In the article “women expect less money than men when entering workforce,study suggest.”The author Sarah Boesveld listed three segments which respectively gave a graphic description of the women salary expectations in different occupations and with different experiences. And she mainly argued why women choose lower salary than their male counterparts through various examples from a number of researchers’ study.Although the author listed adequate instances to reinforce this view’s exactness, I still have some opposite opinions toward what she presented.
It is true that women indeed expect to earn less money than men in most cases. And the author put forward a reason why women decide lower salaries is for they’re less likely to be aggressive when they have opportunities to raise their salaries, leading them to ultimately accept lower-paying jobs than men.However, from my point, this view is controversial.We can’t say women have few enterprise when they prepare to enter in a organization.In fact, women who posses high university degree occupy a larger part than their male peers,especially in the art and social work field. But why women still predict less salary than men? Women actually have enough abilities to be competent in a number of fields such as science and engineering ,which males are traditionally dominated.While most of women are lack of confidence when they graduate and plan to find a relevant job, and there exist some possibilities that they believe it has a kind of discrimination among females and males. This discrimination has spread for many years. In the past, most women were arranged to stay at home, feeding their kids and cleaning the house, and men were able to work in many crucial positions. This circumstance convinced women that their prime assignment is to look after the whole family.
As this article illustrated women have less initial salaries expectation even for those women who have least five-year work experience, it also existed some issues in this view. I think this view is too general.Based on another website“BAIN&COMPANY”, it found that “nearly half of all new women employees aspire to top management.”(2014). This evidence can explain women actually have enough confidence to pursue high salaries at the beginning of entering a company. It is not similar to what the article has presented that women leaving university expect smaller paychecks than their male counterparts.This article has lots of subjective ideas which have no truly evidence to proof that women have less initial salary expectation than male peers. As to those female practitioners who work for least five years, their salary expectation is exceeded by males. Could it be said that they are actually inferior to men with ambition? From a website “INSIGHT” , it told that “within five years, 34 percent women still hold that ambition; this compared with 16 percent of men who begin their careers confident they will reach the top and remain so after two or more years of experience.”(n.d). From this article, I have seen an alternative idea. I can’t judge which view is correct,while I know that gender can’t determine people’s fate, women should believe they have abilities to earn more money.
In conclusion, in my opinions,as is illustrated by some above examples I presented, firstly that women wouldn’t like to predict higher salaries than male peers is not caused by less ambition and negative attitudes toward salary raise. While their few confidence and traditional thinking have no appetite to expect higher salary than male .In the second part,I think it is general for what the author illustrated, and I listed some opposite instances against to what the article has told.So,women expectation for salaries are not completely determined by their gender, it is decided by individual conditions. This certainly cannot be a cause or effect of regionalism as the author argues.
Reference
NEW BAIN & COMPANY STUDY FINDS: BAIN&COMPANY.(2014) Retrieved February4,2015, from http://www.bain.com/about/press/press-releases/professional-women-lose-confidence-ambition-as-they-reach-mid-career.aspx
Julie Coffman .(n.d) INSIGHT.Retrieved February4,2015, from http://www.bain.com/publications/articles/everyday-moments-of-truth.aspx
You May Also Find These Documents Helpful
-
According to research findings into the gender pay gap by the Equal Opportunities Commission (EOC), the argument of many economists as to why there is still a substantial pay gap between the genders is that of an individual 's acquired human capital; the individual differences (made) in the choice of investment in education and training, type of occupation, sector of employment and employment status. '…
- 2157 Words
- 9 Pages
Best Essays -
During the developing of human civilization, gender equality is increasingly accepted around the world; nevertheless there is still a public issue which the difference in earnings between men and women. Normally, the main reason of the gap in paying is considered career choice, which women trend to choose jobs with low salaries, so that this lead to lower overall average wages for women. However, children and male-dominated environment play more significant roles in this gap. This essay will talk about these main reasons of the gender gap in earnings through some figures.…
- 846 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
Roos, P. A. (1981). Sex stratification in the workplace: Male-Female differences in economic returns to occupation. Social Science Research, 10(3), 195-224. The study causes the idea that there is a large earning gap between men and women. Gender differences in earning are important because it focuses on the gender-based inequalities of power at the workplace. The author of the study used a literature review to explain the gender gap in earning, and it showed that sex segregated characteristics still remain at the occupational level. It shows that women work at low paying jobs and they are less likely to use authority in those jobs. The main reason why there are gender differences in earnings is the belief of human capital theory, and it has a huge concern with the supply side of the market. The researcher used a non-institutionalized English speaking population to explain the data for gender influenced gap in earning. The sample included 959 men and 670 women. The results showed that women are paid low wages, and are in positions of low responsibility. Even when a women reaches a higher level job, their earning is much lower than that of men. The results also show that women’s low income is mainly because of their job characteristics, in that men and women are distributed differently across jobs. Men earn more than women, mainly because women are not considered employers. The study demonstrated that the characteristics of the workers create inequality at the workplace; this is also a reason for why there is a large gap in earning between genders. Human capital theory discourages women from working and it presents women as low rent employees. They have less understanding of the mean of production. The characteristics of this research show improvement in the earnings of men and women.…
- 1966 Words
- 8 Pages
Good Essays -
In the 21st Century the number of women enrolling in higher education institutions is surpassing the numbers of men enrolled. The graduation rates of women from high school and higher education are most often higher than for men. The number of women graduates from most professional occupations, including higher paying medicine, law and business, will exceed the number of men graduates in the near future. In numerous occupational areas with a majority of women graduates, salaries already surpass salaries in occupational areas with a majority of men graduates. The idea that the majority of women are working the same types of jobs, and same amount of hours but still being paid much less than men is causing much concern.…
- 906 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
For example, it is considered as a women profession being maids, secretaries, nurses or teachers meanwhile, it is considered as man profession being managers, lawyers, engineers or professors. This creates the idea that women are not able to do a “man job”, we talk specifically about women due to it is where we mostly see the occupational segregation. Even though, the rate of women taking “man” jobs has increased, there exists another problem: the pay gap between men and women. As we talk before, socialization plays a key factor in this issue. Usually women are paid less for the same job that men do because of their gender. As a patriarchal society, women are considered less important than men, even if they have the same educative level as men. After 1980, the wage rate between men and women started to equalize; however, in the 2000’s women are still earning just 76% of what man do. Why have women been paying less than men when they have the same abilities? Some of the reasons are “the idea that women should be modest while men should promote themselves, women may negotiate less strongly for pay”, “women are concentrated in lower-paying occupations”, “employers often do this out of a biased perception that whatever is done by women must be easier and not as important or the company” (The Sociology Project 2.0), even if there exist some laws that protect women against…
- 693 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
Women are enrolled in colleges just like men and they finish their bachelors, however, many degrees that require higher education are dominated by men. The one thing in this article that I don’t really agree with/understand too comprehensively is the gender pay gap. Women do earn less according to studies, however these studies are very broad, they don’t take into consideration the jobs that are being done by men and women. It’s the 21st century, and to make a decent amount of money one should focus their attention to STEM subjects. If we look at the graduation rates for STEM fields, these areas of study are dominated by…
- 870 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
Evaluation of whether a company is fair to women in terms of pay structure could be done from two perspectives. The first would include a comparison of remuneration of women with regard to that of men. In this regard, the determination of whether the company is fair or discriminative to women when it comes to pay structure would be based on whether there exist great disparities or differences between pay for men and that for women serving in the same job group. On the other hand, this could be determined through recruitment and employment policy of the company. Whereas the company may not directly pay women less amounts of pay as compared to men, it may do so through developing policies that inhibit professional growth and advancement of women employs and indirectly keeps their pay at the lowest rates (Weiss, 2004).…
- 594 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
“In 2015, only half of the world’s working-age women are in the labor force, compared to 77 percent of working-age men,” (MAKERS). Everyday, women face unequal circumstances and situations within the workplace. The average woman’s wage is significantly lower than their male colleagues. This would also mean that men have more job opportunities than women. All these disadvantages women face negatively affect their careers. The government has tried to decrease the inequality by creating laws, but they are never harshly enforced. Improvements for women are needed in the workplace because they will increase women’s career rights and the quality in the workplace overall.…
- 1728 Words
- 7 Pages
Good Essays -
Women have experienced a historic situation of inequality in the social as well as professional aspects. Women are normally the ones that would take care of the children, do the household chores, and in rural areas; they would work in the field with the rest of the family. Just like how the Breaking Barriers article states, “from an early age, girls are dressed in pink boys in blue. Boys are given trucks to play with while girls are offered dolls [..] girls are assigned household duties like washing the dishes and doing laundry, while boys are relegated to mowing the lawn and talking out the trash” (18). Gender inequality in the workplace is becoming less common; yet, gender is a factor that affects both men and women. Also, in Breaking Barriers article it says how “females and males often choose career paths that are traditional for their gender” (18). Females are usually seen in jobs such as nursing or paralegals. Males are typically doing jobs that have to do with welding, carpentry, or engineering. Women could have the same capabilities and maybe even higher qualifications than a men going for the same position, but because of gender inequality the male is more likely to get the job then the female. Men and women should be offered the same job opportunities no matter what gender they are; it should be based on their ability to complete the…
- 992 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
People who do not believe that the wage gap exist argue, “[women] are now earning a higher salary than men and if they choose to make the decision to stay in the workforce, they are more likely to be promoted than their male counterparts” (Andrews). While there are few studies that support this, the main issue that this raises is that of the women having to choose whether or not to stay in the workforce. In today’s workplace, many women have to choose between families and promotions. While men are not penalized for becoming parents, women will often see their earning power reduced because they have to take time off for childbirth or childcare. Women should not be made to choose whether they want careers or…
- 1344 Words
- 6 Pages
Powerful Essays -
Although the American society that we live in today prides itself on equal job opportunity and progression, it is easy to see behind the deceiving façade. Women have always been viewed as the less dominant gender due to the patriarchy that is provided by society. In fact, women are still making a measly seventy-seven cents for every dollar that a man makes, and the gap is even worse for African-American or Latina women working (Huffington). Even with women having a greater entry into the workforce in recent years, their pay is still considerably less than a man’s (Conley 312). Due to this suffering pay disparity, the women in the workplace are forced to suffer through many barriers that are not thought…
- 960 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
Over the past several decades, women have succeeded in conquering some of the barriers in the workplace. Equal pay has been the law since l963, but women are still paid less then men, even when they have similar education, skills, and experience. In 1998, women were only earning 73 cents for every dollar earned by men. Over a lifetime, this can add up to a loss of thousands of dollars. (www.aflcio.org/women/equalpay.htm)…
- 518 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
The presence of women in the workplace has been increasing since the 1920s, with the amount of working women doubling between the 1960s and 2000 (Gilbert p. 88). Gilbert illustrates the level of women as the sole household earner in his ‘income parade’. Gilbert notes the high level of women at the beginning of the parade. He explains how many of the women who have to be the sole breadwinner for their household often find themselves in positions that are not as well compensated than that of their male counterparts (Gilbert p. 87). Gilbert does mention how the pay gap between men and women is lessening (Gilbert p. 88).…
- 1500 Words
- 6 Pages
Powerful Essays -
Economically, as one women interviewed for the article put it, “Women used to rely on men, but we don’t need to any more”. Over the past 30 years, the income of men with some college but no degrees has fallen by 8%, while the income of their female counterparts has risen by 8%.…
- 1180 Words
- 5 Pages
Powerful Essays -
Lack of equality is also evident in the workplace, where women often do not have equal opportunities and benefits and a level playing field as men. One reason that some employees are not keen on employing women is because of the fact that women may have to give birth to children at some point in time. Giving birth will mean maternity leave for the employers, and some people also have the impression that some women will quit their jobs after they give birth. These factors may discourage people from employing female workers. Studies have shown that women only earn 77 cents on the dollar relative to the men for the same job. Jobs available to men were challenging positions with potential for advancement, while those available to women were typically low-paying and involved mundane clerical tasks. These reasons can show that women’s capabilities are undermined.…
- 1380 Words
- 6 Pages
Good Essays