Preview

Why Do Bog Bodies?

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
732 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Why Do Bog Bodies?
Introduction
Bog bodies have been found in many locations in northwestern Europe: Ireland, England, Germany, and Denmark. Generally, these countries have poor preservation conditions, but the bogs are an exception to the rule. Most bodies found show severe trauma from a violent death. The scope of the article encompasses Europe during the Iron and Bronze periods. It is difficult, frequently impossible to distinguish between ritual behavior towards bodies after death and outright sacrificial killing. Why were the bodies interred in these locations? Were they brutal murders? Ruthless executions of criminals? Perhaps merciless sacrifices. From a modern prospective there is an immense difference between inanimate and human offerings, but this
…show more content…
However, they were also put into bogs, so the reasons behind the different types of executions, as recorded by Tacitus, don’t exactly explain why they were both hung and interred in a bog. If a hanging were a way to create a public example, why would the body then be hidden immediately? Why not just leave it out for people to see? Tacitus also records that one of several punishments for adulterous women was to have their hair shaved off.
Because of its reliance on records, the punishment hypothesis has some serious flaws. For example, as helpful as written records can be, at times they can also lead research in a wrong direction, because there is a worldview with a bias behind the words, which cannot always be perceived at the first reading. The Roman accounts project Roman culture onto the practices of an entirely different society, so we are left with a partially true, partially made up record. This is a crucial flaw in the concepts behind the punishment hypothesis. Also, Tacitus’ document was written a while after the Iron Age, so practices and ideologies could have
…show more content…
As the hypothesis most widely accepted by archaeologists of the present, this explanation is based mainly on the archaeological evidence from the bog bodies themselves and from other sites in Iron Age Europe. In contrast to the punishment hypothesis' assertion that the violence indicates that the bog bodies had been socially despised individuals, class discussion suggests that the violence is evidence that they were sacrifices.
In my opinion, the hypothesis that the bog bodies are ritual sacrifices is the stronger of the two explanations. It is based on the material evidence and what is known of the culture from their own objects and accounts, while the other hypothesis is based on a biased narrative of the Celtic and Germanic tribes’ practices. However, many questions remain and there is still much to be learned about these bodies, so theories will probably change over time and new ones will spring up as young archaeologists join the ranks of researchers studying these intriguing individuals. As our archaeological methods improve, we will be able to learn more about the bodies that have already been exhumed, as well as those that have yet to be

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    At first glance, the human remains found here demonstrate torture and killing for some purpose. The film somewhat focuses on one particular set of remains, an intentional burial of a head and a pair of feet. These questions raised questions about the purpose of the sacrifice, how it occurred,…

    • 581 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Bog Bodies

    • 600 Words
    • 2 Pages

    1) The stomach contents of Tollund Man and Grauballe Man consisted of porridge, made of mostly barely and wheat, parts of domesticated plants such as linseed flax and knotweed and many wild plants. A total of forty different plant seeds were found in the contents of Tollund Man’s stomach, Grauballe Man had almost sixty different species of plants in his stomach. Also, small pieces of bone and animal hairs were found, leading scientists to believe rodents must have contaminated the food used to prepare the last meals. Unlike Tollund Man and Grauballe Man, the body found in Borremose had only wild seeds in its stomach contents; no traces of porridge or cereals were found. With all the evidence from the contents of Tollund Man, Graballe Man, and Iron Age Man, scientist were able to come to the conclusion that all three men’s last meals were entirely vegetarian. Judging by the presence of chaff fragments and weeds in the last meals of these men, one could come to the conclusion they all were from poor families. When the crops failed to produce an acceptable harvest, poor families needed to stretch the crops they did harvest to be able to provide enough food until the next harvest. They would add weed seeds, runt grain and chaff pulled out of the previous year’s grain before that grain was put into storage. Poor families would also use anything harvestable from the field as food; that included weeds, and chaff as well. These parts would be made into porridge. To sum it up, the meal consisted of some kind of porridge or gruel made primarily of grain and seeds - flaxseed had probably been added in order to increase the amount of fat in the meal. As already mentioned, the contents showed no traces of meat. At an excavation close to Aalborg, archaeologists discovered a jar with a similar meal in a house from the Iron Age – just add water and put it over the fire and then you could have eaten it with great pleasure 2,000 years…

    • 600 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    How Did The Bog Body Die?

    • 630 Words
    • 3 Pages

    In 1952, a body was found in a grass bog, in the town of Windeby, Germany. The owners of the land wanted to cut the bog down for fuel and sell it. Though as they were cutting the bog they found a human body. However when they came across the bog body they stopped digging and saw that the body was damaged, there was damages to one leg, a foot and a hand which was detached from the body. When the body was discovered archaeologists had pieced all of evidence together, which caused many theories to arise and people asking why, how and when did, the mystery bog body die?…

    • 630 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The analysis of the article Body Ritual Among the Nacerima by Horace Minor uses key principles to help decipher the hidden meanings behind his work. The article is based off of Americans but written in a primitive manner to help show readers the importance of keeping an open mind. Cultural relativism is crucial when researching a new topic. This culture is different than others based on their obsession with physical appearance but it does not make them wrong. Also, the culture that practices different rituals has a different belief system. One culture may place great importance on preserving the land while…

    • 1522 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Punishments should vary reliant on state, state, metropolis, or dominion reliant on the community’s beliefs, faith, and state of basis generally of European descent. Punishments might scope from whippings to be locale to demise by hanging. Supplementary areas favored the stocks patio above bloodshed and leaned extra in the direction of area humiliation in were the individual who…

    • 3118 Words
    • 13 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Bog Bodies

    • 512 Words
    • 3 Pages

    No one really knows why these bog bodies had been tortured many times, as they would be dead from a blow to a head, but I guess is a mystery that no one will never really find the full truth on why they were being sacrificed in these ways such as blows to the head, smashed skull, cuts, severe wounds, hanged, garrotted and all types of other gruesome ways of killing. Arceohlogtist and forensic scientist had also discovered that some got tortured either for punishment or sacrifice, though some found it an honour to be sacrificed. “If sacrificing an animal shows your respect to the ones they worshiped, they also thought a human sacrifice would show even more respect and commitment”. They found there possible causes of death by examining not just the bog body by itself but by examining…

    • 512 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    AP EURO Witches DBQ

    • 597 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Using the following documents, identify and analyze at least three major reasons for the persecution of individuals as witches in Europe from the late fifteenth through the seventeenth century:…

    • 597 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Yde Girl

    • 1356 Words
    • 4 Pages

    -Miranda Green. (1998). 'Humans as ritual victims in later prehistoric of western Europe. Available: http://www.ffzg.unizg.hr/arheo/ska/tekstovi/ritual_victims.pdf. Last accessed 31/3/14.…

    • 1356 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Bog Bodies

    • 1300 Words
    • 6 Pages

    Bog bodies, also known as bog people, are preserved human bodies found in sphagnum bogs in Northern Europe, Great Britain and Ireland. Unlike most ancient human remains, bog bodies have retained their skin and internal organs due to the unusual conditions of the surrounding area. These conditions include highly acidic water, cold temperature, and a lack of oxygen, combining to preserve but severely tan their skin.…

    • 1300 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    The history of the death penalty can be traced back in time all the way to the fifth century B.C. through Roman’s Law of the Twelve Tablets, where people would be put to death through crucifixion, drowning, and even by being burnt alive.. From there it can be found in seventh B.C.’s Draconian Code, and even in eighteenth century B.C. through the Code of King Hammurabi of Babylon, in which twenty-five various crimes would lead to the death penalty (Part I, 2015). Though the crimes punishable under the death penalty and the methods of which the death penalty have changed over time, the ideology behind the method still stands the same: An eye for an eye. The argument for the death penalty stands that those who commit a crime such as capital murder should be punished the same way that they punished their victim: by death. However, while this ethical principle may sound clear and cut on paper, the stance-both for and against-and methodology behind the death penalty is much more complicated than that.…

    • 2028 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    The concept of sacrifice is a fundamental basis of almost every religion. However, its manifestation in the form of human sacrifice is both more controversial and, as a result, rarely studied by anthropologists today. As one scholar observes: "The modern social anthropologist does not best endear himself to the elite of the Third World by an obsessive interest in how great-grandfather shrunk the heads he hunted or in the quality of the wood needed to burn great-grandmother alive" (Davies, 1981, p.13).…

    • 3009 Words
    • 13 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    At some point in our lives, we all come to realize that death is a part of life. Cultural diversity provides a wide variety of lifestyles and traditions for each of the unique groups of people in our world. Within these different cultures, the rituals associated with death and burial can also be uniquely diverse. Many consider ritualistic traditions that differ from their own to be somewhat strange and often perceive them as unnatural. A prime example would be the burial rituals of the Native American people.…

    • 1187 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Bodies: The Exhibition

    • 887 Words
    • 3 Pages

    "Bodies…. The Exhibition," at the South Street Seaport featured the preserved remains of 22 humans and many other specimens, including a set of conjoined fetuses, an example of male genitalia and a human brain. I found everything visually appalling, yet at the same time I could not take my eyes off of everything I was taking in. Every single body part looked fake to me. However, that isn't a bad thing. They make things look so amazing. So amazing, in fact, that these body parts simply just don't look natural or even real. People get a much deeper understanding of what's inside their bodies after experiencing this exhibit. They preserve the organs in a way that they look like they were artificially machine made. I was shocked to learn that these organs and body parts were once in a real person's body and actually functioning at one time.…

    • 887 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    In searching for a thesis for this paper, I was faced with a singular problem. With the ghastly subject of human sacrifice, what could possibly be argued and defended? During my reading and research, the stark and horrible reality of a butchered, battered, or burned human being slain in some grisly, weird ceremony for some equally weird gargoyle-like idol nearly caused me to choose another subject.…

    • 2547 Words
    • 11 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    "Twenty bodies were thrown out of our wagon. Then the train resumed its journey, leaving behind it a few hundred naked dead, deprived of burial, in the deep snow of a field in Poland." Eliezer, ch.7…

    • 938 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Powerful Essays