Preview

Women in the Crusades Historiography Paper

Powerful Essays
Open Document
Open Document
2655 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Women in the Crusades Historiography Paper
Veronica Bilenkin HIS 329-701
Dr. Gathagan 10/19/12

Women in the Crusades:
A Historiographical Essay

When writing about women’s participation in the Crusades, there is more than just the topic of the Crusades involved. Historians have unfortunately come to the conclusion that women’s participation in any type of warfare was practically unheard of during most part of the Middle Ages, due to tight social structures and gender roles. Each historian delves into the topic between the twelfth and thirteenth centuries of the Crusades, dates in which most sources that they found reveal the most representation of women in combat. By finding a source that legitimately proves that women’s participation in war was more common than it is actually perceived, more details about the society’s thoughts on gender roles and issues were brought to light as well. Where historians Meghan McLaughlin, Elena Lourie and Helena Solterer differ is how they present the topic, what angle they argue for or against it, and the sources used to prove their arguments. Many may wonder how sources on women warriors can exist at a time when gender roles were a strict and unchangeable social issue of the Medieval Ages. Anything that seemed in favor of woman’s role in warfare or even towards feminism or equal rights in general seemed to be counter-culture, and was not reflected in a positive way because it was against the norm. Thus, writers of this tense topic had to use subtle methods of representation on behalf of their female heroines. Helena Solterer delves into such a direction in “Figures of Female Militancy in Medieval France”, using Peter Gencien’s iconic Li Tournoiement as dames to demonstrate such an attempt in Medieval French society.
Throughout his narrative, Gencien assumes male authorship by writing in a way that portrays women as sexual objects of an erotic fantasy; making sure that his character’s



Bibliography: M. McLaughlin, ‘The woman warrior: Gender, warfare and society in medieval Europe’, Women’s Studies, 17 (1990) 193–209. H. Solterer, ‘Figures of female militancy in medieval France’, Signs, 16 (1991) 522–49. E. Lourie, ‘Black women warriors in the Muslim army besieging Valencia and the Cid’s victory: A problem of interpretation’, Traditio, 55 (2000) 181–209.

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Better Essays

    During the most brutal war of the United States, women took the field in ways never imagined. In the historical fiction novel Two Girls of Gettysburg, Rosanna finds herself amidst the chaos on the battlefield, putting the needs of injured soldiers above her own. Rosanna was never the girl to get dirty, for what would the girls at the academy she attended think? However, as the needs of her country call her husband to fight, she follows her spouse where it was thought no girl should go. She, along with many other women, began to realize the soldiers’ need for their service. Women in both the North and South risked their lives to serve the injured, sick, and diseased men whom many would have not lived without the nurses’ self-sacrificing care.…

    • 1696 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Better Essays

    “They Fought Like Demons: Women Soldiers in The Civil War” focused its attention around about 250 individual ladies who disguise themselves as men and fought along with their counterpart in the Civil War. Commonly, when you think of women and war together in the early years, your mind would center around them being self-sacrificing nurses, romantic spies, and brave women that would maintained the home front the absence of their men. The idea of the gender roles does not tell the entire story that men were not the only ones to march off to war and that women bore arms and charged into battle along with them. Authors DeAnne Blanton and Lauren M. Cook did about ten years of research of these phenomenon Civil War soldiers. The women soldiers never told their own stories and while looking for details about them, the authors had to use military records, government documents, regimental histories, diaries, memoirs, and along with the works of fellow historians to piece together the stories of these women soldiers.…

    • 1032 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    The period of 500 AD to 1500 AD, known to us as the medieval period, saw the blossoming of a rather new art in the form of written and spoken epics. From long winded tales of heroic warriors to shorter romances and comedies, these stories are a fantastic tool in recreating medieval society and structure, as well as determining religious, political and personal ideas. Such things as women’s roles and importance seem rather like a modern movement, but in reality were very much active during these days, as seen in Beowulf and Marie de France’s Lanval. Although written almost two hundred years apart (with some major societal changes at that), both Beowulf and Lanval give the modern reader a great inside view of the roles, lifestyle, and importance…

    • 1232 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Best Essays

    [ 2 ]. Elizabeth De Cacqueray, ‘Introduction: Gender Disturbance; Women and War in 20th Century United Kingdom’, Revue LISA/LISA e-journal, 6/4 (2008).…

    • 4291 Words
    • 18 Pages
    Best Essays
  • Better Essays

    King Horn Gender Roles

    • 1626 Words
    • 7 Pages

    In this essay I will discuss the ways in which the story of King Horn and the stories of the saint’s lives from the Katherine Group can be read as representations of the way women were treated and gender roles were viewed in the medieval period. I will do this by analysing the stories and language used within the text, how women are written about and portrayed, and how, in King Horn, the gender roles expected are reversed between the female and male character, and what that could mean.…

    • 1626 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Better Essays

    The two sources selected for the ‘Secondary Source Assignment’ include Christopher Tyerman’s The Crusades (chapter six), and William Urban’s Victims of the Baltic Crusade. To start, Tyerman’s primary proposition contends that the Crusades were more than just a religious movement, as the process of executing the Crusades – extensive economic planning, recruitment, logistics, and other necessary plans – was needed to run each Crusade. The author proves this arguments through highlighting the differences in how people are enticed to join the Crusades (such as immunity from debts and lawsuits); how each Crusade was financed; and the non-religious motives of those Crusades for both the Crusaders and Papacy. The second source, written by William L. Urban, primarily argues that despite emphasise Western culture places on victims, victimization of the Baltic people did not occur in the case of the Baltic Crusades. The author primarily supports his thesis by criticizing the approach of other historians on three topics: the outcomes and intentions of the Crusade; scope of…

    • 1613 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    It is claimed that “sex is the weapon of life, the shooting sperm sent like an army of guerrillas to penetrate the egg’s defenses-the only victory that really matters.” With this being said, sex, and how the sperm must go through several enemy territories to declare victory, is war. Interchangeably, according to William Broyles in his novel Why Men Love War, war is actually sex. The power generated through war and the bonding of individuals “heightens…sexuality” and as a result makes “war…a turn on.” People love war because people love weapons and the power and opportunity to destroy nations, infrastructure, and/or ideas. War therefore is the union between sex and destruction—between love and death. Broyles believes that to fully understand the seduction of the opposite gender, it is crucial to hear the war stories of women. If their voices are heard, the gender-encoding stereotypes in war and the war stories can be denaturalized. We must understand the women’s viewpoint of the war to grasp the importance of ideological power for people, cultures, and humanity overall (Schneider 6). When we reach this understanding and gain insight on “the other side” of war, the parameters of war literature can be altered and we can “re-conceptualize aspects of…war’s political history” (Scott…

    • 2004 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Women of the eighteenth century had very different roles before the Revolutionary War than after, and the movement of gender equality can be attributed to their increased importance in wartime. Before the war, women had primarily one job: manage and care for her household. While men were responsible for a family’s income, security, and overall leadership, women were responsible for the well-being of her home and children. Having many children was considered a wife’s duty, as sons would help their father, and daughters their mother. As a result, a woman’s place was often in the home, and when out in public, they were expected to be quiet, humble, and submissive.…

    • 676 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Why do we blame Helen’s beauty for the Trojan War or Eve’s curious nature for Adam’s choice to eat the apple, thus beginning the mortal human civilization? Throughout history men have found it convenient to hold women responsible for their own weaknesses and intolerance. The apathy of anti-feminist and conservative movements showcases the reality of the Stockholm syndrome and medieval serfdom. Men have been the captors and the masters of the women for time in antiquity, but we still see empathy in women. Henry Kissinger could not have summarized it any better when he said, “Nobody will ever win the Battle of the Sexes. There is too much fraternizing with the enemy.” Tim O’Brien’s The Things They Carried is neither about the battle of sexes nor is it a feminist manifesto. The literary inferences, socio-political context, portrayal of various female characters, and their influence on the male characters truly depict changes in the social perception of gender roles, resulting conflict, and their outcome for American society.…

    • 2651 Words
    • 11 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Lady Matilda Case Study

    • 656 Words
    • 3 Pages

    The statement provided by Arch-Bishop Desmond Tutu, “For there to be peace, women must lead,” relates because in this case it did take a woman to bring peace to the kingdom. The male knights tried to use violence to bring peace to the kingdom, but it…

    • 656 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In an incensed yet condemnatory manner, Greg Sheridan, in a Newspaper Editorial for ‘The Australian’ titled “Women have no place in combat” (29/09/2011) contends that Women are too weak both physically and morally to be of any adequate use in combat roles for the ADF. This piece appeals to its target audience of a male dominated society,…

    • 909 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Throughout the texts we have read in class, including in the ones examined closely in this paper (namely Lanval, The Wife’s Lament, and Chaucer’s The Wife of Bath’s Tale) women consistently appear as powerful beings. This introduces a certain amount of threat simply because the woman’s position in medieval society was largely guided by the principles in the Bible – and thus, women were treated as “lesser” according to writings that stated that they weren’t allowed to teach, were to submit to the men in their life, and were to avoid “playing the whore” (Leviticus 21:9). The texts, then, will often attempt to rid those women of their powerful status or explain why they do not deserve it. At the very least,…

    • 1764 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    The Crusades Paper

    • 3827 Words
    • 16 Pages

    The Crusades were expeditions that originated in completion of a solemn vow in order to deliver the Holy areas from Mohammedan domination. The origin of the word can be traced to the cross. This meaningful cross was worn as a badge on the outer garment of those who took part in these enterprises and also made out of cloth. Since the Middle Ages, the meaning of the word crusade has been comprehended to contain all wars undertaken in the act or practice of pursuing a vow. It was also directed against infidels who were the Mohammedans, Pagans, Heretics, or those under the bar of excommunication. Modern literature has abused the word crusade by applying it to all wars having anything to do with religion. An example would be the voyage of Heraclius against the Persians in the seventh century and the conquest of Saxony by Charlemagne.…

    • 3827 Words
    • 16 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Throughout human history across the globe, wartime rape has been perceived as an unfortunate, but natural and expected by-product of war (see Kennedy-Pipe and Stanley, 2001). In essence wartime rape was normalized so that not much had been done in terms of policy and legal prosecution, and therefore has been publicly invisible (Hansen, 2001). Raped women (and raped men) have been absent from historical records that usually describe the victories, defeats, and heroic battles from a male perspective (see for instance Nikolic-Ristanovic, 2002). In discourses on collective violence wartime rape was silenced, placed outside the political sphere and therefore rendered mute by appropriation into the language of property rights, with women considered…

    • 300 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    To the Young Women of Malolos

    • 4001 Words
    • 115 Pages

    When I wrote Noli Me Tangere, I asked myself whether bravery was a common thing in the women of our people. I brought back to my recollection and reviewed those I had known since my infancy, but there were only few who seem to come up to my ideal. There was, it is true, an abundance of girls with agreeable manners, beautiful ways, and modest demeanor, but there was in all an admixture of servitude and deference to the words or whims of their so-called “spiritual fathers” (as if the spirit or soul had any father other than God), due to excessive kindness, modesty, or perhaps ignorance. They seemed faded plants sown and reared in darkness, having flowers without perfume and fruits without sap. However, when the news of what happened at Malolos reached us, I saw my error, and great was my rejoicing. After all, who is to blame me? I did not know Malolos nor its young women, except one called Emilia, and her I knew by name only. Now that you�ve responded to our first appeal in the interest of the welfare of the people; now that you have set an example to those who, like you, long to have their eyes opened and be delivered from servitude, new hopes are awakened in us and we now even dare to face adversity, because we have you for our allies and are confident of victory. No longer does the Filipina stand with her head bowed nor does she spend her time on her knees, because she is quickened by hope in the future; no longer will the mother contribute to keeping her daughter in darkness and bring her up in contempt and moral annihilation. And no longer will the science of all sciences consist in blind submission to any unjust order, or in extreme complacency, nor will a courteous smile be deemed the only weapon against insult or humble tears the ineffable panacea for all tribulations. You know that the will of God is different of that of the priest; that religiousness does not consist of long periods spent on your on…

    • 4001 Words
    • 115 Pages
    Good Essays

Related Topics