Preview

Zinn's 'The Socialist Challenge'

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
718 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Zinn's 'The Socialist Challenge'
In the chapter 13, “The Socialist Challenge”, Zinn’s underlying point to highlight the horror and mistreatment working class Americans faced prior to the creation of laws that protected them. To show and support these ideas, Zinn showcases various events in history when working Americans were treated as replaceable and unworthy of protection; while also highlighting the poor, dangerous conditions they were expected to work in.
One such way Zinn supports these points is by recounting the Triangle Shirtwaist Factory fire and its devastating aftermath. With the NYC fire department only having ladders tall enough to reach up to the fifth floor, workers above were left to suffer in the fire due the horrible environmental conditions that left them unable to escape safely. While laws stated that factory doors were to open outward and those doors must remain unlocked, the factory had done the exact opposite; which in turn led to the deaths of over a hundred factory workers. Zinn draws to light the fact the factory held no regard for the safety of their
…show more content…
Upon seeing their already low-wages had been reduced to even smaller amounts, workers would power down the looms and leave in masses, protesting against the companies that paid them in pennies. Likewise, Zinn recounts the treatment of American workers who dared protest against the injustice and treatment they faced. Strikers were often met with violence, jail time and, in some cases, even death, for marching against their mistreatment. Zinn shines light upon the event that would become known as the Ludlow Massacre for its bloodshed. The events leading up to the massacre are known as the Colorado Coal strike, and Zinn recounts how miners were protesting against low wages, hazardous working conditions, and mining company having complete and utter control over their

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Satisfactory Essays

    Reading the first paragraph I get the feeling that Zinn does not like the Robber Barons at all with the words “at the expense of black labor, white labor, Chinese labor, European immigrant labor, female labor, rewarding them differently by race, sex, national origin, and social class”. Zinn’s world paints the picture in my head of these men standing…

    • 227 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Ross is an article that looks the carpenter strike in Chicago between the years of 1890-1891 and how we can learn from what happened so we can prevent it from happening again. Ross has a bachelor of anthropology/sociology from West Chester University of Pennsylvania, a master in geography from the University College London, and PH.D. of philosophy from Syracuse University. Ross is currently teaching and researching the geographies of capitalism and his areas of specialty include the Middle East and the North America. This article was published on September 2011 and the publisher is Wiley…

    • 831 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Molly Maguires often used murder, arson, kidnapping, and other crimes to fight to try to get better working conditions and to protest the mine owners’ rejection for them to unionize. Mine owners, then would respond by killing anyone, that they thought, was taking part in the union. The Mollies were very violent because they hoped it would strike the attention that they wanted things to change. For example, The Long Strike of 1875. It was very violent, a lot of killings, and from there came the “Pennsylvania Cossacks.” These men were police specifically asked to kill any of the violent strikes. Nothing was being done, it was just back and forth killings between the mine owner’s and the union workers. The workers did not have enough strength and money to go up against the major industrial companies, even though they tried. The Molly Maguires, did do one thing right. They encouraged new labor unions to form. The Mollies lead the path for all labor unions to follow, even though they were not successful, they opened the doors for someone to step…

    • 634 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The Colorado Coal strike was one of the most influential and large scale from September 1913 to December 1914 in the southern Colorado in the early 20th century of America. On the April 1914, the battle battle was broke out that between the striking coal miners and the Colorado National Guard at the Ludlow Tent Colony, the battle which caused the multiple deaths which including innocent victims 2 women and 11 children. They died in the cellar under the tent when the tents were set fire by the guard. This massacre has evolved into the Ten Days’ War, as the striking miners retaliated with the merciless massacre of the militia until the President Woodrow Wilson sent federal troops stationed in southern Colorado to intervene and mediate the battle.…

    • 247 Words
    • 1 Page
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    By Kelton's lights, the strike occurred in the crucible of corporate encroachment upon the cattle industry that brought an end to the free range. Rationalization and greater efficiency in the beef business left the liberty loving cowboys with a beef of their own and they struck in response to it.…

    • 614 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In the Seven Guidelines for Civil Disobedience, Howard Zinn presents civil disobedience as an act of deliberately violating a law for a societal purpose (Zinn 1). Therefore, civil disobedience is completely justified when society is threatened by a regime that practices absolute sovereignty. It is justified because absolute sovereignty only serves the interests of the state, not ours. Zinn perfectly uncovers the agenda of absolute sovereignty by stating: “We must never forget that we and the state are separate in our interest, and we must not be lured into forgetting this by the agents of the state. The state seeks power and wealth…[while] the individual seeks, health, peace, creative activity, and love” (Zinn 2). Consequently, absolute sovereignty…

    • 351 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Combining their efforts made these men wealthier and more powerful. Although the national government implemented regulations that seemed neutral between the masses and big business, Zinn believed that these regulations were never enforced and ignored for the sake of the elite. While Zinn acknowledges the philanthropy of some big businessmen, he also claims that these men invested their money back into their communities merely to train the masses to continue corporate traditions. Joel Spring claims, “The development of the factory-like system in the nineteenth-century classroom was not accidental” (Zinn 61). Zinn wants his audience to believe that corporations as well as the government conspires against the masses to continue a capitalist American that only benefits the rich and takes advantage of the people. In order to end the control of the people through corporations, America must transform into a Socialist…

    • 1182 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Where to begin with the multitude of facts left out? Such hints equating material inequities with injustice abound in Zinn’s history. Zinn banks on the fact that schools produce graduates with only “a smattering of knowledge about the American past” at best—and almost no understanding about the foundations and intellectual history of our government. Other questions come up in regards to the rationale of our system of government. Zinn, in what has now become standard practice, indicts the founders for leaving out of the idea of all men being “created equal” black men, property-less men, and women. Then he preempts the reply that such exclusions have since been corrected by claiming that The problem of democracy in the post-Revolutionary society was not, however, Constitutional limitations on voting. It lay deeper, beyond the Constitution, in the division of society into rich and poor. For if some people had great wealth and great influence; if they had the land, the money, the newspapers, the church, the educational system—how could voting, however broad, cut into such power? There was still another problem: wasn’t it the nature of representative government, even when most broadly based, to be conservative, to prevent tumultuous change?20 Indeed, this sets up the basis for the rest of Zinn’s critique through over 700 tedious pages. All of Zinn’s analyses of succeeding events and developments follow from the flawed premise and the unwillingness to acknowledge the fact that his question had already been answered by the founders. Differences arise also from Zinn’s goals. Zinn is after “tumultuous change.” He seeks to overthrow the government rather than reform it. And he will display this view in his academic activities, especially when it comes to the civil rights movement. The need for “tumultuous” change will inform like-minded radicals who will keep raising the bar even as…

    • 4694 Words
    • 19 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    1. Howard Zinn, author of A Peoples History of the United States believes that American history is influenced the most by the following concepts: class, racism, and a bias against the government elitists. Zinn is able to showcase these ideas by featuring the viewpoint of those who are commonly swept under the rug; the conquered, enslaved, worked and dominated. Zinn brings to light that America has been run by rich white males for most of this nations existence, and the assumption that the upper, middle and lower class all want the same things is utterly nonsensical. Racism, one of the largest parts of American history, is a constant theme throughout the book. Whether it be the black people of Africa, being enslaved and traded like inanimate objects or the Indians being massacred and killed off by disease. Zinn focused his book on the opinions and viewpoints of those not spoken for and made it clear of his opinions of the rich white men that have controlled the United States for most of it's existence. In the chapter The Coming Revolt of the Guards he showcases the idea that most American people have a distrust for the government considering most of them are of the upper class. Zinns ideas, throughout the book, stress a basis of equality over freedom, an active national government over state government, greater women's rights, and gave no religious opinions making him more secular by omission. These ideas by definition are of a liberal standpoint, making Zinn's book with more liberal contributions.…

    • 843 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Howard Zinn Thesis

    • 896 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Historian Howard Zinn doesn’t believe that Americans were civilized in terms of sex and national origin. He views the United States from 1865 to 1900 as oppressed and racist. Many examples are presented in his book “A people’s History of the United States”, one of the examples he presents and perhaps one of the most important is that in 1877 the industrial and political elites of North and South would take hold of the country and organize the greatest march of economic growth in human history (Zinn, 253). Zinn views this country as unorganized because of the working strike, they oppressed minorities to do the work to built and stabilize the economy of this country. The separation of labor between black and whites is what emphasizes the idea…

    • 896 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Beverly Silver’s Forces of Labor provides a candid explanation of historical labor strife movements that characterized the US and UK. She uses a database of the London Times and New York Times newspapers to profile the labor unrest in the two countries. By profiling every mention of labor unrest in the two papers, Silver gives a candid analysis of the dynamics of labor and capital in the twentieth century. In the first three chapters, Silver demonstrates the relationship between capital and labor; in that capital determines the profitability strategies that an entity will embrace, which when implemented results to resistance. Actions by employers to counter resistance consequently yield other forms of resistance.…

    • 1111 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Socialism is a system where every member of society has political, social and economical freedoms and equalities. Society owns the land collectively in Socialism. Lanier and the majority of the workers wanted a better life, and for a better life they demanded more money. Families of the coalmine workers live in poverty, where there isn 't enough food to go around and living conditions are filthy and hard to come by. Fathers, mothers, children and grandfathers work in the mines to attain enough money to survive through day to day. Lanier and most of the coalmine workers favored socialism where all are taken care of and no one is left behind to struggle for existence. In order to gain justice, Lanier and most of the coalmine workers peacefully demanded better wages from one of the coalmine operators. The coalmine owner and operators rejected the workers ' plea for better wages explaining " Before you make a living I must make a living first. The smallest increase will bankrupt me." After hearing this, Lanier and his followers were hopeless and infuriated and threatened to strike until the coalmine owner decided to obey their demands. "A strike is a disaster for everyone. Within a week you 'll all starve. Then what will you do?" the owner replied and left them. The workers chose to go on strike for week after week. There was no evidence of reform and hope…

    • 1276 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Analysis of Germinal

    • 644 Words
    • 3 Pages

    As the drudgery of working in the mine worsens, and pay is cut back, Etienne prods Maheu into organizing a strike. At first peaceful, it doesn't take long before the labor unrest explodes into violence, with predictable consequences.…

    • 644 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Let Me Speak Essay

    • 1199 Words
    • 5 Pages

    In the books that we have read this semester, the theme of the masses being exploited constantly reoccurs in the novels. Two novels that we studied that demonstrate the exploitation of the masses are Let me speak and One day of life. When thinking about the quote, "Any critical examination of exploitation is at the same time a critique of capitalism, for capitalist relations of exploitation are central to capitalism” these two books immediately come to mind.…

    • 1199 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    'Working classes have existed since the development of agriculture, about ten thousand years ago. Serfs, slaves, tradespeople and others were forced to turn over the fruits of their labor to an exploiting class. But the modern working class - the class of "free labor," whose exploitation is hidden by the wage system - is only several hundred years old. Although its exploitation is masked, it is no less brutal. Men, women and children are forced to work long hours in miserable conditions just to eke out a bare subsistence.' (Andy McInerney, in Liberation & Marxism, issue no. 27, Spring 1996)…

    • 829 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays