Preview

When Mr Pirzada Came to Dine Essay

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
911 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
When Mr Pirzada Came to Dine Essay
When Mr Pirzada Came to Dine – Essay
Lilia’s parents are from India, which seem to have come to America to ensure that she receives a good education and life. Even though the characters are in America, they all seem to be affected by the events occurring in their homeland. Lilia’s mum seems genuinely proud over the fact that Lilia was born in America. However, the book gives the impression that her parent’s still misses their home. To ease their homesickness they phone and invite compatriots for dinner, which brings Mr Pirzada and Lilia’s family together.

Mr Pirzada has left his home, his wife, and his seven children in Dacca, Pakistan. He misses them terribly and is very concerned, because he has not been able to contact them for months. He watches the news over dinner each night at Lilia’s house looking for news of his family. Mr Pirzada is very generous with Lilia and brings her a piece of candy each time he comes by, but he only spoils her because she is capable of it. Mr Pirzada is curious about American culture, so Lilia tries to teach him about her culture. Lilia brings a childlike innocence to her relationship with Mr Pirzada, who she thinks is no different from her parents despite being Pakistani.

The only American-born character is Lilia, the narrator of the story. She is a first generation American from India. Through the visits of Mr Pirzada, she learns more about her Indian culture and the history between India and Pakistan. When Mr Pirzada returns to Pakistan, Lilia learns how it is to miss someone who lives across the world.

Lilia’s father is concerned if Lilia is becoming Americanized; She is unfamiliar with the current events in India. He is also concerned about her American education and he seems very frustrated about her unawareness.

There are many themes in the book. The immigrant experience is a major theme in the book. Lilia’s parents looks forward to the opportunities the new country can afford their child. America affords them a

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Powerful Essays

    Her father was one of the many adversaries of the dictator of the Dominican Republic who tried to overthrow him. The encyclopedia said, “The dictator of the Dominican Republic, Rafael Leonidas Trujillo Molina, could not victimize a family with such strong American ties. However, when Alvarez's father secretly joined the forces attempting to oust Trujillo, the police set up surveillance of his home.” (Encyclopedia of World Biography) This shows up in her story In the Time of the Butterflies where the women's husbands and sons were joining a revolution to get rid of the dictator. Because of her father’s involvement in the revolution, Alvarez and her family had to flee to America. One source said, “Describing the scene as their plane landed in the United States in American Scholar, Alvarez wrote, ‘All my childhood I had dressed like an American, eaten American foods, and befriended American children. I had gone to an American school and spent most of the day speaking and reading English. At night, my prayers were full of blond hair and blue eyes and snow.... All my childhood I had longed for this moment of arrival. And here I was, an American girl, coming home at last.’" (Encyclopedia of World Biography) Like Alvarez, characters had to flee from Trujillo’s rule to avoid persecution. However, even though she was born in America, the move back was arduous for Alvarez…

    • 1403 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Better Essays

    Political turmoil force Rufino, Lourdes, and Pilar to migrate to the United States in 1961, leaving Lourdes parents behind in Cuba. Pilar's search for herself, as she tries to come to terms with her position in regards to the Cuban Revolution, this will be the main reason of content with her mother. Pilar takes offense to her mother's patriotism. Pilar struggles with her own identity, which is why she can't accept her mother's love for America. Toward the end of the novel she embraces all that America has to offer by letting Ivanito go to America. In the beginning of the story, Pilar rejects her mother's patriotism. Pilar believes that her mother is "convinced she can fight communism from behind her bakery counter"(136), mocking her mother. Lourdes and Pilar are on opposite…

    • 947 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    The film portrays Mariana, the female protagonist’s quick fall into poverty with her two young children. Over the course of a summer, Mariana loses her apartment and is homeless and desperate to take care of her children. Her husband’s friends effectively avoid her and leave her isolated with no knowledge of English or means to support herself. Mariana’s story is about the lack of support single immigrant women receive in terms of housing, health, childcare, and employment services. The film also shows the undue burden that Mariana’s children pose to her. Childcare almost always falls on the backs of women, especially immigrant women. Her children are precious to her, but she has a harder time finding employment because she cannot leave her young children alone. This time in their lives is a transformative moment for the…

    • 1352 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Elisa Gomez Cristinio

    • 393 Words
    • 2 Pages

    To begin with, Elisa came to the United States of America on the 20th of January, 2001. Back at home, Elisa’s family lived in poverty. Some of her relatives had already come to America, so it became easier for her to migrate. Although she had faded memories of how she traveled to the U.S, she was able to tell her story. Flor Calixto Dolores,…

    • 393 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The text emphasizes the hardships that immigrants often have to endure when going into a new country in the search of a better life or the American dream as many call it. The text potentially symbolizes America’s people as well as its culture because America has and is still today very diverse due to the wide variety of races, religions, and cultures that immigrants introduce when they come here. America can be seen as a melting pot because the different nationalities, cultures, and ethnicities of immigrants eventually “melt” together to create a common culture although several immigrants choose to retain their culture no matter what. The majority if not all immigrants leave behind everything they know and love to try and get a better life in a new country where there are more opportunities. America has always been a popular choice for immigrants as it has a plentiful of resources to offer such as employment, freedom of religion, and better education programs. Immigrants often choose to leave their home country because they have a family to sustain and their home country is simply not adequate for their necessities. In My Ántonia Willa Cather really focuses on the struggles that immigrants face upon arriving to their new country. People often think it is easy for immigrants to simply leave and go into other countries but Willa proves that it is quite the opposite. Immigrants do not immediately get a better life upon arriving to a new country which is depressing but it is the truth. Immigrants still have to face new problems that come with the change of countries. The problems that immigrants face in the new countries can sometimes be worse than the problems they faced at home which can be really discouraging. Willa Cather portrays the hardships that many immigrants struggle through the story of the Shimerdas, “tony was barefooted, and she shivered in her cotton dress and was…

    • 1088 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Laura, a Mexican immigrant and student in Rose’s remedial English class, has a completely different frame of reference than California born UCLA students she finds herself in class with. She remembers in detail how her father made a meager living as a “food vendor” in Tijuana. The types of food, the smells and the other items he sold are cannot be forgotten by Laura. She emigrated, with her parents, to the United States at the age of six (Rose 1). These memories keep her connected to Mexico.…

    • 1076 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Film Essay on Entre Nos

    • 328 Words
    • 2 Pages

    What was the hardest for Marianna and her kids was money and when money is a struggle so is shelter and food. With Marianna not being familiar with how getting a job works in America she ends up trying to sell her empanadas. It was hard for her to sell them because she could not speak English and not knowing that selling food on the streets is kind of iffy here in America.…

    • 328 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Tita de la Garza, a daughter of Mama Elena, was selected by her mother to follow the family’s tradition—one member of the family must not marry but grow up taking care of the parents. By the time she was born, she was already deprived of this freedom, to live a life filled with comfort and a life to share with the man she loves. Such deprivation of freedom has caused her to make use of magical realism.…

    • 621 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The Great Gatsby

    • 938 Words
    • 1 Page

    The main theme of this book, in which all other themes support, is the American Dream…

    • 938 Words
    • 1 Page
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The common use of the food motif and repetitive contrasts between the cultures of India and America throughout The Namesake create cultural jarring, which demonstrate cultural transitions. The novel opens with Ashima, a newly arrived Indian immigrant in America, making an Indian snack as best she can using American-branded ingredients. Ashima focalizes, “as usual there’s something missing”, reinforcing the challenge of her own transition to adopting a new culture alternatives. Whilst the iconical American brands of “Rice Krispies and Planter’s Peanuts” are familiar to western readers, for Ashima it emphasizes her difference, establishing a cultural jarring within her experience of immigration. Another instance where the food motif is evident is at Gogol’s ‘Rice Ceremony’. The traditional Bengali ritual, lays a pen, a handful of earth and some money in front of the baby to determine their future career. The objects are layed in front of Gogol and he turns away. An ‘uncle’ then proclaims that, “most children will grab at one of them…but Gogol touches nothing’. The inability of the baby Gogol to choose anything forshadows uncertainty plaguing him throughout his life. This contrast between Gogol and ‘most children’ makes him become different, which emphasis Gogol’s struggle to belong in both American and Indian civilization.…

    • 834 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Leila Ahmed Religion

    • 583 Words
    • 3 Pages

    From a nine year old Leila Ahmed’s perspective, she had been molested by an older boy, not intentionally broken laws of society, as her mother’s reaction accused. Ahmed notes this as one of the defining moment that separated her from her mother, and much of society in whole. This separation and enmity resulting from her mother caused Leila to channel her opposition at the entire culture she was a part of. This period also resulted in Ahmed’s immersion into literature, further rounding and shaping her world view and identity. Western culture became a prominent influence in her life, so much that she desired nothing other than to go to school in England. Once again, her mother took this dream away from her, only after a long vacation to…

    • 583 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Pirzada Came to Dine” contains many examples which support the theme of acceptance. The short story states, “ Hindus and Muslims had set fire to each other’s homes. For many, the idea of eating in the other’s company was still unthinkable. It made no sense to me… into successive cups of tea.” Lilia says this when her father informs her about the conflicts occurring in Dacca. Lilia is confused on why the 2 religions fought over there when Mr. Pirzada and her family got along just fine. Lilia asks these questions since she and her family accept Mr. Pirzada in their house, however the 2 religious groups in the Eastern Hemisphere aren’t able to do the same. Additionally, the text states, “Yes, let’s carve it...tabletop with newspaper” during the time Mr. Pirzada is carving the pumpkin for Lilia. This event shows how Mr. Pirzada and Lilia become even closer, as if they are uncle and niece. The affection that Mr. Pirzada shows to Lilia in this scene shows that he accepts her despite her different beliefs in Halloween and American culture. Also, Mr. Pirzada is scared for Lilia when she goes out alone. The text states, “Mr. Pirzada knit his brow together… his eyes contained a panic I had never seen before.” Mr. Pirzada shows how much he cares about Lilia, but in the end he doesn’t go trick-or-treating with Lilia and Dora. After this, the Lilia learns that war was to be waged on East Pakistani soil. This shows how accepting and caring Mr. Pirzada is, which differs from the people waging war in South…

    • 611 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The theme I find important in the novel is the pursuit of the American Dream.…

    • 929 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    One day at work Carla hears the word ”polish” being used by the headmaster. Normally she did not listen, but as being half polish, it woke her interest. Now she had the oppertunity to get a penfriend in Poland. Through the letters she realizes a part of herself, which has been dormant since her early childhood.…

    • 722 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    SUMMARY: At first Liyana walks into her home and spots a woman sitting in her living room. Nobody knows who she is so when “Poppa” gets home, they talk. He finds out that she is a cousin of a cousin of a cousin. As tradition “Poppa” had to buy her fabric in order to make a dress. This was a symbol of success from their trip to Jerusalem from America. In retrospect, Liyana thinks about her life in America and the memories she had. She sees herself as a “blur” in Jerusalem. Nobody knows her like people do in America. But this all changes when Liyana finally decides to sleep over at Sitti’s house for a weekend. Sitti and her do a number of activities. One of these activities that stand out is when they went to get water from a spring. They hiked down to a spring, and Sitti showed her the freshness of the water and how to balance it on her head. This was a crucial bonding time for Liyana and Sitti because they communicated so much without even speaking the same language. When they arrive home they prepare a meal for the family and talk more. After a day passes, Liyana and Rafik go outside and play with the hens. One of the hens flies away and a kid named Khaled captures it. This character, along with his sister Nadine, is the Abboud’s new friend.…

    • 349 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays