Preview

Who Owns The Elgin Marbles Precis

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
1135 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Who Owns The Elgin Marbles Precis
“Who Owns the Elgin Marbles?” – The Précis

“Who Owns the Elgin Marbles?” this question continues to linger in some minds today, and just so happens to be reviewed in the respectfully titled article written by John Henry Merryman in 1986. In this article, Merryman, in the most unbiased way possible, assesses both Britain’s and Greece’s side of the argument pertaining to the ownership of the Elgin Marbles and whether they should be returned to Greece after being removed from the Parthenon by Lord Elgin in the early 19th century. Within the article, the main points discussed regard the morality and legality of the removal of the marbles. Merryman goes on to discuss three more main concerns dealing with the marbles and where they belong: preservation, integrity and distribution. The author discusses all of these points in a well-organized manner that keeps the paper flowing and continuously makes sense to the reader. Merryman tries to remain as unbiased as he can, but with all the facts presented, it is hard to not see the article as biased towards the British. Overall, the article boils down to Greece winning the emotional argument, but Britain holds power with a legal ownership. Was the removal of the marbles from the Parthenon legal? The answer to this commonly asked question is one hundred percent yes. The Ottoman government gave Elgin a formal firman allowing him to take what he pleased from the Parthenon. Although this firman is at best ambiguous, the law states that an act in excess of the authority granted can be legalized by ratification, and the Ottomans ratified Elgin’s removals twice. Since permission was given multiple times and with proper paperwork, Greece’s argument against legality is very weak and insignificant, especially considering the statutes of limitations. The Greeks have lost any right of action due to the fact that they could have sued for the marbles since 1828 and have never attempted to. Ultimately, they waited too long. Some wonder
Continue Reading
View Writing Issues

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    Juan Travyo Lonesome George Essay
    • 596 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Juan Travyo Lonesome George Essay

    When considering cultures in collision a museum is a fine example of a clash of positives and negatives. This can be a troubling idea for the curators and visitors of museums because their collective pursuit of further cultural knowledge is often pure. However, in constructing a museum more often than not items of important significance are transplanted from their original location to be viewed and studied by a foreign people in a foreign land. The concept of the “rightful owners” of history and artifacts is a complicated one that leads to many cultural collisions. This is because multiple cultures often lay claim to the same artifacts leading to conflict among the claimants. With all of these ideas in mind the process of selecting a piece of art from the Cornell Fine Arts Museum for analysis became far more difficult. In examining the thought-provoking piece Lonesome George by Juan Travieso a warning message is telegraphed loud and clear.…

    • 596 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
    Read More
  • Good Essays

    Analyzing Joyce Mortimer's Article Who Owns The Past
    • 482 Words
    • 2 Pages

    Analyzing Joyce Mortimer's Article Who Owns The Past

    In the article “Who Owns the Past” in passage three, paragraph fifteen, sentence two, states “But these laws rest on a couple of highly debatable assumptions; artifacts should remain in whatever country they were found, and that the best way to protect archaeological sites is to restrict the international trade in antiquities.” This shows that if an artifact is found in a country, it does not leave; whoever finds it will probably keep it or give it to a museum so it can be presented to everyone. In conclusion museums keep artifacts that belong to other people; but the people should get them…

    • 482 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
    Read More
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Mla Work Cited
    • 342 Words
    • 2 Pages

    Mla Work Cited

    Smith, Joshua, Ph.D. "Those Insufferable Greeks." Ed. James Wygonik. Infamous World Empires. Colonial Press of Denver, (1983): 201-47. Print.…

    • 342 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
    Read More
  • Powerful Essays

    Art 204 Final Essay
    • 2576 Words
    • 11 Pages

    Art 204 Final Essay

    The progression of Greek art does not simply begin with the Olympics in 776 BCE, but finds its origins in all of the civilizations that gave rise to the Greeks – the remnants of the besieged Mycenaeans, and all who conquered (and traded) with them. The loss of great civilizations often leads to dark periods, but from the ashes of Greece’s dark age emerged a civilization that revered humanity and went to great lengths to incorporate the idea of philosophy into all aspects of their empire – including art. City states joined forces, democracy was established, and skills lost during times of turmoil (reading, writing, painting, sculpting, architecture) were not only rediscovered, but reinvented. From the eastern inspired geometrics of earliest Greece, to stylize humanism in the Archaic, the mathematical perfection of the Classical periods, and the flowery realism of the Hellenistic - Greek art remains the standard by which all future art will be judged. This article will mainly focus on changes in Greek sculpture as an analogy for the changes in all of Greek art, simply because an attempt to chronicle all of the changes in the historical period would require much more than a short essay, and it’s my belief that sculpture most thoroughly reflected how art reflected the greater changes in the society. Regardless of historical argument about whether or not Greek culture and society were as great or as evil as either extreme proclaims, the fact remains that incredible works of art were spawned by great thinkers. Sure, maybe there was slavery, and maybe women were treated poorly, but that doesn’t negate the artistic value of the truly innovative art forms, starting with the very earliest pieces attributed to the Greeks, those in the period of the first Olympics, which also marks the point when the Greeks themselves considered their various city states united as one people, citizens of “Hellas” – distinct in that they spoke a…

    • 2576 Words
    • 11 Pages
    Powerful Essays
    Read More
  • Good Essays

    Bibl 104 Learning Activity 2,3
    • 471 Words
    • 2 Pages

    Bibl 104 Learning Activity 2,3

    The “Elgin Marbles” are Ancient Greek art from The Parthenon in Greece, named this after Lord Elgin. The ancient art was acquired by Britain, initially through Lord Elgin’s removal from the Parthenon during his time as an Ottoman ambassador in Athens, Greece. He somehow convinced the Ottoman emperor to allow him to take the ancient art, beginning in 1805. The British government purchased the ancient artifacts from Lord Elgin and placed them in the British Museum, where they have remained since 1816. Currently, Greece’s government argues that the artifacts should be returned. Britain states that it is a bad idea due to the irreversible damage that…

    • 471 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
    Read More
  • Good Essays

    The Boy on a Dolphin
    • 549 Words
    • 3 Pages

    The Boy on a Dolphin

    The Governments interest toward the statue is for the benefit of Greece. It would bring money to their land and people. They do not want Victor Parmalee to steal it from them and sale it to some other country. The government feels the statue belongs to them since it was found off the coast of their country and since it is art that is a part of their ancient history.…

    • 549 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
    Read More
  • Powerful Essays

    Art History: Mask of Agamemnon
    • 1759 Words
    • 8 Pages

    Art History: Mask of Agamemnon

    Schliemann was a German archeologist who excavated the shaft graves of Mycenae. He found a mask which has been claimed to be the mask of Agamemnon. This has brought up endless debates about the authenticity of the mask. The mask is said to be one of Schliemann's forgeries. Some scholars claim the mask is too new or does not have any qualities that prove that it is Mycenaean. It is difficult to know whether the mask is authentic or fake. William A. Calder and David A. Traill are two archeologists who challenge the authenticity of the mask. They have come up with arguments that try to prove the mask is a forgery. Some scholars claim that their arguments are not valid and lack scholarly reasoning to support their arguments. Some scholars believe that the mask is a mixture of different styles from different places and times. No one can really tell if the mask is authentic or fake. I believe that the mask was edited by Schliemann and his men. The mask of Agamemnon is not authentic due to its lack of Mycenaean qualities that would prove its authenticity. The mask of Agamemnon is not authentic; therefore it was edited by Schliemann and his workers.…

    • 1759 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Powerful Essays
    Read More
  • Better Essays

    Athenians and Spartans : Difference in Values
    • 1369 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Athenians and Spartans : Difference in Values

    Ancient Greece provided the rudiments of Western civilisation; it has had a colossal influence on language, politics, educational systems, philosophy, science, and arts. In the following several pages I hope to demonstrate explicitly, the bold differences between the two provinces, and to suggest the relativity, of Ancient Greece conventions, to modern times. In doing this I will bring upon wars, economic stances, and most importantly, previous historians point of view on the events.…

    • 1369 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Better Essays
    Read More
  • Powerful Essays

    Summary Of The Parthenon Marbles
    • 1621 Words
    • 7 Pages

    Summary Of The Parthenon Marbles

    The Home of the Parthenon Marbles The Parthenon Marbles are national treasures of Greece and many years ago, were maliciously stolen by Lord Elgin, a corrupt business man, for his own personal gain. With aid of enemies of Greece and with the full knowledge of the crime Brittan refused to relinquish the stolen property to its rightful owner. The greed and corruption of England has allowed for the long-term confinement of a Greek monument within the dark and winding halls of a dusty British museum. Even as facts have repeatedly come out over the centuries showing just how corrupt Lord Elgin’s “noble” expedition was, the British Museum continues to deny Greece access to the art. To this day, the British Museum will not consider…

    • 1621 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Powerful Essays
    Read More
  • Good Essays

    The Battle Over Ownership Of Marble Sculpture
    • 1044 Words
    • 5 Pages

    The Battle Over Ownership Of Marble Sculpture

    New ownership of the marbles was not only a controversy itself, but it also initiated a new controversy over the treatment of the marbles. The marbles had previous been put through the punishment of war, earthquakes, and fires in its’ original location in Athens. Elgin’s acquisition of the marbles did obvious damage to marble since they had to cut out of their original location. Not to mention the marbles that remained under water for 2 years, after one of the…

    • 1044 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
    Read More
  • Better Essays

    The Parthenon Research Paper
    • 3000 Words
    • 12 Pages

    The Parthenon Research Paper

    During this time it had seen a number of changes. For nearly a thousand years the Parthenon was still used as a temple to Athena until as late as the 4th Century AD. By this time Athens had been turned into a province of the Roman Empire and had lost most of its former glory. Unfortunately sometime in the 5th Century the Parthenon was raided by a Roman Emperor and the statue of the cult image of Athena was stolen and taken to Constantinople where it was later destroyed during the crusades (around 1204 AD). After the looting by the Roman Emperors the building itself was still intact and was turned into a church in the 5th Century AD by the Christians. The Byzantine Christians converted the Parthenon in honour of Parthena Maria (Virgin Mary), or the Church of the Theotokos (Mother of God), which it remained for around 250 years. Turning the temple into a church meant that the building was still kept in good condition apart from a bit a restructuring internally; for example a few of the columns were removed as well as some of the marble statues. It also meant that statues and other motifs depicting more than one god were either removed or destroyed. The Ottomans converted the Parthenon from a church to a mosque (ca. 1460s). Again the Parthenon was well maintained and looked after until the late 17th Century. In 1687 the Venetians, under Francesco Morosini, attacked the Ottomans in Athens.…

    • 3000 Words
    • 12 Pages
    Better Essays
    Read More
  • Better Essays

    Parthenon
    • 1199 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Parthenon

    The Parthenon in Athens Greece was built from 447 BCE- 438 BCE, the sculptures continuing to be worked on for an additional six years after. The building of the Parthenon was possible because of the embezzlement of Delos, a small city that allied with Athens during the war. After the war was ended, Athens had control of Delo’s treasury, and choose to use it to rebuild the temple that the Persians had burnt down. They had vowed to not rebuild the temple until after the Persians had been defeated, making the construction of this massive building after the signing of the Peace Treaty in 449 significant. The construction of the Parthenon, and the analytical choice of specific stories and their placement on the building, perpetuate three main…

    • 1199 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
    Read More
  • Good Essays

    Zeus In Olympia
    • 1167 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Zeus In Olympia

    The subject for my abstract is the statue of Zeus in Olympia. The statue was fashioned by Phidias and occupied half the width of the aisle of the large temple built to house it. "It seems that if Zeus were to stand up," the geographer Strabo said in the 1st century BC, "he would sunroof the temple.” The statue was a chryselephantine sculpture, made with ivory and gold panels on a wooden substructure. No copy in marble or bronze has lasted this long, though that can be recognized by only certain kinds of currency, Roman coins and some engraved gems.…

    • 1167 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
    Read More
  • Good Essays

    Greek Architectural Influence
    • 765 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Greek Architectural Influence

    “The parthenon is a temple to the Greek goddess of wisdom Athena. In the nineteenth century, the Parthenon became a symbol of honesty,heroism, and civic virtue of the highest ideals in art and politics, a model for national monuments, government building, and even homes.” (Marilyn Stokstad, 149). The Parthenon was at the top of the acropolis, a citadel or a complex built on a high hill, in Athens, so everyone in the city was able to see it. “The Parthenon was large in every dimension, built entirely of fine marble” (Marilyn Stokstad, 150). “The classical Parthenon was constructed between 447-432 BCE to be the focus of the Acropolis building complex. The architects were Iktinos and Kallikrates (Vitruvius also names Karpion as an architect) and it was dedicated to the goddess Athena Pallas or Parthenos (virgin). The temple’s main function was to shelter the monumental statue of Athena that was made by Pheidias out of gold and ivory.” (“The Parthenon”, Ancient-Greece.org) The Parthenon is important in today’s world because buildings are modeled after it, and helping shape America’s government. “Nineteenth-century Americans their democratic, mercantile culture by adapting the Parthenon’s form to government, business, and even domestic buildings.” (Marilyn Stokstad,…

    • 765 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
    Read More
  • Good Essays

    The Parthenon Research Paper
    • 478 Words
    • 2 Pages

    The Parthenon Research Paper

    The Acropolis is located in Athens, Greece and was built in 5th century BCE. The Parthenon, the prime temple, has a height of 150m, with the whole Acropolis having a surface area of approximately 7 acres. The Acropolis is located on a hill that overlooks Athens. In addition to the Acropolis, this hill has the same name. The Parthenon’s foundations were built out of limestone while the columns were Pentelic marble. This was the first time the greeks utilised this material and the finished Parthenon was built of approximately 13400 stones. The men who did most of the work were stone masons who specialised in marble. Those with a high level of skill were employed, no matter their social status. Surrounding the Acropolis are many ruins but not much nature as it was cleared out to build these structures.…

    • 478 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
    Read More

Related Topics