Preview

What Is The Loss Of True Identity In Larry Watson's Montana 1948

Better Essays
Open Document
Open Document
1507 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
What Is The Loss Of True Identity In Larry Watson's Montana 1948
Imagine a situation where one's most valued person in their life turned against them. Think how they would honestly feel and how would they act? Larry Watson writes an incredible book, Montana 1948. The main character, David, who is twelve years old, lives in Bentrock, Montana and was born into a high up family who seems to be perfect in other's eyes. When a tragic happens in the family, many will get hurt and peoples' true identity become exposed. When people have a special connection with others, they can once in a while turn against each other when they least except it.

Wes, David's father, has had a hard life of making people happy and have a good relationship with his family and his loved ones, but people turned on him by making a simple decision. Wes went to explain to Gloria why
…show more content…
On Grandpa Julian's behalf, the citizens of Bentrock threw a party for Frank's returning from the war. Wes was not taken back by this event and almost expected the party. " 'Now I'd like to bring my son up here.' Uncle Frank had not hesitated either, he knew that Julian meant him." (37). Wes had always been in the back round while knowing Frank was a little questionable. The question which left a hole in Wes's life was finally solved, he did not hesitate to accept. Frank was molesting Indian women, and through out the book Grandpa Julian makes many inside remarks about knowing Frank's secret actions. The parents of Wes and Frank were blind when their favorite kid grow up into a cocky war hero, and the other kid was a mirror figure of Julian. Many would conclude a parent would be proud of their child if they turned out like them, but here, they are mistaken. Wes worked hard in his life for making his wife and child proud and keeping up the name in town. Working hard on specific material and make one blind of the people around them who would sadly turn against

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Better Essays

    “Barn Burning”, by William Faulkner shows how conflicting obligations to family loyalty can affect the decisions that are made and the responsibility that comes with making them. However, the story concentrates on how a 10 year old boy is faced with the dilemma of choosing to be loyal to his father and family or do what he feels is morally right and just by being able to be free as his own person and leaves his sorrow, grief and family behind.…

    • 1370 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Murder Home Case Study

    • 252 Words
    • 2 Pages

    Wes’ school performance wasn’t perfect. He didn’t pay much attention in class because he was bored. I believe it was because Wes knew what was being taught so much so that it didn’t…

    • 252 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Two Wes's Two Faits

    • 647 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Both Weses are challenged with adapting to their new neighborhoods. After moving to the Bronx, Joy, the author Wes’s mother, sought that he wouldn’t go to a public school. All the schools she had gone to as a child were still there, but not the same institutions. “Crumbling walls, faded paint and if you were one of the lucky 50 percent who made it out in four years” (47). It was definitely not clear that you’d be prepared for a college or a job. The other Wes had previously lived in three other places. Now, he is trying to adapt to a fourth location. His new location was only 10 miles away from his old neighborhood. However, thick old trees that lined the streets were evidence of how far he really was from the Baltimore city row houses. The other Wes now lives in Baltimore County.…

    • 647 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Consequence have been already passed on through Gail to Wes then to Julian, this has effected each and everyone one of them. Gail started off by find out what Wes's brother "Frank" does to Indian patients through Maire Little Solider. This made Gail somewhat concerned and devastated, this ended knowing what's best by telling Wes about the concern. Now that has been stated, Wes is under a lot of pressure, has to make a decision whether or not if he should lock up his brother "Frank" in the public Jail Cell but doesn’t want to cause, Wes doesn’t want to look "Jealous" about Franks ambitions to the public town of Bentrock, just as his father Julian assumed, or he could arrest him in the down stairs basement, where no one can find him or notice.…

    • 250 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    The Other Moore Analysis

    • 1072 Words
    • 5 Pages

    The Other Wes Moore is a story about two boys who ironically both happen to share the same name, “Wes Moore”, and grew up in the same area. While the two boys shared the same name, they never managed to meet as children, despite living blocks apart and being born within a year of each other. In fact, the two Wes Moores would never officially meet until they were both well into their adulthood. The story follows the two boys on their separate journeys into adulthood in an effort to determine what factors might have caused each Wes Moore to end up in the situations that they ended up in later in life; one a criminal and convicted murderer, and the other one a successful businessman, veteran, Rhodes Scholar, and White House Fellow. Wes…

    • 1072 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Wes’s future could have always changed, but the fact that his brother was a drug dealer who became a father as a teen, his mom did drugs and partied while she had responsibilities ,and his father was a deadbeat and was never in his life. His surroundings were never something to look up to. Wes skipped school; therefore he never really had a proper education. Wes went to jail and ended…

    • 398 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    The author writes about how both Wes’s lives could have been interchangeable. That his life could have led him to being behind bars, and the others Wes’s life could have been free and happy. I believe that they could have been interchanged. A major difference in their lives were there mentors. The type of mentors each of them had were very different. The author had mentors like his mother, grandparents, and aunt that pushed him to make decisions that would make his life even better than their own. The author looked up to his family seeing how strong they were in all of their life troubles. The other Wes had his mother and one friend that pushed him towards the right path but he didn’t look up to them. He looked up to his older brother who was already in all the trouble with gangs and drugs. This Wes wanted to be just like his brother, even though his brother tried to encourage Wes at a young age to not do what he does but do what he says. In the book, both Wes’s are sent away to try to create a better future for themselves. The author, who was sent to a military school, he at first wanted nothing to do with the school and continuously tried to run away. After getting brought into the office the last time and talking to his mother, Wes got the attention he needed while he was still young and he had men at the school to show him that his life is not set in stone. They proved to him that he does have control of his future. They showed him how to stay focused on what really matters in life. The author kept this military life style throughout his life which kept him around people who cared and kept him on the right path. The now incarcerated Wes, went to Job Corps. I believe this was one of the best choices that Wes made in his life. He went there to better himself and his family. He got his GED and became a carpenter. The only problem he had with this was when he came home he was making honest money but not “fast…

    • 576 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Wes Moore

    • 517 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Although Wes and the other Wes Moore both grew up in the same city at the same time, the two men have many differences, such as their mother`s involvement, their fathers and the level of accomplishment. First, Wes (the author) had compassionate and an educated mother. His mother attended university of Washington D.C and she graduated from there. She took care of him as well as sending him to private school to get good education. Second, Wes (The author) lived with his father. His father was educated and had a job. One day Wes punched his sister Nikki after she bite him because he jabbed at her face. Then his father come to him and spoke about punching his sister. Wes`s father said him “it`s totally wrong to hit women, especially if she is your sister. Finally, Wes was succeeded and achieved his goals. He attended school through his childhood. He graduate from Valley Forge Military School College, as well as university of Hopkins and he completed his master degree. On the other hand, the other Wes Moore a had careless mother. His mother used to work every single day and she didn't know anything about his situation. Even though his mother went University of Hopkins and wanted to continue her education, she didn`t get the opportunity to continue it. Not only he had a careless mother, but he also had an alcoholic father. His father was a drug dealer. Due to this, Wes’s mother kicked his father out of the house, because she didn`t want her son to be drug dealer. Finally, the other Wes Moore wasn`t successful. He became drug seller as well as a murder. Due to this, he was sent to jail for life. Clearly, the type of parents that they had makes big differences.…

    • 517 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Playing Beatie Bow

    • 783 Words
    • 4 Pages

    In the novel Playing Beatie Bow by Ruth Park, the protagonist Abigail learns about the importance of the family. She is a headstrong fourteen-year old girl who has had troubles in her own family, but when she is transported to the Rocks, 1873, and meets the Bow family, she realizes her selfish ways. From her experiences with them Abigail learns that in any situation every family member, including herself, must demonstrate the key elements of keeping a family together. These include love, forgiveness, support and understanding. Ruth Park uses many techniques that illustrate the main theme of the novel – how Abigail learns about the importance of the family.…

    • 783 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The choices made by Wes 2 impacted his life. Even though Wes didn’t have the best life he tried to make the best of it. He knew who is main supporters were and took their thoughts into consideration. Wes didn’t want to stay in the military school his mom sent him to, but with time he found out that it is what’s best for him and stuck it out. Due that choices Wes got many other great opportunities. He got to attend different schools and study about and graduate with a master’s…

    • 777 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Wes Moore

    • 574 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Wes mother Joy brought the story to her son’s attention. Wes came to realize that the young man had been raised in a neighborhood, not far from where he’d lived with his family, before moving to the Bronx. Just blocks, seemed to separated the two of them at one time. But, there was more to this article, not just the familiarity of the neighborhood, but the name, of “one” of “four” young men, mentioned in the article. The name that stood out, was his own, Wes Moore.…

    • 574 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    The Other Wes Moore essay

    • 1321 Words
    • 4 Pages

    While the environments that both boys grew up in were similar, there are key differences that influenced each Wes Moore into making different decisions later in their lives. The book begins with a discussion of their fathers; the author Wes Moore, although for a short time in his life, had a loving father who was involved and active. The other Wes Moore, however, had an alcoholic father who was absent his entire life, not bothering to get involved with his son. The second Wes Moore, unlike the author of this novel, never had a father figure and the only male role model he had was his elder brother who eventually dropped out of school to sell drugs. Both boys were also raised by their mothers but were raised in entirely different matters. Joy was a hardworking, strong and independent woman who had an education and grew up in a disciplined and structured environment. Joy was determined to provide the same for her three children, going as far as moving in with her parents and working multiple jobs to allow her children to go to private school instead of the failing public schools of the Bronx. Joy and Wes’ grandparents were strict and provided a stable household with high expectations and respect for rules and severe punishments for breaking those rules. For example, when Wes started to fail in school and did not improve his grades or his behavior his mother sent him to military school. Joy was a strict disciplinarian. Mary, the mother of the other Wes Moore, was not a strict disciplinarian and did not grow up in a stable environment. Mary’s mother died when she…

    • 1321 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    David is an immature person. After his father moved away, he was so angry that he refused to talk to his dad and even burnt all the letters from his father. He thinks that he is as same as his neighbour's dog, Monty, a victim of neglect. He even stopped working and got low marks at…

    • 537 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Character in Montana 1948

    • 614 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Secondly, Wesley Hayden grows the most as a person throughout the novel. At first he is portrayed as an average man, who isn’t very interesting or adventurous as seen through the eyes of his son, David. When Frank is found to be a rapist, Wes then transforms into a deep and critical thinker, who investigates the situation and does the right thing in the end as he knows that he must be fair and unbiased towards the crimes that Frank had committed. Through the situation around him, Wesley Hayden becomes almost a different man because he grows as a person and sees that he must step up and take action otherwise nothing will be…

    • 614 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    What did David tell his father that he saw? Why does Wes ask David so many questions about it?…

    • 1156 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays