouldn’t want to be treated how they are treated. Also, if we look at The Book Thief we can see Liesel hiding her friend because it’s the right thing to do. She doesn’t care about the consequences because she sees this as a noble cause worth fighting for.
If we look overall at both of these tales, they are both tough journeys. If I had to give an opinion on who’s was more difficult I would hands down say it was Liesel. Her mother had to leave her and didn’t tell her why. Her brother died on the train, so she now has no one from a time before Himmel Street. She lives in a war ridden country and is in constant fear of bombings and loss of everything she ever knew. She did lose everything, her friends, family, and home. Was constantly wondering what would happen if they found the Jew in the basement. It could not have been

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    However, the Hubermanns are too poor to pay for something extra like a book for Liesel, so Liesel getting a Christmas present was completely out of the question. Even though Papa wanted to get Liesel a book, “the Hubermanns were essentially broke, still paying off debts and paying rents quicker than money could come in” (88). After Liesel, Rosa, and Hans got back from church on Christmas Liesel sees something wrapped under the tree in newspaper addressed to her, even though it is from Saint Nicholas she knows her Papa got it for her. When Liesel got the gift it completely surprised, that she even got a gift, at that a book, when her family couldn’t even afford it, without going further into debt. Also the way Hans got the books surprised me, making cigarettes and trading them to a…

    • 610 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Liesel Part 2 Summary

    • 568 Words
    • 3 Pages

    The beginning of part 3 begins when Liesel’s papa, Hans, sees that she stole a book out of the celebratory fire. He promises not to tell Rosa, her mama. You also find out that the mayor’s wife was the mystery identity who saw her steal the book. Later, when she goes to the mayor’s house to pick up the washing, she fears Frau Hermann will scold her, but instead, the Frau invites her into her library room. That puts Liesel in awe and also makes her very happy. Everytime she goes to the Hermann house for the washing, she also reads a few books at a time, a few paragraphs each. Liesel’s understanding of the literary world is expanded. It is in the library Liesel finds out that Frau Hermann’s son had died and that is why she is so reserved. At the…

    • 568 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In discussion question 3, we analyze the reasons behind Liesel’s book thievery and how they were important to her- emotionally wise and as well as in her outside relationships.…

    • 688 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The first book Liesel steals, The Grave Digger, symbolizes her grievance. “There was something black and rectangular lodged in the snow. Only the girl saw it. She bent down and picked it up and held it firmly in her fingers.” Liesel steals her first book book from the snow in the graveyard in which her recently deceased little brother has just been buried, after dying on the train they were taking to their foster parents. This book is the only memento she has left with her on her now lonely journey.…

    • 548 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Stealing her first book opened Liesel up to a world filled with words and grammar. As she stared at The Grave Digger’s Handbook, “touching the print inside, she had no idea what it was saying.”(38). Because Liesel could not read or write, as a nine-year-old, she was forced to attend school with children who just started learning the alphabet. There was a stolen book hidden under Liesel’s bed and she didn’t know what any of the words said. That inspired her to have “sudden desire to read it that she didn’t even attempt to understand” (66). However, it was also ironic that she asked her foster father to teach her these skills, when he could not comprehend them himself. It all became beneficial for Liesel because his lack of ability “would cause less frustration in coping with the girl’s lack of ability” (65). Because Hans could not read acutely, he understood what she was going through, and he was patient. In a few years, she was able to pick up a book and read…

    • 438 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    This passage makes me feel sad because of the sudden death of Liesel. As a result, this prompts me into realizing that one of theme of this book is about how life is unpredictable. An example of this is when Liesel dies without warning. I can relate to this theme because a friend of mine from elementary has committed suicide and none of her friends knew until her parents posted a post on Facebook declaring that she has died. Therefore, I've learned that cherishing the people around me is important as they might die without warning, like…

    • 98 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Children these days worry about many things, from having the newest style of clothing, to fitting in with friends. Liesel Meminger from The Book Thief by Markus Zusak had many more serious things to worry about. Being a foster girl from Munich in Nazi Germany during World War II also treats Leisel horribly, for she runs into many problems. Not only is World War II terrifying for Liesel, but it is also terrifying to many people in her life. This book is considered a classic because Liesel’s life as a righteous Gentile is relatable, captivating, and universally accepted.…

    • 669 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Essay On The Book Thief

    • 1162 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Her brother died halfway the trip and had to be buried somewhere nearby the railroad; that’s when Liesel stole the first book about how to dig a proper grave and when death and Liesel took a first glimpse of each other. After all the commotion, Liesel and her mother got to the designated train station and greeted her mother goodbye to never see again and head towards her new Mama and Papa on a new street; Himmel (Heaven) Street. There she meets her new best friend Rudy, a lemon haired boy that loved Liesel within at first sight; a new home and family for her, new surroundings with new people to like or dislike.…

    • 1162 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    To begin, in the novel the character Liesel helps to develop a theme of courage Firstly, Liesel purposely tripped a man riding his bike so she could steal food he was going to give to fat priests This is displayed in the following quotation, "Of course I do, but I'm not hungry…

    • 359 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    No one believed she was smart enough to read, and instead of being placed in her age appropriate classes, she was out with the kids at her reading level. For her it was humiliating, but it only gave her the fuel she needed to keep moving forward. Desperate for help, she confronted her uneducated step father Hans for help. Hans himself cannot read that well, but she knows any help is better than none. Hans, referred to as Papa by Liesel, began to teach Liesel basic reading skills every night. They had a tradition, “unofficially…called the midnight class, even though it commenced around two in the morning”. Now Liesel knew how to read. She had an unlimited amount of knowledge available to her through literature. But, she herself could not take down Hitler. That does not mean that she could not fight back though. When the Nazi’s bombed her street, most people stood in the bomb shelter terrified. Yet, Liesel instead took out a book and began to read. Everyone soon began to congregate around her and listen. The fear of what was going on around them subsided, and at the moment they had won. Though Hitler was still attack them, he no longer had control over them, they were not scared. It was at this moment that Liesel realized the true power of literature, and the book she held between her fingers transformed into the sword she would use to fight her way out of Nazi Germany.…

    • 554 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Plot * Liesel, her mother and her brother Werner are all travelling on a train, to greet Werner’s and Liesels foster parents. * Liesel, illiterate has a dream o Adolf Hitler and speaks to him in broken German. * As she is half awake, Liesels brother dies, and there were two Nazi soldiers who argue on weather they leave the body there or take it with them. * Both Liesel and her mother are traumatized by his sudden death and 2 days later he is buried. * After the ceremony finishes Liesel digs at his grave but is dragged away by her mother, but before getting on another train Liesel steals a book she is unable to even read the title of. * She is taken to a place in Munich called Himmel -"Heaven" to meet Rosa and Hans Hubermann, her foster parents. * She refuses to meet or get out of the car with her suitcase that only contains her clothes and the book she stole from her brother’s gravesite. * The only person that manages to get her out of the care is her foster father. * Liesel feels abandoned by her mother, but understands that it’s better for her to live there and be protected from the poverty; she also learns that her father was a communist, but she doesn’t yet know the meaning of that word. * Liesels foster mother acts harshly upon her and calls her a "pig girl" when she refuses to bathe, but claims to loves her. * Her foster father, Hans develops a closer relationship with her and teaches her how to roll cigarettes. she starts calling them "mama" and "papa" * Liesel got terrible nightmares about her brother the first few months and was accompanied by Hans, who she kept the book hidden from. * She kept the book as a symbol reminding her the last time she saw her brother, and the last time she saw her mother. * Liesel is put in school but has to stay with a much younger grade, just learning the alphabet. When she turns ten she joins the Hitler Youth. * Liesel makes a friend names Rudy who…

    • 1453 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    The single greatest loss Liesel experiences is the death of her little brother. After she watches him die she has to watch him get buried and the brutality of the situation is more than her young mind can understand "Still in disbelief, she started to dig. He couldn't be dead. He couldn't be dead. He couldn't." pg.23 She takes her first book, even though she cannot read, as a memento of her brother, a reminder of the brutality she has just witnessed. However as her foster father teaches her to read and she…

    • 668 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Therefore, Liesel evolves from a lonely character that had nobody to a character who creates many incredible bonds with her new family and friends. Even though Liesel has a hard time trusting and allowing herself to vulnerable, she easily starts an incredible and amazing bond with her foster father, Hans Hubermann. When Liesel was getting to know him, “Liesel observed the strangeness of her foster father’s eyes. They were made of kindness, and sliver... Upon seeing those eyes, understood that Hans Hubermann was worth a lot” (Zusak 34). No one has ever played her music, and no one has ever taught her how to read till Hans came along. No one has ever cared for her like Hans has. This is why Liesel loves Hans the most out of everybody. Liesel also starts an amazing and a heartwarming relationship with Max Vandenburg, who is a Jew surviving in Hubermann’s basement. “You could say argue that Liesel Meminger had it easy. She did have it easy compared to max Vanderburg... anything was better than being a Jew.” (Zusak 161). Liesel was a lost girl who had nobody till her new family found her. Max has also lost his family but he is also by the Nazis. Liesel and Max are both broken people living in a broken world. They both have lost many important things in their lives, this is what makes them bond really easily. Liesel did not care that Max was Jewish; they still create…

    • 1233 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    In the Book Thief, Zusak shows through Liesel's relationships with books how she develops from a helpless and weak girl to a strong and mature young woman. Mostly it is not the books themselves that change Liesel but it is how she responds and relates to them. For instance, when she stole her first book, "The Grave Digger's Guide" at her brother's funeral she was feeling helpless and weak, by picking up the book, even though she couldn't read it, it gave her a sense of control to steal it. It also piqued her curiosity to find out what was in it by learning to read. Later in the novel when Liesel is learning to read and write she also begins to understand and relate to the people and the story in her books.…

    • 258 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Liesel has lost and suffered so much in life. She was raised without a father, and later given to a foster home. Being raised by a single mother, their family was very poor and didn’t get a lot of food. Sadly, on the train ride to the foster family the two kids would live in, Werner, her brother, passed away. Leisel could see “without question that her younger brother, Werner, was now sideways and dead. His blue eyes stared at the floor. Seeing nothing,” (20).…

    • 757 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays