I believe that the thesis that this piece is, “ It suggests that even these relatively primitive robots have been accepted as companionate objects and are changing the term by which people judge the “appropriateness” of machine relationships.” The strongest feature of the piece is how the author keeps coming back to how strongly people can bond to inanimate things. It seems that all of the people that are included in the case study have an easier time bonding with the robots than they ever had to people. I got the feeling that the people in the case study were able to work out personal problems with the help of the robots that they could never had worked out with real human being. An example that confirms this is the 74-year-old Jonathan who said he, “would be more comfortable speaking to a computer or robot about his problems than with a person”. The reason for why I feel that this is the strongest feature is because it is very controversial, at the same time as very true. I would think that most people would agree that it is easier to confide something to someone that wont judge you. An objection that could be raised against the piece is that robots will never be able to become accepted as companions because of all the movies that suggest that the robots will eventually turn on the human race. But then that brings us the question whether or not inanimate things could ever start thinking/feel by them selves. Personally I do not feel that robots are a bad thing. If they can help people get over certain personal issues or make every day life easier, I feel that the idea of personal robots should be explored further.
You May Also Find These Documents Helpful
-
Do you believe that the potential dangers of superintelligent robots are such that we should restrict their development? Why or why not? In formulating your response, consider the ethical theories we have discussed in class, including the categorical imperative, utilitarianism, libertarianism, and natural…
- 435 Words
- 2 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
I believe that Mr. Stanton is representing a lot of values and philosophical ideals in his short quote. The fact that two robots love could reinhabit a planet and create an example for humans to follow is extraordinary. He also does an incredible job foreshadowing an Armageddon of consumerism that could very well become real if humans forget about love and their environment.…
- 406 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
| “She confined that she would trade in her boyfriend ‘for a sophisticated Japanese robot’ if the robot would produce what she called “caring environment”… I would be happy to produce the illusion that there is somebody really with me… A responsive robot even exhibited scripted behavior, seemed better to her than he demanding boyfriend” (Turkle 269).…
- 580 Words
- 3 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
Robots provide the perfect work to human beings. They still not real and only exist in the virtual world. Robots have no demands which is different to the real animals. They are setting by human beings. Humans create robots and make them functional for the whole society.…
- 1465 Words
- 6 Pages
Good Essays -
The robots are governed by 3 main laws: “1) A robot may not injure a human being or, through inaction, allow a human being to come to harm 2) A robot must obey orders given it by human beings except where such orders would conflict with the First Law 3) A robot must protect its own existence as long as such protection does not conflict with the First or Second Law (Asimov…
- 742 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
Moreover, giving robots legal rights might positively impact how modern technology is developed and utilised. By considering machines as sentient beings with rights and protections, we can promote the creation of more ethically designed electronics. In turn, this can result in the creation of technology benefiting society as a whole and help allay worries about machine abuse, which is an underlying issue in the cyber world. By authorising machine rights, they would be subject to regulation and surveillance as humans are, according to Foucault, thus implementing them to be used ethically and diminishing technical misuse. In addition, the implementation of legal personhood’s extension to non-human agents can be achieved with the help of comprehensive changes in the legislative and regulatory areas.…
- 2387 Words
- 10 Pages
Powerful Essays -
Some believe that uniqueness is based on empathy or intimacy-based emotions that are expressed through shared experiences. If humans did not have the ability to share their thoughts and emotions, their relationship would be so awkward. In Turkle’s essay, robots are not really imitating humans because they are missing something the most important thing in human society, which is sharing emotions. Turkle says “ I am troubled by the idea of seeking intimacy with a machine that has no feelings, can have no feelings, and is really just a clever collection of “as if” performances, behaving as if it cared, as if it understood us” (Turkle 267). Robots easily accept any amount of memory and other information that are applied to them by humans. However, many people doubt if emotions and emotional interactions with humans can also be applied to robots. Certainly, that is impossible. Feelings, experience, or consciousness are some concepts that robots cannot implement or understand. Those characteristics are biological traits and robots are not a biological system. They are artificial and created by humans. Their body is filled with all different inorganic materials, which is totally different from human body. Also, they do not have any backgrounds and experiences that can sympathize with humans. They cannot love anyone back. Every information and data is just installed and put into their body. When things are implemented in robots, both emotions and feelings are performing such a crucial role that has to be accounted for. However, since emotions are not an electric activity that takes huge part in humans’ brain, no one would believe that robots would be able to have emotions as humans do. Furthermore, Blackmore believes that emotions contribute to human’s uniqueness. The author states, “We wage wars, believe in religions, bury our dead and get embarrassed about sex” (Blackmore 31). Robots, or any other machines, do not believe in any religions or get embarrassed about…
- 435 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
Probably brought on by science fiction, it portrayed robots resembling man, having artificial intelligence, and not existing today. The most basic robot is just a tool that does a job automatically. These tools have been around for long time, and ideas of these tools have been around even longer. The tools have many shapes and sizes and are used for an endless amount of…
- 904 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
Asides from causing human social dysfunction, the robots are neither safer nor more reliable compared to human resources, which is totally opposite to most people’s common sense. One extreme case is that a women bought a robot to substitute for her boyfriend because she believes the machine is safer and will never betray her (Turkle, 2012). The main reason why she abandoned human boyfriend is the eager for “no-risk relationship” (Turkle, 2012). However, does this machine which always obeys her order and never has different thoughts really give her boyfriend-like care? The technology of human replacement robots is not advanced enough and still limited by huge barriers. For example, a kind of robot works as an alternative role to those disabled students who have problems attend classroom, can’t guarantee receiving perfect wireless signal when moving in the campus (Brown, 2013).…
- 273 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
Hot electrical wires under a cold, metal shell versus blood- flowing veins beneath a warm, furry skin. Robotic pets are replacing true, loving emotions with computer programmed actions. Robots make human lives easier, like what could happen in a science fiction movie. Just following three simple steps on the instruction manual could change lives dramatically. For example, humans are gradually moving towards social isolation, lack of responsibility, and loneliness. Robotic machines have many negative outcomes. Therefore, they should not get to replace the relationship between humans and their pets.…
- 660 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
2. In the reading, Sherry Turkle is implicating putting forward that’s humans are distancing themselves from each other and instead relying on technology for companionship. Turkle proves these ideas by observing how children, adults and the elderly interact with these social robots. Children crave the attention and affection of the robots and get unhappy when it they feel like the robot is interested in another child. The introduction to robots in nursing homes has enabled the elderly…
- 236 Words
- 1 Page
Satisfactory Essays -
The Kevin Kelly article “Better Than Human” explains that people should not be reluctant or scared that robots will soon be the norm. Robots are being made to work together with humans to improve the…
- 785 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
In a somewhat simple and straightforward mystery story, Asimov brings up several thought-provoking themes and difficult questions which are never answered definitely. The first major theme is what the social treatment of robots should be once they become fully integrated into society. In the beginning of the novel, the main character Elijah Baley is living on Earth, a planet fearful and suspicious of intelligent robots. Throughout the introduction, he refers to his temporary robot guide as “boy,” making a distinct connection to the way African Americans were treated during and even after slavery in America. However, when he travels to the planet Aurora, where robots are accepted instead of feared, he must change his behavior significantly, transferring to a more respectful tone by the end of the book. As artificial intelligence becomes more advanced, the natural question of…
- 569 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
In this day and age, new technology is everywhere, but it’s usually in the form of phones, computers, and, now, watches. However, we’re forgetting one, robots. Now, they’re still quite popular, but they’re mostly the ideals of science fiction worlds set so far into the future we’ve migrated to space. Is it really so farfetched of an idea, though, to think that maybe we could achieve that level? No, in fact and despite the spotlight being diverted away, we’re heading down the path to robo-world already. What a robot is and has been is quite a lenient description, but no one can deny how much they’ve already shaped our lives. According to the passage “Robots Long Ago” by Karen Brinkmann, “Today robots help people with everything from surgery…
- 836 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
Then again, it is summer all year in the Swintons’ garden, and David obviously does not see himself as just a toy. Important themes are therefore man versus machine, loneliness, and ethical responsibility towards artificial life forms. The text questions whether machines really can replace humans in all aspects. Surely, they can help us with a lot of work, but can they also substitute for social relations with other humans? And if we do succeed in creating a “toy” with human emotions, are we not then obligated to treat “it” with the same respect and care, as we would treat any other living being? A message could be that we must think carefully and thoroughly before letting ourselves get carried away by all the new technologies…
- 1214 Words
- 5 Pages
Good Essays