Preview

"Why Are We Losing All Our Good People" - Case Analysis

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
984 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
"Why Are We Losing All Our Good People" - Case Analysis
Background
Sambian Partners is a family-owned architecture and engineering firm. It was known for innovation and had been a front-runner of the industry for "green building" movement. The CEO Helen Gasbarian firmly believed the company offered a great environment to work, however, for some unknown reasons the company struggling to retain its top talents. After Tom Forsythe, one of the star employees left and defected to a rival company. Helen urged May Donillo, the head of human recourses to conduct an employee survey to find out the root causes behind the departures. Meanwhile, Adrienne Perle, another top performer from engineering was going to quit, Helen promoted her regardless the objections from Mary. When the survey results came back, it did not define any problems or raise the red flags for the management.

Diagnosis of The Problems
There were three major management issues in Sambian Partner and caused its keep losing talents:
1. Problems With Leadership
2. Poor Leader-Member Relationship and Communication Barriers
3. Lack of Recognition and Motivation

Problems With Leadership
Helen inherited this position from her father. Although she was an award winning architect and very passionate about the firm, she was extremely overwhelming and was lack of leadership skills. In fact I believed her personally was not suitable to the company leader role. My first impression about Helen was her impatience and quick tempered. She was meaning, impulsive and made people feel stressful. I noticed that every time she had a conversation with her subordinates, they always felt so nervous and chose their word very carefully. Secondly, Helen was lack of long-term vision and decision making skills. She tried to fix problems with short term solutions. She bypassed the suggestions of Mary and ignored the long term impacts of her decision of promoting Adrienne on other employees. In addition, Helen failed to empower leadership and preferred to make decisions on her own.

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    In this scenario, InterClean, had a plan in place that would assist the sanitation company in increasing its profitability. In doing so, there was a possibility of having to completely restructure the sales teams and marketing strategies that were already in place. The CEO of InterClean, David Spencer, is a middle aged businessman, who remains focused, and is completely driven in his efforts to ensure that this cleaning company increases its growth to become a leader within the sanitation industry. Initially, David and his team proposed a new service focus that entailed being the first within the industry to expand their cleaning company by introducing an all-inclusive service. While this is a great opportunity for growth, a huge concern is that the current sales team at InterClean is not knowledgeable on the current sanitation regulations, based on legal and environmental requirements. Because of this, Janet in HR began to work on screening new sales hires that had existing sales experience, which caused the existing employees to feel threatened for their job security. However, with the company headed in this new direction, mandatory training would take place for all employees, in hopes for boosting morale. As employees began to start rumors about the changes, the morale began to drop and they felt there was no long time employee loyalty.…

    • 1035 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Dawn Riley Case Report

    • 951 Words
    • 4 Pages

    She needs to be more assertive in her role as CEO and not take the passive, participant role as a key leader of the team.…

    • 951 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Kindred Spirit Case Study

    • 1070 Words
    • 5 Pages

    c) The problems seem to mostly stem from the inexperience of the owner in the industry and her poor relations to the employees and assistant manager. By running on a short fuse Ms. Kindred has succeeded in alienating some if not all of her employees, and the firing of three long term employees and instant shift in business practices will and are having detrimental effects on both customer service and profits. The problems seem to mostly stem from Ms. Kindred taking and unfriendly and impersonal attitude to what is a very close-knit staff who are used to contributing to the company in more ways then just manually.…

    • 1070 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Problems:During the time of management by Leslie, there were several issues and crisis coming up as following:The executive director:Leslie was learned her management skills from college, in actual, things happen differently from book; her previous job was focused on administration, not on business management, working as a executive direct in a non-profit organization is a totally different thing than her last job, during the time she's facing to the problems of lack of experience, and having different management style from prior CEO.…

    • 1476 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    3.1.1 If Tom were to fire Alyssa it would be the only sure-fire way to fix the problem. By firing Alyssa Tom minimizes the time that has to be spent focusing on this problem. He is then able to move onto fixing the next problem and get back to enjoying quality time with his family. Although this is the only straightforward way to fix the problem, Tom will then have to find a replacement for Alyssa. The hiring process can take weeks and be a gruelling process. Meanwhile, Tom will have to fill in as the temporary replacement for Alyssa which is what he was trying to prevent in the first place by promoting Alyssa. Once he finds a…

    • 2730 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    6. Another issue i found is that Ethel decided to give everyone a raise and a promotion when we know that it is unfair for others when Nick is getting one also. This would cause a financial impact because Ethel does not know what is really going on and who is not doing their job well. Therefore, money would be lost for not properly evaluating each employee's performance; both objective and…

    • 286 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    This student feels that Kelly Zuiker is a successful leader because she is not afraid to jump in and take the reins in any situation. Kelly shows great motivation in supporting her staff and making the decisions needed within management to create a balanced work environment. Although, Kelly is handed many obstacles to deter her forward progress she continues to move forward, handling each set back as a new goal to work through. This student feels that Kelly uses a Democratic, or participative, leadership style with her employees. Kelly involves staff in some decision making and creates an open line of communication. Kelly has made a concerted effort to increase satisfaction for the employees.…

    • 720 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    The focus of this section is to provide a description of the Software Engineering and Development (SEAD) organization at MCG, the leadership practices of the company’s CEO, and the link between the CEO’s leadership practices and the SEAD organizational culture.…

    • 5491 Words
    • 16 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Fred Mairino

    • 5283 Words
    • 14 Pages

    Reading through the Fred Maiorino’s case, it is very much clear that the main key issue for this case was lack of motivation. The way Fred’s new boss Jim Reed motivated Fred to get going on his job wasn’t a very good way. Reed failed to understand that motivating an old employee is completely different than motivating a new energized employee. From motivating followers Dr. Yammarino points out that the individualized leadership should be evaluated with respect to three practical considerations; first human motivations are complex and are not always nice; second, leaders must cope with difficult people and a competitive, somewhat Darwinian world; third, leaders must make decisions that often result in someone losing and someone winning (Yammarino, 2000). Every human being and/or employee is different in nature and reacts differently given a variety of situations. Being a leader of a group of people is a complex job where the leader has to understand each employee. Some humans are easy to understand and make understand certain things while some people are so much difficult that they can never be understood in our whole life, just like our professor Dr. Humphreys mentioned in class about one person in his career whom he didn’t find out a way to motivate. Not just a single or couple, but there will be many people in every leader’s career whom they cannot find a way to motivate in a proper way. Thus, for these kinds of situations a leader should always be prepared with a bag of solutions. It’s a leader’s job to make sure that the workplace is competitive, rewarding and appraising so that someone is winning and someone is losing.…

    • 5283 Words
    • 14 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Sam could also arrange for training programs for the workers. Those training courses can include management or leadership training, to enhance communication skills within the organization. Training courses would also enhance relationships of employees and…

    • 807 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Management Exam

    • 554 Words
    • 3 Pages

    R. First Helen needs to analyze, understand and change her vision towards the organization goals and expectations of her and her employees, for example she needs to understand that if the company expects a low rate on…

    • 554 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Motivational Plan

    • 942 Words
    • 4 Pages

    | |There may be certain job aspects that affected her |supervisors to promote trust and confidence in the management |three significant needs that motivate individuals. |…

    • 942 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Consider the factors from the situational leadership theory outlined in Figures 13.4 and apply these factors to Jacobs and Windber. In the mini-case the factors that Jacob faced at Windber Medical facility ask three factors; what is the task to be accomplished, what was the level of follower readiness, and what leadership style will be explain for his style purpose? The main situation of this case was that Jacobs overtook the role as president of the Windber Medical facility and recognize many issues that may be the reason or cause of the facility becoming a suspected falling facility. The issues that Jacobs noticed in the situation of the small scale medical facility were: The employees were paid much less than their counterparts, insufficiency of infrastructure and facilities, and decreasing financial resources. According to Hughes et al, regarding the follower readiness in the case is likely to be moderate at the level of S3. Jacobs has begun using developmental interventions and shifted to a delegating style to increase follower development on certain, specific tasks. The employee’s interest was not coherent with Jacobs’s new direction in those changing times. By observing all of these issues the main obstacle was Jacobs needed to transform the medical facility in the opposite direction and rescue the facility from becoming another fallen target to a…

    • 598 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    My evaluation of Mary Barra uncovered several positive and negative attributes to her leadership style and leadership style. First let’s examine Barra’s positive attributes. Barra exhibits a task-oriented management style. Leaders like Barra whom exhibit some task-oriented leadership behaviors is to ensure that people, equipment, and other resources are used in an efficient way to accomplish the mission of a group or organization. With this style Barra clearly and consistently has demonstrated that she is goal oriented. Barra is relentless in her efforts to dive in and find the root cause to an issue then resolve it. She does this by staying organized and appointing the right people and positioning them in the right place to assist her in coming up with the most…

    • 743 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Organizational Structure

    • 1361 Words
    • 6 Pages

    In this case study Roger Cahill has been acting as the head of mobile division for less than a year. Currently he is struggling as he faces great difficulties adapting BoldFlash to a changing marketplace. The problem really started a year ago when Mr. Jim Harrison appointed the young Roger Cahill to a VP position. Although Roger has led a research project in his previous work, he is only 24 years old and inexperienced to manage a company at VP level. Positions at those levels require years of strategic leadership and management skills. Nevertheless in the last 12 months, the company focused primarily on the redundant production of customized chips without further research or product development in new and upcoming areas like the storage device. This negligence from both product development and marketing is a huge loss to the company as they missed out on the opportunity to launch new product line; therefore missed the opportunity to penetrate the potential market. Now the company has old products not priced competitively and struggling to penetrate the marketshare. Also the four groups within the division, product development, marketing, sales and manufacturing are constantly in conflict and don’t have the reinforcement from the leadership to work as a team. Although Cahill has observed the dysfunctions, he has not implemented any processes or trainings to work as a cross functional team. The company’s profit margins are low and Cahill has to take initiatives to suggest number of changes. With the staff that has low morale and lacking motivation, Cahill has to develop action plan for improvement. He has to define roles and propose organization change design to deliver an outcome necessary to be successful and generate higher profits.…

    • 1361 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Powerful Essays

Related Topics