For this essay‚ I have chosen to take on the prompt that covers the hypothetical scenario in which my sister is the person being hooked up to the violinist in Judith Jarvis Thomson’s violinist thought experiment. I will begin by discussing my thoughts regarding this scenario and what advice I would offer my sister. I will then go on to take a more general look at this topic and try and establish whether my reasoning could be used as basic moral code for this issue or is there more complexity to it
Premium Psychology Essay Philosophy
To cause a fetus ’ death through abortion is morally wrong since it violates one of the basic rights of an already considered person ‚ that is ‚ the right to life of the fetus In Judith Jarvis Thompson ’s A Defense of Abortion ’ a different view of abortion is presented (47 . She contends that even if it is to be perceived that a fetus is a person worthy of the basic right to life still ‚ it does not follow that abortion must be condemned
Premium Human rights Abortion Pregnancy
Judith Jarvis Thomson’s “A Defense of Abortion” argues that even if we all agree that a fetus a person from the moment of conception‚ and a person has an essential right to life‚ the mother’s right to determine what she does and does not do with her body supersedes the rights of the unborn infant. Judith Jarvis Thomson illustrates her point by asking the reader to imagine that you wake up in the morning‚ and you discover that you have been kidnapped in order to save a life of a famous violinist
Premium Abortion Pregnancy Abortion debate
As the title makes plain‚ Thomson asserts that abortion is not impermissible. More exactly‚ she argues for the conclusion that at times‚ abortion is permissible; she asserts that there are scenarios in which getting an abortion would be immoral. What is especially innovative is the way in which her argument is constructed by Thomson. She starts the essay by pointing out the argument over abortion seems to numerous individuals to hinge on whether the fetus is a man. Most feel that if we could simply
Premium Abortion Pregnancy Abortion debate
prolife side’s main argument is that the fetus is a person and therefore has a right to life. Judith Thomson addresses this argument in her paper‚ “A Defense of Abortion‚” by giving a hypothetical sick violinist example. In this example‚ kidnappers abduct a healthy stranger and‚ after rendering him unconscious‚ performs a surgery to “connect” the healthy stranger to the famous ailing violinist (1. Thomson‚ CC 153). This violinist has a fatal kidney condition and‚ if detached from the healthy stranger
Premium Abortion Pregnancy Human rights
strangle-hold on the opinions of all. Judith Thomson‚ presents ’A Defence of Abortion’ through a process of thought experiments and ’reasonable’ reactions or thoughts to such absurd hypothetical situations. As absurd as they may be‚ they shine a bright light on where modern society places itself on the moral pendulum‚ in relation to abortion ethics. However is Sarah morally obliged to carry her unwanted child to term? This essay will delve deep into arguments from Thomson. To create an ethically just answer
Premium Abortion Pregnancy Human rights
Judith Thomson’s argument through her article‚ “A Defence of Abortion” is one that adopts the premise that the fetus is a human being from the moment of conception. By doing this‚ Thomson is distancing her argument from the various theorists who maintain the moral view that it is wrong to kill another human being‚ such as (Marquis‚ 1989). This ultimately allows her to assume various hypothetical situations in which the cognitive status of the fetus is otherwise not considered. This is important.
Premium Abortion Pregnancy Fetus
to keep abortion while others argued for banning it. In the article "The Rights of a Woman Do Not Outweigh the Rights of A Child" by Judith Jarvis Thomson‚ who is a philosopher and invented an analogy for her debate‚ talks about how a child has more right than the mother in the case of abortion and that abortion is the same thing as "killing" ‚ Thomson says. Thomson claims the idea that anyone can argue that all abortion is impermissible. The article "Abortions Should Be Restricted to Before Twenty
Premium Abortion Human rights Pregnancy
James Jarvis In Alan Paton’s Cry‚ the Beloved Country there is two protagonists‚ Reverend Stephen Kumalo‚ and James Jarvis. Both characters play significant roles to the story but James Jarvis’ situation is noteworthy and inspirational. James is an influential‚ dynamic character because his opinion dramatically changes upon reading his son’s manuscript. A series of events influences James to shift his mindset into the mindset of his son. An analysis on James Jarvis’ changing mindset reveals
Premium South Africa 2003 Cricket World Cup
the article ‘A Defense of Abortion’ Judith Jarvis Thomson provides an argument that abortion in some cases is morally permissible‚ because all persons have a right to life. Thomson defends the case by the premise that life begins at the moment of conception; therefore a fetus has the right to life. At the same point Thomson argues that women with unplanned pregnancies that occur from acts of rape have the right to decide what happens to their body. Yet Thomson suggests the unborn child’s right to
Free Pregnancy Abortion