Preview

William Rowe's Argument On The Existence Of Evil

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
1033 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
William Rowe's Argument On The Existence Of Evil
This week, the topic of discussion was on William Rowe’s argument on if evil exists or not. I believe that evil does exist. It is not a religious thing, I guess for me, it’s a morals thing. If there was no evil, how would we know what good is and vice versa? Who is to say what is good and what is bad? Mr. Rowe brought up some good points on evil and its existence.
In the article that was assigned for us to read, Mr. Rowe states three problems. They are if pointless evils exist, then God does not exist, pointless evils do exist so therefore, God does not exist. I have an issue with him stating that because it makes absolutely no sense to me. How does Mr. Rowe come to these conclusions or these thoughts? How does evil exist if there is no God? Or how does believing in evil make it so hard for him not to believe in God?
I am not a religious person, and I don’t believe in all the stories that are written about in the Bible in regards to how life what started and what not, but I do believe that there is a higher being out there. If he is called God, or whatever else there is, I believe that there is a higher being out
…show more content…
Rowe mentioned in the article that I read on a natural tragedy. It was the case of the five-year-old little girl that was beaten to death her mother’s boyfriend. In the article, he said that it was a natural tragedy that occurred, like a natural disaster. In this case, I am not going to say that it was an evil act, I am going to say that it was an act done by a person that was needing mental health help. A grown person that would take it upon themselves to take out their anger on a defenseless child is not evil. In my eyes, it is a person that is needing mental health help. Many experience some serious issues growing up and that carries with them when they are adults. They don’t get the help they need due to affordability or cultural issues and it comes out in their adult years in the most incomprehensible

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    Evil, how did it happen and why is it still here on this earth? There is this belief that the Christian God is good and all-powerful. He has the power to create worlds and beings, yet there is still evil in the world. Both Pierre Bayle and Voltaire address these questions in their works “Paulicians” and Candide (respectively). They both believe the Manichean philosophy as a more rational thought process than the contemporaneous Christian view. This belief is that there is not one, but two gods in the world; a god of good and a god of evil. I myself believe in a world of balance and like the two authors listed above, accept this as more rational thought than a single omnipotent god. My reasoning is that without evil, there is no concept of good,…

    • 592 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Rowe begins his paper by distinguishing two types of theists as well as two types of atheists. He makes a distinction between broad and narrow forms of each particular position. For Rowe a broad theist is someone who believes in a divine being while a narrow theist is someone who believes in an omniscient, omnipotent, eternal, supremely good, being who created of the world (335). The distinctions for an atheist are similar. A broad atheist is someone who denies the existence of a divine being while a narrow atheist is someone who denies the existence of an omniscient, omnipotent, eternal, supremely good, being who created of the world. In Rowe 's paper these distinctions are important because he only addresses the narrow versions of each.…

    • 1206 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Here John Wick confronts the classic Christian teaching rejection of evil by introducing Augustine’s theory. Augustine holds the conviction that the universe is inherently good, but if so, where does evil originate? In Augustine’s theory, he suggests that every matter that God creates is in some form of good, however God did not place disorder or distortion of good in the universe. This is what he means that “evil represents the going wrong of something which in itself is good”: while matter is born good, the perception of good varies resulting the outcome of perceived evil. In a social situation, what I perceive as good, others may perceive as off. Every matter is good, until I distort the value of…

    • 121 Words
    • 1 Page
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    First of we have to clarify what both of these arguments are and what there are saying. The logical problem of evil explains that the existence of evil is not consistent with the existence of a God. The evidential problem is just the opposite. For example, in Rowe’s essay, he used the example of a suffering fawn. The evidential problem states that if there is an omniscient being, how could he allow this kind of suffering and evil? If there is an omniscient being, couldn’t he stop this kind of evil? That is there argument. But the logical problem tells us that there has to be some kind of good or well-being of suffering and evil. That this evil will lead to good. That is what they use to back up that argument.…

    • 581 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Better Essays

    If God proves non-existence, we should rightly have a high epistemic standard. Finally, one could object that this criticism applies generally to arguments about evil and our limited human knowledge, rather than bearing specifically on Rowe's particular formulation. However, by constructing his case as a deductive argument that depends on a strong claim about the lack of justifying goods for specific instances of suffering, Rowe's argument takes on a higher burden of proof than more generalized arguments from evil that make weaker claims. Its validity hinges on establishing the truth of that weighty first premise to a very high degree of confidence. The limited human viewpoint seems insufficient to meet this burden.…

    • 1596 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Better Essays

    It goes without question, that human beings will always question the existence of “God”. Whether these questions are formed in support or denial of an omnipresent creator they are important in helping shape our morality. H J McCloskey and his article “On Being and Atheist” is very critical of theists. It thus presents several arguments on how believers are incorrect in their belief in “God”, cosmological and teleological. McCloskey also focus’s on the existence of evil and how one can find comfort in atheism when facing evil.…

    • 1881 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Summary: James Rachels addresses the conflicts of evil in his book “Problems from Philosophy” by providing various forms of logical problems. The author points out the different possible explanations to why evil would exist. The first major idea Rachels makes is that perhaps pain is essential to caution people of danger. He goes on to suggest that this would not account for why some people are born with deadly diseases. Another idea he makes is that evil helps people appreciate the good in life. One would not be able to distinguish the good in life if evil did not exist. However, this does not explain why the world needs so much evil to exist, instead of letting a few bad things happen occasionally. The third idea the author makes questions why bad things happen to good people. Rachels suggests maybe those bad things that occur in life are…

    • 998 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Theology 202 Essay 1

    • 505 Words
    • 3 Pages

    The question of evil is a common hot button topic among atheists and non-Christians who attempt to disprove Christianity. They argue that an omnipotent and omniscient God cannot exist in a world with so much evil. The argument is used by them to try to prove that Christianity is “internally self-contradictory and thereby to be rejected.” Many claim that a benevolent and caring God would certainly not create evil or allow it to flourish in the world that He created. So, the problem of evil is how to explain that there can be a perfect, all-powerful, and all-loving God that exists in a world with so much moral and natural evil.…

    • 505 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Why Is Blackburn Wrong

    • 1019 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Why Blackburn is wrong In his paper “God” Blackburn argues the existence of evil strongly suggesting that there is not an entity which can be all-good all-knowing and all-powerful. Throughout this paper I will shine light where Blackburn could not and prove how he was unquestionably wrong. In his Chapter the Problem of evil Blackburn states a God who created a perfect world for his children could not be worshipped as all loving, because no parent would ever throw their kids into a harsh environment specially one as unforgiving as ours.…

    • 1019 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    In fact McCloskey places the bar even lower by referring to the “proofs of” rather than “arguments for” God’s existence, thereby overstating the Theist’s claim. With respect to the “proofs” for God’s existence that McCloskey attempts to deal with, namely the Cosmological and Teleological Arguments, McCloskey offers trivial objections that are easily answered. With respect to arguments for God’s non-existence, McCloskey offers the logical form of the problem of evil which, while rich in rhetoric, does not contain enough logic to necessitate its title. McCloskey ends his article with a pragmatic justification of Atheist, stating that Atheism is more comforting that Theism; a point that is stark in its irrelevance.…

    • 2161 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    The problem of evil, as articulated by J.L. Mackie, is directed at theism and concerns the consistency of the following claims: God is omniscient; God is omnipotent; God is omnibenevolent; evil exists. If God is indeed omniscient, then he should be completely knowledgeable about all evil that exists. If God is omnipotent, then it should be within his power to prevent all evil from occurring. Finally, if God is omnibenevolent, or morally perfect, then it should be the case that he would not allow the evil that he is capable of preventing to occur. Consequently, the fact that evil does exist seems to indicate that there must be an inconsistency in the set of claims.…

    • 1699 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    To present the topic of “the problem with evil,” without acknowledging there is a God can be confusing. I think one of the best questions that you could ask is, why does God allow evil being a perfect and loving God (Elwell, pg 413…

    • 828 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    A rational belief in God, who is an omniscient, omnipotent and omnibenevolent, is not sustainable due to the evil which exists within the world. This central claim is supported by William Rowe’s evidential argument from evil and the factual premise, which explores instances of intense suffering which could have been prevented with the loss of good or by allowing further gracious evil that of moral and natural kind to occur. Theodicy objects the central claim and supporting argument by offering reasonings as to why God would allow instances of evil to occur and this notion is support by three primary supporting arguments of Theodicy. The first covers the concept of soul-making, the second is that of the free will of humans and the last is the…

    • 1534 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    H.J. McCloskey, in his article, “On Being an Atheist,” presents a series of arguments to defend and justify his atheist beliefs. He debates arguments for God’s existence including the cosmological argument and the teleological argument; stating that these arguments are false and argues that without “proof,” the idea of God should be rejected entirely. He is critical of the arguments for God’s existence and offers the problem of evil to be a major concern and reason why one should not believe in the existence of God. Ultimately, his main objection to the idea of God is the evil in the world and how a perfect, all-knowing creator would allow evil in the world to occur (McCloskey 63). McCloskey scrutinizes specific claims made by those who support…

    • 1991 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Better Essays

    Today the news is filled with coverage on various natural catastrophes and other related causalities that people face daily. Anyone can look into their lives or even their neighbors and see the presence of misfortune that surrounds our world. This problem has brought up the issue of God’s existence in religious philosophical discussions. For centuries, many have tried to dismiss the existence of God on the basis of the existence of evil. Let’s consider where God has been placed in people’s lives throughout our history. For the Greeks and Romans gods were thought to personify wisdom, war, and other actions that human beings took (Spitzer 5). As knowledge continued to progress god was thought to live in heaven, beyond the realm of the planets. He was believed to have created life thousands of years ago. Soon as human knowledge progressed even further we’ve learned about the Big Bang, DNA, and evolution (Spitzer 14). It seems that the more humans know, the further back God gets pushed. Often, it appears as if humans use God as a placeholder for the unknown, but as we learn more, he gets redefined. Philosophers question whether or not there can be a wholly good God that would create such a world where evil exists. This pursuit is known as the problem of evil. “According to the ‘problem of evil’, the extent of evils in the world seems to conflict with the existence of an omniscient, omnibenevolent, and omnipotent God. Theodicy is a study where theists are able to get together and make their arguments disclosing information on the compatibility between God and evil. This seems to be one of the most perplexing problems theists have to face. In today's…

    • 2572 Words
    • 11 Pages
    Better Essays