Wish Upon A Weinstein Analysis
“I would never join a club that would allow a person like me to become a member.” This quote from Woody Allen puts into perspective the way in which Jews are portrayed in movies and T.V. The whiny, high-pitched, annoying, voice that won’t stop complaining about the mundane realities of life has become a staple of our society. Shows like Seinfeld and Curb Your Enthusiasm fuel these stereotypes to their highest potential. And guess what? Its funny! The writers of almost all the Jewish shows are Jewish, and these people have made a fortune off of the hilarity of these caricatures of real life. Of course not all mothers are as over-protective and sensitive about their son as Jerry’s mom on Seinfeld, but viewers know it is just used as a means of making people laugh. This is what makes good T.V. taking the regular things in everyday life and
…show more content…
exaggerating them. Although there is a negative portrayal of Jewish people in the media, this negativity barely has an affect on U.S. culture and can be beneficial to the Jewish people and society as a whole. With producers and writers pushing new boundaries, many think that these negative portrayals have a negative affect on the way society views Jews in general. In the 1990s people were very worried about being politically correct. The most controversial shows on T.V. were Cops and other shows that just had some violence. As we moved into the 21st Century, the atmosphere seemed to change. People have become fascinated with seeing how far they can go. This is true of T.V. shows using stereotypes to drive audiences. While the 90s included shows like Seinfeld that just poked fun at some of the stereotypes, new shows such as South Park really angered people with its openness to go after stereotypes. On South Park there is a Jewish family, the Broflovskis, whose son Kyle is supposedly the smart one on the show. Although he is constantly mocked for his religious beliefs, Kyle doesn’t really mind. The main stereotypes are seen through his mother. The over protective, whiny, annoying, controlling mother who won’t stop badgering the kids for what they do wrong and will stop at nothing to protect them. Many antagonists of the show point out how terrible it is to make her a hated mother, and make her the only Jewish mother on the show. Some believe it creates a negative image of all Jews because this one particular character is a bitch. There is even a song in the movie entitled “Kyle’s Mom is a Big Fat Bitch.” While parents may think that this negative connotation next to a Jewish mother will teach their children that all Jewish people are whiny and annoying, that is just not the case. Most of the children who watch the show don’t even know the difference and wouldn’t be able to pick up on the subtleness of the show anyway. Also, the majority of the show’s viewers are old enough to understand the exaggerations the show demonstrates. The viewers understand that there is a Jewish stereotype out there, it can’t be denied, however they also understand what a stereotype is and it is just a generalization of falsehoods. Sure some Jewish moms are whiny and annoying, but so are some Catholic mothers. Kids today know the difference between comedy and reality, and the negative effects of stereotyping a Jewish mother is overplayed by intelligence of today’s youth as well as the positive affect of bringing humor to these normally dark and negative stereotypes. These negative stereotypes have been around for centuries and have always had a dark cloud hovering over them.
While it is important to recognize the seriousness and the harmful effects of stereotyping, it is equally as important to recognize the humor in the stereotypes and being able to poke fun at them. Family Guy, a cartoon on FOX, recently came back to television after a brief absence that involved an episode that many viewed as inappropriate. “Wish Upon a Weinstein” starts with the catholic dad Peter losing his family’s savings and looking for someone to help him with his money problems. After a trip to the bar he concludes that Jewish people are good with money, therefore he needs to find a Jew. While this stereotype is obviously false, not all Jews are good with money; it is a funny premise for an episode. The episode created such a backlash FOX canceled the show. However, after DVD sales were through the roof, FOX decided to allow Family Guy back on the air, proving that although it can sometimes be harmful, people today are intelligent enough to determine the difference between comedy and
ignorance.
Most individuals are able to take a small joke and see is as a joke; they don’t make the quick connection to the underlying problems with stereotyping in our country. Shows such as Seinfeld showed an entire generation a part of Jewish culture that was intertwined with the rest of society. Arguably the most popular show during the 90s, Seinfeld became a culture in itself and allowed anyone to join in its cult. While using many Jewish stereotypes for humor, such as Jerry’s cheap neurotic uncle Leo, Seinfeld also helped dispel many negative Jewish stereotypes. Jews are for the most part criticized for keeping to themselves, separating themselves from the rest of society, but by placing Jerry in an eclectic group of friends it proved that anyone can be an arrogant selfish person. In one episode Jerry accuses his dentist of attempting to convert to Judaism strictly for the jokes. Throughout the episode the dentist is seen telling Jewish jokes while Jerry just cringes. Although one would assume a Jewish person would be happy about the possibility of someone converting, Jerry is weary because he is doing it for the wrong reasons. At the end of the episode Jerry goes into a church confessional to reveal his angst about his dentist. When the priest in the confessional asks Jerry if this offends him as a Jewish person, he quickly replies, “no it offends me as a comedian.” This demonstration of Jerry’s lack of care that he is making Jewish jokes reflects the opinions of most of Jewish society. While some extreme stereotypes can be seen as offensive, it is difficult for people to be really offended by such small intricacies of life. Most people aren’t offended by the stereotypes because they aren’t thinking about them. Our generation is an accepting one, and most people don’t see people as white or black, they just see people. This is true of the stereotypes on T.V. While they might have a Jewish stereotype behind them, it is just comedy and people don’t make the connection that the reason uncle Leo is cheap is because he is Jewish, he is cheap because he is cheap. While the stereotype is apparent when looking directly at it, to the casual viewer it is just a character on a show, not a representation of a culture. Although there is stereotyping, it isn’t having a huge impact on society.
Part of the reason that Jewish stereotypes don’t have that large of an effect on our culture is every culture is stereotyped on T.V. Every single race, religion, and species are criticized and mocked on television and it is humorous and should be taken for what it is. The affects of Jewish stereotypes in pop culture do not have a huge affect on society in general because every type of person is stereotyped on T.V. and it is accepted in our society. Chappelle Show, one of the most controversial yet popular shows of the past few years, is a perfect example. On one episode there is a racial draft, where the whites, blacks, Asians, Jews, and Latinos draft people who are biracial. While 30 years ago this would have never been on T.V. it is now commonplace for shows to depict other races and other religions in a “negative” way. However if all races are portrayed than it is difficult to really say one particular race has the bad end of the deal.
Not only are there shows now like Chappelle Show, but there are sitcoms for different people too. With so many options on television any one can watch a show for them. Producers are allowed to go after certain markets and it isn’t racist or anti-Semitic, it is just business. The show Curb Your Enthusiasm, written by Seinfeld creator Larry David, is a show that while really funny to some, may not be to others which is why there are also shows like Martin and George Lopez. Of course anyone can find these shows funny, but they are targeted at a certain audience. There is a BET channel devoted just for Black Entertainment. Although it sounds somewhat racist to say black entertainment, it is just a market, no different than Nickeloden appeals to children. While many of the shows on BET contain stereotypes of African-Americans, there isn’t much outrage because it is what is expected. People are not constantly upset with these shows that portray different races in a certain way because they now that it is a mockery of their society and people understand the jokes are not made to put them down, but to empower a culture and celebrate the differences in cultures. The producers benefit from these shows because they are perfect for their target audience. Plus people can actually learn about a culture from watching these different shows. Although they are extremely exaggerated much of the time, it is interesting to see the way in which certain cultures portray themselves. While it may seem Curb is diminishing many aspects of the Jewish religion, the show is written by a Jewish person and is in actuality a good insight into some of the culture. In one episode Larry is scalping tickets for a High Holiday service at his temple. While it may seem outlandish to most, there are some temples that have few tickets and members of the congregation look for tickets to buy from people who may have bought too many. Even though on the show it is exaggerated, people understand that and are able to get a little insight into the different nature of the synagogues. These different shows not only allow producers to make money and allow people to watch a show that is catered to them, but it is also beneficial for people to see how certain cultures portray themselves through television. It isn’t as much as a mockery of a culture, but can be seen as a celebration of the nuances of the culture.
Television is a media in which we see a mirror into our lives. It is for this reason that stereotypes are not that big of a deal anymore. People want to watch other people like them that live the same type of life but exaggerated. I watch shows that appeal to me and that can relate to my life. Have I ever scalped a ticket to synagogue, no, but I can definitely see someone doing it. Is it a bad thing, no, it is what my culture is and it is funny when exaggerated. The point of stereotypes on T.V. is to mock the very thought of stereotypes, of course everyone is different, but that is what makes this country great. While some find television offensive, most find it a gateway into their lives and a way in which to escape their actual life to laugh at someone who is going through the same thing, but in a much worse scenario. We watch T.V. to be entertained, not to think about how a group is being stereotyped.
exaggerating them. Although there is a negative portrayal of Jewish people in the media, this negativity barely has an affect on U.S. culture and can be beneficial to the Jewish people and society as a whole. With producers and writers pushing new boundaries, many think that these negative portrayals have a negative affect on the way society views Jews in general. In the 1990s people were very worried about being politically correct. The most controversial shows on T.V. were Cops and other shows that just had some violence. As we moved into the 21st Century, the atmosphere seemed to change. People have become fascinated with seeing how far they can go. This is true of T.V. shows using stereotypes to drive audiences. While the 90s included shows like Seinfeld that just poked fun at some of the stereotypes, new shows such as South Park really angered people with its openness to go after stereotypes. On South Park there is a Jewish family, the Broflovskis, whose son Kyle is supposedly the smart one on the show. Although he is constantly mocked for his religious beliefs, Kyle doesn’t really mind. The main stereotypes are seen through his mother. The over protective, whiny, annoying, controlling mother who won’t stop badgering the kids for what they do wrong and will stop at nothing to protect them. Many antagonists of the show point out how terrible it is to make her a hated mother, and make her the only Jewish mother on the show. Some believe it creates a negative image of all Jews because this one particular character is a bitch. There is even a song in the movie entitled “Kyle’s Mom is a Big Fat Bitch.” While parents may think that this negative connotation next to a Jewish mother will teach their children that all Jewish people are whiny and annoying, that is just not the case. Most of the children who watch the show don’t even know the difference and wouldn’t be able to pick up on the subtleness of the show anyway. Also, the majority of the show’s viewers are old enough to understand the exaggerations the show demonstrates. The viewers understand that there is a Jewish stereotype out there, it can’t be denied, however they also understand what a stereotype is and it is just a generalization of falsehoods. Sure some Jewish moms are whiny and annoying, but so are some Catholic mothers. Kids today know the difference between comedy and reality, and the negative effects of stereotyping a Jewish mother is overplayed by intelligence of today’s youth as well as the positive affect of bringing humor to these normally dark and negative stereotypes. These negative stereotypes have been around for centuries and have always had a dark cloud hovering over them.
While it is important to recognize the seriousness and the harmful effects of stereotyping, it is equally as important to recognize the humor in the stereotypes and being able to poke fun at them. Family Guy, a cartoon on FOX, recently came back to television after a brief absence that involved an episode that many viewed as inappropriate. “Wish Upon a Weinstein” starts with the catholic dad Peter losing his family’s savings and looking for someone to help him with his money problems. After a trip to the bar he concludes that Jewish people are good with money, therefore he needs to find a Jew. While this stereotype is obviously false, not all Jews are good with money; it is a funny premise for an episode. The episode created such a backlash FOX canceled the show. However, after DVD sales were through the roof, FOX decided to allow Family Guy back on the air, proving that although it can sometimes be harmful, people today are intelligent enough to determine the difference between comedy and
ignorance.
Most individuals are able to take a small joke and see is as a joke; they don’t make the quick connection to the underlying problems with stereotyping in our country. Shows such as Seinfeld showed an entire generation a part of Jewish culture that was intertwined with the rest of society. Arguably the most popular show during the 90s, Seinfeld became a culture in itself and allowed anyone to join in its cult. While using many Jewish stereotypes for humor, such as Jerry’s cheap neurotic uncle Leo, Seinfeld also helped dispel many negative Jewish stereotypes. Jews are for the most part criticized for keeping to themselves, separating themselves from the rest of society, but by placing Jerry in an eclectic group of friends it proved that anyone can be an arrogant selfish person. In one episode Jerry accuses his dentist of attempting to convert to Judaism strictly for the jokes. Throughout the episode the dentist is seen telling Jewish jokes while Jerry just cringes. Although one would assume a Jewish person would be happy about the possibility of someone converting, Jerry is weary because he is doing it for the wrong reasons. At the end of the episode Jerry goes into a church confessional to reveal his angst about his dentist. When the priest in the confessional asks Jerry if this offends him as a Jewish person, he quickly replies, “no it offends me as a comedian.” This demonstration of Jerry’s lack of care that he is making Jewish jokes reflects the opinions of most of Jewish society. While some extreme stereotypes can be seen as offensive, it is difficult for people to be really offended by such small intricacies of life. Most people aren’t offended by the stereotypes because they aren’t thinking about them. Our generation is an accepting one, and most people don’t see people as white or black, they just see people. This is true of the stereotypes on T.V. While they might have a Jewish stereotype behind them, it is just comedy and people don’t make the connection that the reason uncle Leo is cheap is because he is Jewish, he is cheap because he is cheap. While the stereotype is apparent when looking directly at it, to the casual viewer it is just a character on a show, not a representation of a culture. Although there is stereotyping, it isn’t having a huge impact on society.
Part of the reason that Jewish stereotypes don’t have that large of an effect on our culture is every culture is stereotyped on T.V. Every single race, religion, and species are criticized and mocked on television and it is humorous and should be taken for what it is. The affects of Jewish stereotypes in pop culture do not have a huge affect on society in general because every type of person is stereotyped on T.V. and it is accepted in our society. Chappelle Show, one of the most controversial yet popular shows of the past few years, is a perfect example. On one episode there is a racial draft, where the whites, blacks, Asians, Jews, and Latinos draft people who are biracial. While 30 years ago this would have never been on T.V. it is now commonplace for shows to depict other races and other religions in a “negative” way. However if all races are portrayed than it is difficult to really say one particular race has the bad end of the deal.
Not only are there shows now like Chappelle Show, but there are sitcoms for different people too. With so many options on television any one can watch a show for them. Producers are allowed to go after certain markets and it isn’t racist or anti-Semitic, it is just business. The show Curb Your Enthusiasm, written by Seinfeld creator Larry David, is a show that while really funny to some, may not be to others which is why there are also shows like Martin and George Lopez. Of course anyone can find these shows funny, but they are targeted at a certain audience. There is a BET channel devoted just for Black Entertainment. Although it sounds somewhat racist to say black entertainment, it is just a market, no different than Nickeloden appeals to children. While many of the shows on BET contain stereotypes of African-Americans, there isn’t much outrage because it is what is expected. People are not constantly upset with these shows that portray different races in a certain way because they now that it is a mockery of their society and people understand the jokes are not made to put them down, but to empower a culture and celebrate the differences in cultures. The producers benefit from these shows because they are perfect for their target audience. Plus people can actually learn about a culture from watching these different shows. Although they are extremely exaggerated much of the time, it is interesting to see the way in which certain cultures portray themselves. While it may seem Curb is diminishing many aspects of the Jewish religion, the show is written by a Jewish person and is in actuality a good insight into some of the culture. In one episode Larry is scalping tickets for a High Holiday service at his temple. While it may seem outlandish to most, there are some temples that have few tickets and members of the congregation look for tickets to buy from people who may have bought too many. Even though on the show it is exaggerated, people understand that and are able to get a little insight into the different nature of the synagogues. These different shows not only allow producers to make money and allow people to watch a show that is catered to them, but it is also beneficial for people to see how certain cultures portray themselves through television. It isn’t as much as a mockery of a culture, but can be seen as a celebration of the nuances of the culture.
Television is a media in which we see a mirror into our lives. It is for this reason that stereotypes are not that big of a deal anymore. People want to watch other people like them that live the same type of life but exaggerated. I watch shows that appeal to me and that can relate to my life. Have I ever scalped a ticket to synagogue, no, but I can definitely see someone doing it. Is it a bad thing, no, it is what my culture is and it is funny when exaggerated. The point of stereotypes on T.V. is to mock the very thought of stereotypes, of course everyone is different, but that is what makes this country great. While some find television offensive, most find it a gateway into their lives and a way in which to escape their actual life to laugh at someone who is going through the same thing, but in a much worse scenario. We watch T.V. to be entertained, not to think about how a group is being stereotyped.