Written by William Scarff, module leader, Corporate Social Responsibility and Ethics.
Answer the following questions, using the case study.
1 Identify the different stakeholder groups for Nike. Can some stakeholder groups be ignored? Explain and justify your views
2 Examine and justify actions Nike could take to improve the labour conditions of its workers in developing countries.
3 Assume you are the Chief Executive Officer (CEO). Discuss whether or not you should carry any personal responsibility for alleged misdeeds in the multinational company.
4 Is it reasonable, or fair, to expect a large company in one part of the world to be responsible for the activities of a supplier in another part of the world? (This question is linked to question 2)
The case study
This case study is based on an article by Simon Zadek in the Harvard Business Review for 2004. The case study has however been adapted and supported by academic commentary from other noted authors. There is one appendix. It gives more detail to the activities taken by Nike. Here are some ideas and debates from those authors. The quotations are given to highlight some of the issues in the subject areas of business ethics and corporate social responsibility. Not all comments from these authors can be used directly in the answers to the case study, but they are included to encourage thinking around company behaviour and practice, and to illustrate some of the very real dilemmas faced by managers and policy makers in large organisations.
Here are some sources to help you develop your thinking and understanding of the subject areas.
1 ‘It is being increasingly recognized by managers, policy-makers and researchers that business ethics in the global economy is simply too important to be left merely to chance. Global corporations such as McDonalds’s, Shell, Nike, Nestle and others have realized to their cost the threat that perceived
Bibliography: Buchholtz A and Carroll A (2012) Business and society, Ethics and Stakeholder Management, 8th edition, South Western, Cengage Learning Crane A and Matten D (2010), Business ethics, 3rd edition, Oxford, Oxford University Press Griseri P and Seppala N, (2010) Business ethics and corporate social responsibility, South Western, Cengage Learning Wicks A C, Freeman R E, Werhane P H, Martin K E, (2010) Business ethics, a managerial approach, Boston, Prentice Hall Zadek S (2004) The path to corporate social responsibility, Harvard Business Review 82, December 125-32 Appendix: the five stages of organisational learning