Gerard Jones, in “Violent Media is Good for Kids,” expresses personal experiences about how violent comic books can often help children break through their shells of self-isolation. Because Jones largely discusses his own opinions, I feel the essay should provide more statistical evidence to support his thoughts. Although I agree with his point that children do need to have an outlet to express their underlying rage, I think a boundary of how extreme we can allow children to stretch this idea needs to be set.…
In “Violent Media is Good for Kids,” the author Gerard Jones claims that violent media is good for children because it prepares them for violence in reality and teaches them how to control with rage. He argues against people’s view of violent media being negative influence on children. This view suggests that it is important to keep children away from violent media because it promotes imaginary gun battles, killing, blood, and violent fighting. In response, the author argues that such violence in media can give children a tool to master their rage.…
[“If a child is growing up in a home where Dad is beating up Mom all the time, the child is going to learn that hitting is an acceptable way to handle problems. This child is much more likely than other children to grow up to handle problems the same way and become a violent adult himself. The same can be said for cartoon violence.”] (PATHOS)…
Gerard Jones' essay “Violent Media is Good for Kids” was a very interesting paper. He opens with a story of him as a child, “alone and afraid” of the rage that was inside of him. His parents taught him that violence was wrong and that rage was something that could be simply overcome. Jones' main argument was aimed at parents, saying that they are stifling a child's natural instinct of anger and rage. He wrote that “we send the message to our children in a hundred ways that their craving for imaginary gun battles and symbolic killing is wrong...”, and uses his own childhood as an example of how comics were good for him because they were juvenile and violent. I feel that his explanation of our fear of “youth violence” is logically sound, and I agree with him that violent media can actually help children.…
“Violent Media is good for Kids” is an article which attempts to persuade the reader that violence (if used in the correct manner) can help children more than it hurts them. Famous comic-book author Gerard Jones claims that gory video games, comics, and cartoons may do a thing or two in helping to increase a child’s self-confidence. Jones says ‘creative violence’ can help by “giving kids a tool to master their rage.”…
In Violent Media is Good for Kids, Gerard Jones argues that violent forms of media in our pop culture can be used as a means of helping kids cope with rage. Throughout his essay, Jones promotes the idea that kids should use “creative violence” as a tool to transfer their negative emotions rather than acting out on them (197). Although Jones points out valid arguments to defend violence in media, he fails give a clear definition to determine what constitutes it. Thus, he excludes all other forms of media violence such as gaming, movies, television shows, etc. that dominate our current world. Jones’ argument is based mostly on Marvel Comics with superheroes acting out their “violence” to perceived injustices. His lack of sources makes him lose credibility and ineffectively persuade his readers, especially parents, to use media violence as a form of creativity to diminish any negative behaviors.…
From infancy onward, parents and teachers have drilled into the young generation that violence should be avoided at all costs. They have preached cooperation, tolerance, and “using one’s words” as tactics to combat difficult situations. Although those lessons are valid, Gerald Jones claims there is an alternative way. In his essay, “Violent Media is Good for Kids,” Jones argues that “creative violence- bonking cartoons, bloody videogames, toy guns-gives children a tool to master their rage” (Jones). In other words, media violence, used correctly, can serve as an alternative method for powering through adolescence. By reading and writing violent stories, children are able to express themselves safely and even escape from the sometimes harsh reality. Jones effectively supports this stance using the three rhetorical appeals- ethos, pathos, and logos.…
The essay, “Violent media is good for kids”, written by Gerard Jones, was first published in Mother Jones magazine in the year 2000, and nearly two decades later, this subject is still relevant today. Jones is author of violent media himself, as he has written many books for Marvel Comics. The essay argues that violent media is good for kids, which is also Jones’ thesis. To support his thesis, Jones discusses several arguments, such as his personal experience with violent media, as well as his son’s use of superheroes to overcome fears and other overwhelming emotions. Jones also references to authority to back his theory and assert the necessity of violent media as an outlet for overcoming emotional…
A small and gentle Belle tames a ferocious beast; a love-struck mermaid turns into a quiet, lovesick puppy; Snow White saves dwarves from their pigsty by dusting, sweeping, washing dishes, tidying and sprucing. Beneath the smiles, gardens and cheerful woodland creatures of the classic Disney we all remember from our youth lies a host of stereotypes and media violence that has shaped our generation. Since the early 1960s research evidence suggests that exposure to violence in television, movies, video games, cell phones, and on the internet increases the risk of violent behaviour on the viewer’s part increases the risk of them behaving violently. Most researchers define media violence as visual portrayals of acts of aggression by one human or…
Cartoons are not the only ones that display a sexual and violent connotation on public broadcast television. There's always that certain show that displays their cast members with very little clothing. Such shows are the ones that are based on beaches. There's always the occasional, and sometimes not so occasional, slow motion takes. These can be seen as a tool to better emphasize the sexual connotation. Of course, no good show is complete without a struggle coming to a conclusion after a violent scene or two. This is where the children can better see the sexual and violent elements that happen in real life. This sparks the imagination in them.…
The numbers of violent episodes per program correspond to the numbers found by Signorelli and discussed in the chapter in our textbook. I also noticed that those who acts violently are rewarded most of the times. According to a study done at the University of Arizona, 73% of individuals who commit crimes in cartoons and children's shows go unpunished in violent scenes. Television shows that the character who commits the crime receives no punishment, which teaches children that it is alright to commit a crime because nothing will be done. Criminals and violent acts do not get punished. Children begin to believe that violence doesn’t really hurt others.…
More than 1,000 studies on the effects of television and film violence have been done over the past 40 years and the majority of these studies have the same conclusion: television and film violence leads to real-world violence (United States 2). The average 7th grader watches about 4 hours of television per day, and 60% of those shows containg some violence (United States 4). A prime source of these violent images is TV news, which happens to be America 's number one sourse of news and information (Steyer 73). Most local television newscasts are dominated by killings, assaults, kidnappings, terrorist attacks, and other stories designed to provoke a strong emotional reaction from viewers (Steyer 73). In the recent years, Hollywood 's growing taste for grotesque, graphic fare has upped the stakes, from Friday the 13th to Creepshaw and Scream (Steyer 73). Even though these movies are not meant for small kids, it is a fact that young children are often regularly exposed to them in the company of unthinking par-…
Despite super heroes being known as a major force for good in science fiction stories and movies, Tom Jacobs says that children emulate their violent behavior, turning good kids into violent trouble makers. Two hundred and forty pre school kids were examined , and tested one year apart. After a year it was discovered that the super heroes these kids so intently watched had no effect on the kids when it…
When I read articles like “Violent Media is Good for Kids” by Gerard Jones, I have mixed feelings. I reflect on my youth and how comic books and cartoons were an outlet for me, and I would never want to deprive my son of the violent and scary adventures that I found in them. These experiences helped me to grow up. I believe that these personal experiences somewhat validate Jones’s point that violence in the media can be a safe emotional outlet for children some of the time. However, with that said, I still believe that there is more to the…
With violence and strength glamorize within this cartoon it gives children the idea that violence is the way to show ones worth, or show how on is better than another. Several children see fighting and violence through cartoons as the only indicator that displays worth in comparison to other children. With the result of this some children may try to establish themselves as superior through fighting and violence reenacting what they see on television through violent cartoons. Television is a learning tool and with children being exposed to violent cartoons such as Pokemon they learn that violence is a way of showing strength, and superiority.…