Preview

Why My Mother Can T Speak English Language Analysis

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
1155 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Why My Mother Can T Speak English Language Analysis
Identity is something we learn over time. There are many different ways we can discover who we are. The way we were raised, who we surround ourselves with, or what we choose to influence and inspire us. We can uncover truths about ourself, or somehow feel lost and unfamiliar with who we are. In the stories, “Why My Mother Can’t Speak English” and “Growing Up Native”, they both deal with topics in the realm of identity. “Why My Mother Can’t Speak English”, written by Garry Engkent, and “Growing Up Native”, written by Carol Geddes reveal different factors that have a detrimental impact on identity. Discrimination in a society can cause people to be deprived of who they are and feel helpless. An imbalance of power in society can cause hardships …show more content…
In “Growing Up Native” the narrator experiences an imbalance of power which causes her to feel like she loses her true self. The First Nations people were forced into residential schools and they were abused mentally and physically. This left them to feel like they were helpless and had to adopt a new culture they weren't accustomed to. Also, In “Why My Mother Can’t Speak English”, the narrator’s mother was forced to try to learn English or French to gain a Canadian citizenship. She was afraid of being sent back to China and losing her old age pension so she felt she had no other choice. Even though she was worried about losing her true culture and identity. Power influenced the people in both stories and made them feel as if they needed to do things they weren’t comfortable with to …show more content…
Culture plays a big part in both of these stories, and shows the effects on identity when you are deprived of your culture. In “Growing Up Native”, the First Nations people are shamed for the culture they have and are obligated to adopt another culture. Typically, in their culture they have long hair, but in these residential schools they were forced to cut it, because it was thought that they had lice. They were told that Indian culture is evil and their only hope was to be Christian. Also, in the book it said “They had to stand up and say things like ‘I’ve found the Lord,’ when a teacher told them to speak” (Carol Geddes, Growing Up Native, page 46). The teachers embarrassed and harassed them for some reasons the children couldn’t control. Typically in First Nations culture the boys would go out to hunt, and the females would stay in school. Therefore, the boys wouldn’t get as much of an education as he girls, and their skills may not have developed as fast. The residential school teachers did not take this into account and tried to embarrass the boys when they couldn’t read in class. They asked the girls to read instead but it goes against their culture to show up to an older boy. These children lost their identities and felt humiliated by these residential school teachers making them go against their original traditions. In “Why My Mother Can’t Speak English”, the narrator’s mother is worried

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Satisfactory Essays

    Identity is something that makes up a person. People can benefit from stories portraying someone who sticks up to what their identity is. In Thomas King’s “Borders,” the character’s individual does affect their action as the mother rebels against the American and Canadian standard of what national identity is. Particularly, the mother continues to maintain the Blackfoot culture. For instance, she is speaking the language as she says “‘You can still see the mountain from here,’ [the] mother told Laetitia” (Pg. 168) to which Laetitia replies to her in English. It is obvious that the mother speaks Blackfoot despite have a full understanding of English.…

    • 317 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Honore de Balzac, a French novelist, once said, “Equality may perhaps be a right, but no power on earth can ever turn it into a fact”. Tomson Highway’s story “Hearts and Flowers” relates the despairing experiences of an eight-year-old Cree boy whose personal achievement at a small-town music festival takes place on the same day that Parliament provides the franchise to Native people. To begin, the white people were ignorant towards the Native people. Secondly, the white people treated the Native people with a lack of respect. Finally, Native people are revoked from their right to vote as well as being thought of as non-human.…

    • 576 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Through the years Native Americans have long endured from cultural and social assimilation. Native Americans have had to embrace a culture other than their own for many years. Native Americans have had to cope with a new culture known as “white culture”. There are numerous ways by which natives were obligated to learn the new culture. For instance, early colonist believed that through education could a native assimilate to their new culture thus leading to the foundation of boarding schools.…

    • 373 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Identity, as defined by the Oxford Dictionary, is “a group of characteristics, data or information that belongs exactly to one person”. To try and identify oneself is innate, self-analysis is what defines individuals. However, people of the same religion, same ethnicity, or even the same hair color are subject to stereotypes. “The Myth of the Latin Woman” embodies what it is to be a Hispanic woman in America trying to find and embrace her identity while defying stereotypes. Author Judith Ortiz Cofer uses a personal narrative essay to tell the story of the life of a Hispanic girl trying to assimilate herself while still holding on to her culture and traditions. By analyzing the different parts of this essay such as the narration mode, cause and effect model, the descriptive mode, and the language, we can understand better understand the essay.…

    • 479 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Beginning in the late 17th century and continuing into the 1990's was an ongoing struggle between the Natives of Canada and the Euro-Canadian population.1 As Canada began to colonize and create formal provinces the government had to decide how to confront the Natives of the area. The solution the Canadian government decided on was the implementation of Native Residential schools. The ultimate goal of the Native Residential schools was to fully assimilate the Natives into the modern Euro-Canadian society of Canada.2 To achieve complete assimilation the government would use the schools to segregate Native children away from their Indian way of life and then proceed to attack and replace their cultural ties, such as religion and language.3 After overcoming the cultural barriers the Native residential schools would then create circumstances discouraging graduate students from returning to their reserves, and instead assimilate into Euro-Canadian society.4 Although the ultimate goal was assimilation the schools had to first achieve the goals listed above in order to completely assimilate the Natives. The government essentially used Residential schools as a means to achieve the end, which they saw as assimilation.5…

    • 1541 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    In the 1920s the Aboriginals faced much prejudice in Canadian society and it was at this time that their unique way of living was most suppressed. In 1876, the Indian Act had encouraged the gradual disappearance of Indians as Indians and promoted their assimilation into Canadian society. This act had made all Indians "wards of the state" and left them with little control of their own affairs. The 1920s was the time that this act was really applied. The Indian Act had been created earlier, but the Canadian government never seriously implemented it to get rid of the Aboriginal culture once and for all until the 1920s. The government funded Residential schools and they were an extremely effective way to make the Aboriginal children forget their traditions. At first, attendance at these schools was voluntary but in 1920 all aboriginal children between the ages of 7 and 15 were now required to go to residential schools. The children were taken from their homes and at the schools were not allowed to speak their own languages or practice any cultural or spiritual rituals. This was extremely effective as these schools made aboriginal children forget their culture and when they grew up they could not pass it on to their own children, as they themselves knew nothing other than the "great Canadian way of life." In addition, all Aboriginals were sent to reserves in which they lived in poverty and despair. They lost their traditional lifestyles and were given poor land on which to farm. When the Aboriginals…

    • 1154 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    This sub sequentially influences the way they adjust to American culture and education after being discouraged from embodying their own long lasting traditions. The savagery and lack of concern shown towards the Native Americans throughout the Trail of Tears had much to do with this point of view. The awful travel forced thousands of Native Americans to leave their Native land and walk thousands of miles across the Mississippi River to a new area identified as “Indian territory” (histroy.com Staff). A few decades later, Natives were again dealt an injustice when the Dawes Act in 1887 which stimulated the partition of tribes and supported assimilation. Whites had jurisdiction over the land allocated to Natives, and the Natives were given very little little compensation for it (The Dawes Act 1887).…

    • 1329 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    The detrimental enforcement of colonialism sparked an era of oppression that has altered, even destroyed years of cultural and spiritual traditions by creating a forced lifestyle that changed the face of First Nations peoples forever. Forced European culture resulted in the diminishing of Firsts Nations values and rights. A cycle of social, physical, and spiritual obliteration resulted from the dispossession of First Nations lands and the implementation of foreign methods of government. Poverty, poor health, and substance abuse are some of the long-term side effects that came about from this oppression. European settlers came overseas, unwelcome into First Nations territory with absolutely no respect for their traditions and ways of living. Over time children were taken away from their families and native homelands to attend residential schools; Native students were given new names and taught to speak English. Residential schools attempted to brainwash First Nations children to erase their native culture and traditions. First Nations peoples were defenseless under the power of the Europeans; their rights were ignored and their values were completely demoralized. First Nations peoples were forced down the path of violence and educational failure, which eventually led to poverty. These effects were a direct result of the disrespect and insensible attitude put forth towards First Nations peoples by the European settlers.…

    • 1721 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Residential Schools

    • 1845 Words
    • 8 Pages

    The First Nations of our land have endured hundreds of years of suffering. Ever since the first significant European contact the indigenous people have been treated as sub-humans; savages with no religion, intelligence, or right to live (Scott, Duncan). This general idea has carried through-out the history of our supposedly great country; Canada. This essay will examine the residential school system. It will then relate the Canadian Government’s actions in response to residential schools, good and bad. Overall, it will focus on the way in which these effects are represented through a literary text.…

    • 1845 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Better Essays

    Black Americans, segregation, and slavery. Most of the people who have studied American history recognize the inhumane actions towards people of color during the 1960’s and 1980’s. Yet, people often are not aware of the similar acts perpetrated on the Native Americans during the same period of time. The Native Americans had to suffer their past of external shame imposed on their culture and tradition by the White American society, followed by a coercion of White American culture due to the government proposal of the “Indian problem.” Nevertheless, the Native Americans maintained their pride in their identity and culture internally, within their tribes, and carried out such acts as Ghost Dance, valuing their own tradition. While it may seem paradoxical, both shame and pride of culture and identity simultaneously resonate in Native Americans today as a means of letting go of the unpleasant past and moving on to the future with a new hope.…

    • 1263 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Better Essays

    Residential Schools

    • 912 Words
    • 3 Pages

    The First Nation people have a proud and long history that combines rich culture and spiritual traditions. For a century, from the 1880s until 1980s more than 100,000 First Nations children in Canada attended residential schools. The placement of residential schools for the First Nations children has led to serious amount of damage. At the schools, they were banned to practice their beliefs, culture and speak their language. The children suffered from emotional, physical and sexual abuse. Due to these events the First Nations in Canada suffered a significant loss of their culture and traditions, and suffered a negative affect in their future.…

    • 912 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Essay on Difference

    • 776 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Firstly, native people don’t really get treated fairly around places like borders, which can be identified in the short story “Borders”. ‘“I know … and I’d be proud to be Blackfoot if I were Blackfoot. But you have to be American or Canadian”’ (King 84). The Blackfoot woman in the short story does not want to identify her citizenship as American or Canadian but by Blackfoot because she believes that that is what she is. The woman has to tolerate being interviewed and questioned by costume officers and guards just because she was different. This story also shows that natives are not treated fairly and do not have their own privileges even though they have a high status in our history. Lastly the women tolerated the hardship to go see her daughter, and did not give up. She finally got the right to pass the border. This indicates that not understanding differences leads to tolerance.…

    • 776 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In Canada, there is a catastrophic history that accompanies the Aboriginal populations, suffering through colonialism and decades of forced assimilation into the larger Canadian society, and this history has, in turn, had devastating psychological and social consequences. There was a replacement of values and beliefs in society by Euro-Canadians, through ways such as the residential school system in order to assimilate children into mainstream society at the time (Switlo, 2002, pg. 103). Within the residential school system, there was widespread sexual victimization, and this system overall created fractured families, shredding the fabric of many First Nations communities. The goal was to destroy these group’s cultures and values and to teach…

    • 592 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Final Paper

    • 2920 Words
    • 8 Pages

    Before taking the class, “American Indian Literature,” I was not aware that I had stereotypes regarding Native Americans. First, this class brought it to my attention that I had misinterpreted Native people in a few different areas of their lives. It upsets me that I thought the stereotypes that I once held in my mind were true. After I acknowledged these generalizations about this group of people, it was a process of reading truth directly from Native writers in literature class. As I was told the truth from Native people themselves, these stereotypes slowly diminished and I realized how ugly and hurtful categorizing people really is.…

    • 2920 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Residential Schools

    • 2516 Words
    • 11 Pages

    Long before Europeans came to North America, The Aboriginal people had a highly developed way of life. This however all changed when the Europeans decided to settle among them. For the Anglophones and the French people of Canada it became more and more evident that something drastic would need to be done in order to fit them into their ideal perception of what it was to be Canadian. With the help of the church the Canadian government implemented the residential school system, which was devoted to providing a disciplined based ideal that promoted rejection of the aboriginal culture in favor of the dominant white population. The residential system would eventually become an official Canadian policy for the education of Indian. Even though there are those that state that the government was just looking out for the greater good of society. The fact is that the aboriginal people faced many hardships as a result, they lost their cultural identity and spirituality through the loss of the ability to speak their language, practice various ceremonies and rituals, but most importantly the ability to see their families. Many people during their stay within these institutions experienced both physical and emotional abuse, scaring them for the rest of their lives.…

    • 2516 Words
    • 11 Pages
    Powerful Essays

Related Topics